The Family of MapReduce and Large Scale Data Processing Systems

In the last two decades, the continuous increase of computational power has produced an overwhelming flow of data which has called for a paradigm shift in the computing architecture and large scale data processing mechanisms. MapReduce is a simple and powerful programming model that enables easy development of scalable parallel applications to process vast amounts of data on large clusters of commodity machines. It isolates the application from the details of running a distributed program such as issues on data distribution, scheduling and fault tolerance. However, the original implementation of the MapReduce framework had some limitations that have been tackled by many research efforts in several followup works after its introduction. This article provides a comprehensive survey for a family of approaches and mechanisms of large scale data processing mechanisms that have been implemented based on the original idea of the MapReduce framework and are currently gaining a lot of momentum in both research and industrial communities. We also cover a set of introduced systems that have been implemented to provide declarative programming interfaces on top of the MapReduce framework. In addition, we review several large scale data processing systems that resemble some of the ideas of the MapReduce framework for different purposes and application scenarios. Finally, we discuss some of the future research directions for implementing the next generation of MapReduce-like solutions.Comment: arXiv admin note: text overlap with arXiv:1105.4252 by other author

The use of reduction filters in distributed query optimization

A major issue that affects the performance of a distributed database management system is the optimal processing of a query involving data from several sites. The problem of distributed query processing is to determine a sequence of operations, called an execution strategy, with the minimum cost. This has been shown to be an NP-Hard problem [Hen80, WC96]. Therefore, most proposed algorithms for processing distributed queries are heuristic, and focus on producing efficient (but suboptimal) strategies that minimize some particular cost of the query. Many proposed solutions use joins, semijoins, a combination of joins and semijoins, and dynamic methods. Solutions that use a filter-based approach have also been proposed. However, the limitations of such approaches include the assumption of a perfect hash function, the restriction of the algorithm to specific query types, and the restriction of the algorithm to a specific number of relations and joining attributes. Therefore, we propose a new filter-based algorithm that can process general queries consisting of an arbitrary number of relations and joining attributes. Also, it does not assume the use of a perfect hash function. (Abstract shortened by UMI.) Paper copy at Leddy Library: Theses & Major Papers - Basement, West Bldg. / Call Number: Thesis1998 .O87. Source: Masters Abstracts International, Volume: 39-02, page: 0531. Adviser: Joan Morrissey. Thesis (M.Sc.)--University of Windsor (Canada), 1998

An evaluation of a 2-way semijoin distributed query processing algorithm

The 2-way semijoin is proposed as an important extended version of the semijoin, which adds a backward reduction to maximize the reduction capability of traditional semijoin operations used as an effective operator for minimizing transmission cost in distributed query processing. In this thesis, we evaluate the 2-way semijoin algorithm objectively against a full reducer which is the algorithm that fully reduces all relations involved in a query by eliminating all non-participating tuples from relations. Instead of using filter-based algorithm, our algorithm is implemented so that it avoids hash collisions and also allows for composite semijoins. A series of experiments with various queries are carried out to study the above issues. It has been show that using our 2-way semijoin algorithm to reduce the query relations achieves significantly reduction effect. It performs well with respectable results on both the average percentage reduction of query relations and the percentage of queries that achieve full reduction in terms of total cost. Paper copy at Leddy Library: Theses & Major Papers - Basement, West Bldg. / Call Number: Thesis2000 .C344. Source: Masters Abstracts International, Volume: 40-03, page: 0721. Adviser: Joan M. Morrissey. Thesis (M.Sc.)--University of Windsor (Canada), 2001

Distributed Streaming with Finite Memory

We introduce three formal models of distributed systems for query evaluation on massive databases: Distributed Streaming with Register Automata (DSAs), Distributed Streaming with Register Transducers (DSTs), and Distributed Streaming with Register Transducers and Joins (DSTJs). These models are based on the key-value paradigm where the input is transformed into a dataset of key-value pairs, and on each key a local computation is performed on the values associated with that key resulting in another set of key-value pairs. Computation proceeds in a constant number of rounds, where the result of the last round is the input to the next round, and transformation to key-value pairs is required to be generic. The difference between the three models is in the local computation part. In DSAs it is limited to making one pass over its input using a register automaton, while in DSTs it can make two passes: in the first pass it uses a finite-state automaton and in the second it uses a register transducer. The third model DSTJs is an extension of DSTs, where local computations are capable of constructing the Cartesian product of two sets. We obtain the following results: (1) DSAs can evaluate first-order queries over bounded degree databases; (2) DSTs can evaluate semijoin algebra queries over arbitrary databases; (3) DSTJs can evaluate the whole relational algebra over arbitrary databases; (4) DSTJs are strictly stronger than DSTs, which in turn, are strictly stronger than DSAs; (5) within DSAs, DSTs and DSTJs there is a strict hierarchy w.r.t. the number of rounds

Implementation of composite semijoins using a variation of Bloom filters.

Different from a centralized database system, distributed query processing involves data transmission among different sites and this communication cost is a dominant factor compared to local processing cost. So, the objective of distributed query optimization is to find strategies to minimize the amount of data transmitted over the network. Since optimal query processing in distributed database systems has been shown to be an NP-hard problem, heuristics are applied to find a near-optimal processing strategy. Previous research has mainly focused on the use of joins, semijoins, and hash semijoins (Bloom filters). The semijoin is a commonly recognized operator, which provides efficient query results. As a variation of semijoin, the composite semijoin is beneficial to do semijoins as one composite rather than as multiple single column semijoins. The Hash semijoin (which uses a Bloom filter) is used to minimize the cost of a semijoin operation. This thesis report provides a summary of each category of query processing techniques and optimization algorithms. Also in this thesis, we propose a new algorithm called Composite Semijoin Filter by combining the idea of composite semijoins, Bloom filters and PERF joins. One of the advantages of this algorithm is to avoid collisions. The algorithm is evaluated and compared with initial feasible solution (IFS) and another filter-based algorithm. It has been shown that the algorithm gives substantial reduction on relations and the total cost.Dept. of Computer Science. Paper copy at Leddy Library: Theses & Major Papers - Basement, West Bldg. / Call Number: Thesis2004 .Z58. Source: Masters Abstracts International, Volume: 43-01, page: 0249. Adviser: Joan Morrissey. Thesis (M.Sc.)--University of Windsor (Canada), 2004

Reduction of collisions in Bloom filters during distributed query optimization.

The goal of distributed query optimization is to find the optimal strategy for the execution of a given query. The approaches in distributed query processing have mainly focused on the use of joins, semijoins, and filters. Semijoins have the advantage over joins in that there are no increases in data sizes. However, a semijoin needs more local processing such as projection and higher data transmission. To improve the distributed query processing, the filter-based approach is utilized. One of the limitations of this approach is collisions. We investigate how collisions affect the performance of the algorithm and how performance can be improved given those collisions. Our proposed algorithm utilizes two sets of filters to reduce the collisions, so the performance has been improved when collisions exist. Our proposed algorithm is evaluated objectively by comparison to a full reducer which is the algorithm that fully reduces all relations involved in a query by eliminating all non-participating tuples from the relations. The results of the evaluation show that: (1) With a perfect hash function, on average, our algorithm eliminates 97.41% of the unneeded data and fully reduces the relations of over 70% of the queries. (2) Using a single set of filters with specific percentages of collisions, on average, less than half of a queries are fully reduced by the algorithm. Therefore, the collisions substantially affects the performance. (3) Using two sets of filters, On average, our algorithm eliminates 95% of noncontributive tuples and achieves over 60% full reduction. In conclusion, our improved algorithm utilizes the two sets of filters to reduce the effects of collisions substantially. Therefore, we improve the performance of our algorithm under the assumption of collisions which is the major problem in using Bloom filters during distributed query optimization.Dept. of Computer Science. Paper copy at Leddy Library: Theses & Major Papers - Basement, West Bldg. / Call Number: Thesis1999 .L53. Source: Masters Abstracts International, Volume: 39-02, page: 0528. Adviser: Joan Morrissey. Thesis (M.Sc.)--University of Windsor (Canada), 1999

Comparing MapReduce and pipeline implementations for counting triangles

A common method to define a parallel solution for a computational problem consists in finding a way to use the Divide and Conquer paradigm in order to have processors acting on its own data and scheduled in a parallel fashion. MapReduce is a programming model that follows this paradigm, and allows for the definition of efficient solutions by both decomposing a problem into steps on subsets of the input data and combining the results of each step to produce final results. Albeit used for the implementation of a wide variety of computational problems, MapReduce performance can be negatively affected whenever the replication factor grows or the size of the input is larger than the resources available at each processor. In this paper we show an alternative approach to implement the Divide and Conquer paradigm, named dynamic pipeline. The main features of dynamic pipelines are illustrated on a parallel implementation of the well-known problem of counting triangles in a graph. This problem is especially interesting either when the input graph does not fit in memory or is dynamically generated. To evaluate the properties of pipeline, a dynamic pipeline of processes and an ad-hoc version of MapReduce are implemented in the language Go, exploiting its ability to deal with channels and spawned processes. An empirical evaluation is conducted on graphs of different topologies, sizes, and densities. Observed results suggest that dynamic pipelines allows for an efficient implementation of the problem of counting triangles in a graph, particularly, in dense and large graphs, drastically reducing the execution time with respect to the MapReduce implementation.Peer ReviewedPostprint (published version

Compressed positionally encoded record filters in distributed query processing.

Different from a centralized database system, distributed query processing involves data transmission among distributed sites, which makes reducing transmission cost a major goal for distributed query optimization. A Positionally Encoded Record Filter (PERF) has attracted research attention as a cost-effective operator to reduce transmission cost. A PERF is a bit array generated by relation tuple scan order instead of hashing, so that it inherits the same compact size benefit as a Bloom filter while suffering no loss of join information caused by hash collisions. Our proposed algorithm PERF_C (Compressed PERF) further reduces the transmission cost in algorithm PERF by compressing both the join attributes and the corresponding PERF filters using arithmetic coding. We prove by time complexity analysis that compression is more efficient than sorting, which was proposed by earlier research to remove duplicates in algorithm PERF. Through the experiments on our synthetic testbed with 36 types of distributed queries, algorithm PERF_C effectively reduces the transmission cost with a cost reduction ratio of 62%--77% over IFS. And PERF_C outperforms PERF with a gain of 16%--36% in cost reduction ratio. A new metric to measure the compression speed in bits per second, compression bps , is defined as a guideline to decide when compression is beneficial. When compression overhead is considered, compression is beneficial only if compression bps is faster than data transfer speed. Tested on both randomly generated and specially designed distributed queries, number of join attributes, size of join attributes and relations, level of duplications are identified to be critical database factors affecting compression. Tested under three typical real computing platforms, compression bps is measured over a wide range of data size and falls in the range from 4M b/s to 9M b/s. Compared to the present relatively slow data transfer rate over Internet, compression is found to be an effective means of reducing transmission cost in distributed query processing. Paper copy at Leddy Library: Theses & Major Papers - Basement, West Bldg. / Call Number: Thesis2004 .Z565. Source: Masters Abstracts International, Volume: 43-01, page: 0249. Adviser: J. Morrissey. Thesis (M.Sc.)--University of Windsor (Canada), 2004