Acoustic Wind Tunnel Measurements of a Quadcopter in Hover and Forward Flight Conditions

An experimental testing campaign was conducted in the NASA Langley Low Speed Aeroacoustic Wind Tunnel (LSAWT) in order to better understand the acoustic characteristics of a representative quadcopter system in both hover and forward flight conditions. Aerodynamic performance measurements were acquired using a multi-axis load cell to trim the vehicle to desired thrust/lift conditions. Hover acoustic measurements provide evidence of prominent rotor-airframe interaction noise that manifests in the form of high-amplitude harmonics of the fundamental rotor blade passage frequency. Forward flight acoustic measurements of simultaneous rotor operations indicate the presence of strong forward-aft rotor wake interactions that yield increased broadband noise levels relative to cases of individual rotor operation. These results indicate the potential need for modeling complex noise generation mechanisms associated with multirotor and rotor-airframe interactions for vehicles of this class

Initial Developments Toward an Active Noise Control System for Small Unmanned Aerial Systems

Small unmanned aerial systems have the potential to expand commercial markets from package delivery to infrastructure inspection. Many missions, however, require the vehicles to operate in close proximity to people, where community noise concerns could ultimately limit vehicle acceptability. Therefore, noise control technologies may be needed to achieve an acceptable noise signature and enable widespread use of these vehicles. The purpose of this paper is to assess the feasibility of using loudspeakers attached to the vehicle to actively reduce noise. More specifically, this initial study explores the possibility of using a single loudspeaker to reduce the noise from an isolated rotor. Tests performed in an anechoic chamber with a 7.6 cm diameter speaker and 23.9 cm diameter rotor are used to demonstrate the potential benefits and limitations of the concept. Results confirm that active noise control can work in this application with measured tonal reductions of over 30 dB in specific directions. However, since the radiation characteristics of the speaker are different than the rotor, amplification is observed in other directions. This technology has the potential to create a cone of silence, which could be steered during flight operations to minimize the impact on noise sensitive areas

On the Use of Acoustic Wind Tunnel Data for the Simulation of sUAS Flyover Noise

Acoustic measurements of a small, unmanned aerial system were recently acquired during a ground test campaign. The purposes of the ground test, conducted in the NASA Langley Low Speed Aeroacoustic Wind Tunnel, were to characterize the source noise in terms of its tonal and broadband content, and to identify conditions under which multirotor and rotor-airframe interactions are present. The focus of this work is to assess the effectiveness of using those data for the simulation of flyover noise at a ground observer. The assessment is made at two levels of fidelity using different sets of tools. In the first, 1/3 octave band spectra at a ground receiver will be simulated in a frequency domain approach using the NASA Aircraft NOise Prediction Program. In the second, the pressure time history at a ground receiver is simulated in a time domain approach using the NASA Auralization Framework. Various objective measures are used to verify the simulation process. Acoustic wind tunnel and flight test data are used to gain insight into perceptually important effects

A Summary of NASA Research Exploring the Acoustics of Small Unmanned Aerial Systems

Proposed uses of small unmanned aerial systems (sUAS) have the potential to expose large portions of communities to a new noise source. In order to understand the potential noise impact of sUAS, NASA initiated acoustics research as one component of the 3-year DELIVER project, with the goal of documenting the feasibility of using existing aircraft design tools and methods on this class of vehicles. This paper summarizes the acoustics research conducted within the DELIVER project. The research described here represents an initial study, and subsequent research building on the findings of this work has been proposed for other NASA projects. The paper summarizes acoustics research in four areas: measurements of noise generated by flyovers of small unmanned aerial vehicles, measurements in controlled test facilities to understand the noise generated by components of these vehicles, computational predictions of component and full vehicle noise, and psychoacoustic tests including auralizations conducted to assess human annoyance to the noise generated by these vehicles

Investigation of Rotor-Airframe Interaction Noise Associated with Small-Scale Rotary-Wing Unmanned Aircraft Systems

In this study, hover acoustic measurements are taken on isolated rotor-airframe configurations representative of smallscale, rotary-wing unmanned aircraft systems (UAS). Each rotor-airframe configuration consists of two fixed-pitch blades powered by a brushless motor, with a simplified airframe geometry intended to represent a generic multicopter arm. In addition to acoustic measurements, CFD-based aeroacoustic predictions are implemented on a subset of the experimentally tested rotor-airframe configurations in an effort to better understand the noise content of the rotor-airframe systems. Favorable agreements are obtained between acoustic measurements and predictions, based on both time- and frequency-domain post-processing techniques. Results indicate that close proximity of airframe surfaces result in the generation of considerable tonal acoustic content in the form of harmonics of the rotor blade passage frequency (BPF). Analysis of the acoustic prediction data shows that the presence of the airframe surfaces can generate noise levels either comparable to or greater than the rotor blade surfaces under certain rotor tip clearance conditions. Analysis of the on-surface Ffowcs Williams and Hawkings (FW-H) source terms provide insight as to the predicted physical noise-generating mechanisms on the rotor and airframe surfaces

Aerodynamic Performance and Acoustic Measurements of a High-Lift Propeller in an Isolated Configuration

A series of aerodynamic performance and acoustic measurements has been made on a high-lift propeller intended for utilization on a distributed electric propulsion (DEP) aircraft. Tests were performed in the NASA Langley Low Speed Aeroacoustic Wind Tunnel (LSAWT), which has recently undergone a capability enhancement for the testing of small propellers/rotors and small unmanned aircraft system (UAS) platforms. The objectives of this testing campaign are two-fold: first to demonstrate the facility capabilities for performing small propeller aeroacoustic testing, and second to compare experimental measurements with computational fluid dynamic (CFD) predictions and CFD-based acoustic predictions of the tested propeller configurations for tool development and validation purposes

Assessment of Geometry and In-Flow Effects on Contra-Rotating Open Rotor Broadband Noise Predictions

Application of previously formulated semi-analytical models for the prediction of broadband noise due to turbulent rotor wake interactions and rotor blade trailing edges is performed on the historical baseline F31/A31 contra-rotating open rotor configuration. Simplified two-dimensional blade element analysis is performed on cambered NACA 4-digit airfoil profiles, which are meant to serve as substitutes for the actual rotor blade sectional geometries. Rotor in-flow effects such as induced axial and tangential velocities are incorporated into the noise prediction models based on supporting computational fluid dynamics (CFD) results and simplified in-flow velocity models. Emphasis is placed on the development of simplified rotor in-flow models for the purpose of performing accurate noise predictions independent of CFD information. The broadband predictions are found to compare favorably with experimental acoustic results

An Exploration of the Performance and Acoustic Characteristics of UAV-Scale Stacked Rotor Configurations

As interest grows in rotor- and propeller-driven electric vertical takeoff and landing (eVTOL) aircraft for the Urban Air Mobility market, there is a potential for previously studied concepts to reemerge due to the opportunities afforded by novel technologies and operating modes. One such concept is the stacked rotor, which consists of multiple co-rotating rotors positioned co-axially with a small axial offset. The goal of the work presented in this paper is to determine whether stacked rotors offer a compelling advantage for eVTOL aircraft in terms of both performance and acoustic characteristics. Results are presented for new experimental tests and computational modeling of multiple stacked rotor configurations, and comparisons are made with conventional rotor configurations. Testing of thirteen separate configurations each using the same blade shaperevealed a configuration that resulted in an increase in the rotor power loading efficiency by more than 7% and reduced noise by more than 3 dBA when compared with a conventional rotor with all blades located in the same rotational plane

Auralization of Tonal Rotor Noise Components of a Quadcopter Flyover

The capabilities offered by small unmanned vertical lift aerial vehicles, for example, quadcopters, continue to captivate entrepreneurs across the private, public, and civil sectors. As this industry rapidly expands, the public will be exposed to these devices (and to the noise these devices generate) with increasing frequency and proximity. Accordingly, an assessment of the human response to these machines will be needed shortly by decision makers in many facets of this burgeoning industry, from hardware manufacturers all the way to government regulators. One factor of this response is that of the annoyance to the noise that is generated by these devices. This paper presents work currently being pursued by NASA toward this goal. First, physics-based (CFD) predictions are performed on a single isolated rotor typical of these devices. The result of these predictions are time records of the discrete tonal components of the rotor noise. These time records are calculated for a number of points that appear on a lattice of locations spread over the lower hemisphere of the rotor. The source noise is then generated by interpolating between these time records. The sound from four rotors are combined and simulated-propagation techniques are used to produce complete flyover auralizations

Isolated Open Rotor Noise Prediction Assessment Using the F31A31 Historical Blade Set

In an effort to mitigate next-generation fuel efficiency and environmental impact concerns for aviation, open rotor propulsion systems have received renewed interest. However, maintaining the high propulsive efficiency while simultaneously meeting noise goals has been one of the challenges in making open rotor propulsion a viable option. Improvements in prediction tools and design methodologies have opened the design space for next generation open rotor designs that satisfy these challenging objectives. As such, validation of aerodynamic and acoustic prediction tools has been an important aspect of open rotor research efforts. This paper describes validation efforts of a combined computational fluid dynamics and Ffowcs Williams and Hawkings equation methodology for open rotor aeroacoustic modeling. Performance and acoustic predictions were made for a benchmark open rotor blade set and compared with measurements over a range of rotor speeds and observer angles. Overall, the results indicate that the computational approach is acceptable for assessing low-noise open rotor designs. Additionally, this approach may be used to provide realistic incident source fields for acoustic shielding/scattering studies on various aircraft configurations