Cell-Mediated Immunity to AAV Vectors, Evolving Concepts and Potential Solutions

International audienceAdeno-associated virus (AAV) vectors are one of the most efficient in vivo gene delivery platforms. Over the past decade, clinical trials of AAV vector-mediated gene transfer led to some of the most exciting results in the field of gene therapy and, recently, to the market approval of an AAV-based drug in Europe. With clinical development, however, it became obvious that the host immune system represents an important obstacle to successful gene transfer with AAV vectors. In this review article, we will discuss the issue of cytotoxic T cell responses directed against the AAV capsid encountered on human studies. While over the past several years the field has acquired a tremendous amount of information on the interactions of AAV vectors with the immune system, a lot of questions are still unanswered. Novel concepts are emerging, such as the relationship between the total capsid dose and the T cell-mediated clearance of transduced cells, the potential role of innate immunity in vector immunogenicity highlighted in preclinical studies, and the cross talk between regulatory and effector T cells in the determination of the outcome of gene transfer. There is still a lot to learn about immune responses in AAV gene transfer, for example, it is not well understood what are the determinants of the kinetics of activation of T cells in response to vector administration, why not all subjects develop detrimental T cell responses following gene transfer, and whether the intervention strategies currently in use to block T cell-mediated clearance of transduced cells will be safe and effective for all gene therapy indications. Results from novel preclinical models and clinical studies will help to address these points and to reach the important goal of developing safe and effective gene therapy protocols to treat human diseases

Modulation of CD8\u3csup\u3e+\u3c/sup\u3e T cell responses to AAV vectors with IgG-derived MHC class II epitopes

Immune responses directed against viral capsid proteins constitute a main safety concern in the use of adeno-associated virus (AAV) as gene transfer vectors in humans. Pharmacological immunosuppression has been proposed as a solution to the problem; however, the approach suffers from several potential limitations. Using MHC class II epitopes initially identified within human IgG, named Tregitopes, we showed that it is possible to modulate CD8+ T cell responses to several viral antigens in vitro. We showed that incubation of peripheral blood mononuclear cells with these epitopes triggers proliferation of CD4+CD25+FoxP3+ T cells that suppress killing of target cells loaded with MHC class I antigens in an antigen- specific fashion, through a mechanism that seems to require cell-to-cell contact. Expression of a construct encoding for the AAV capsid structural protein fused to Tregitopes resulted in reduction of CD8+ T cell reactivity against the AAV capsid following immunization with an adenoviral vector expressing capsid. This was accompanied by an increase in frequency of CD4+CD25+FoxP3+ T cells in spleens and lower levels of inflammatory infiltrates in injected tissues. This proof-of-concept study demonstrates modulation of CD8+ T cell reactivity to an antigen using regulatory T cell epitopes is possible

Safety of AAV Factor IX Peripheral Transvenular Gene Delivery to Muscle in Hemophilia B Dogs

Muscle represents an attractive target tissue for adeno-associated virus (AAV) vector–mediated gene transfer for hemophilia B (HB). Experience with direct intramuscular (i.m.) administration of AAV vectors in humans showed that the approach is safe but fails to achieve therapeutic efficacy. Here, we present a careful evaluation of the safety profile (vector, transgene, and administration procedure) of peripheral transvenular administration of AAV-canine factor IX (cFIX) vectors to the muscle of HB dogs. Vector administration resulted in sustained therapeutic levels of cFIX expression. Although all animals developed a robust antibody response to the AAV capsid, no T-cell responses to the capsid antigen were detected by interferon (IFN)-γ enzyme-linked immunosorbent spot (ELISpot). Interleukin (IL)-10 ELISpot screening of lymphocytes showed reactivity to cFIX-derived peptides, and restimulation of T cells in vitro in the presence of the identified cFIX epitopes resulted in the expansion of CD4+FoxP3+IL-10+ T-cells. Vector administration was not associated with systemic inflammation, and vector spread to nontarget tissues was minimal. At the local level, limited levels of cell infiltrates were detected when the vector was administered intravascularly. In summary, this study in a large animal model of HB demonstrates that therapeutic levels of gene transfer can be safely achieved using a novel route of intravascular gene transfer to muscle

Endocytosis of DNA-Hsp65 Alters the pH of the Late Endosome/Lysosome and Interferes with Antigen Presentation

BACKGROUND: Experimental models using DNA vaccine has shown that this vaccine is efficient in generating humoral and cellular immune responses to a wide variety of DNA-derived antigens. Despite the progress in DNA vaccine development, the intracellular transport and fate of naked plasmid DNA in eukaryotic cells is poorly understood, and need to be clarified in order to facilitate the development of novel vectors and vaccine strategies. METHODOLOGY AND PRINCIPAL FINDINGS: Using confocal microscopy, we have demonstrated for the first time that after plasmid DNA uptake an inhibition of the acidification of the lysosomal compartment occurs. This lack of acidification impaired antigen presentation to CD4 T cells, but did not alter the recruitment of MyD88. The recruitment of Rab 5 and Lamp I were also altered since we were not able to co-localize plasmid DNA with Rab 5 and Lamp I in early endosomes and late endosomes/lysosomes, respectively. Furthermore, we observed that the DNA capture process in macrophages was by clathrin-mediated endocytosis. In addition, we observed that plasmid DNA remains in vesicles until it is in a juxtanuclear location, suggesting that the plasmid does not escape into the cytoplasmic compartment. CONCLUSIONS AND SIGNIFICANCE: Taken together our data suggests a novel mechanism involved in the intracellular trafficking of plasmid DNA, and opens new possibilities for the use of lower doses of plasmid DNA to regulate the immune response

Gene therapy for monogenic liver diseases: clinical successes, current challenges and future prospects

Over the last decade, pioneering liver-directed gene therapy trials for haemophilia B have achieved sustained clinical improvement after a single systemic injection of adeno-associated virus (AAV) derived vectors encoding the human factor IX cDNA. These trials demonstrate the potential of AAV technology to provide long-lasting clinical benefit in the treatment of monogenic liver disorders. Indeed, with more than ten ongoing or planned clinical trials for haemophilia A and B and dozens of trials planned for other inherited genetic/metabolic liver diseases, clinical translation is expanding rapidly. Gene therapy is likely to become an option for routine care of a subset of severe inherited genetic/metabolic liver diseases in the relatively near term. In this review, we aim to summarise the milestones in the development of gene therapy, present the different vector tools and their clinical applications for liver-directed gene therapy. AAV-derived vectors are emerging as the leading candidates for clinical translation of gene delivery to the liver. Therefore, we focus on clinical applications of AAV vectors in providing the most recent update on clinical outcomes of completed and ongoing gene therapy trials and comment on the current challenges that the field is facing for large-scale clinical translation. There is clearly an urgent need for more efficient therapies in many severe monogenic liver disorders, which will require careful risk-benefit analysis for each indication, especially in paediatrics

Adenovirus-Associated Virus Vector-Mediated Gene Transfer in Hemophilia B

NIHR (RP-PG-0310-1001), the Medical Research Council, the Katharine Dormandy Trust, the U.K. Department of Health, NHS Blood and Transplant, the NIHR Biomedical Research Centers (to University College London Hospital and University College London), the ASSISI Foundation of Memphis, the American Lebanese Syrian Associated Charities, the Howard Hughes Medical Institute, the National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute (HL094396), the Royal Free Hospital Charity Special Trustees Fund 35, the Royal Free Hospital NHS Trust, and St. Jude Children’s Research Hospita

Efficacy and Tolerability of Cyclophosphamide in Multiple Sclerosis: A retrospective Analysis

Cyclophosphamid (Endoxan) ist ein zytostatisches Medikament, welches wegen seiner immunsuppressiven Wirkung eine breite Anwendung in der Therapie systemischer Autoimmunerkrankungen findet. Es wird als Medikation bei schwerer chronisch-progressiver Multipler Sklerose empfohlen, um die weitere Progredienz einzuschränken oder zu verhindern. Bisherige klinische Studien über den Wert dieses therapeutischen Einsatzes liefern aber kontroverse Ergebnisse. Aus diesem Grund erschien es sinnvoll, die über einen längeren Zeitraum an der Neurologischen Universitätsklinik Würzburg mit der Cyclophosphamid-Therapie bei MS-Patienten gesammelten Erfahrungen in einer retrospektiven Analyse darzustellen. Patienten und Methoden: Zwischen 1983 und 2000 wurden 118 MS Patienten (75 Frauen, 43 Männer, durchschnittliches Alter zu Beginn der Therapie 46,6 ± 8,5 Jahre, durchschnittliche Krankheitsdauer zu Beginn der Therapie 9,7 ± 5,1 Jahre) mit Cyclophosphamid behandelt. 103 Patienten (87%) litten an chronisch progressiver MS (69 SPMS, 25 PPMS, 5 CP, 4 CP mit RR) und 2 an einem schubförmigen Verlauf. Bei den meisten Patienten war eine rapide Verschlechterung (Mittlerer EDSS-Wert 6,5), mit Gefahr des Gehverlustes, Grund für den Therapiebeginn. Die Induktionstherapie wurde mit 350 mg/m2 Körperoberfläche Cyclophosphamid, zumeist in Kombination mit 1000mg Methylprednisolon, über 3 - 5 Tage eingeleitet und mit 600 - 1000 mg/m2 in 4 - 12-wöchigen Abständen beibehalten. Die EDSS-Werte wurden zu Beginn, jährlich und nach Beendigung der Therapie erfasst. Der Progressions-Index wurde als Quotient aus EDSS-Wert und Krankheitsdauer definiert. Ergebnisse: 63 Patienten erhielten Cyclophosphamid länger als ein Jahr und wurden eingehender untersucht. Die vorherrschenden Gründe für einen vorzeitigen Therapieabbruch waren weitere Progression (n=18) oder nicht tolerable Nebenwirkungen (n=9). Zwei Patienten nahmen die Therapie nach einer Pause wieder auf. Die länger als ein Jahr behandelten Patienten vertrugen die Therapie gut. Nebenwirkungen wurden von 82 % berichtet, wobei die meisten als mild bezeichnet wurden (WHO Grad 1). Bei 9 % waren sie schwerwiegend (WHO Grad 2), bei weiteren 10 % führten sie zum Therapieabbruch (WHO Grad 3). Die durchschnittliche Behandlungsdauer betrug 28,8 +/- 12,3 Monate, mit einer durchschnittlichen kumulativen Dosis von 12,3 ± 7,4 g. Der durchschnittliche Nachbeobachtungszeitraum betrug 39,3 ± 28,7 Monate. Der mittlere EDSS-Wert stieg signifikant von 5,0 auf 6,25 in den zwei Jahren vor Therapiebeginn, blieb stabil während der Behandlung und stieg nach Beendigung der Therapie weiter auf 7,0. Parallel dazu war der Progressions-Index am höchsten bei Therapiebeginn mit 0,64, fiel zum Ende der Therapie auf 0,50 und sank weiter auf 0,44 während des Follow-Ups. 71% blieben stabil während der Behandlung, 13% verbesserten sich, und 16% verschlechterten sich. Schlussfolgerung: Die Daten dieser retrospektiven Analyse zeigen, dass bei Versagen der Standardtherapie einer schweren chronisch-progredienten Multiplen Sklerose Cyclophosphamid in Form einer Induktionstherapie mit Auffrischzyklen alle 4-12 Wochen im Rahmen einer Eskalationstherapie effektiv und vertretbaren NW eingesetzt werden kann.Cyclophosphamide is a cytostatic medication is widely appied due to its immuno-suppressive potential in the thapy of auto-immun diseases. It is recommended in the treatment of multiple sclerosis in order to prevent further disease progression although clinical evidence is limited. This retrospective study evaluates clinical data of the University Hospital of Neurology, Wuerzburg. Results: Cyclophosphamid is effective and safe in therapy-refractory Multiple sclerosis

Preclinical Assessment of Immune Responses to AAV (adeno-associated virus) Vectors

Transitioning to human trials from preclinical models resulted in the emergence of inhibitory AAV vector immune responses which has become a hurdle for sustained correction. Early animal studies did not predict the full range of host immunity to the AAV vector in human studies. While pre-existing antibody titers against AAV vectors has been a lingering concern, cytotoxic T-cell (CTL) responses against the input capsid can prevent long-term therapy in humans. These discoveries spawned more thorough profiling of immune response to rAAV in pre-clinical models, which have assessed both innate and adaptive immunity, and explored methods for bypassing these responses. Many efforts towards measuring innate immunity have utilized Toll-Like Receptor (TLR) deficient models and have focused on differential responses to viral capsid and genome. From adaptive studies, it is clear that humoral responses are relevant for initial vector transduction efficiency while cellular responses impact long-term outcomes of gene transfer. Measuring humoral responses to AAV vectors has utilized in vitro neutralizing antibody (NAb) assays and transfer of seropositive serum to immunodeficient mice. Overcoming antibodies using CD20 inhibitors, plasmapheresis, altering route of delivery and using different capsids have been explored. CTL responses were measured using in vitro and in vivo models. In in vitro assays expansion of antigen-specific T cells as well as cytotoxicity towards AAV transduced cells can be shown. Many groups have successfully mimicked antigen-specific T cell proliferation, but actual transgene level reduction and parameters of cytotoxicity towards transduced target cells has only been shown in one model. The model utilized adoptive transfer of capsid specific in vitro expanded T-cells isolated from immunized mice with LPS as an adjuvant. Finally, the development of immune tolerance to AAV vectors by enriching regulatory T-cells has also been explored as well as modulating

Immune responses to AAV vectors, from bench to bedside

The recent wave of clinical studies demonstrating long-term therapeutic efficacy highlights the enormous potential of gene therapy as an approach to the treatment of inherited disorders and cancer. While in recent years lentiviral vectors have dominated the field of ex vivo gene therapy in man, adeno-associated virus (AAV) vectors have become the platform of choice for the in vivo gene delivery, both local and systemic.Despite the achievements in the clinic however, a number of hurdles remain to be overcome in gene therapy, these include availability of scalable vector production systems, potential issues associated with insertional mutagenesis, and concerns related to immunogenicity of gene therapeutics. For AAV vectors, clinical trials showed that immunity directed against the vector could either prevent transduction of a target tissue or limit the duration of therapeutic efficacy. Initial observations in the context of a gene therapy trial for hemophilia spurred over a decade efforts by gene therapists and immunologists to understand the mechanism and identify factors that contribute to AAV’s immunogenicity, including the prevalence of B cell and T cell immunity to wild type AAV in humans and the interaction of AAV vectors with the innate and adaptive immune system. Despite a number of important contributions in particular in the more recent past, our knowledge on the immunology of gene transfer is still rudimental; this is partly due to the fact that the basic understanding of the complex balance between tolerance and immunity to an antigen, key aspect of gene transfer with AAV, keeps evolving rapidly. However, continuing work towards a better definition of the interaction of viral vectors with the immune system has led to significant advances in the knowledge of the factors influencing the outcome of gene transfer, such as the vector dose, the immune privilege of certain tissues, and the induction of tolerance to an antigen. A better understanding of the structure-function relationship of the viral capsid has boosted the development of novel immune-escape vector variants. In addition, novel immunomodulatory strategies were established to prevent or reduce anti-capsid immunity have been developed and are being tested in preclinical models and in clinical trials. Together, these advances are bringing us closer to the goal of achieving safe and sustained therapeutic gene transfer in humans. In this research topic, a collection of Original Research and Review Articles highlights critical aspects of the interaction between gene AAV vectors and the immune system, discussing how these interactions can be either detrimental or constitute an advantage, depending on the context of gene transfer, and providing tools and resources to better understand the issue of immunogenicity of AAV vectors in gene transfer