The robot who tried too hard: social behaviour of a robot tutor can negatively affect child learning

Social robots are finding increasing application in the domain of education, particularly for children, to support and augment learning opportunities. With an implicit assumption that social and adaptive behaviour is desirable, it is therefore of interest to determine precisely how these aspects of behaviour may be exploited in robots to support children in their learning. In this paper, we explore this issue by evaluating the effect of a social robot tutoring strategy with children learning about prime numbers. It is shown that the tutoring strategy itself leads to improvement, but that the presence of a robot employing this strategy amplifies this effect, resulting in significant learning. However, it was also found that children interacting with a robot using social and adaptive behaviours in addition to the teaching strategy did not learn a significant amount. These results indicate that while the presence of a physical robot leads to improved learning, caution is required when applying social behaviour to a robot in a tutoring context

Nonverbal immediacy as a characterisation of social behaviour for human-robot interaction

An increasing amount of research has started to explore the impact of robot social behaviour on the outcome of a goal for a human interaction partner, such as cognitive learning gains. However, it remains unclear from what principles the social behaviour for such robots should be derived. Human models are often used, but in this paper an alternative approach is proposed. First, the concept of nonverbal immediacy from the communication literature is introduced, with a focus on how it can provide a characterisation of social behaviour, and the subsequent outcomes of such behaviour. A literature review is conducted to explore the impact on learning of the social cues which form the nonverbal immediacy measure. This leads to the production of a series of guidelines for social robot behaviour. The resulting behaviour is evaluated in a more general context, where both children and adults judge the immediacy of humans and robots in a similar manner, and their recall of a short story is tested. Children recall more of the story when the robot is more immediate, which demonstrates an e�ffect predicted by the literature. This study provides validation for the application of nonverbal immediacy to child-robot interaction. It is proposed that nonverbal immediacy measures could be used as a means of characterising robot social behaviour for human-robot interaction

Social robot tutoring for child second language learning

An increasing amount of research is being conducted to determine how a robot tutor should behave socially in educa- tional interactions with children. Both human-human and human- robot interaction literature predicts an increase in learning with increased social availability of a tutor, where social availability has verbal and nonverbal components. Prior work has shown that greater availability in the nonverbal behaviour of a robot tutor has a positive impact on child learning. This paper presents a study with 67 children to explore how social aspects of a tutor robot’s speech influences their perception of the robot and their language learning in an interaction. Children perceive the difference in social behaviour between ‘low’ and ‘high’ verbal availability conditions, and improve significantly between a pre- and a post-test in both conditions. A longer-term retention test taken the following week showed that the children had retained almost all of the information they had learnt. However, learning was not affected by which of the robot behaviours they had been exposed to. It is suggested that in this short-term interaction context, additional effort in developing social aspects of a robot’s verbal behaviour may not return the desired positive impact on learning gains

Toward supervised reinforcement learning with partial states for social HRI

Social interacting is a complex task for which machine learning holds particular promise. However, as no sufficiently accurate simulator of human interactions exists today, the learning of social interaction strategies has to happen online in the real world. Actions executed by the robot impact on humans, and as such have to be carefully selected, making it impossible to rely on random exploration. Additionally, no clear reward function exists for social interactions. This implies that traditional approaches used for Reinforcement Learning cannot be directly applied for learning how to interact with the social world. As such we argue that robots will profit from human expertise and guidance to learn social interactions. However, as the quantity of input a human can provide is limited, new methods have to be designed to use human input more efficiently. In this paper we describe a setup in which we combine a framework called Supervised Progressively Autonomous Robot Competencies (SPARC), which allows safer online learning with Reinforcement Learning, with the use of partial states rather than full states to accelerate generalisation and obtain a usable action policy more quickly

SPARC: an efficient way to combine reinforcement learning and supervised autonomy

Shortcomings of reinforcement learning for robot control include the sparsity of the environmental reward function, the high number of trials required before reaching an efficient action policy and the reliance on exploration to gather information about the environment, potentially resulting in undesired actions. These limits can be overcome by adding a human in the loop to provide additional information during the learning phase. In this paper, we propose a novel way to combine human inputs and reinforcement by following the Supervised Progressively Autonomous Robot Competencies (SPARC) approach. We compare this method to the principles of Interactive Reinforcement Learning as proposed by Thomaz and Breazeal. Results from a study involving 40 participants show that using SPARC increases the performance of the learning, reduces the time and number of inputs required for teaching and faces fewer errors during the learning process. These results support the use of SPARC as an efficient method to teach a robot to interact with humans

Teaching robots social autonomy from in situ human guidance

Striking the right balance between robot autonomy and human control is a core challenge in social robotics, in both technical and ethical terms. On the one hand, extended robot autonomy offers the potential for increased human productivity and for the off-loading of physical and cognitive tasks. On the other hand, making the most of human technical and social expertise, as well as maintaining accountability, is highly desirable. This is particularly relevant in domains such as medical therapy and education, where social robots hold substantial promise, but where there is a high cost to poorly performing autonomous systems, compounded by ethical concerns. We present a field study in which we evaluate SPARC (supervised progressively autonomous robot competencies), an innovative approach addressing this challenge whereby a robot progressively learns appropriate autonomous behavior from in situ human demonstrations and guidance. Using online machine learning techniques, we demonstrate that the robot could effectively acquire legible and congruent social policies in a high-dimensional child-tutoring situation needing only a limited number of demonstrations while preserving human supervision whenever desirable. By exploiting human expertise, our technique enables rapid learning of autonomous social and domain-specific policies in complex and nondeterministic environments. Last, we underline the generic properties of SPARC and discuss how this paradigm is relevant to a broad range of difficult human-robot interaction scenarios

From Penguins to Parakeets: a Developmental Approach to Modelling Conceptual Prototypes

The use of concepts is a fundamental capacity underlying complex, human-level cognition. A number of theories have explored the means of concept representation and their links to lower-level features, with one notable example being the Conceptual Spaces theory. While these provide an account for such essential functional processes as prototypes and typicality, it is not entirely clear how these aspects of human cognition can arise in a system undergoing continuous development - postulated to be a necessity from the developmental systems perspective. This paper seeks to establish the foundation of an approach to this question by showing that a distributed, associative and continuous development mechanism, founded on principles of biological memory, can achieve classification performance comparable to the Conceptual Spaces model. We show how qualitatively similar prototypes are formed by both systems when exposed to the same dataset, which illustrates how both models can account for the development of conceptual primitives

A Cautionary Note on Personality (Extroversion) Assessments in Child-Robot Interaction Studies

The relationship between personality and social human-robot interaction is a topic of increasing interest. There are further some indications from the literature that there is an association between personality dimensions and various aspects of educational behaviour and performance. This brief contribution seeks to explore the single personality dimension of extroversion/introversion: specifically, how children rate them- selves with a validated questionnaire in comparison to how teachers rate them using a relative scale. In an exploratory study conducted in a primary school, we find a non-significant association between these two ratings. We suggest that this mismatch is related to the context in which the respective ratings were made. In order to facilitate generalisation of personality- related results across studies, we propose two general reporting recommendations. Based on our results, we suggest that the application of personality assessments in a child-robot interaction context may be more complex than initially envisaged, with some dependence on context

From characterising three years of HRI to methodology and reporting recommendations

Human-Robot Interaction (HRI) research requires the integration and cooperation of multiple disciplines, technical and social, in order to make progress. In many cases using different motivations, each of these disciplines bring with them different assumptions and methodologies.We assess recent trends in the field of HRI by examining publications in the HRI conference over the past three years (over 100 full papers), and characterise them according to 14 categories.We focus primarily on aspects of methodology. From this, a series of practical rec- ommendations based on rigorous guidelines from other research fields that have not yet become common practice in HRI are proposed. Furthermore, we explore the primary implications of the observed recent trends for the field more generally, in terms of both methodology and research directions.We propose that the interdisciplinary nature of HRI must be maintained, but that a common methodological approach provides a much needed frame of reference to facilitate rigorous future progress

Towards augmenting dialogue strategy management with multimodal sub-symbolic context

Abstract. A synthetic agent requires the coordinated use of multiple sensory and effector modalities in order to achieve a social human-robot interaction (HRI). While systems in which such a concatenation of multiple modalities exist, the issue of information coordination across modalities to identify relevant context information remains problematic. A system-wide information formalism is typically used to address the issue, which requires a re-encoding of all information into the system ontology. We propose a general approach to this information coordination issue, focussing particularly on a potential application to a dialogue strategy learning and selection system embedded within a wider architecture for social HRI. Rather than making use of a common system ontology, we rather emphasise a sub-symbolic association-driven architecture which has the capacity to influence the ‘internal ’ processing of all individual system modalities, without requiring the explicit processing or interpretation of modality-specific information