Lessons Learned from Read-Across Case Studies for Repeated-Dose Toxicity

A series of case studies designed to further acceptance of read-across predictions, especially for chronic health-related endpoints, have been evaluated with regard to the knowledge and insight they provide. A common aim of these case studies was to examine sources of uncertainty associated with read-across. While uncertainty is related to the quality and quantity of the read across endpoint data, uncertainty also includes a variety of other factors, the foremost of which is uncertainty associated with the justification of similarity and quantity and quality of data for the source chemical(s). This investigation has demonstrated that the assessment of uncertainty associated with a similarity justification includes consideration of the information supporting the scientific arguments and the data associated with the chemical, toxicokinetic and toxicodynamic similarity. Similarity in chemistry is often not enough to justify fully a read-across prediction, thus, for chronic health endpoints, toxicokinetic and/or toxicodynamic similarity is essential. Data from New Approach Methodology(ies) including high throughput screening, in vitro and in chemico assay and in silico tools, may provide critical information needed to strengthen the toxicodynamic similarity rationale. In addition, it was shown that toxicokinetic (i.e., ADME) similarity, especially metabolism, is often the driver of the overall uncertainty

Development of a Fragment-Based in Silico Profiler for Michael Addition Thiol Reactivity

The Adverse Outcome Pathway (AOP) paradigm details the existing knowledge that links the initial interaction between a chemical and a biological system, termed the molecular initiating event (MIE), through a series of intermediate events, to an adverse effect. An important example of a well-defined MIE is the formation of a covalent bond between a biological nucleophile and an electrophilic compound. This particular MIE has been associated with various toxicological end points such as acute aquatic toxicity, skin sensitization, and respiratory sensitization. This study has investigated the calculated parameters that are required to predict the rate of chemical bond formation (reactivity) of a dataset of Michael acceptors. Reactivity of these compounds toward glutathione was predicted using a combination of a calculated activation energy value (Eact, calculated using density functional theory (DFT) calculation at the B3YLP/6-31G+(d) level of theory, and solvent-accessible surface area values (SAS) at the α carbon. To further develop the method, a fragment-based algorithm was developed enabling the reactivity to be predicted for Michael acceptors without the need to perform the time-consuming DFT calculations. Results showed the developed fragment method was successful in predicting the reactivity of the Michael acceptors excluding two sets of chemicals: volatile esters with an extended substituent at the β-carbon and chemicals containing a conjugated benzene ring as part of the polarizing group. Additionally the study also demonstrated the ease with which the approach can be extended to other chemical classes by the calculation of additional fragments and their associated Eact and SAS values. The resulting method is likely to be of use in regulatory toxicology tools where an understanding of covalent bond formation as a potential MIE is important within the AOP paradigm

Read-Across for Rat Oral Gavage Repeated-Dose Toxicity for Short-Chain Mono-Alkylphenols: A Case Study

Short-chain mono-alkylphenols provide an example of where a category-approach to read-across may be used to estimate the repeated-dose endpoint for a number of derivatives. Specifically, the NOAELs of 50 mg/kg bw/d for mono-methylphenols based on a LOAEL of very low systemic toxicity can be read across with confidence to untested mono-alkylphenols in the category. These simple alkylphenols are non-reactive and exhibit an unspecific, reversible polar narcosis mode of toxic action. Briefly, polar narcotics act via unspecific, reversible interactions with biological membranes in a manner similar to cataleptic anaesthetics. The read-across premise includes rapid and complete absorption via the gastrointestinal tract, distribution in the circulatory system, first-pass Phase 2 metabolism in the liver, and elimination of sulphates and glucuronides in the urine. Thus, toxicokinetic parameters are considered to be similar and have the same toxicological significance. Five analogues have high quality experimental oral repeated-dose toxicity data (i.e., OECD TG 408 or OECD TG 422). These repeated-dose toxicity test results exhibit qualitative consistency in symptoms. Typical findings include decreased body weight and slightly increased liver and kidney weights which are generally without concurrent histopathological effects. The sub-chronic findings are quantitatively consistent with the No Observed Adverse Effect Level (NOAEL) of ≥ 50 mg/kg bw/d. Chemical similarity between the analogues is readily defined, and data uncertainty associated with the similarities in toxicokinetic properties, as well as toxicodynamic properties, are low. Uncertainty associated with mechanistic relevance and completeness of the read-across is low-to-moderate, largely because there is no adverse outcome pathway or intermediate event data. Uncertainty associated with mechanistic relevance and completeness of the read-across is reduced by the concordance of in vivo, in vitro, USEPA toxicity forecaster (ToxCast) results, as well as the in silico data. The rat oral repeated-dose NOAEL values for the source substances can be read across to fill the data gaps of the untested analogues in this category with uncertainty deemed equivalent to results from a TG 408 assessment

Validation of a fragment-based profiler for thiol reactivity for the prediction of toxicity: skin sensitisation and tetrahymena pyriformis

This study outlines the use of a recently developed fragment-based thiol reactivity profiler for Michael acceptors to predict toxicity towards Tetrahymena pyriformis and skin sensitisation potency as determined in the Local Lymph Node Assay (LLNA). The results showed that the calculated reactivity parameter from the profiler, -log RC50(calc), was capable of predicting toxicity for both endpoints with excellent statistics. However, the study highlighted the importance of a well-defined applicability domain for each endpoint. In terms of Tetrahymena pyriformis this domain was defined in terms of how fast or slowly a given Michael acceptor reacts with thiol leading to two separate quantitative structure-activity models. The first, for fast reacting chemicals required only –Log RC50(calc) as a descriptor, whilst the second required the addition of a descriptor for hydrophobicity. Modelling of the LLNA required only a single descriptor, -log RC50(calc), enabling potency to be predicted. The applicability domain excluded chemicals capable of undergoing polymerisation and those that were predicted to be volatile. The modelling results for both endpoints, using the –log RC50(calc) value from the profiler, were in keeping with previously published studies that have utilised experimentally determined measurements of reactivity. This results demonstrate the output from the fragment-based thiol reactivity profiler can be used to develop quantitative structure-activity relationship models where reactivity towards thiol is a driver of toxicity

Assessing Uncertainty in Read-Across: Questions to Evaluate Toxicity Predictions Based on Knowledge Gained from Case Studies

Read-across as an alternative assessment method for chemical toxicity has growing interest in both the regulatory and industrial communities. The pivotal means of acquiring acceptance of a read-across prediction is identifying and assessing uncertainties associated with it. This study has identified and summarised in a structured way the variety of uncertainties that potentially impact acceptance of a readacross argument. The main sources of uncertainty were established and divided into four main categories: i) the regulatory use of the prediction, ii) the data for the apical endpoint being assessed, iii) the readacross argumentation, and iv) the similarity justification. Specifically, the context of, and relevance to, the regulatory use of a read-across will dictate the acceptable level of uncertainties. The apical endpoint (or other) data must be of sufficient quality and relevance for data gap filling. Read-Across argumentation uncertainties include: 1) mechanistic plausibility (i.e., the knowledge of the chemical and biological mechanisms leading to toxicity), 2) completeness of the supporting evidence, 3) robustness of the supporting data, and 4) Weight-of-Evidence. In addition, similarity arguments for chemistry, physicochemical properties, toxicokinetics and toxicodynamics are linked to these read-across argumentation issues. To further progress in this area, a series of questions are proposed with the goal of addressing each type of uncertainty

Read-across of 90-day rodent repeated-dose toxicity: A case study for selected simple aryl alcohol alkyl carboxylic acid esters

Aryl alcohol alkyl carboxylic acid esters constitute a wide-employed class of fragrance materials. Outcomes presented within this study illustrate formulation of a read-across protocol for 90-day, repeat-dose toxicity within a series of these compounds, extending in scope to the dodecanoic acid esters of both benzyl and 2-phenylethyl alcohol. Central to the filling of data gaps is the hypothesis that adverse impact – mediated through mechanisms analogous to narcosis-associated non-specific basal cytotoxicity – is as a consequence of the hydrolysis of parent compounds to their corresponding alcohol. High-quality in vivo data (equivalent to either OECD Test Guideline 408 or 411) relating the toxicodynamic and toxicokinetic profiles of benzyl alcohol, 2-phenylethyl alcohol and benzyl acetate within rodents were retrieved, permitting extrapolation to each ester derivative with great confidence. NOAEL values of 250-500 mg/kg/day were assigned to esters, with a greater toxicity present within females. In order to greater enhance reliability, further theoretical support for the read-across prediction is provided through the integration, where appropriate, of in vitro and in silico data

Deletion of the GABAA α2-subunit does not alter self dministration of cocaine or reinstatement of cocaine seeking

Rationale GABAA receptors containing α2-subunits are highly represented in brain areas that are involved in motivation and reward, and have been associated with addiction to several drugs, including cocaine. We have shown previously that a deletion of the α2-subunit results in an absence of sensitisation to cocaine. Objective We investigated the reinforcing properties of cocaine in GABAA α2-subunit knockout (KO) mice using an intravenous self-administration procedure. Methods α2-subunit wildtype (WT), heterozygous (HT) and KO mice were trained to lever press for a 30 % condensed milk solution. After implantation with a jugular catheter, mice were trained to lever press for cocaine (0.5 mg/kg/infusion) during ten daily sessions. Responding was extinguished and the mice tested for cue- and cocaine-primed reinstatement. Separate groups of mice were trained to respond for decreasing doses of cocaine (0.25, 0.125, 0.06 and 0.03 mg/kg). Results No differences were found in acquisition of lever pressing for milk. All genotypes acquired self-administration of cocaine and did not differ in rates of self-administration, dose dependency or reinstatement. However, whilst WT and HT mice showed a dose-dependent increase in lever pressing during the cue presentation, KO mice did not. Conclusions Despite a reported absence of sensitisation, motivation to obtain cocaine remains unchanged in KO and HT mice. Reinstatement of cocaine seeking by cocaine and cocaine-paired cues is also unaffected. We postulate that whilst not directly involved in reward perception, the α2-subunit may be involved in modulating the “energising” aspect of cocaine’s effects on reward-seeking

Relationship Between Adverse Outcome Pathways and Chemistry-Based in Silico Models to Predict Toxicity

The current landscape of Adverse Outcome Pathways (AOPs) provides a means of organising information relating to the adverse effects elicited following exposure to chemicals. As such, AOPs are an excellent driver for the development and application of in silico models for predictive toxicology allowing for the direct relationship between chemistry and adverse effects to be established. Information may be extracted from AOPs to support the creation of (quantitative) structure-activity relationships ((Q)SARs) as well as to increase confidence in grouping and read-across. Any part of an AOP can be linked to these various types of in silico models. There is, however, an emphasis on using information from known Molecular Initiating Events (MIEs) to create models including 2D and 3D structural alerts, SARs and QSARs. MIEs can be classified according to the nature of the interaction e.g. covalent reactivity, oxidative stress, phototoxicity, chronic receptor mediated, acute enzyme inhibition, unspecific, physical and other effects. Different types of MIEs require different approaches to their in silico modelling. Modelling Key Events and Key Event Relationships is useful if they represent the rate limiting step or key determinant of toxicity. Modelling of metabolism and chemical interactions will become part of AOP networks, which are also driving species-specific extrapolation and respective adaptation of models. With more information and data being captured, in silico approaches will increasingly support the application of knowledge from AOPs to build weight of evidence and support risk assessment, e.g. in the context of Integrated Assessment and Testing Approaches (IATAs)

Disposition of Federally Owned Surpluses

PDZ domains are scaffolding modules in protein-protein interactions that mediate numerous physiological functions by interacting canonically with the C-terminus or non-canonically with an internal motif of protein ligands. A conserved carboxylate-binding site in the PDZ domain facilitates binding via backbone hydrogen bonds; however, little is known about the role of these hydrogen bonds due to experimental challenges with backbone mutations. Here we address this interaction by generating semisynthetic PDZ domains containing backbone amide-to-ester mutations and evaluating the importance of individual hydrogen bonds for ligand binding. We observe substantial and differential effects upon amide-to-ester mutation in PDZ2 of postsynaptic density protein 95 and other PDZ domains, suggesting that hydrogen bonding at the carboxylate-binding site contributes to both affinity and selectivity. In particular, the hydrogen-bonding pattern is surprisingly different between the non-canonical and canonical interaction. Our data provide a detailed understanding of the role of hydrogen bonds in protein-protein interactions

The Social Construction of Competition for Graduate Jobs: A Comparison between Great Britain and the Netherlands

This article examines how Dutch and British students socially construct the positional competition for jobs within their educational and labour market contexts. The findings illustrate two contrasting approaches to employability. The competition for jobs as understood by the Dutch students is based on absolute performance, an unclear relationship between skills and the labour market, and the development of human capital in areas of experiences, skills and abilities. For the British students it is based on relative performance, ranking of candidates and the importance of signals. The study also shows that these principles are aligned to national labour market and educational contexts. These results highlight the importance of the institutional context in how the positional competition for graduate jobs is played out