Morality and the nation: law, pornography and Indonesia's Islamic Defenders Front

© 2013 Dr. Helen PausackerThis thesis examines how largely symbolic law reforms can be used to establish and enforce societal norms. In 2005-6, Indonesia’s Islamic Defenders Front (Front Pembela Islam, FPI) campaigned for the controversial Anti-Pornography Bill. It reported three alleged violations of Criminal Code (KUHP) provisions prohibiting pornography to the police: an artwork (Pinkswing Park), Indonesian Playboy (which had no nudes) and Indonesian Princess (Puteri Indonesia) 2005, a Miss Universe entrant. Between them, these cases represent three contentious areas regulated in Indonesia’s controversial Pornography Bill (the arts, the media and display of the human body). This Bill caused heated debate across Indonesia between two opposing groups. On the one hand, conservative Muslims argued that the state should legislate to ensure the upholding of the nation’s morality, according to Islamic values. On the other, progressive Muslims and others opposed the Bill, including ethnic and religious minorities and artists. This latter group argued that religion and morality should be personal issues and responsibilities. Despite their objections, the Bill was passed as Law No 44 on Pornography in 2008. Of the three cases reported by FPI, only Playboy proceeded to court, progressing through appeals, until the prosecutors reached the Supreme Court on cassation (kasasi). Here the editor of Playboy was found guilty on charges of violating the prohibition of pornography in the KUHP and was imprisoned. This decision, however, was overturned in a Reconsideration (Peninjauan Kembali or final appeal) judgment in the Supreme Court. Although this may seem like a set-back for FPI, this thesis argues that, in fact, these cases may have been reported more as publicity for the Pornography Bill than to punish the individuals involved. This relates to the wider question of how law is used to effect change in Indonesian society and whether the chief purpose for passing the Pornography Law was largely symbolic, given that there have long been Articles in the KUHP which prohibited pornography. Drawing on the theories of Islamic legal concepts as a type of legal transplant, the symbolic nature of law, and law as a field in the struggle for power, this thesis investigates each case, to develop insights into the nature of Islamisation in contemporary Indonesia. It concludes that while some conservative Islamist groups are pushing for their form of Islam to be enforced through legislation, the struggle for Islamisation is one that is in progress rather than concluded, and it remains contested