Fingerprinting stress: stylolite and calcite twinning paleopiezometry revealing the complexity of progressive stress patterns during folding-the case of the Monte Nero anticline in the Apennines, Italy

In this study we show for the first time how quantitative stress estimates can be derived by combining calcite twinning and stylolite roughness stress fingerprinting techniques in a fold-and-thrust belt. First, we present a new method that gives access to stress inversion using tectonic stylolites without access to the stylolite surface and compare results with calcite twin inversion. Second, we use our new approach to present a high-resolution deformation and stress history that affected Meso-Cenozoic limestone strata in the Monte Nero Anticline during its late Miocene-Pliocene growth in the Umbria-Marche Arcuate Ridge (northern Apennines, Italy). In this area an extensive stylolite-joint/vein network developed during layer-parallel shortening (LPS), as well as during and after folding. Stress fingerprinting illustrates how stress in the sedimentary strata did build up prior to folding during LPS. The stress regime oscillated between strike slip and compressional during LPS before ultimately becoming strike slip again during late stage fold tightening. Our case study shows that high-resolution stress fingerprinting is possible and that this novel method can be used to unravel temporal relationships that relate to local variations of regional orogenic stresses. Beyond regional implications, this study validates our approach as a new powerful toolbox to high-resolution stress fingerprinting in basins and orogens combining joint and vein analysis with sedimentary and tectonic stylolite and calcite twin inversion techniques

Quantification des paléocontraintes par l'analyse des macles de la calcite : nouvelle approche d'acquisition et d'inversion des données et mécaniques du maclage

The understanding and modelling of deformation mechanics in the upper crust are important scientific and technical issues. The calcite is a common mineral in the upper crust and mainly deforms by twinning under 200°C. That is why we are interested by calcite twinning as part of this thesis. It is not the first time that calcite twinning is used to reconstruct paleostress or paleostrain tensors. This thesis propose a new inversion method based on the Etchecopar’s one allowing to reconstruct 5 among 6 parameters of the stress tensor with an accurate quantification of the uncertainties. This method allows to automatically detect the realness of one or several tectonic events recorded by calcite twinning. A second part of the thesis consists in the improvement of the data acquisition by using EBSD (electron backscatter diffraction). In fact, the traditional use of the universal stage has technical limitations and brings some optical doubt about the untwinned status of few planes in addition to the long and tedious side. The last part of the thesis consists in the establishing the threshold of calcite twinning for different grain sizes by mechanical tests under a uniaxial press. Moreover, the continuous monitoring of the experiments using single crystals of calcite allowed to highlight the macroscopic behavior of a single crystal and the sequence of twinning.La compréhension et la simulation des mécanismes de déformation dans la croûte supérieure sont des enjeux scientifiques et techniques importants. La calcite étant un minéral commun de la croûte supérieure se déformant essentiellement par maclage sous 200 °C, c'est pour cette raison que l'on s'intéresse plus particulièrement au maclage de la calcite dans le cadre de cette thèse. L'utilisation du maclage de la calcite n'en est pas à son coup d'essai et de nombreuses méthodes d'inversions existent que ce soit pour remonter aux tenseurs des contraintes comme aux tenseurs des déformations. Cette thèse propose une nouvelle méthode d'inversion basée sur l'inversion d'Etchopar permettant de reconstruire 5 sur 6 paramètres du tenseur des contraintes avec une quantification fine des incertitudes. Cette méthode permet de détecter automatiquement l'existence d'un ou de plusieurs évènements tectoniques enregistrés par le maclage de la calcite. Un deuxième volet de la thèse consiste en l'amélioration de la méthode d'acquisition des données de macles en utilisant un EBSD (electron backscatter diffraction). En effet, l'utilisation traditionnelle de la platine universelle a des limitations techniques et amène aussi à un doute visuel sur l'appréciation du statut non-maclé de certains plans, en plus du côté long et fastidieux. Le dernier volet de la thèse consiste à déterminer le seuil de maclage de la calcite pour différentes tailles de grains à l'aide de tests mécaniques sous une presse uniaxiale. Qui plus est, le suivi en continu des déformations sur les monocristaux de calcite a permis de mettre en évidence le comportement macroscopique d'un cristal de calcite et la séquence de maclage

In-Situ Evolution of Calcite Twinning during Uniaxial Compression of Carrara Marble at Room Temperature

Calcite twinning is a dominant deformation mechanism at low temperatures. It is often used to reconstruct paleostresses: orientations of the principal stress axes, stress ratios and differential stress. Despite numerous studies, on single crystals and aggregates, questions remain about the initiation and evolution of the twinning. In particular, the existence of a critical value for the activation of twin planes is debated. In this study, Carrara marble samples were uniaxially deformed at low temperature. The experiments were monitored in situ in an SEM (Scanning Electron Microscope) and a deformation analysis was performed at regular intervals using image correlation. Image correlation analysis shows the link between the overconcentration of strains and the appearance of the first twinned planes. This is followed by a densification and a gradual thickening of the twin lamellae. Fracturing only appears in a third stage as a precursor to the collapse of the sample. The inversion, using the CSIT-2 technique, showed that the twinned planes are globally related to the applied macroscopic stress. The inversion allows one to retrieve the macroscopic stress tensor. Schmid factors were extracted from this analysis and correlated to the loading curves. For crystals of about 200 µm diameter, the threshold value is in between 6.75 and 8.25 MPa

Paleostresses quantification by calcite twin analysis : new data acquisition and inversion approach and twinning mechanics

La compréhension et la simulation des mécanismes de déformation dans la croûte supérieure sont des enjeux scientifiques et techniques importants. La calcite étant un minéral commun de la croûte supérieure se déformant essentiellement par maclage sous 200 °C, c'est pour cette raison que l'on s'intéresse plus particulièrement au maclage de la calcite dans le cadre de cette thèse. L'utilisation du maclage de la calcite n'en est pas à son coup d'essai et de nombreuses méthodes d'inversions existent que ce soit pour remonter aux tenseurs des contraintes comme aux tenseurs des déformations. Cette thèse propose une nouvelle méthode d'inversion basée sur l'inversion d'Etchopar permettant de reconstruire 5 sur 6 paramètres du tenseur des contraintes avec une quantification fine des incertitudes. Cette méthode permet de détecter automatiquement l'existence d'un ou de plusieurs évènements tectoniques enregistrés par le maclage de la calcite. Un deuxième volet de la thèse consiste en l'amélioration de la méthode d'acquisition des données de macles en utilisant un EBSD (electron backscatter diffraction). En effet, l'utilisation traditionnelle de la platine universelle a des limitations techniques et amène aussi à un doute visuel sur l'appréciation du statut non-maclé de certains plans, en plus du côté long et fastidieux. Le dernier volet de la thèse consiste à déterminer le seuil de maclage de la calcite pour différentes tailles de grains à l'aide de tests mécaniques sous une presse uniaxiale. Qui plus est, le suivi en continu des déformations sur les monocristaux de calcite a permis de mettre en évidence le comportement macroscopique d'un cristal de calcite et la séquence de maclage.The understanding and modelling of deformation mechanics in the upper crust are important scientific and technical issues. The calcite is a common mineral in the upper crust and mainly deforms by twinning under 200°C. That is why we are interested by calcite twinning as part of this thesis. It is not the first time that calcite twinning is used to reconstruct paleostress or paleostrain tensors. This thesis propose a new inversion method based on the Etchecopar’s one allowing to reconstruct 5 among 6 parameters of the stress tensor with an accurate quantification of the uncertainties. This method allows to automatically detect the realness of one or several tectonic events recorded by calcite twinning. A second part of the thesis consists in the improvement of the data acquisition by using EBSD (electron backscatter diffraction). In fact, the traditional use of the universal stage has technical limitations and brings some optical doubt about the untwinned status of few planes in addition to the long and tedious side. The last part of the thesis consists in the establishing the threshold of calcite twinning for different grain sizes by mechanical tests under a uniaxial press. Moreover, the continuous monitoring of the experiments using single crystals of calcite allowed to highlight the macroscopic behavior of a single crystal and the sequence of twinning

In-Situ Evolution of Calcite Twinning during Uniaxial Compression of Carrara Marble at Room Temperature

International audienc

Calcite Twin Formation, Measurement and Use as Stress–Strain Indicators: A Review of Progress over the Last Decade

International audienceMechanical twins are common microstructures in deformed calcite. Calcite twins have been used for a long time as indicators of stress/strain orientations and magnitudes. Developments during the last decade point toward significant improvements of existing techniques as well as new applications of calcite twin analysis in tectonic studies. This review summarises the recent progress in the understanding of twin formation, including nucleation and growth of twins, and discusses the concept of CRSS and its dependence on several factors such as strain, temperature and grain size. Classical and recent calcite twin measurement techniques are also presented and their pros and cons are discussed. The newly proposed inversion techniques allowing for the use of calcite twins as indicators of orientations and/or magnitudes of stress and strain are summarized. Benefits for tectonic studies are illustrated through the presentation of several applications, from the scale of the individual tectonic structure to the continental scale. The classical use of calcite twin morphology (e.g., thickness) as a straightforward geothermometer is critically discussed in the light of recent observations that thick twins do not always reflect deformation temperature above 170–200 °C. This review also presents how the age of twinning events in natural rocks can be constrained while individual twins cannot be dated yet. Finally, the review addresses the recent technical and conceptual progress in calcite twinning paleopiezometry, together with the promising combination of this paleopiezometer with mechanical analysis of fractures or stylolite roughnes

Inversion of calcite twin data for paleostress orientations and magnitudes: A new technique tested and calibrated on numerically-generated and natural data

The inversion of calcite twin data is a powerful tool to reconstruct paleostresses sustained by carbonate rocks during their geological history. Following Etchecopar's (1984) pioneering work, this study presents a new technique for the inversion of calcite twin data that reconstructs the 5 parameters of the deviatoric stress tensors from both monophase and polyphase twin datasets. The uncertainties in the parameters of the stress tensors reconstructed by this new technique are evaluated on numerically-generated datasets. The technique not only reliably defines the 5 parameters of the deviatoric stress tensor, but also reliably separates very close superimposed stress tensors (30° of difference in maximum principal stress orientation or switch between σ3 and σ2 axes). The technique is further shown to be robust to sampling bias and to slight variability in the critical resolved shear stress. Due to our still incomplete knowledge of the evolution of the critical resolved shear stress with grain size, our results show that it is recommended to analyze twin data subsets of homogeneous grain size to minimize possible errors, mainly those concerning differential stress values. The methodological uncertainty in principal stress orientations is about ± 10°; it is about ± 0.1 for the stress ratio. For differential stresses, the uncertainty is lower than ± 30%. Applying the technique to vein samples within Mesozoic limestones from the Monte Nero anticline (northern Apennines, Italy) demonstrates its ability to reliably detect and separate tectonically significant paleostress orientations and magnitudes from naturally deformed polyphase samples, hence to fingerprint the regional paleostresses of interest in tectonic studies

Uniaxial compression of calcite single crystals at low temperature: insights into twinning activation and development

International audienceE-twinning is a common plastic deformation mechanism in calcite. Previous experiments have shown that temperature, strain rate and confining pressure have negligible effects on twinning activation, the latter being mainly dependent on differential stresses. Temperature is however reported to control the aspect of twin lamellae, with thickness exceeding 2-5 µm mostly at temperature above 200 °C. The critical resolved shear stress (CRSS) required for activation of twinning has been shown to be dependent on grain size and to be subjected to strain hardening: its value increases with the amount of strain accommodated and decreases with increasing grain size. This CRSS value may obey the Hall-Petch relation, but due to sparse experimental data the actual evolution of the CRSS with grain size and strain still remains a matter of debate. Numerous experiments were carried out at high temperature to investigate gliding systems in calcite, but just few data are available on the plastic behavior of calcite crystals at low temperature, despite the fact that the latter may help understand deformation processes of carbonate rocks in sedimentary basins. New mechanical tests were carried out at room temperature on unconfined single crystals of calcite, with different sizes and crystallographic orientations. Uniaxial deformation was performed at controlled displacement rate, meanwhile the sample surface was monitored using optical microscopy (reflected light) and high resolution CCD camera. The retrieved macroscopic stress-strain behavior of the crystals was correlated with the surface observations of the deformation process

Is EBSD a more efficient tool than universal stage to collect calcite twin data as used in calcite twin inversion for stress?

International audienc