An introduction to model compounds of lignin linking motifs; synthesis and selection considerations for reactivity studies

C.W.L., P.C.J.K. and P.J.D. would like to thank the European Union (Marie Curie ITN “SuBiCat” PITN-GA-2013-607044, C.W.L. also thanks the framework of the Dutch TKI-BBEI project “CALIBRA”, reference TEBE117014. P.C.J.K. also thanks the EPSRC (critical mass grant EP/J018139/ 1). C.S.L. thanks the Leverhulme Trust Early Career Fellowship (ECF‐2018‐480) and the University of St Andrews.The development of fundamentally new valorization strategies for lignin plays a vital role in unlocking the true potential of lignocellulosic biomass as sustainable and economically compatible renewable carbon feedstock. In particular, new catalytic modification and depolymerization strategies are required. Progress in this field, past and future, relies for a large part on the application of synthetic model compounds that reduce the complexity of working with the lignin biopolymer. This aids the development of catalytic methodologies and in-depth mechanistic studies and guides structural characterization studies in the lignin field. However, due to the volume of literature and the piecemeal publication of methodology, the choice of suitable lignin model compounds is far from straight forward, especially for those outside the field and lacking a background in organic synthesis. For example, in catalytic depolymerization studies, a balance between synthetic effort and fidelity compared to the actual lignin of interest needs to be found. In this review, we provide a broad overview of the model compounds available to study the chemistry of the main native linking motifs typically found in lignins from woody biomass, the synthetic routes and effort required to access them, and discuss to what extent these represent actual lignin structures. This overview can aid researchers in their selection of the most suitable lignin model systems for the development of emerging lignin modification and depolymerization technologies, maximizing their chances of successfully developing novel lignin valorization strategies.Publisher PDFPeer reviewe

Combined lignin defunctionalisation and synthesis gas formation by acceptorless dehydrogenative decarbonylation

The valorization of lignin, consisting of various phenylpropanoids building blocks, is hampered by its highly functionalized nature. The absence of the γ-carbinol group in an unnatural C2 β-O-4 motif compared to the native lignin C3 β-O-4 motif provides great opportunities for developing new valorization routes. Thus efficient defunctionalisation approaches that transform the C3 β-O-4 motif into a simplified C2 β-O-4 motif are of interest. Based on a study with a series of model compounds, we established a feasible application of an iridium-catalysed acceptorless dehydrogenative decarbonylation method to efficiently remove the γ-carbinol group in a single step. This defunctionalisation generates valuable synthesis gas, which can be collected as a reaction product. By this direct catalytic transformation, a yield of ∼70% could be achieved for a C3 β-O-4 model compound that was protected from undergoing retro-aldol cleavage by alkoxylation of the benzylic secondary alcohol in the α position. A phenylcoumaran model compound containing a γ-carbinol group as well as a benzylic primary alcohol also proved to be reactive under dehydrogenative decarbonylation conditions, which can further contribute to the reduction of the structural complexity of lignin. Notably, the liberation of synthesis gas was confirmed and the signals for the defunctionalized C2 β-O-4 motif were observed when this dehydrogenative decarbonylation approach was applied on organosolv lignins. This selective defunctionalized lignin in conjunction with the formation of synthesis gas has the potential to enhance the development of profitable and sustainable biorefineries.</p

Chemicals from lignin by diol-stabilized acidolysis:Reaction pathways and kinetics

The product selectivity, production rates and the required process conditions are important for technology development. Selective lignin depolymerisation on the prime β-O-4 motif provides an opportunity to obtain valuable functionalized phenolic monomers. Diol-stabilized acidolysis of lignin with sulfuric acid, triflic acid or triflate salts is a proven β-O-4 cleavage methodology that forms acetals by trapping of released reactive aldehydes. For future scale-up, a better understanding of the prime reaction pathways and how these can be controlled upon changing reaction parameters is required. By using β-O-4 model compounds and ytterbium(iii) triflate as catalyst, starting material conversion and product formation including two key intermediates, the diol adducts (in this study, ethylene glycol as the diol) and the vinyl ethers, were accurately monitored, allowing for detailed kinetic modelling. Over the selected temperature range (80-150 °C), higher temperatures led to higher overall carbon balance and selectivity for the main desired acetal product. The kinetic modelling allowed for establishing a detailed reaction network with activation energies and rate constants. These collectively led to new insights into the key steps involved in the diol-stabilized β-O-4 motif acidolysis and how the reaction selectivity can be manipulated by controlling the reaction temperature, and the ethylene glycol and water content. The elucidation on reaction kinetics and networks constitutes a further step in the design of a diol-stabilized lignin acidolysis process

Unravelling stereoisomerism in acid catalysed lignin conversion:An integration of experimental trends and theoretical evaluations

For the effective valorization of lignin, which is a significant component in agricultural residues, its reactivity needs to be understood in detail. Selective acid-catalysed depolymerisation of the lignin β-O-4 linking motif with stabilization of the formed aldehydes by diols is a promising approach to obtain phenolic monomers in high yields. However, the lignin β-O-4 linking motif exists in both the erythro and threo isomeric forms, and very little information is available on the influence of stereochemistry on the efficiency of the lignin diol-stabilised acidolysis. This is especially true for the set of intermediates in which the presence of stereochemistry persists. In this study, the stereoisomer ratios of two key intermediates, namely the diol (here ethylene glycol) adducts and C2-vinyl ethers, are monitored carefully in ytterbium(iii) trifluoromethanesulfonate [Yb(OTf)3]-catalysed conversion of an erythro β-O-4 model compound. The reactions showed the preferential formation and consumption of the ethylene glycol adduct in the erythro configuration, and the favored formation of trans C2-vinyl ether. Multiscale computational methods (including classical reactive molecular dynamics simulations and quantum chemistry calculations) were applied to elucidate the catalytic origins of the observed stereo-preferences and suggested that a proto-trans intermediate complex is stabilised by a hydrogen bond network connecting the carbocation, ethylene glycol, and the anionic [OTf]− species. The synergistic combination of experiments and computational studies disclosed the stereo-preference and the underlying mechanism in triflate-catalysed acidolysis, especially the catalytic role of [OTf]−, which can be helpful for a further improvement of the chemical process

The influence of exposure and physiology on microplastic ingestion by the freshwater fish Rutilus rutilus (roach) in the River Thames, UK

Microplastics are widespread throughout aquatic environments. However, there is currently insufficient understanding of the factors influencing ingestion of microplastics by organisms, especially higher predators such as fish. In this study we link ingestion of microplastics by the roach Rutilus rutilus, within the non-tidal part of the River Thames, to exposure and physiological factors. Microplastics were found within the gut contents of roach from six out of seven sampling sites. Of sampled fish, 33% contained at least one microplastic particle. The majority of particles were fibres (75%), with fragments and films also seen (22.7% and 2.3% respectively). Polymers identified were polyethylene, polypropylene and polyester, in addition to a synthetic dye. The maximum number of ingested microplastic particles for individual fish was strongly correlated to exposure (based on distance from the source of the river). Additionally, at a given exposure, the size of fish correlated with the actual quantity of microplastics in the gut. Larger (mainly female) fish were more likely to ingest the maximum possible number of particles than smaller (mainly male) fish. This study is the first to show microplastic ingestion within freshwater fish in the UK and provides valuable new evidence of the factors influencing ingestion that can be used to inform future studies on exposure and hazard of microplastics to fish

Sequential Catalytic Modification of the Lignin alpha-Ethoxylated beta-O-4 Motif To Facilitate C-O Bond Cleavage by Ruthenium-Xantphos Catalyzed Hydrogen Transfer

Lignin is an abundant natural biopolymer that has the potential to act as a renewable feedstock for valuable aromatic compounds via selective catalytic depolymerization. In recent years, elegant, mild, catalytic hydrogen neutral C-O bond cleavage methodologies have been developed on model compounds yielding acetophenone derivatives. However, none of these have been reported to be effective once applied to lignin. One of the reasons for this is the highly functionalized nature of the native lignin beta-O-4 motif; which is often not taken into account in the beta-O-4 model compounds used for methodology development. In this work, we demonstrate the development of a stepwise modification protocol on lignin beta-O-4 model compounds to overall yield a partially defunctionalized beta-O-4 motif. This was achieved by making use of an a-ethoxylated beta-O-4 motif that is readily available from ethanosolv extraction of lignocellulosic biomass. This specific motif allowed us to apply selective copper catalyzed aerobic oxidation and subsequent rhodium catalyzed decarbonylation of the primary hydroxyl group in the y position. The obtained partially defunctionalized beta-O-4 lignin motif allowed effective homogeneous ruthenium catalyzed hydrogen neutral C-O bond cleavage (>99% of 3,4-dimethoxyacetophenone and >99% of guaiacol). The stepwise modification strategy was extended to walnut ethanosolv lignin, demonstrating that the specific structural motifs are accessible from such a readily available lignin. Overall, this work illustrates that the structure of lignin can be strategically modified to allow access to otherwise inaccessible specific aromatic compounds via selective depolymerization methodologies

Experimental studies on a combined pyrolysis/staged condensation/hydrotreatment approach to obtain biofuels and biobased chemicals

Fast pyrolysis is an efficient technology to convert lignocellulosic biomass to a liquid product. However, the high contents of oxygenated compounds and water hinder the direct utilization of pyrolysis oils. Here, we report an upgrading concept to obtain liquid products with improved product properties and enriched in valuable low molecular weight chemicals and particularly alkylphenols. It entails two steps, viz. i) pyrolysis with in-situ staged condensation at multiple kg scale followed by ii) a catalytic hydrotreatment of selected fractions using a Ru/C catalyst. Of all pyrolysis oil fractions after staged condensation, the product collected in a condenser equipped with an electrostatic precipitator (ESP) at 120 °C was identified as the most attractive for hydrotreatment when considering product yields and composition. The best hydrotreatment results (Ru/C, 350 °C, 100 bar H2, 4 h) were achieved using beechwood and walnut shells as feedstock, resulting in a high oil yield (about 64 wt% based on pyrolysis oil fraction intake) with a higher heating value of about 37 MJ/kg and enriched in alkylphenols (about 16 wt%). Overall, it was shown that the type of biomass (beech sawdust, walnut granulates, and pine/spruce sawdust) has a limited impact on liquid and alkylphenols yields which implies feedstock flexibility of this integrated concept

Presence and abundance of microplastics in the Thames River Basin, UK

The global increase in plastic production has led to growing concern about the environmental impacts of plastics and their degradation products. Microplastics have been extensively observed and studied in the marine environment but little is known about their presence and abundance in freshwater environments. Although rivers are recognised as a significant source of microplastics to the oceans, they are seldom considered in studies of the environmental presence of microplastics and there are no data reported to date on microplastics in UK rivers (or indeed any freshwater bodies). This study aimed to identify and quantify the abundance and types of plastics in the Thames Basin where population densities and sewage inputs are well described. Ten sampling sites on the River Thames and its tributaries were selected, ranging from densely populated, urban areas to sparsely populated, rural areas. Sites are all downstream of sewage treatment works (STWs) serving known populations, allowing correlation between population density with plastic types and abundances found. In addition samples were collected from sites at known distances downstream of STW outfalls, as well as the effluent itself, to try and establish the proportion of plastics directly entering from STWs, and its fate and transport pathways. River sediment and water samples were collected at all sites. Sediment samples were initially searched by eye, followed by flotation and overflowing using ZnCl2 solution. Plastics collected from the sediments were subsequently identified by Raman spectroscopy. Initial observations indicate that coloured and manmade particles are obviously visible in sediments from sites with high population densities compared to few evident manmade particles in sediments from areas with low population densities. Further analysis will allow for correlation of the plastic types and abundance with population density and sewage inputs to understand the distribution of plastics in river systems

Different routes, same pathways: molecular mechanisms under silver ion and nanoparticle exposures in the soil sentinel Eisenia fetida

Use of nanotechnology products is increasing; with silver (Ag) nanoparticles particularly widely used. A key uncertainty surrounding the risk assessment of AgNPs is whether their effects are driven through the same mechanism of action that underlies the toxic effects of Ag ions. We present the first full transcriptome study of the effects of Ag ions and NPs in an ecotoxicological model soil invertebrate, the earthworm Eisenia fetida. Gene expression analyses indicated similar mechanisms for both silver forms with toxicity being exerted through pathways related to ribosome function, sugar and protein metabolism, molecular stress, disruption of energy production and histones. The main difference seen between Ag ions and NPs was associated with potential toxicokinetic effects related to cellular internalisation and communication, with pathways related to endocytosis and cilia being significantly enriched. These results point to a common final toxicodynamic response, but initial internalisation driven by different exposure routes and toxicokinetic mechanisms

Extending standard testing period in honeybees to predict lifespan impacts of pesticides and heavy metals using dynamic energy budget modelling

Concern over reported honeybee (Apis mellifera spp.) losses has highlighted chemical exposure as a risk. Current laboratory oral toxicity tests in A. mellifera spp. use short-term, maximum 96 hour, exposures which may not necessarily account for chronic and cumulative toxicity. Here, we use extended 240 hour (10 day) exposures to examine seven agrochemicals and trace environmental pollutant toxicities for adult honeybees. Data were used to parameterise a dynamic energy budget model (DEBtox) to further examine potential survival effects up to 30 day and 90 day summer and winter worker lifespans. Honeybees were most sensitive to insecticides (clothianidin > dimethoate ≫ tau-fluvalinate), then trace metals/metalloids (cadmium, arsenic), followed by the fungicide propiconazole and herbicide 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid (2,4-D). LC50s calculated from DEBtox parameters indicated a 27 fold change comparing exposure from 48 to 720 hours (summer worker lifespan) for cadmium, as the most time-dependent chemical as driven by slow toxicokinetics. Clothianidin and dimethoate exhibited more rapid toxicokinetics with 48 to 720 hour LC50s changes of <4 fold. As effects from long-term exposure may exceed those measured in short-term tests, future regulatory tests should extend to 96 hours as standard, with extension to 240 hour exposures further improving realism