Water in cratonic lithosphere : calibrating laboratory-determined models of electrical conductivity of mantle minerals using geophysical and petrological observations

Author Posting. © American Geophysical Union, 2012. This article is posted here by permission of American Geophysical Union for personal use, not for redistribution. The definitive version was published in Geochemistry Geophysics Geosystems 13 (2012): Q06010, doi:10.1029/2012GC004055.Measurements of electrical conductivity of “slightly damp” mantle minerals from different laboratories are inconsistent, requiring geophysicists to make choices between them when interpreting their electrical observations. These choices lead to dramatically different conclusions about the amount of water in the mantle, resulting in conflicting conclusions regarding rheological conditions; this impacts on our understanding of mantle convection, among other processes. To attempt to reconcile these differences, we test the laboratory-derived proton conduction models by choosing the simplest petrological scenario possible – cratonic lithosphere – from two locations in southern Africa where we have the most complete knowledge. We compare and contrast the models with field observations of electrical conductivity and of the amount of water in olivine and show that none of the models for proton conduction in olivine proposed by three laboratories are consistent with the field observations. We derive statistically model parameters of the general proton conduction equation that satisfy the observations. The pre-exponent dry proton conduction term (σ0) and the activation enthalpy (ΔHwet) are derived with tight bounds, and are both within the broader 2σ errors of the different laboratory measurements. The two other terms used by the experimentalists, one to describe proton hopping (exponent r on pre-exponent water content Cw) and the other to describe H2O concentration-dependent activation enthalpy (term αCw1/3 added to the activation energy), are less well defined and further field geophysical and petrological observations are required, especially in regions of higher temperature and higher water content.The SAMTEX data were acquired through funding provided by the Continental Dynamics program of the U.S. National Science Foundation (grant EAR0455242 to RLE), the South African Department of Science and Technology (grant to South African Council for Geoscience), and Science Foundation Ireland (grant 05/RGP/GEO001 to AGJ) plus financial and/or logistical support provided by all members of the SAMTEX consortium. JF was initially supported by an IRCSET grant to AGJ for the TopoMed project (TopoMed: Plate reorganization in the western Mediterranean: Lithospheric causes and topographic consequences) within the European Science Foundation’s TOPOEUROPE EUROCORES (http://www.esf.org/activities/eurocores/ running-programmes/topo-europe.html), and subsequently by an SFI PI grant (10/IN.1/I3022) to AGJ for IRETHERM (www.iretherm.ie).2012-12-1

Velocity–conductivity relationships for mantle mineral assemblages in Archean cratonic lithosphere based on a review of laboratory data and Hashin–Shtrikman extremal bounds

Author Posting. © Elsevier B.V., 2009. This is the author's version of the work. It is posted here by permission of Elsevier B.V. for personal use, not for redistribution. The definitive version was published in Lithos 109 (2009): 131-143, doi:10.1016/j.lithos.2008.10.014.Can mineral physics and mixing theories explain field observations of seismic velocity and electrical conductivity, and is there an advantage to combining seismological and electromagnetic techniques? These two questions are at the heart of this paper. Using phenomologically-derived state equations for individual minerals coupled with multi-phase, Hashin-Shtrikman extremal-bound theory we derive the likely shear and compressional velocities and electrical conductivity at three depths, 100 km, 150 km and 200 km, beneath the central part of the Slave craton and beneath the Kimberley region of the Kaapvaal craton based on known petrologically-observed mineral abundances and magnesium numbers, combined with estimates of temperatures and pressures. We demonstrate that there are measurable differences between the physical properties of the two lithospheres for the upper depths, primarily due to the different ambient temperature, but that differences in velocity are negligibly small at 200 km. We also show that there is an advantage to combining seismic and electromagnetic data, given that conductivity is exponentially dependent on temperature whereas the shear and bulk moduli have only a linear dependence in cratonic lithospheric rocks. Focussing on a known discontinuity between harzburgite-dominated and lherzolitic mantle in the Slave craton at a depth of about 160 km, we demonstrate that the amplitude of compressional (P) wave to shear (S) wave conversions would be very weak, and so explanations for the seismological (receiver function) observations must either appeal to effects we have not considered (perhaps anisotropy), or imply that the laboratory data require further refinement

Do mantle xenoliths preserve deep OH signatures? Evidences from field and experiments

International audienc

Microscopie electronique en transmission de geomateriaux; volcanisme : produits pyroclastiques des Antilles; metamorphisme : coesite dans un quartzite alpin

SIGLECNRS T 58556 / INIST-CNRS - Institut de l'Information Scientifique et TechniqueFRFranc

Results of experimental tests of OH preservation in mantle xenoliths: Example from Allègre volcano samples (Massif Central, France)

International audienc

Hydrogen in Ca-rich garnets (diffusion and stability of the OH-defects)

TOULOUSE3-BU Santé-Centrale (315552105) / SudocSudocFranceF

Low-temperature infrared spectrum and atomic-scale structure of hydrous defects in diopside

Hydrous defects in diopside (CaMgSi2O6) play an important role in the water budget of the Earth's mantle. Related OH-stretching modes lead to a variety of infrared absorption bands observed in natural or experimental samples. In the present study, we report new low-temperature infrared spectra of reference natural diopside samples in the OH-stretching range. In parallel, the structure and vibrational properties of a series of OH-bearing defects in diopside are theoretically determined at the density functional theory level. The infrared spectra make it possible to resolve additional bands in the region above 3600&thinsp;cm−1 and reveal that their anharmonic behavior differs from that of the bands at lower frequency. A comparison of theoretical results with experimental data makes it possible to propose atomic-scale geometries corresponding to observed OH-stretching bands. It confirms that the bands observed at 3620–3651&thinsp;cm−1 are related to M3+ ions substituted for Si in tetrahedral sites, while the 3420 cm−1 band is associated with the Na+ for Ca2+ substitution. In both cases, H+ incorporation compensates the charge deficit due to the heterovalent substitution. The other major mechanism of water incorporation in diopside relates to the charge compensation of cationic vacancies, among which Ca vacancies play a central role. The 3357&thinsp;cm−1 band corresponds to doubly protonated Ca vacancies in pure diopside. In experimental diopside-bearing trivalent cations, the bands at 3432–3460&thinsp;cm−1 correspond to singly protonated Ca vacancies with a nearby octahedral M3+ ion, while the 3310&thinsp;cm−1 band likely involves a more remote charge compensation by M3+ ions. More complex defects associating Ca vacancies with tetrahedral M3+ and octahedral Ti4+ ions are proposed for the bands observed between 3500 and 3600&thinsp;cm−1 in natural diopside. The Fe2+ for Mg2+ and Fe2+ for Ca2+ substitutions are also found to affect nearby OH-bearing defects, causing a shift and broadening of OH stretching bands in chemically more complex diopside samples.</p