What can we learn from melt inclusions in migmatites and granulites?

With less than two decades of activity, research on melt inclusions (MI) in crystals from rocks that have undergone crustal anatexis \u2013 migmatites and granulites \u2013 is a recent addition to crustal petrology and geochemistry. Studies on this subject started with glassy inclusions in anatectic crustal enclaves in lavas, and then progressed to regionally metamorphosed and partially melted crustal rocks, where melt inclusions are normally crystallized into a cryptocrystalline aggregate (nanogranitoid). Since the first paper on melt inclusions in the granulites of the Kerala Khondalite Belt in 2009, reported and studied occurrences are already a few tens. Melt inclusions in migmatites and granulites show many analogieswith theirmore common and long studied counterparts in igneous rocks, but also display very important differences and peculiarities,which are the subject of this review. Microstructurally, melt inclusions in anatectic rocks are small, commonly 10 \u3bcm in diameter, and their main mineral host is peritectic garnet, although several other hosts have been observed. Inclusion contents vary from glass in enclaves that were cooled very rapidly from supersolidus temperatures, to completely crystallized material in slowly cooled regional migmatites. The chemical composition of the inclusions can be analyzed combining several techniques (SEM, EMP, NanoSIMS, LA\u2013ICP\u2013MS), but in the case of crystallized inclusions the experimental remelting under confining pressure in a piston cylinder is a prerequisite. The melt is generally granitic and peraluminous, although granodioritic to trondhjemitic compositions have also been found. Being mostly primary in origin, inclusions attest for the growth of their peritectic host in the presence of melt. As a consequence, the inclusions have the unique ability of preserving information on the composition of primary anatectic crustal melts, before they undergo any of the common following changes in their way to produce crustal magmas. For these peculiar features, melt inclusions in migmatites and granulites, largely overlooked so far, have the potential to become a fundamental tool for the study of crustal melting, crustal differentiation, and even the generation of the continental crust

granitoid magmas preserved as melt inclusions in high grade metamorphic rock

This review presents a compositional database of primary anatectic granitoid magmas, entirely based on melt inclusions (MI) in high-grade metamorphic rocks. Although MI are well known to igneous petrologists and have been extensively studied in intrusive and extrusive rocks, MI in crustal rocks that have undergone anatexis (migmatites and granulites) are a novel subject of research. They are generally trapped along the heating path by peritectic phases produced by incongruent melting reactions. Primary MI in high-grade metamorphic rocks are small, commonly 5–10 μm in diameter, and their most common mineral host is peritectic garnet. In most cases inclusions have crystallized into a cryptocrystalline aggregate and contain a granitoid phase assemblage (nanogranitoid inclusions) with quartz, K-feldspar, plagioclase, and one or two mica depending on the particular circumstances. After their experimental remelting under high-confining pressure, nanogranitoid MI can be analyzed combining several techniques (EMP, LA-ICP-MS, NanoSIMS, Raman). The trapped melt is granitic and metaluminous to peraluminous, and sometimes granodioritic, tonalitic, and trondhjemitic in composition, in agreement with the different ![Formula][1] conditions of melting and protolith composition, and overlap the composition of experimental glasses produced at similar conditions. Being trapped along the up-temperature trajectory—as opposed to classic MI in igneous rocks formed during down-temperature magma crystallization—fundamental information provided by nanogranitoid MI is the pristine composition of the natural primary anatectic melt for the specific rock under investigation. So far ~600 nanogranitoid MI, coming from several occurrences from different geologic and geodynamic settings and ages, have been characterized. Although the compiled MI database should be expanded to other potential sources of crustal magmas, MI data collected so far can be already used as natural "starting-point" compositions to track the processes involved in formation and evolution of granitoid magmas. [1]: /embed/mml-math-1.gi

Primary crustal melt compositions: Insights into the controls, mechanisms and timing of generation from kinetics experiments and melt inclusions

We explore the controls, mechanisms and timing of generation of primary melts and their compositions, and show that the novel studies of melt inclusions in migmatites can provide important insights into the processes of crustal anatexis of a particular rock. Partial melting in the source region of granites is dependent on five main processes: (i) supply of heat; (ii) mineral–melt interface reactions associated with the detachment and supply of mineral components to the melt, (iii) diffusion in the melt, (iv) diffusion in minerals, and (v) recrystallization of minerals. As the kinetics of these several processes vary over several orders of magnitude, it is essential to evaluate in Nature which of these processes control the rate of melting, the composition of melts, and the extent to which residue–melt chemical equilibrium is attained under different circumstances. To shed light on these issues, we combine data from experimental and melt inclusion studies. First, data from an extensive experimental program on the kinetics of melting of crustal protoliths and diffusion in granite melt are used to set up the necessary framework that describes how primary melt compositions are established during crustal anatexis. Then, we use this reference frame and compare compositional trends from experiments with the composition of melt inclusions analyzed in particular migmatites. We show that, for the case of El Hoyazo anatectic enclaves in lavas, the composition of glassy melt inclusions provides important information on the nature and mechanisms of anatexis during the prograde suprasolidus history of these rocks, including melting temperatures and reactions, and extent of melt interconnection, melt homogenization and melt–residue equilibrium. Compositional trends in several of the rehomogenized melt inclusions in garnet from migmatites/granulites in anatectic terranes are consistent with diffusion in melt-controlled melting, though trace element compositions of melt inclusions and coexisting minerals are necessary to provide further clues on the nature of anatexis in these particular rocks.This work was supported by the National Science Foundation [grants EAR-9603199, EAR-9618867, EAR-9625517 and EAR-9404658], the Italian Consiglio Nazionale delle Ricerche, the European Commission (grant 01-LECEMA22F through contract No. ERAS-CT-2003-980409; and a H2020 Marie Skłodowska-Curie Actions under grant agreement No. 654606), the Italian Ministry of Education, University and Research (grants PRIN 2007278A22, 2010TT22SC and SIR RBSI14Y7PF), the Università degli Studi di Padova [Progetto di Ateneo CPDA107188/10 and a Piscopia—Marie Curie Fellowship under grant agreement No. 600376], the Australian Research Council (Australian Professorial Fellowship and Discovery Grants Nos. DP0342473 and DP0556700), and the National Research Foundation (South Africa; Incentives For Rated Researchers Program)

The Unconventional Peridotite-Related Mg-Fe-B Skarn of the El Robledal, SE Spain

The El Robledal deposit is a Mg-Fe-B skarn hosted in a dismembered block from the footwall contact of the Ronda orogenic peridotites in the westernmost part of the Betic Cordillera. The skarn is subdivided into two different zones according to the dominant ore mineral assemblage: (1) the ludwigite–magnetite zone, hosted in a completely mineralized body along with metasomatic forsterite, and (2) the magnetite–szaibelyite zone hosted in dolomitic marbles. In the ludwigite–magnetite zone, the massive mineralization comprises ludwigite (Mg2Fe3+(BO3)O2), Mgrich magnetite, and magnetite, with minor amounts of kotoite (Mg3(BO3)2), szaibelyite (MgBO2(OH)), accessory schoenfliesite (MgSn4+(OH)6), and pentlandite. The ratio of ludwigite–magnetite decreases downwards in the stratigraphy of this zone. In contrast, the mineralization in the magnetite– szaibelyite zone is mainly composed of irregular and folded magnetite pods and bands with pull-apart fractures, locally associated with a brucite-, szaibelyite-, and serpentine-rich groundmass. The set of inclusions identified within these ore minerals, using a combination of a focused ion beam (FIB) and high-resolution transmission electron microscope (HRTEM), supports the proposed evolution of the system and reactions of the mineral formation of the skarn. The analysis of the microstructures of the ores by means of electron backscatter diffraction (EBSD) allowed for the determination that the ores experienced ductile deformation followed by variable degrees of recrystallization and annealing. We propose a new classification of the deposit as well as a plausible genetic model in a deposit where the heat source and the ore-fluid source are decoupled.PRE2019-088262 “Ayudas para contratos predoctorales para la formación de doctores”, defrayed by the “Ministerio de Ciencia, Innovación y Universidades”the MECRAS Project A-RNM-356-UGR20 “Proyectos de I+D+i en el marco del Programa Operativo FEDER Andalucía 2014-2020” defrayed by the “Junta de Andalucía

The unconventional peridotite-related Mg-Fe-B skarn of the el robledal, SE Spain

The El Robledal deposit is a Mg-Fe-B skarn hosted in a dismembered block from the footwall contact of the Ronda orogenic peridotites in the westernmost part of the Betic Cordillera. The skarn is subdivided into two different zones according to the dominant ore mineral assemblage: (1) the ludwigite–magnetite zone, hosted in a completely mineralized body along with metasomatic forsterite, and (2) the magnetite–szaibelyite zone hosted in dolomitic marbles. In the ludwigite–magnetite zone, the massive mineralization comprises ludwigite (Mg2Fe3+(BO3)O2), Mg-rich magnetite, and magnetite, with minor amounts of kotoite (Mg3(BO3)2), szaibelyite (MgBO2(OH)), accessory schoenfliesite (MgSn4+(OH)6), and pentlandite. The ratio of ludwigite–magnetite decreases downwards in the stratigraphy of this zone. In contrast, the mineralization in the magnetite–szaibelyite zone is mainly composed of irregular and folded magnetite pods and bands with pull-apart fractures, locally associated with a brucite-, szaibelyite-, and serpentine-rich groundmass. The set of inclusions identified within these ore minerals, using a combination of a focused ion beam (FIB) and high-resolution transmission electron microscope (HRTEM), supports the proposed evolution of the system and reactions of the mineral formation of the skarn. The analysis of the microstructures of the ores by means of electron backscatter diffraction (EBSD) allowed for the determination that the ores experienced ductile deformation followed by variable degrees of recrystallization and annealing. We propose a new classification of the deposit as well as a plausible genetic model in a deposit where the heat source and the ore-fluid source are decoupled

Geochemistry of phosphorus and the behavior of apatite during crustal anatexis: Insights from melt inclusions and nanogranitoids

The solubility of apatite in anatectic melt plays an important role in controlling the trace-element compositions and isotopic signatures of granites. The compositions of glassy melt inclusions and nanogranitoids in migmatites and granulites are compared with the results of experimental studies of apatite solubility to evaluate the factors that influence apatite behavior during prograde suprasolidus metamorphism and investigate the mechanisms of anatexis in the continental crust. The concentration of phosphorus in glassy melt inclusions and rehomogenized nanogranitoids suggests a strong control of melt aluminosity on apatite solubility in peraluminous granites, which is consistent with existing experimental studies. However, measured concentrations of phosphorus in melt inclusions and nanogranitoids are generally inconsistent with the concentrations expected from apatite solubility expressions based on experimental studies. Using currently available nanogranitoids and glassy melt inclusion compositions, we identify two main groups of inclusions: those trapped at lower temperature and showing the highest measured phosphorus concentrations, and melt inclusions trapped at the highest temperatures having the lowest phosphorus concentrations. The strong inconsistency between measured and experimentally predicted P concentrations in higher temperature samples may relate to apatite exhaustion during the production of large amounts of peraluminous melt at high temperatures. The inconsistency between measured and predicted phosphorus concentrations for the lower-temperature inclusions, however, cannot be explained by problems with the electron microprobe analyses of rehomogenized nanogranitoids and glassy melt inclusions, sequestration of phosphorus in major minerals and/or monazite, shielding or exhaustion of apatite during high-temperature metamorphism, and apatite-melt disequilibrium. The unsuitability of the currently available solubility equations is probably the main cause for the discrepancy between the measured concentrations of phosphorus in nanogranites and those predicted from current apatite solubility expressions. Syn-entrapment processes such as the generation of diffusive boundary layers at the mineral-melt interface may also be responsible for concentrations of P in nanogranitoids and glassy melt inclusions that are higher than those predicted in apatite-saturated melt. © 2019 Walter de Gruyter GmbH, Berlin/Boston 2019

Kimberlite-like melts trapped in mantle wedge peridotites in subduction setting

Goldschmidt, Barcelona (Spain), 18th-23th august 201

High-temperature metamorphism and crustal melting: Working with melt inclusions

The application of melt inclusion (MI) studies to migmatitic and granulitic terranes is a recent, small-scale approach for a better understanding of melting in the continental crust. In order to show the role of anatectic MI in providing a wealth of microstructural and compositional information on high-temperature metamorphism and crustal anatexis, we review a series of studies on the crustal footwall of the Ronda peridotites (Betic Cordillera, S Spain), which consists of an inverted metamorphic sequence with granulite-facies rocks showing extensive melting on top and amphibolites-facies rocks at the bottom. We studied the microstructures and geochemistry of small (2-10 mu m) primary MI hosted in peritectic garnet of metatexites at the bottom of the migmatitic sequence and of mylonitic diatexites close to the contact with the mantle rocks. The occurrence of MI is a proof that the investigated rocks were partially melted at some time in their history, despite other microstructures indicating the former presence of melt in diatexites were erased by deformation. MI show a variable degree of crystallization ranging from totally glassy to fully crystallized (nanogranites), consisting of Qtz+Pl+Kfs+Bt+Ms aggregates (often modal Kfs > P1 in diatexites). Piston cylinder remelting experiments led to the complete rehomogenization of nanogranites in metatexites at the conditions inferred for anatexis. Compositions of investigated MI are all leucogranitic and peraluminous and differ from those of coexisting leucosomes and from melts calculated by phase equilibria modeling. Systematic compositional variations have been observed between ME in metatexites and diatexites: the former commonly show higher H2O, CaO, Na2O/K2O and lower FeO. The compositions of MI in metatexites and diatexites are interpreted to record the composition of the anatectic melts produced from a peraluminous greywacke i) on, and immediately after crossing, the fluid-saturated solidus of this metasedimentary rock, and ii) during anatexis via biotite dehydration melting at increasing temperature, respectively. While partial melting at the bottom of the migmatitic sequence likely started in the presence of an aqueous fluid phase, MI data support the fluid-absent character of the melting event in diatexites. Anatectic MI should therefore be considered as a new and important opportunity to understand the partial melting processes

Diffusive equilibration between hydrous metaluminous-peraluminous haplogranite liquid couples at 200 MPa (H2O) and alkali transport in granitic liquids.

13 pages, 6 figures, 4 tables.This study examines the systematics and rate of alkali transport in haplogranite diffusion couples in which a chemical potential gradient in Al is established between near water-saturated metaluminous and peraluminous liquids that differ only in their initial content of normative corundum. At 800°C, measurable chemical diffusion of alkalis occurs throughout the entire length (∼1 cm) of the diffusion couples in 2–6 h, indicating long range diffusive communication through melt. Alkali transport results in homogenization of initially different Na/Al and ASI [=mol. Al2O3/(CaO + Na2O + K2O)] throughout the couples within ∼24 h, whereas initially homogenous K* evolves to become uniformly different between metaluminous and peraluminous ends. Calculated effective binary diffusion coefficients for alkalis in experiments that do not significantly violate the requirement of a semi-infinite chemical reservoir (0- to 2-h duration at 800°C) are similar to those observed in previous studies: in the range of (1–8) × 10−12 m2/s. Such a magnitude of diffusivity, however, is inadequate to account for the observed changes of alkali concentrations and molecular ratios throughout the couples in 2- to 6-h experiments. The latter changes are consistent with diffusivities estimated via the x 2 = Dt approximation, which yields effective values around 10−9 m2/s. These observations suggest that Fick’s law alone does not adequately describe the diffusive transport of alkalis in granitic liquids. In addition to simple ionic diffusion associated with local gradients in concentration or chemical potential of the diffusing component described by Fick’s second law (local diffusion), alkali transport through melt involves system-wide diffusion (field diffusion) driven by chemical potential gradients that also include components with which the alkalis couple or complex (e.g., Al). Field diffusion involves the coordinated migration of essentially all alkali cations, resembling a positive ionic current that drives the system to a metastable state having a minimum energy configuration with respect to alkali distribution. The net result is effective transport rates perhaps three orders of magnitude faster than simple local alkali diffusion, and at least seven to eight orders of magnitude faster than the diffusive equilibration of Al and Si.We wish to thank Don Baker and Bruce Watson, whose reviews of the first draft of this manuscript were tremendously helpful for re-evaluating the diffusion modeling. We note that it was this re-evaluation that eventually led us to propose the mechanism of field diffusion of alkalis (which the reveiwers did not see). Support for this research was provided by National Science Foundation grants EAR-9603199, EAR-9618867, EAR-9625517, and EAR-9404658, and to A.A.-V. by a Ramón y Cajal research contract and project CTM2005-08071-C03-01 from the Ministerio de Educación y Ciencia, SpainPeer reviewe