A Genetic-Algorithm-Based Approach for Optimizing Tool Utilization and Makespan in FMS Scheduling

This paper proposes a genetic algorithm approach to solve the identical parallel machines problem with tooling constraints in job shop flexible manufacturing systems (JS-FMSs) with the consideration of tool wear. The approach takes into account the residual useful life of tools and allocates a set of jobs with specific processing times and tooling requirements on identical parallel machines. Two metrics are introduced to evaluate the scheduling decisions and optimize the scheduling process, with the competitive goal of maximizing tool utilization and minimizing production makespan. The proposed approach searches for a set of optimal solutions on the Pareto front that offers the best possible balance between these two objectives, achieving optimal local performance in terms of both makespan and tool utilization. The approach is implemented with a customized genetic algorithm and validated on a real case study from a company operating in the aerospace sector, which confirms its effectiveness in increasing tool utilization and reducing the makespan. The results show that the proposed approach has significant practical implications for the manufacturing industry, particularly in the production of high-value materials such as those in the aerospace sector that require costly tools. This paper contributes to the operational research community by providing advanced scheduling algorithms that can optimize both the makespan and the tool utilization concurrently, improving production efficiency and maintaining competitiveness in the manufacturing industry

Scheduling research in multiple resource constrained job shops: a review and critique

Over the past several years, a number of survey, classification, and review articles have focused on scheduling research in machine [only] constrained job shops. Barring the work of Treleven (1989), there is no reported research that presents a detailed review of the issues related to scheduling and sequencing in job shops with multiple resource constraints. In his article, Treleven reviewed the research in job shops constrained by machines and labour. Job shops are not only constrained by machines and labour, but by auxiliary resources (in the form of tooling. etc.) as well. This paper extends the work of Treleven by reviewing the literature on scheduling in job shops constrained by more than one resource and comparing the scheduling research in auxiliary resource-constrained job shops with that of labour-constrained job shops. In addition, this article raises some issues for future scheduling research in multiple resource-constrained job shops

The Integration of Process Planning and Shop Floor Scheduling in Small Batch Part Manufacturing

In this paper we explore possibilities to cut manufacturing leadtimes and to improve delivery performance in a small batch part manufacturing shop by integrating process planning and shop floor scheduling. Using a set of initial process plans (one for each order in the shop), we exploit a resource decomposition procedure to determine schedules to determine schedules which minimize the maximum lateness, given these process plans. If the resulting schedule is still unsatisfactory, a critical path analysis is performed to select jobs as candidates for alternative process plans. In this way, an excellent due date performance can be achieved, with a minimum of process planning and scheduling effort

Simulation and optimization techniques applied in semiconductor assembly and test operations

The importance of back-end operations in semiconductor manufacturing has been growing steadily in the face of higher customer expectations and stronger competition in the industry. In order to achieve low cycle times, high throughput, and high utilization while improving due-date performance, more effective tools are needed to support machine setup and lot dispatching decisions. In previous work, the problem of maximizing the weighted throughput of lots undergoing assembly and test (AT), while ensuring that critical lots are given priority, was investigated and a greedy randomized adaptive search procedure (GRASP) developed to find solutions. Optimization techniques have long been used for scheduling manufacturing operations on a daily basis. Solutions provide a prescription for machine setups and job processing over a finite the planning horizon. In contrast, simulation provides more detail but in a normative sense. It tells you how the system will evolve in real time for a given demand, a given set of resources and rules for using them. A simulation model can also accommodate changeovers, initial setups and multi-pass requirements easily. The first part of the research is to show how the results of an optimization model can be integrated with the decisions made within a simulation model. The problem addressed is defined in terms of four hierarchical objectives: minimize the weighted sum of key device shortages, maximize weighted throughput, minimize the number of machines used, and minimize makespan for a given set of lots in queue, and a set of resources that includes machines and tooling. The facility can be viewed as a reentrant flow shop. The basic simulation was written in AutoSched AP (ASAP) and then enhanced with the help of customization features available in the software. Several new dispatch rules were developed. Rule_First_setup is able to initialize the simulation with the setups obtained with the GRASP. Rule_All_setups enables a machine to select the setup provided by the optimization solution whenever a decision is about to be made on which setup to choose subsequent to the initial setup. Rule_Hotlot was also proposed to prioritize the processing of the hot lots that contain key devices. The objective of the second part of the research is to design and implement heuristics within the simulation model to schedule back-end operations in a semiconductor AT facility. Rule_Setupnum lets the machines determine which key device to process according to a machine setup frequency table constructed from the GRASP solution. GRASP_asap embeds a more robust selection features of GRASP in the ASAP model through customization. This allows ASAP to explore a larger portion of the feasible region at each decision point by randomizing machine setups using adaptive probability distributions that are a function of solution quality. Rule_Greedy, which is a simplification of GRASP_asap, always picks the setup for a particular machine that gives the greatest marginal improvement in the objective function among all candidates. The purpose of the third part of the research is to statistically validate the relative effectiveness of our top six dispatch rules by comparing their performance on 30 real and randomly generated data sets. Using both GRASP and our ASAP discrete event simulation model, we have (1) identified the general order of dispatch rule performance, (2) investigated the impact of having setups installed on machines at time zero on rule performance, (3) determined the conditions under which restricting the maximum number of changeover affects the rule performance, and (4) studied the factors that might simultaneously affect rule performance with the help of a common random numbers experimental design. In the analysis, the first two objectives, weighted key device shortages and weighted throughput, are used to measure outcomes.Operations Research and Industrial Engineerin

Capacity Planning and Leadtime management

In this paper we discuss a framework for capacity planning and lead time management in manufacturing companies, with an emphasis on the machine shop. First we show how queueing models can be used to find approximations of the mean and the variance of manufacturing shop lead times. These quantities often serve as a basis to set a fixed planned lead time in an MRP-controlled environment. A major drawback of a fixed planned lead time is the ignorance of the correlation between actual work loads and the lead times that can be realized under a limited capacity flexibility. To overcome this problem, we develop a method that determines the earliest possible completion time of any arriving job, without sacrificing the delivery performance of any other job in the shop. This earliest completion time is then taken to be the delivery date and thereby determines a workload-dependent planned lead time. We compare this capacity planning procedure with a fixed planned lead time approach (as in MRP), with a procedure in which lead times are estimated based on the amount of work in the shop, and with a workload-oriented release procedure. Numerical experiments so far show an excellent performance of the capacity planning procedure

SIMAID: a rapid development methodology for the design of acyclic, bufferless, multi-process and mixed model agile production facilities for spaceframe vehicles

The facility layout problem (FL) is a non-linear, NP-complete problem whose complexity is derived from the vast solution space generated by multiple variables and interdependent factors. For reconfigurable, agile facilities the problem is compounded by parallelism (simultaneity of operations) and scheduling issues. Previous work has either concentrated on conventional (linear or branched) facility layout design, or has not considered the issues of agile, reconfigurable facilities and scheduling. This work is the first comprehensive methodology incorporating the design and scheduling of parallel cellular facilities for the purpose of easy and rapid reconfiguration in the increasingly demanding world of agile manufacturing. A novel three-stage algorithm is described for the design of acyclic (asynchronous), bufferless, parallel, multi-process and mixed-model production facilities for spaceframe-based vehicles. Data input begins with vehicle part processing and volume requirements from multiple models and includes time, budget and space constraints. The algorithm consists of a powerful combination of a guided cell formation stage, iterative solution improvement searches and design stage scheduling. The improvement iterations utilise a modified (rules-based) Tabu search applied to a constant-flow group technology, while the design stage scheduling is done by the use of genetic algorithms. The objective-based solution optimisation direction is not random but guided, based on measurement criteria from simulation. The end product is the selection and graphic presentation of the best solution out of a database of feasible ones. The case is presented in the form of an executable program and three real world industrial examples are included. The results provide evidence that good solutions can be found to this new type and size of heavily constrained problem within a reasonable amount of time

Controlling work in process during semiconductor assembly and test operations

In the semiconductor industry, products go through a series of steps over a three- to four-month period that begins with the fabrication of chips and ends with assembly and test (AT) and shipment. This paper introduces a mid-term planning model for scheduling AT operations aimed at minimizing the difference between customer demand and product completions each day. A secondary objective is to maximize daily throughput. Typically, semiconductor companies have 1000s of products or devices in their catalog that can be organized into unique groups of up to 100 devices each. This simplifies the planning process because it is only necessary to consider the groups as a whole rather than the individual devices when constructing schedules. In all, we developed and tested three related models. Each provides daily run rates at each processing step or logpoint for each device group for up to one month at a time. The models are distinguished by how cycle time is treated. The first takes a steady-state approach and uses Little’s Law to formulate a WIP target constraint based on the average cycle time at each processing step. The second and third include integer and fractional cycle times in the variable definitions. To find solutions, raw production data are analyzed in a preprocessing step and then converted to input files in a standard format. FlopC++ from the COIN-OR open source software project is used to write and solve the model. Testing was done using three datasets from the Taiwan AT facility of a global semiconductor firm. By comparing model output with historical data for 6 device groups and 33 logpoints, we were able to realize decreases in shortages of up to 40% per month.Mechanical Engineerin

Non-identical parallel CNC machine scheduling

In this study, we solve the non-identical parallel CNC machine scheduling problem. We have two objectives: minimizing the manufacturing cost (comprising machining, non-machining and tooling costs) and minimizing the total weighted tardiness. The tooling constraints affect the non-machining times as well as the machining conditions, such as cutting speed and feed rate, which in turn specify the machining times and tool lives. We propose a two-stage algorithm to find optimal machining conditions and to determine machine allocation, tool allocation and part scheduling decisions. The proposed algorithm generates different schedules according to the relative importance of the objectives