Combining Time-Triggered Plans with Priority Scheduled Task Sets

The final publication is available at Springer via http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-39083-3_13Time-triggered and concurrent priority-based scheduling are the two major approaches in use for real-time and embedded systems. Both approaches have their own advantages and drawbacks. On the one hand, priority-based systems facilitate separation of concerns between functional and timing requirements by relying on an underlying real- time operating system that takes all scheduling decisions at run time. But this is at the cost of indeterminism in the exact timing pattern of execution of activities, namely variable release jitter. On the other hand, time-triggered schedules are more intricate to design since all schedul- ing decisions must be taken beforehand in the design phase, but their advantage is determinism and more chances for minimisation of release jitter. In this paper we propose a software architecture that enables the combined and controlled execution of time-triggered plans and priority- scheduled tasks. We also describe the implementation of an Ada library supporting it. Our aim is to take advantage of the best of both ap- proaches by providing jitter-controlled execution of time-triggered tasks (e.g., control tasks), coexisting with a set of priority-scheduled tasks, with less demanding jitter requirements.This work has been partly supported by the Spanish Government’s project M2C2 (TIN2014-56158-C4-1-P-AR) and the European Commission’s project EMC2 (ARTEMIS-JU Call 2013 AIPP-5, Contract 621429).Real Sáez, JV.; Sáez Barona, S.; Crespo, A. (2016). Combining Time-Triggered Plans with Priority Scheduled Task Sets. En Reliable Software Technologies – Ada-Europe 2016. Springer. 195-212. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-39083-3_13S195212Liu, C., Layland, J.: Scheduling algorithms for multiprogramming in a hard real-time environment. J. ACM 20(1), 46–61 (1973)Martí, P., Fuertes, J., Fohler, G.: Jitter compensation for real-time control systems. In: Real-Time Systems Symposium (2001)Dobrin, R.: Combining off-line schedule construction and fixed priority scheduling in real-time computer systems. Ph.D. thesis. Mälardalen University (2005)Cervin, A.: Integrated control and real-time scheduling. Ph.D. thesis. Lund Institute of Technology, April 2003Balbastre, P., Ripoll, I., Vidal, J., Crespo, A.: A task model to reduce control delays. Real-Time Syst. 27(3), 215–236 (2004)Hong, S., Hu, X., Lemmon, M.: Reducing delay jitter of real-time control tasks through adaptive deadline adjustments. In: 22nd Euromicro Conference on Real-Time Systems - ECRTS, pp. 229–238. IEEE Computer Society (2010)ISO/IEC-JTC1-SC22-WG9: Ada Reference Manual ISO/IEC 8652:2012(E) (2012). http://www.ada-europe.org/manuals/LRM-2012.pdfBaker, T.P., Shaw, A.: The cyclic executive model and Ada. In: Proceedings IEEE Real Time Systems Symposium 1988, Huntsville, Alabama, pp. 120–129 (1988)Liu, J.W.S.: Real-Time Systems. Prentice-Hall Inc., Upper Saddle River (2000)Pont, M.J.: The Engineering of Reliable Embedded Systems: LPC1769. SafeTTy Systems Limited, Skelmersdale (2014). ISBN: 978-0-9930355-0-0Aldea Rivas, M., González Harbour, M.: MaRTE OS: an Ada kernel for real-time embedded applications. In: Strohmeier, A., Craeynest, D. (eds.) Ada-Europe 2001. LNCS, vol. 2043, pp. 305–316. Springer, Heidelberg (2001)Palencia, J., González-Harbour, M.: Schedulability analysis for tasks with static and dynamic offsets. In: 9th IEEE Real-Time Systems Symposium (1998)Wellings, A.J., Burns, A.: A framework for real-time utilities for Ada 2005. Ada Lett. XXVI XXVII(2), 41–47 (2007)Real, J., Crespo, A.: Incorporating operating modes to an Ada real-time framework. Ada Lett. 30(1), 73–85 (2010)Sáez, S., Terrasa, S., Crespo, A.: A real-time framework for multiprocessor platforms using Ada 2012. In: Romanovsky, A., Vardanega, T. (eds.) Ada-Europe 2011. LNCS, vol. 6652, pp. 46–60. Springer, Heidelberg (2011

Dynamics analysis and integrated design of real-time control systems

Real-time control systems are widely deployed in many applications. Theory and practice for the design and deployment of real-time control systems have evolved significantly. From the design perspective, control strategy development has been the focus of the research in the control community. In order to develop good control strategies, process modelling and analysis have been investigated for decades, and stability analysis and model-based control have been heavily studied in the literature. From the implementation perspective, real-time control systems require timeliness and predictable timing behaviour in addition to logical correctness, and a real-time control system may behave very differently with different software implementations of the control strategies on a digital controller, which typically has limited computing resources. Most current research activities on software implementations concentrate on various scheduling methodologies to ensure the schedulability of multiple control tasks in constrained environments. Recently, more and more real-time control systems are implemented over data networks, leading to increasing interest worldwide in the design and implementation of networked control systems (NCS). Major research activities in NCS include control-oriented and scheduling-oriented investigations. In spite of significant progress in the research and development of real-time control systems, major difficulties exist in the state of the art. A key issue is the lack of integrated design for control development and its software implementation. For control design, the model-based control technique, the current focus of control research, does not work when a good process model is not available or is too complicated for control design. For control implementation on digital controllers running multiple tasks, the system schedulability is essential but is not enough; the ultimate objective of satisfactory quality-of-control (QoC) performance has not been addressed directly. For networked control, the majority of the control-oriented investigations are based on two unrealistic assumptions about the network induced delay. The scheduling-oriented research focuses on schedulability and does not directly link to the overall QoC of the system. General solutions with direct QoC consideration from the network perspective to the challenging problems of network delay and packet dropout in NCS have not been found in the literature. This thesis addresses the design and implementation of real-time control systems with regard to dynamics analysis and integrated design. Three related areas have been investigated, namely control development for controllers, control implementation and scheduling on controllers, and real-time control in networked environments. Seven research problems are identified from these areas for investigation in this thesis, and accordingly seven major contributions have been claimed. Timing behaviour, quality of control, and integrated design for real-time control systems are highlighted throughout this thesis. In control design, a model-free control technique, pattern predictive control, is developed for complex reactive distillation processes. Alleviating the requirement of accurate process models, the developed control technique integrates pattern recognition, fuzzy logic, non-linear transformation, and predictive control into a unified framework to solve complex problems. Characterising the QoC indirectly with control latency and jitter, scheduling strategies for multiple control tasks are proposed to minimise the latency and/or jitter. Also, a hierarchical, QoC driven, and event-triggering feedback scheduling architecture is developed with plug-ins of either the earliest-deadline-first or fixed priority scheduling. Linking to the QoC directly, the architecture minimises the use of computing resources without sacrifice of the system QoC. It considers the control requirements, but does not rely on the control design. For real-time NCS, the dynamics of the network delay are analysed first, and the nonuniform distribution and multi-fractal nature of the delay are revealed. These results do not support two fundamental assumptions used in existing NCS literature. Then, considering the control requirements, solutions are provided to the challenging NCS problems from the network perspective. To compensate for the network delay, a real-time queuing protocol is developed to smooth out the time-varying delay and thus to achieve more predictable behaviour of packet transmissions. For control packet dropout, simple yet effective compensators are proposed. Finally, combining the queuing protocol, the packet loss compensation, the configuration of the worst-case communication delay, and the control design, an integrated design framework is developed for real-time NCS. With this framework, the network delay is limited to within a single control period, leading to simplified system analysis and improved QoC

Real-Time Guarantees For Wireless Networked Sensing And Control

Wireless networks are increasingly being explored for mission-critical sensing and control in emerging domains such as connected and automated vehicles, Industrial 4.0, and smart city. In wireless networked sensing and control (WSC) systems, reliable and real- time delivery of sensed data plays a crucial role for the control decision since out-of-date information will often be irrelevant and even leads to negative effects to the system. Since WSC differs dramatically from the traditional real-time (RT) systems due to its wireless nature, new design objective and perspective are necessary to achieve real-time guarantees. First, we proposed Optimal Node Activation Multiple Access (ONAMA) scheduling protocol that activates as many nodes as possible while ensuring transmission reliability (in terms of packets delivery ratio). We implemented and tested ONAMA on two testbeds both with 120+ sensor nodes. Second, we proposed algorithms to address the problem of clustering heterogeneous reliability requirements into a limit set of service levels. Our solutions are optimal, and they also provide guaranteed reliability, which is critical for wireless sensing and control. Third, we proposed a probabilistic real-time wireless communication framework that effectively integrates real-time scheduling theory with wireless communication. The per- packet probabilistic real-time QoS was formally modeled. By R3 mapping, the upper-layer requirement and the lower-layer link reliability are translated into the number of trans- mission opportunities needed. By optimal real-time communication scheduling as well as admission test and traffic period optimization, the system utilization is maximized while the schedulability is maintained. Finally, we further investigated the problem of how to minimize delay variation (i.e., jitter) while ensuring that packets are delivered by their deadlines

Generalizing List Scheduling for Stochastic Soft Real-time Parallel Applications

Advanced architecture processors provide features such as caches and branch prediction that result in improved, but variable, execution time of software. Hard real-time systems require tasks to complete within timing constraints. Consequently, hard real-time systems are typically designed conservatively through the use of tasks? worst-case execution times (WCET) in order to compute deterministic schedules that guarantee task?s execution within giving time constraints. This use of pessimistic execution time assumptions provides real-time guarantees at the cost of decreased performance and resource utilization. In soft real-time systems, however, meeting deadlines is not an absolute requirement (i.e., missing a few deadlines does not severely degrade system performance or cause catastrophic failure). In such systems, a guaranteed minimum probability of completing by the deadline is sufficient. Therefore, there is considerable latitude in such systems for improving resource utilization and performance as compared with hard real-time systems, through the use of more realistic execution time assumptions. Given probability distribution functions (PDFs) representing tasks? execution time requirements, and tasks? communication and precedence requirements, represented as a directed acyclic graph (DAG), this dissertation proposes and investigates algorithms for constructing non-preemptive stochastic schedules. New PDF manipulation operators developed in this dissertation are used to compute tasks? start and completion time PDFs during schedule construction. PDFs of the schedules? completion times are also computed and used to systematically trade the probability of meeting end-to-end deadlines for schedule length and jitter in task completion times. Because of the NP-hard nature of the non-preemptive DAG scheduling problem, the new stochastic scheduling algorithms extend traditional heuristic list scheduling and genetic list scheduling algorithms for DAGs by using PDFs instead of fixed time values for task execution requirements. The stochastic scheduling algorithms also account for delays caused by communication contention, typically ignored in prior DAG scheduling research. Extensive experimental results are used to demonstrate the efficacy of the new algorithms in constructing stochastic schedules. Results also show that through the use of the techniques developed in this dissertation, the probability of meeting deadlines can be usefully traded for performance and jitter in soft real-time systems

Combined Scheduling of Time-Triggered Plans and Priority Scheduled Task Sets

© Owner/Author (2016). This is the author's version of the work. It is posted here for your personal use. Not for redistribution. The definitive Version of Record was published in ACM SIGAda Ada Letters, 36(1), 68-76, http://dx.doi.org/10.1145/10.1145/2971571.2971580.[EN] Preemptive, priority-based scheduling on the one hand, and time-triggered scheduling on the other, are the two major techniques in use for development of real-time and embedded software. Both have their advantages and drawbacks with respect to the other, and are commonly adopted in mutual exclusion. In a previous paper, we proposed a software architecture that enables the combined and controlled execution of time-triggered plans and priority-scheduled tasks. The goal was to take advantage of the best of both approaches by providing deterministic, jitter-controlled execution of time-triggered tasks (e.g., control tasks), coexisting with a set of priority-scheduled tasks, with less demanding jitter requirements. In this paper, we briefly describe the approach, in which the time-triggered plan is executed at the highest priority level, controlled by scheduling decisions taken only at particular points in time, signalled by recurrent timing events. The rest of priority levels are used by a set of concurrent tasks scheduled by static or dynamic priorities. We also discuss several open issues such as schedulability analysis, use of the approach in multiprocessor architectures, usability in mixed-criticality systems and needed changes to make this approach Ravenscar compliant.This work has been partly supported by the Spanish Government’s project M2C2 (TIN2014-56158-C4-1-P-AR) and the European Commission’s project EMC2 (ARTEMIS-JU Call 2013 AIPP-5, Contract 621429).Real Sáez, JV.; Sáez Barona, S.; Crespo Lorente, A. (2016). Combined Scheduling of Time-Triggered Plans and Priority Scheduled Task Sets. Ada Letters. 36(1):68-76. https://doi.org/10.1145/2971571.2971580S6876361T. P. Baker and A. Shaw. The cyclic executive model and Ada. In Proceedings IEEE Real Time Systems Symposium 1988, Huntsville, Alabama, pages 120--129, 1988.P. Balbastre, I. Ripoll, J. Vidal, and A. Crespo. A Task Model to Reduce Control Delays. Real-Time Systems, 27(3):215--236, September 2004.A. Burns and R. Davis. Mixed Criticality Systems - A Review. Technical report, Depatment of Computer Science, University of York, 2013.A. Cervin. Integrated Control and Real-Time Scheduling. PhD thesis, Lund Institute of Technology, April 2003.R. Dobrin. Combining Offline Schedule Construction and Fixed Priority Scheduling in Real-Time Computer Systems. PhD thesis, Mälardalen University, 2005.S. Hong, X. Hu, and M. Lemmon. Reducing Delay Jitter of Real-Time Control Tasks through Adaptive Deadline Adjustments. In IEEE Computer Society, editor, 22nd Euromicro Conference on Real-Time Systems -- ECRTS, pages 229--238, 2010.J. W. S. Liu. Real-Time Systems. Prentice-Hall Inc., 2000.J. Palencia and M. González-Harbour. Schedulability Analysis for Tasks with Static and Dynamic Offsets. In 9th IEEE Real-Time Systems Symposium, 1998.M. J. Pont. The Engineering of Reliable Embedded Systems: LPC1769 edition. Number ISBN: 978-0-9930355-0-0. SafeTTy Systems Limited, 2014.J. Real and A. Crespo. Incorporating Operating Modes to an Ada Real-Time Framework. Ada Letters, 30(1):73--85, April 2010.J. Real, S. Sáez, and A. Crespo. Combining time-triggered plans with priority scheduled task sets. In M. Bertogna and L. M. Pinho, editors, Reliable Software Technologies -- Ada-Europe 2016, volume 9695 of Lecture Notes in Computer Science. Springer, June 2016.S. Sáez, J. Real, and A. Crespo. An integrated framework for multiprocessor, multimoded real-time applications. In M. Brorsson and L. Pinho, editors, Reliable Software Technologies -- Ada-Europe 2012, volume 7308, pages 18--34. Springer-Verlag, June 2012.S. Sáez, J. Real, and A. Crespo. Implementation of Timing-Event Anities in Ada/Linux. Ada Letters, 35(1), April 2015.A. J. Wellings and A. Burns. A Framework for Real-Time Utilities for Ada 2005. Ada Letters, XXVII(2), August 2007

Better Admission Control and Disk Scheduling for Multimedia Applications

General purpose operating systems have been designed to provide fast, loss-free disk service to all applications. However, multimedia applications are capable of tolerating some data loss, but are very sensitive to variation in disk service timing. Present research efforts to handle multimedia applications assume pessimistic disk behaviour when deciding to admit new multimedia connections so as not to violate the real-time application constraints. However, since multimedia applications are ``soft\u27 real-time applications that can tolerate some loss, we propose an optimistic scheme for admission control which uses average case values for disk access. Typically, disk scheduling mechanisms for multimedia applications reduce disk access times by only trying to minimize movement to subsequent blocks after sequencing based on Earliest Deadline First. We propose to implement a disk scheduling algorithm that uses knowledge of the media stored and permissible loss and jitter for each client, in addition to the physical parameters used by the other scheduling algorithms. We will evaluate our approach by implementing our admission control policy and disk scheduling algorithm in Linux and measuring the quality of various multimedia streams. If successful, the contributions of this thesis are the development of new admission control and flexible disk scheduling algorithm for improved multimedia quality of service

smARTflight: An Environmentally-Aware Adaptive Real-Time Flight Management System

Multi-rotor drones require real-time sensor data processing and control to maintain flight stability, which is made more challenging by external disturbances such as wind. In this paper we introduce smARTflight: an environmentally-aware adaptive real-time flight management system. smARTflight adapts the execution frequencies of flight control tasks according to timing and safety-critical constraints, in response to transient fluctuations of a drone’s attitude. In contrast to current state-of-the-art methods, smARTflight’s criticality-aware scheduler reduces the latency to return to a steady-state target attitude. The system also improves the overall control accuracy and lowers the frequency of adjustments to motor speeds to conserve power. A comparative case-study with a well-known autopilot shows that smARTflight reduces unnecessary control loop executions under stable conditions, while reducing response time latency by as much as 60% in a given axis of rotation when subjected to a 15° step attitude disturbance.https://www.cs.bu.edu/fac/richwest/papers/smARTflight-ecrts20.pdfhttps://drops.dagstuhl.de/opus/volltexte/2020/12387/pdf/LIPIcs-ECRTS-2020-24.pdfPublished versio

Erreichen von Performance in Netzwerken-On-Chip für Echtzeitsysteme

In many new applications, such as in automatic driving, high performance requirements have reached safety critical real-time systems. Consequently, Networks-on-Chip (NoCs) must efficiently host new sets of highly dynamic workloads e.g., high resolution sensor fusion and data processing, autonomous decision’s making combined with machine learning. The static platform management, as used in current safety critical systems, is no more sufficient to provide the needed level of service. A dynamic platform management could meet the challenge, but it usually suffers from a lack of predictability and the simplicity necessary for certification of safety and real-time properties. In this work, we propose a novel, global and dynamic arbitration for NoCs with real-time QoS requirements. The mechanism decouples the admission control from arbitration in routers thereby simplifying a dynamic adaptation and real-time analysis. Consequently, the proposed solution allows the deployment of a sophisticated contract-based QoS provisioning without introducing complicated and hard to maintain schemes, known from the frequently applied static arbiters. The presented work introduces an overlay network to synchronize transmissions using arbitration units called Resource Managers (RMs), which allows global and work-conserving scheduling. The description of resource allocation strategies is supplemented by protocol design and verification methodology bringing adaptive control to NoC communication in setups with different QoS requirements and traffic classes. For doing that, a formal worst-case timing analysis for the mechanism has been proposed which demonstrates that this solution not only exposes higher performance in simulation but, even more importantly, consistently reaches smaller formally guaranteed worst-case latencies than other strategies for realistic levels of system's utilization. The approach is not limited to a specific network architecture or topology as the mechanism does not require modifications of routers and therefore can be used together with the majority of existing manycore systems. Indeed, the evaluation followed using the generic performance optimized router designs, as well as two systems-on-chip focused on real-time deployments. The results confirmed that the proposed approach proves to exhibit significantly higher average performance in simulation and execution.In vielen neuen sicherheitskritische Anwendungen, wie z.B. dem automatisierten Fahren, werden große Anforderungen an die Leistung von Echtzeitsysteme gestellt. Daher müssen Networks-on-Chip (NoCs) neue, hochdynamische Workloads wie z.B. hochauflösende Sensorfusion und Datenverarbeitung oder autonome Entscheidungsfindung kombiniert mit maschineller Lernen, effizient auf einem System unterbringen. Die Steuerung der zugrunde liegenden NoC-Architektur, muss die Systemsicherheit vor Fehlern, resultierend aus dem dynamischen Verhalten des Systems schützen und gleichzeitig die geforderte Performance bereitstellen. In dieser Arbeit schlagen wir eine neuartige, globale und dynamische Steuerung für NoCs mit Echtzeit QoS Anforderungen vor. Das Schema entkoppelt die Zutrittskontrolle von der Arbitrierung in Routern. Hierdurch wird eine dynamische Anpassung ermöglicht und die Echtzeitanalyse vereinfacht. Der Einsatz einer ausgefeilten vertragsbasierten Ressourcen-Zuweisung wird so ermöglicht, ohne komplexe und schwer wartbare Mechanismen, welche bereits aus dem statischen Plattformmanagement bekannt sind einzuführen. Diese Arbeit stellt ein übergelagertes Netzwerk vor, welches Übertragungen mit Hilfe von Arbitrierungseinheiten, den so genannten Resource Managern (RMs), synchronisiert. Dieses überlagerte Netzwerk ermöglicht eine globale und lasterhaltende Steuerung. Die Beschreibung verschiedener Ressourcenzuweisungstrategien wird ergänzt durch ein Protokolldesign und Methoden zur Verifikation der adaptiven NoC Steuerung mit unterschiedlichen QoS Anforderungen und Verkehrsklassen. Hierfür wird eine formale Worst Case Timing Analyse präsentiert, welche das vorgestellte Verfahren abbildet. Die Resultate bestätitgen, dass die präsentierte Lösung nicht nur eine höhere Performance in der Simulation bietet, sondern auch formal kleinere Worst-Case Latenzen für realistische Systemauslastungen als andere Strategien garantiert. Der vorgestellte Ansatz ist nicht auf eine bestimmte Netzwerkarchitektur oder Topologie beschränkt, da der Mechanismus keine Änderungen an den unterliegenden Routern erfordert und kann daher zusammen mit bestehenden Manycore-Systemen eingesetzt werden. Die Evaluierung erfolgte auf Basis eines leistungsoptimierten Router-Designs sowie zwei auf Echtzeit-Anwendungen fokusierten Platformen. Die Ergebnisse bestätigten, dass der vorgeschlagene Ansatz im Durchschnitt eine deutlich höhere Leistung in der Simulation und Ausführung liefert