CAPT를 위한 발음 변이 분석 및 CycleGAN 기반 피드백 생성

학위논문(박사)--서울대학교 대학원 :인문대학 협동과정 인지과학전공,2020. 2. 정민화.Despite the growing popularity in learning Korean as a foreign language and the rapid development in language learning applications, the existing computer-assisted pronunciation training (CAPT) systems in Korean do not utilize linguistic characteristics of non-native Korean speech. Pronunciation variations in non-native speech are far more diverse than those observed in native speech, which may pose a difficulty in combining such knowledge in an automatic system. Moreover, most of the existing methods rely on feature extraction results from signal processing, prosodic analysis, and natural language processing techniques. Such methods entail limitations since they necessarily depend on finding the right features for the task and the extraction accuracies. This thesis presents a new approach for corrective feedback generation in a CAPT system, in which pronunciation variation patterns and linguistic correlates with accentedness are analyzed and combined with a deep neural network approach, so that feature engineering efforts are minimized while maintaining the linguistically important factors for the corrective feedback generation task. Investigations on non-native Korean speech characteristics in contrast with those of native speakers, and their correlation with accentedness judgement show that both segmental and prosodic variations are important factors in a Korean CAPT system. The present thesis argues that the feedback generation task can be interpreted as a style transfer problem, and proposes to evaluate the idea using generative adversarial network. A corrective feedback generation model is trained on 65,100 read utterances by 217 non-native speakers of 27 mother tongue backgrounds. The features are automatically learnt in an unsupervised way in an auxiliary classifier CycleGAN setting, in which the generator learns to map a foreign accented speech to native speech distributions. In order to inject linguistic knowledge into the network, an auxiliary classifier is trained so that the feedback also identifies the linguistic error types that were defined in the first half of the thesis. The proposed approach generates a corrected version the speech using the learners own voice, outperforming the conventional Pitch-Synchronous Overlap-and-Add method.외국어로서의 한국어 교육에 대한 관심이 고조되어 한국어 학습자의 수가 크게 증가하고 있으며, 음성언어처리 기술을 적용한 컴퓨터 기반 발음 교육(Computer-Assisted Pronunciation Training; CAPT) 어플리케이션에 대한 연구 또한 적극적으로 이루어지고 있다. 그럼에도 불구하고 현존하는 한국어 말하기 교육 시스템은 외국인의 한국어에 대한 언어학적 특징을 충분히 활용하지 않고 있으며, 최신 언어처리 기술 또한 적용되지 않고 있는 실정이다. 가능한 원인으로써는 외국인 발화 한국어 현상에 대한 분석이 충분하게 이루어지지 않았다는 점, 그리고 관련 연구가 있어도 이를 자동화된 시스템에 반영하기에는 고도화된 연구가 필요하다는 점이 있다. 뿐만 아니라 CAPT 기술 전반적으로는 신호처리, 운율 분석, 자연어처리 기법과 같은 특징 추출에 의존하고 있어서 적합한 특징을 찾고 이를 정확하게 추출하는 데에 많은 시간과 노력이 필요한 실정이다. 이는 최신 딥러닝 기반 언어처리 기술을 활용함으로써 이 과정 또한 발전의 여지가 많다는 바를 시사한다. 따라서 본 연구는 먼저 CAPT 시스템 개발에 있어 발음 변이 양상과 언어학적 상관관계를 분석하였다. 외국인 화자들의 낭독체 변이 양상과 한국어 원어민 화자들의 낭독체 변이 양상을 대조하고 주요한 변이를 확인한 후, 상관관계 분석을 통하여 의사소통에 영향을 미치는 중요도를 파악하였다. 그 결과, 종성 삭제와 3중 대립의 혼동, 초분절 관련 오류가 발생할 경우 피드백 생성에 우선적으로 반영하는 것이 필요하다는 것이 확인되었다. 교정된 피드백을 자동으로 생성하는 것은 CAPT 시스템의 중요한 과제 중 하나이다. 본 연구는 이 과제가 발화의 스타일 변화의 문제로 해석이 가능하다고 보았으며, 생성적 적대 신경망 (Cycle-consistent Generative Adversarial Network; CycleGAN) 구조에서 모델링하는 것을 제안하였다. GAN 네트워크의 생성모델은 비원어민 발화의 분포와 원어민 발화 분포의 매핑을 학습하며, Cycle consistency 손실함수를 사용함으로써 발화간 전반적인 구조를 유지함과 동시에 과도한 교정을 방지하였다. 별도의 특징 추출 과정이 없이 필요한 특징들이 CycleGAN 프레임워크에서 무감독 방법으로 스스로 학습되는 방법으로, 언어 확장이 용이한 방법이다. 언어학적 분석에서 드러난 주요한 변이들 간의 우선순위는 Auxiliary Classifier CycleGAN 구조에서 모델링하는 것을 제안하였다. 이 방법은 기존의 CycleGAN에 지식을 접목시켜 피드백 음성을 생성함과 동시에 해당 피드백이 어떤 유형의 오류인지 분류하는 문제를 수행한다. 이는 도메인 지식이 교정 피드백 생성 단계까지 유지되고 통제가 가능하다는 장점이 있다는 데에 그 의의가 있다. 본 연구에서 제안한 방법을 평가하기 위해서 27개의 모국어를 갖는 217명의 유의미 어휘 발화 65,100개로 피드백 자동 생성 모델을 훈련하고, 개선 여부 및 정도에 대한 지각 평가를 수행하였다. 제안된 방법을 사용하였을 때 학습자 본인의 목소리를 유지한 채 교정된 발음으로 변환하는 것이 가능하며, 전통적인 방법인 음높이 동기식 중첩가산 (Pitch-Synchronous Overlap-and-Add) 알고리즘을 사용하는 방법에 비해 상대 개선률 16.67%이 확인되었다.Chapter 1. Introduction 1 1.1. Motivation 1 1.1.1. An Overview of CAPT Systems 3 1.1.2. Survey of existing Korean CAPT Systems 5 1.2. Problem Statement 7 1.3. Thesis Structure 7 Chapter 2. Pronunciation Analysis of Korean Produced by Chinese 9 2.1. Comparison between Korean and Chinese 11 2.1.1. Phonetic and Syllable Structure Comparisons 11 2.1.2. Phonological Comparisons 14 2.2. Related Works 16 2.3. Proposed Analysis Method 19 2.3.1. Corpus 19 2.3.2. Transcribers and Agreement Rates 22 2.4. Salient Pronunciation Variations 22 2.4.1. Segmental Variation Patterns 22 2.4.1.1. Discussions 25 2.4.2. Phonological Variation Patterns 26 2.4.1.2. Discussions 27 2.5. Summary 29 Chapter 3. Correlation Analysis of Pronunciation Variations and Human Evaluation 30 3.1. Related Works 31 3.1.1. Criteria used in L2 Speech 31 3.1.2. Criteria used in L2 Korean Speech 32 3.2. Proposed Human Evaluation Method 36 3.2.1. Reading Prompt Design 36 3.2.2. Evaluation Criteria Design 37 3.2.3. Raters and Agreement Rates 40 3.3. Linguistic Factors Affecting L2 Korean Accentedness 41 3.3.1. Pearsons Correlation Analysis 41 3.3.2. Discussions 42 3.3.3. Implications for Automatic Feedback Generation 44 3.4. Summary 45 Chapter 4. Corrective Feedback Generation for CAPT 46 4.1. Related Works 46 4.1.1. Prosody Transplantation 47 4.1.2. Recent Speech Conversion Methods 49 4.1.3. Evaluation of Corrective Feedback 50 4.2. Proposed Method: Corrective Feedback as a Style Transfer 51 4.2.1. Speech Analysis at Spectral Domain 53 4.2.2. Self-imitative Learning 55 4.2.3. An Analogy: CAPT System and GAN Architecture 57 4.3. Generative Adversarial Networks 59 4.3.1. Conditional GAN 61 4.3.2. CycleGAN 62 4.4. Experiment 63 4.4.1. Corpus 64 4.4.2. Baseline Implementation 65 4.4.3. Adversarial Training Implementation 65 4.4.4. Spectrogram-to-Spectrogram Training 66 4.5. Results and Evaluation 69 4.5.1. Spectrogram Generation Results 69 4.5.2. Perceptual Evaluation 70 4.5.3. Discussions 72 4.6. Summary 74 Chapter 5. Integration of Linguistic Knowledge in an Auxiliary Classifier CycleGAN for Feedback Generation 75 5.1. Linguistic Class Selection 75 5.2. Auxiliary Classifier CycleGAN Design 77 5.3. Experiment and Results 80 5.3.1. Corpus 80 5.3.2. Feature Annotations 81 5.3.3. Experiment Setup 81 5.3.4. Results 82 5.4. Summary 84 Chapter 6. Conclusion 86 6.1. Thesis Results 86 6.2. Thesis Contributions 88 6.3. Recommendations for Future Work 89 Bibliography 91 Appendix 107 Abstract in Korean 117 Acknowledgments 120Docto

Prediction and Realisation of Conversational Characteristics by Utilising Spontaneous Speech for Unit Selection

Unit selection speech synthesis has reached high levels of naturalness and intelligibility for neutral read aloud speech. However, synthetic speech generated using neutral read aloud data lacks all the attitude, intention and spontaneity associated with everyday conversations. Unit selection is heavily data dependent and thus in order to simulate human conversational speech, or create synthetic voices for believable virtual characters, we need to utilise speech data with examples of how people talk rather than how people read. In this paper we included carefully selected utterances from spontaneous conversational speech in a unit selection voice. Using this voice and by automatically predicting type and placement of lexical fillers and filled pauses we can synthesise utterances with conversational characteristics. A perceptual listening test showed that it is possible to make synthetic speech sound more conversational without degrading naturalness

Utilising Spontaneous Conversational Speech in HMM-Based Speech Synthesis

Spontaneous conversational speech has many characteristics that are currently not well modelled in unit selection and HMM-based speech synthesis. But in order to build synthetic voices more suitable for interaction we need data that exhibits more conversational characteristics than the generally used read aloud sentences. In this paper we will show how carefully selected utterances from a spontaneous conversation was instrumental for building an HMM-based synthetic voices with more natural sounding conversational characteristics than a voice based on carefully read aloud sentences. We also investigated a style blending technique as a solution to the inherent problem of phonetic coverage in spontaneous speech data. But the lack of an appropriate representation of spontaneous speech phenomena probably contributed to results showing that we could not yet compete with the speech quality achieved for grammatical sentences

Modelo acústico de língua inglesa falada por portugueses

Trabalho de projecto de mestrado em Engenharia Informática, apresentado à Universidade de Lisboa, através da Faculdade de Ciências, 2007No contexto do reconhecimento robusto de fala baseado em modelos de Markov não observáveis (do inglês Hidden Markov Models - HMMs) este trabalho descreve algumas metodologias e experiências tendo em vista o reconhecimento de oradores estrangeiros. Quando falamos em Reconhecimento de Fala falamos obrigatoriamente em Modelos Acústicos também. Os modelos acústicos reflectem a maneira como pronunciamos/articulamos uma língua, modelando a sequência de sons emitidos aquando da fala. Essa modelação assenta em segmentos de fala mínimos, os fones, para os quais existe um conjunto de símbolos/alfabetos que representam a sua pronunciação. É no campo da fonética articulatória e acústica que se estuda a representação desses símbolos, sua articulação e pronunciação. Conseguimos descrever palavras analisando as unidades que as constituem, os fones. Um reconhecedor de fala interpreta o sinal de entrada, a fala, como uma sequência de símbolos codificados. Para isso, o sinal é fragmentado em observações de sensivelmente 10 milissegundos cada, reduzindo assim o factor de análise ao intervalo de tempo onde as características de um segmento de som não variam. Os modelos acústicos dão-nos uma noção sobre a probabilidade de uma determinada observação corresponder a uma determinada entidade. É, portanto, através de modelos sobre as entidades do vocabulário a reconhecer que é possível voltar a juntar esses fragmentos de som. Os modelos desenvolvidos neste trabalho são baseados em HMMs. Chamam-se assim por se fundamentarem nas cadeias de Markov (1856 - 1922): sequências de estados onde cada estado é condicionado pelo seu anterior. Localizando esta abordagem no nosso domínio, há que construir um conjunto de modelos - um para cada classe de sons a reconhecer - que serão treinados por dados de treino. Os dados são ficheiros áudio e respectivas transcrições (ao nível da palavra) de modo a que seja possível decompor essa transcrição em fones e alinhá-la a cada som do ficheiro áudio correspondente. Usando um modelo de estados, onde cada estado representa uma observação ou segmento de fala descrita, os dados vão-se reagrupando de maneira a criar modelos estatísticos, cada vez mais fidedignos, que consistam em representações das entidades da fala de uma determinada língua. O reconhecimento por parte de oradores estrangeiros com pronuncias diferentes da língua para qual o reconhecedor foi concebido, pode ser um grande problema para precisão de um reconhecedor. Esta variação pode ser ainda mais problemática que a variação dialectal de uma determinada língua, isto porque depende do conhecimento que cada orador têm relativamente à língua estrangeira. Usando para uma pequena quantidade áudio de oradores estrangeiros para o treino de novos modelos acústicos, foram efectuadas diversas experiências usando corpora de Portugueses a falar Inglês, de Português Europeu e de Inglês. Inicialmente foi explorado o comportamento, separadamente, dos modelos de Ingleses nativos e Portugueses nativos, quando testados com os corpora de teste (teste com nativos e teste com não nativos). De seguida foi treinado um outro modelo usando em simultâneo como corpus de treino, o áudio de Portugueses a falar Inglês e o de Ingleses nativos. Uma outra experiência levada a cabo teve em conta o uso de técnicas de adaptação, tal como a técnica MLLR, do inglês Maximum Likelihood Linear Regression. Esta última permite a adaptação de uma determinada característica do orador, neste caso o sotaque estrangeiro, a um determinado modelo inicial. Com uma pequena quantidade de dados representando a característica que se quer modelar, esta técnica calcula um conjunto de transformações que serão aplicadas ao modelo que se quer adaptar. Foi também explorado o campo da modelação fonética onde estudou-se como é que o orador estrangeiro pronuncia a língua estrangeira, neste caso um Português a falar Inglês. Este estudo foi feito com a ajuda de um linguista, o qual definiu um conjunto de fones, resultado do mapeamento do inventário de fones do Inglês para o Português, que representam o Inglês falado por Portugueses de um determinado grupo de prestígio. Dada a grande variabilidade de pronúncias teve de se definir este grupo tendo em conta o nível de literacia dos oradores. Este estudo foi posteriormente usado na criação de um novo modelo treinado com os corpora de Portugueses a falar Inglês e de Portugueses nativos. Desta forma representamos um reconhecedor de Português nativo onde o reconhecimento de termos ingleses é possível. Tendo em conta a temática do reconhecimento de fala este projecto focou também a recolha de corpora para português europeu e a compilação de um léxico de Português europeu. Na área de aquisição de corpora o autor esteve envolvido na extracção e preparação dos dados de fala telefónica, para posterior treino de novos modelos acústicos de português europeu. Para compilação do léxico de português europeu usou-se um método incremental semi-automático. Este método consistiu em gerar automaticamente a pronunciação de grupos de 10 mil palavras, sendo cada grupo revisto e corrigido por um linguista. Cada grupo de palavras revistas era posteriormente usado para melhorar as regras de geração automática de pronunciações.The tremendous growth of technology has increased the need of integration of spoken language technologies into our daily applications, providing an easy and natural access to information. These applications are of different nature with different user’s interfaces. Besides voice enabled Internet portals or tourist information systems, automatic speech recognition systems can be used in home user’s experiences where TV and other appliances could be voice controlled, discarding keyboards or mouse interfaces, or in mobile phones and palm-sized computers for a hands-free and eyes-free manipulation. The development of these systems causes several known difficulties. One of them concerns the recognizer accuracy on dealing with non-native speakers with different phonetic pronunciations of a given language. The non-native accent can be more problematic than a dialect variation on the language. This mismatch depends on the individual speaking proficiency and speaker’s mother tongue. Consequently, when the speaker’s native language is not the same as the one that was used to train the recognizer, there is a considerable loss in recognition performance. In this thesis, we examine the problem of non-native speech in a speaker-independent and large-vocabulary recognizer in which a small amount of non-native data was used for training. Several experiments were performed using Hidden Markov models, trained with speech corpora containing European Portuguese native speakers, English native speakers and English spoken by European Portuguese native speakers. Initially it was explored the behaviour of an English native model and non-native English speakers’ model. Then using different corpus weights for the English native speakers and English spoken by Portuguese speakers it was trained a model as a pool of accents. Through adaptation techniques it was used the Maximum Likelihood Linear Regression method. It was also explored how European Portuguese speakers pronounce English language studying the correspondences between the phone sets of the foreign and target languages. The result was a new phone set, consequence of the mapping between the English and the Portuguese phone sets. Then a new model was trained with English Spoken by Portuguese speakers’ data and Portuguese native data. Concerning the speech recognition subject this work has other two purposes: collecting Portuguese corpora and supporting the compilation of a Portuguese lexicon, adopting some methods and algorithms to generate automatic phonetic pronunciations. The collected corpora was processed in order to train acoustic models to be used in the Exchange 2007 domain, namely in Outlook Voice Access

SYNTHESIZING DYSARTHRIC SPEECH USING MULTI-SPEAKER TTS FOR DSYARTHRIC SPEECH RECOGNITION

Dysarthria is a motor speech disorder often characterized by reduced speech intelligibility through slow, uncoordinated control of speech production muscles. Automatic Speech recognition (ASR) systems may help dysarthric talkers communicate more effectively. However, robust dysarthria-specific ASR requires a significant amount of training speech is required, which is not readily available for dysarthric talkers. In this dissertation, we investigate dysarthric speech augmentation and synthesis methods. To better understand differences in prosodic and acoustic characteristics of dysarthric spontaneous speech at varying severity levels, a comparative study between typical and dysarthric speech was conducted. These characteristics are important components for dysarthric speech modeling, synthesis, and augmentation. For augmentation, prosodic transformation and time-feature masking have been proposed. For dysarthric speech synthesis, this dissertation has introduced a modified neural multi-talker TTS by adding a dysarthria severity level coefficient and a pause insertion model to synthesize dysarthric speech for varying severity levels. In addition, we have extended this work by using a label propagation technique to create more meaningful control variables such as a continuous Respiration, Laryngeal and Tongue (RLT) parameter, even for datasets that only provide discrete dysarthria severity level information. This approach increases the controllability of the system, so we are able to generate more dysarthric speech with a broader range. To evaluate their effectiveness for synthesis of training data, dysarthria-specific speech recognition was used. Results show that a DNN-HMM model trained on additional synthetic dysarthric speech achieves WER improvement of 12.2% compared to the baseline, and that the addition of the severity level and pause insertion controls decrease WER by 6.5%, showing the effectiveness of adding these parameters. Overall results on the TORGO database demonstrate that using dysarthric synthetic speech to increase the amount of dysarthric-patterned speech for training has a significant impact on the dysarthric ASR systems

Statistical parametric speech synthesis using conversational data and phenomena

Statistical parametric text-to-speech synthesis currently relies on predefined and highly controlled prompts read in a “neutral” voice. This thesis presents work on utilising recordings of free conversation for the purpose of filled pause synthesis and as an inspiration for improved general modelling of speech for text-to-speech synthesis purposes. A corpus of both standard prompts and free conversation is presented and the potential usefulness of conversational speech as the basis for text-to-speech voices is validated. Additionally, through psycholinguistic experimentation it is shown that filled pauses can have potential subconscious benefits to the listener but that current text-to-speech voices cannot replicate these effects. A method for pronunciation variant forced alignment is presented in order to obtain a more accurate automatic speech segmentation something which is particularly bad for spontaneously produced speech. This pronunciation variant alignment is utilised not only to create a more accurate underlying acoustic model, but also as the driving force behind creating more natural pronunciation prediction at synthesis time. While this improves both the standard and spontaneous voices the naturalness of spontaneous speech based voices still lags behind the quality of voices based on standard read prompts. Thus, the synthesis of filled pauses is investigated in relation to specific phonetic modelling of filled pauses and through techniques for the mixing of standard prompts with spontaneous utterances in order to retain the higher quality of standard speech based voices while still utilising the spontaneous speech for filled pause modelling. A method for predicting where to insert filled pauses in the speech stream is also developed and presented, relying on an analysis of human filled pause usage and a mix of language modelling methods. The method achieves an insertion accuracy in close agreement with human usage. The various approaches are evaluated and their improvements documented throughout the thesis, however, at the end the resulting filled pause quality is assessed through a repetition of the psycholinguistic experiments and an evaluation of the compilation of all developed methods

Toward a needs-based architecture for 'intelligent' communicative agents: speaking with intention

The past few years have seen considerable progress in the deployment of voice-enabled personal assistants, first on smartphones (such as Apple’s Siri) and most recently as standalone devices in people’s homes (such as Amazon’s Alexa). Such ‘intelligent’ communicative agents are distinguished from the previous generation of speech-based systems in that they claim to offer access to services and information via conversational interaction (rather than simple voice commands). In reality, conversations with such agents have limited depth and, after initial enthusiasm, users typically revert to more traditional ways of getting things done. It is argued here that one source of the problem is that the standard architecture for a contemporary spoken language interface fails to capture the fundamental teleological properties of human spoken language. As a consequence, users have difficulty engaging with such systems, primarily due to a gross mismatch in intentional priors. This paper presents an alternative needs-driven cognitive architecture which models speech-based interaction as an emergent property of coupled hierarchical feedback-control processes in which a speaker has in mind the needs of a listener and a listener has in mind the intentions of a speaker. The implications of this architecture for future spoken language systems are illustrated using results from a new type of ‘intentional speech synthesiser’ that is capable of optimising its pronunciation in unpredictable acoustic environments as a function of its perceived communicative success. It is concluded that such purposeful behavior is essential to the facilitation of meaningful and productive spoken language interaction between human beings and autonomous social agents (such as robots). However, it is also noted that persistent mismatched priors may ultimately impose a fundamental limit on the effectiveness of speech-based human–robot interaction

Emotional Prosody Measurement (EPM): A voice-based evaluation method for psychological therapy effectiveness

The voice embodies three sources of information: speech, the identity, and the emotional state of the speaker (i.e., emotional prosody). The latter feature is resembled by the variability of the F0 (also named fundamental frequency of pitch) (SD F0). To extract this feature, Emotional Prosody Measurement (EPM) was developed, which consists of 1) speech recording, 2) removal of speckle noise, 3) a Fourier Transform to extract the F0-signal, and 4) the determination of SD F0. After a pilot study in which six participants mimicked emotions by their voice, the core experiment was conducted to see whether EPM is successful. Twenty-five patients suffering from a panic disorder with agoraphobia participated. Two methods (storytelling and reliving) were used to trigger anxiety and were compared with comparable but more relaxed conditions. This resulted in a unique database of speech samples that was used to compare the EPM with the Subjective Unit of Distress to validate it as measure for anxiety/stress. The experimental manipulation of anxiety proved to be successful and EPM proved to be a successful evaluation method for psychological therapy effectiveness