Reasoning on Feature Models: Compilation-Based vs. Direct Approaches

Analyzing a Feature Model (FM) and reasoning on the corresponding configuration space is a central task in Software Product Line (SPL) engineering. Problems such as deciding the satisfiability of the FM and eliminating inconsistent parts of the FM have been well resolved by translating the FM into a conjunctive normal form (CNF) formula, and then feeding the CNF to a SAT solver. However, this approach has some limits for other important reasoning issues about the FM, such as counting or enumerating configurations. Two mainstream approaches have been investigated in this direction: (i) direct approaches, using tools based on the CNF representation of the FM at hand, or (ii) compilation-based approaches, where the CNF representation of the FM has first been translated into another representation for which the reasoning queries are easier to address. Our contribution is twofold. First, we evaluate how both approaches compare when dealing with common reasoning operations on FM, namely counting configurations, pointing out one or several configurations, sampling configurations, and finding optimal configurations regarding a utility function. Our experimental results show that the compilation-based is efficient enough to possibly compete with the direct approaches and that the cost of translation (i.e., the compilation time) can be balanced when addressing sufficiently many complex reasoning operations on large configuration spaces. Second, we provide a Java-based automated reasoner that supports these operations for both approaches, thus eliminating the burden of selecting the appropriate tool and approach depending on the operation one wants to perform

SAT-based approaches for constraint optimization

La optimització amb restriccions ha estat utilitzada amb èxit par a resoldre problemes en molts dominis reals (industrials). Aquesta tesi es centra en les aproximacions lògiques, concretament en Màxima Satisfactibilitat (MaxSAT) que és la versió d’optimització del problema de Satisfactibilitat booleana (SAT). A través de MaxSAT, s’han resolt molts problemes de forma eficient. Famílies d’instàncies de la majoria d’aquests problemes han estat sotmeses a la MaxSAT Evaluation (MSE), creant així una col•lecció pública i accessible d’instàncies de referència. En les edicions recents de la MSE, els algorismes SAT-based han estat les aproximacions que han tingut un millor comportament per a les instàncies industrials. Aquesta tesi està centrada en millorar els algorismes SAT-based . El nostre treball ha contribuït a tancar varies instàncies obertes i a reduir dramàticament el temps de resolució en moltes altres. A més, hem trobat sorprenentment que reformular y resoldre el problema MaxSAT a través de programació lineal sencera era especialment adequat per algunes famílies. Finalment, hem desenvolupat el primer portfoli altament eficient par a MaxSAT que ha dominat en totes las categories de la MSE des de 2013.La optimización con restricciones ha sido utilizada con éxito para resolver problemas en muchos dominios reales (industriales). Esta tesis se centra en las aproximaciones lógicas, concretamente en Máxima Satisfacibilidad (MaxSAT) que es la versión de optimización del problema de Satisfacibilidad booleana (SAT). A través de MaxSAT, se han resuelto muchos problemas de forma eficiente. Familias de instancias de la mayoría de ellos han sido sometidas a la MaxSAT Evaluation (MSE), creando así una colección pública y accesible de instancias de referencia. En las ediciones recientes de la MSE, los algoritmos SAT-based han sido las aproximaciones que han tenido un mejor comportamiento para las instancias industriales. Esta tesis está centrada en mejorar los algoritmos SAT-based. Nuestro trabajo ha contribuido a cerrar varias instancias abiertas y a reducir dramáticamente el tiempo de resolución en muchas otras. Además, hemos encontrado sorprendentemente que reformular y resolver el problema MaxSAT a través de programación lineal entera era especialmente adecuado para algunas familias. Finalmente, hemos desarrollado el primer portfolio altamente eficiente para MaxSAT que ha dominado en todas las categorías de la MSE desde 2013.Constraint optimization has been successfully used to solve problems in many real world (industrial) domains. This PhD thesis is focused on logic-based approaches, in particular, on Maximum Satisfiability (MaxSAT) which is the optimization version of Satisfiability (SAT). There have been many problems efficiency solved through MaxSAT. Instance families on the majority of them have been submitted to the international MaxSAT Evaluation (MSE), creating a collection of publicly available benchmark instances. At recent editions of MSE, SAT-based algorithms were the best performing single algorithm approaches for industrial problems. This PhD thesis is focused on the improvement of SAT-based algorithms. All this work has contributed to close up some open instances and to reduce dramatically the solving time in many others. In addition, we have surprisingly found that reformulating and solving the MaxSAT problem through Integer Linear Programming (ILP) was extremely well suited for some families. Finally, we have developed the first highly efficient MaxSAT portfolio that dominated all categories of MSE since 2013

SAT-based Analysis, (Re-)Configuration & Optimization in the Context of Automotive Product documentation

Es gibt einen steigenden Trend hin zu kundenindividueller Massenproduktion (mass customization), insbesondere im Bereich der Automobilkonfiguration. Kundenindividuelle Massenproduktion führt zu einem enormen Anstieg der Komplexität. Es gibt Hunderte von Ausstattungsoptionen aus denen ein Kunde wählen kann um sich sein persönliches Auto zusammenzustellen. Die Anzahl der unterschiedlichen konfigurierbaren Autos eines deutschen Premium-Herstellers liegt für ein Fahrzeugmodell bei bis zu 10^80. SAT-basierte Methoden haben sich zur Verifikation der Stückliste (bill of materials) von Automobilkonfigurationen etabliert. Carsten Sinz hat Mitte der 90er im Bereich der SAT-basierten Verifikationsmethoden für die Daimler AG Pionierarbeit geleistet. Darauf aufbauend wurde nach 2005 ein produktives Software System bei der Daimler AG installiert. Später folgten weitere deutsche Automobilhersteller und installierten ebenfalls SAT-basierte Systeme zur Verifikation ihrer Stücklisten. Die vorliegende Arbeit besteht aus zwei Hauptteilen. Der erste Teil beschäftigt sich mit der Entwicklung weiterer SAT-basierter Methoden für Automobilkonfigurationen. Wir zeigen, dass sich SAT-basierte Methoden für interaktive Automobilkonfiguration eignen. Wir behandeln unterschiedliche Aspekte der interaktiven Konfiguration. Darunter Konsistenzprüfung, Generierung von Beispielen, Erklärungen und die Vermeidung von Fehlkonfigurationen. Außerdem entwickeln wir SAT-basierte Methoden zur Verifikation von dynamischen Zusammenbauten. Ein dynamischer Zusammenbau repräsentiert die chronologische Zusammenbau-Reihenfolge komplexer Teile. Der zweite Teil beschäftigt sich mit der Optimierung von Automobilkonfigurationen. Wir erläutern und vergleichen unterschiedliche Optimierungsprobleme der Aussagenlogik sowie deren algorithmische Lösungsansätze. Wir beschreiben Anwendungsfälle aus der Automobilkonfiguration und zeigen wie diese als aussagenlogisches Optimierungsproblem formalisiert werden können. Beispielsweise möchte man zu einer Menge an Ausstattungswünschen ein Test-Fahrzeug mit minimaler Ergänzung weiterer Ausstattungen berechnen um Kosten zu sparen. DesWeiteren beschäftigen wir uns mit der Problemstellung eine kleinste Menge an Fahrzeugen zu berechnen um eine Testmenge abzudecken. Im Rahmen dieser Arbeit haben wir einen Prototypen eines (Re-)Konfigurators, genannt AutoConfig, entwickelt. Unser (Re-)Konfigurator verwendet im Kern SAT-basierte Methoden und besitzt eine grafische Benutzeroberfläche, welche interaktive Konfiguration erlaubt. AutoConfig kann mit Instanzen von drei großen deutschen Automobilherstellern umgehen, aber ist nicht alleine darauf beschränkt. Mit Hilfe dieses Prototyps wollen wir die Anwendbarkeit unserer Methoden demonstrieren

On Formal Methods for Large-Scale Product Configuration

<p>In product development companies mass customization is widely used to achieve better customer satisfaction while keeping costs down. To efficiently implement mass customization, product platforms are often used. A product platform allows building a wide range of products from a set of predefined components. The process of matching these components to customers' needs is called product configuration. Not all components can be combined with each other due to restrictions of various kinds, for example, geometrical, marketing and legal reasons. Product design engineers develop configuration constraints to describe such restrictions. The number of constraints and the complexity of the relations between them are immense for complex product like a vehicle. Thus, it is both error-prone and time consuming to analyze, author and verify the constraints manually. Software tools based on formal methods can help engineers to avoid making errors when working with configuration constraints, thus design a correct product faster.</p> <p>This thesis introduces a number of formal methods to help engineers maintain, verify and analyze product configuration constraints. These methods provide automatic verification of constraints and computational support for analyzing and refactoring constraints. The methods also allow verifying the correctness of one specific type of constraints, item usage rules, for sets of mutually-exclusive required items, and automatic verification of equivalence of different formulations of the constraints. The thesis also introduces three methods for efficient enumeration of valid partial configurations, with benchmarking of the methods on an industrial dataset.</p> <p>Handling large-scale industrial product configuration problems demands high efficiency from the software methods. This thesis investigates a number of search-based and knowledge-compilation-based methods for working with large product configuration instances, including Boolean satisfiability solvers, binary decision diagrams and decomposable negation normal form. This thesis also proposes a novel method based on supervisory control theory for efficient reasoning about product configuration data. The methods were implemented in a tool, to investigate the applicability of the methods for handling large product configuration problems. It was found that search-based Boolean satisfiability solvers with incremental capabilities are well suited for industrial configuration problems.</p> <p>The methods proposed in this thesis exhibit good performance on practical configuration problems, and have a potential to be implemented in industry to support product design engineers in creating and maintaining configuration constraints, and speed up the development of product platforms and new products.</p

Du génie logiciel pour déployer, gérer et reconfigurer les logiciels

As a discipline, software engineering embraces various schools of thought, yet remains consistent with respect to its objective. It aims at providing means for effective and inexpensive production of software by contributing mathematical frameworks, methods and tools. Consequently, we witness some automation in software production process that, as of today, allows producing astronomical amounts of lines of code daily. This rapidly and massively produced software is required for all computer equipment that has invaded our daily life in various forms of other devices (PC, tablet, phone, refrigerator, car, etc.). In this world of large software consumption, it is somewhat surprising that the management of software, after its production, remains dominated by manual practices like searching in lists, downloading units and manual installations. In this context, I organized my research activities such that they aim at providing mathematical frameworks, methods and tools to deploy, distribute or update massive amounts of software since 2001, the year of my PhD defense. These research activities were mainly conducted in Brest at the CS department of Telecom Bretagne as part of the PASS team of IRISA. This document puts into perspective my various scientific contributions, undertaken projects, endeavors in training research students and efforts invested as a teacher. My scientific contributions can be divided into five parts: mathematical models and algorithms for dependency management in software deployment; software component models; processes and tools for massive software deployment; dynamic update of programs at runtime; languages for the design and implementation of software development processes. All these works complement each other, thus making it possible to imagine the proposition of methods and tools for large-scale software deployment.Le génie logiciel est une discipline constituée de nombreux courants mais cohérente par l'objectif affiché. Il s'agit d'aider à la production, de manière efficace et peu coûteuse, de logiciels en offrant des cadres mathématiques, des méthodes et des outils. Ainsi, on a pu assister à une certaine industrialisation du processus de production de logiciel qui permet aujourd'hui de produire, chaque jour, des quantités astronomiques de logiciel. Ce logiciel produit rapidement et en grande quantité est nécessaire pour tous les équipements informatiques qui ont envahi notre quotidien (ordinateur, tablette, téléphone, réfrigérateur, voiture, ...). Dans ce monde de grande consommation du logiciel, il est cependant surprenant de constater que la gestion des logiciels après leur production est resté dominé par des pratiques manuelles de recherche dans des listes, de téléchargement unitaire et d'installation manuelle. C'est dans ce cadre que j'ai développé une activité de recherche visant à fournir des cadres mathématiques, des méthodes et des outils pour déployer, diffuser ou mettre à jour massivement les logiciels depuis 2001 année de ma soutenance de thèse. Ces activités de recherche ont été conduites principalement à Brest au sein du département informatique de Télécom Bretagne dans le cadre de l'équipe PASS de l'IRISA. Mon Habilitation à Diriger des Recherches est l'occasion de remettre en perspective mes différentes contributions scientifiques, les étudiants formés à la recherche, les projets réalisés ainsi que mon investissement en tant qu'enseignant. Les contributions scientifiques peuvent être classées en cinq parties : - des modèles mathématiques et les algorithmes associés pour la gestion des dépendances de logiciels lors de leur déploiement ; - les modèles de composants logiciels ; - les processus et outils pour le déploiement de logiciel massif ; - la mise à jour de programmes sans interrompre leur exécution ; - des langages pour la conception et la réalisation de processus de développement logiciel. Tous ces travaux qui se nourrissent et se complètent permettent d'imaginer la proposition de méthodes et outils pour passer à l'échelle dans la gestion du déploiement des logiciels