Predicting Java Computer Programming Task Difficulty Levels Using EEG for Educational Environments

Understanding how difficult a learning task is for a person allows teaching material to be appropriately designed to suit the person, especially for programming material. A first step for this would be to predict on the task difficulty level. While this is possible through subjective questionnaire, it could lead to misleading outcome and it would be better to do this by tapping the actual thought process in the brain while the subject is performing the task, which can be done using electroencephalogram. We set out on this objective and show that it is possible to predict easy and difficult levels of mental tasks when subjects are attempting to solve Java programming problems. Using a proposed confidence threshold, we obtained a classification performance of 87.05% thereby showing that it is possible to use brain data to determine the teaching material difficulty level which will be useful in educational environments

Affective e-learning approaches, technology and implementation model: a systematic review

A systematic literature study including articles from 2016 to 2022 was done to evaluate the various approaches, technologies, and implementation models involved in measuring student engagement during learning. The review’s objective was to compile and analyze all studies that investigated how instructors can gauge students’ mental states while teaching and assess the most effective teaching methods. Additionally, it aims to extract and assess expanded methodologies from chosen research publications to offer suggestions and answers to researchers and practitioners. Planning, carrying out the analysis, and publishing the results have all received significant attention in the research approach. The study’s findings indicate that more needs to be done to evaluate student participation objectively and follow their development for improved academic performance. Physiological approaches should be given more support among the alternatives. While deep learning implementation models and contactless technology should interest more researchers. And, the recommender system should be integrated into e-learning system. Other approaches, technologies, and methodology articles, on the other hand, lacked authenticity in conveying student feeling

Representational Learning Approach for Predicting Developer Expertise Using Eye Movements

The thesis analyzes an existing eye-tracking dataset collected while software developers were solving bug fixing tasks in an open-source system. The analysis is performed using a representational learning approach namely, Multi-layer Perceptron (MLP). The novel aspect of the analysis is the introduction of a new feature engineering method based on the eye-tracking data. This is then used to predict developer expertise on the data. The dataset used in this thesis is inherently more complex because it is collected in a very dynamic environment i.e., the Eclipse IDE using an eye-tracking plugin, iTrace. Previous work in this area only worked on short code snippets that do not represent how developers usually program in a realistic setting. A comparative analysis between representational learning and non-representational learning (Support Vector Machine, Naive Bayes, Decision Tree, and Random Forest) is also presented. The results are obtained from an extensive set of experiments (with an 80/20 training and testing split) which show that representational learning (MLP) works well on our dataset reporting an average higher accuracy of 30% more for all tasks. Furthermore, a state-of-the-art method for feature engineering is proposed to extract features from the eye-tracking data. The average accuracy on all the tasks is 93.4% with a recall of 78.8% and an F1 score of 81.6%. We discuss the implications of these results on the future of automated prediction of developer expertise. Adviser: Bonita Shari

Leveraging Targeted Regions of Interest by Analyzing Code Comprehension With AI-Enabled Eye-Tracking

Code comprehension studies techniques for extracting information that give insights on how code is understood. For educators teaching programming courses, this is an important but often difficult task, especially given the challenges of large class sizes, limited time, and grading resources. By analyzing where a student looks during a code comprehension task, instructors can gain insights into what information the student deems important and assess whether they are looking in the right areas of the code. The proportion of time spent viewing a part of the code is also a useful indicator of the student\u27s decision-making process. The goal of this research is to analyze the differences in how students\u27 eyes traverse across code during coding comprehension activities and to offer a systematic way for distinguishing students with a solid understanding of the exercise from those who require further assistance. The study uses coding exercises seeded with errors, measured fixation counts, and average fixation durations of the students\u27 eyes within targeted regions of interest (TROI) using an AI-Enabled Eye-Tracking System (NiCATS). The results of the study showed that students\u27 grades (as a proxy for understanding of the code\u27s context and their decision-making skills) were positively correlated with a higher ratio of the number of fixations in the TROI

Virtual Reality Games for Motor Rehabilitation

This paper presents a fuzzy logic based method to track user satisfaction without the need for devices to monitor users physiological conditions. User satisfaction is the key to any product’s acceptance; computer applications and video games provide a unique opportunity to provide a tailored environment for each user to better suit their needs. We have implemented a non-adaptive fuzzy logic model of emotion, based on the emotional component of the Fuzzy Logic Adaptive Model of Emotion (FLAME) proposed by El-Nasr, to estimate player emotion in UnrealTournament 2004. In this paper we describe the implementation of this system and present the results of one of several play tests. Our research contradicts the current literature that suggests physiological measurements are needed. We show that it is possible to use a software only method to estimate user emotion

Multimodal data as a means to understand the learning experience

publishedVersionPaid Open AccessUNIT-agreemen

Affective modelling and feedback in programming practice systems

指導教員：角　

Embedding mobile learning into everyday life settings

The increasing ubiquity of smartphones has changed the way we interact with information and acquire new knowledge. The prevalence of personal mobile devices in our everyday lives creates new opportunities for learning that exceed the narrow boundaries of a school’s classroom and provide the foundations for lifelong learning. Learning can now happen whenever and wherever we are; whether on the sofa at home, on the bus during our commute, or on a break at work. However, the flexibility offered by mobile learning also creates its challenges. Being able to learn anytime and anywhere does not necessarily result in learning uptake. Without the school environment’s controlled schedule and teacher guidance, the learners must actively initiate learning activities, keep up repetition schedules, and cope with learning in interruption-prone everyday environments. Both interruptions and infrequent repetition can harm the learning process and long-term memory retention. We argue that current mobile learning applications insufficiently support users in coping with these challenges. In this thesis, we explore how we can utilize the ubiquity of mobile devices to ensure frequent engagement with the content, focusing primarily on language learning and supporting users in dealing with learning breaks and interruptions. Following a user-centered design approach, we first analyzed mobile learning behavior in everyday settings. Based on our findings, we proposed concepts and designs, developed research prototypes, and evaluated them in laboratory and field evaluations with a specific focus on user experience. To better understand users’ learning behavior with mobile devices, we first characterized their interaction with mobile learning apps through a detailed survey and a diary study. Both methods confirmed the enormous diversity in usage situations and preferences. We observed that learning often happens unplanned, infrequently, among the company of friends or family, or while simultaneously performing secondary tasks such as watching TV or eating. The studies further uncovered a significant prevalence of interruptions in everyday settings that affected users’ learning behavior, often leading to suspension and termination of the learning activities. We derived design implications to support learning in diverse situations, particularly aimed at mitigating the adverse effects of multitasking and interruptions. The proposed strategies should help designers and developers create mobile learning applications that adapt to the opportunities and challenges of learning in everyday mobile settings. We explored four main challenges, emphasizing that (1) we need to consider that Learning in Everyday Settings is Diverse and Interruption-prone, (2) learning performance is affected by Irregular and Infrequent Practice Behavior, (3) we need to move From Static to Personalized Learning, and (4) that Interruptions and Long Learning Breaks can Negatively Affect Performance. To tackle these challenges, we propose to embed learning into everyday smartphone interactions, which could foster frequent engagement with – and implicitly personalize – learning content (according to users’ interests and skills). Further, we investigate how memory cues could be applied to support task resumption after interruptions in mobile learning. To confirm that our idea of embedding learning into everyday interactions can increase exposure, we developed an application integrating learning tasks into the smartphone authentication process. Since unlocking the smartphone is a frequently performed action without any other purpose, our subjects appreciated the idea of utilizing this process to perform quick and simple learning interactions. Evidence from a comparative user study showed that embedding learning tasks into the unlocking mechanism led to significantly more interactions with the learning content without impairing the learning quality. We further explored a method for embedding language comprehension assessment into users’ digital reading and listening activities. By applying physiological measurements as implicit input, we reliably detected unknown words during laboratory evaluations. Identifying such knowledge gaps could be used for the provision of in-situ support and to inform the generation of personalized language learning content tailored to users’ interests and proficiency levels. To investigate memory cueing as a concept to support task resumption after interruptions, we complemented a theoretical literature analysis of existing applications with two research probes implementing and evaluating promising design concepts. We showed that displaying memory cues when the user resumes the learning activity after an interruption improves their subjective user experience. A subsequent study presented an outlook on the generalizability of memory cues beyond the narrow use case of language learning. We observed that the helpfulness of memory cues for reflecting on prior learning is highly dependent on the design of the cues, particularly the granularity of the presented information. We consider interactive cues for specific memory reactivation (e.g., through multiple-choice questions) a promising scaffolding concept for connecting individual micro-learning sessions when learning in everyday settings. The tools and applications described in this thesis are a starting point for designing applications that support learning in everyday settings. We broaden the understanding of learning behavior and highlight the impact of interruptions in our busy everyday lives. While this thesis focuses mainly on language learning, the concepts and methods have the potential to be generalized to other domains, such as STEM learning. We reflect on the limitations of the presented concepts and outline future research perspectives that utilize the ubiquity of mobile devices to design mobile learning interactions for everyday settings.Die Allgegenwärtigkeit von Smartphones verändert die Art und Weise wie wir mit Informationen umgehen und Wissen erwerben. Die weite Verbreitung von mobilen Endgeräten in unserem täglichen Leben führt zu neuen Möglichkeiten des Lernens, welche über die engen Grenzen eines Klassenraumes hinausreichen und das Fundament für lebenslanges Lernen schaffen. Lernen kann nun zu jeder Zeit und an jedem Ort stattfinden: auf dem Sofa Zuhause, im Bus während des Pendelns oder in der Pause auf der Arbeit. Die Flexibilität des mobilen Lernens geht jedoch zeitgleich mit Herausforderungen einher. Ohne den kontrollierten Ablaufplan und die Unterstützung der Lehrpersonen im schulischen Umfeld sind die Lernenden selbst dafür verantwortlich, aktiv Lernsitzungen zu initiieren, Wiederholungszyklen einzuhalten und Lektionen in unterbrechungsanfälligen Alltagssituationen zu meistern. Sowohl Unterbrechungen als auch unregelmäßige Wiederholung von Inhalten können den Lernprozess behindern und der Langzeitspeicherung der Informationen schaden. Wir behaupten, dass aktuelle mobile Lernanwendungen die Nutzer*innen nur unzureichend in diesen Herausforderungen unterstützen. In dieser Arbeit erforschen wir, wie wir uns die Allgegenwärtigkeit mobiler Endgeräte zunutze machen können, um zu erreichen, dass Nutzer*innen regelmäßig mit den Lerninhalten interagieren. Wir fokussieren uns darauf, sie im Umgang mit Unterbrechungen und Lernpausen zu unterstützen. In einem nutzerzentrierten Designprozess analysieren wir zunächst das Lernverhalten auf mobilen Endgeräten in alltäglichen Situationen. Basierend auf den Erkenntnissen schlagen wir Konzepte und Designs vor, entwickeln Forschungsprototypen und werten diese in Labor- und Feldstudien mit Fokus auf User Experience (wörtl. “Nutzererfahrung”) aus. Um das Lernverhalten von Nutzer*innen mit mobilen Endgeräten besser zu verstehen, versuchen wir zuerst die Interaktionen mit mobilen Lernanwendungen durch eine detaillierte Umfrage und eine Tagebuchstudie zu charakterisieren. Beide Methoden bestätigen eine enorme Vielfalt von Nutzungssituationen und -präferenzen. Wir beobachten, dass Lernen oft ungeplant, unregelmäßig, im Beisein von Freunden oder Familie, oder während der Ausübung anderer Tätigkeiten, beispielsweise Fernsehen oder Essen, stattfindet. Die Studien decken zudem Unterbrechungen in Alltagssituationen auf, welche das Lernverhalten der Nutzer*innen beeinflussen und oft zum Aussetzen oder Beenden der Lernaktivität führen. Wir leiten Implikationen ab, um Lernen in vielfältigen Situationen zu unterstützen und besonders die negativen Einflüsse von Multitasking und Unterbrechungen abzuschwächen. Die vorgeschlagenen Strategien sollen Designer*innen und Entwickler*innen helfen, mobile Lernanwendungen zu erstellen, welche sich den Möglichkeiten und Herausforderungen von Lernen in Alltagssituationen anpassen. Wir haben vier zentrale Herausforderungen identifiziert: (1) Lernen in Alltagssituationen ist divers und anfällig für Unterbrechungen; (2) Die Lerneffizienz wird durch unregelmäßiges Wiederholungsverhalten beeinflusst; (3) Wir müssen von statischem zu personalisiertem Lernen übergehen; (4) Unterbrechungen und lange Lernpausen können dem Lernen schaden. Um diese Herausforderungen anzugehen, schlagen wir vor, Lernen in alltägliche Smartphoneinteraktionen einzubetten. Dies führt zu einer vermehrten Beschäftigung mit Lerninhalten und könnte zu einer impliziten Personalisierung von diesen anhand der Interessen und Fähigkeiten der Nutzer*innen beitragen. Zudem untersuchen wir, wie Memory Cues (wörtl. “Gedächtnishinweise”) genutzt werden können, um das Fortsetzen von Aufgaben nach Unterbrechungen im mobilen Lernen zu erleichtern. Um zu zeigen, dass unsere Idee des Einbettens von Lernaufgaben in alltägliche Interaktionen wirklich die Beschäftigung mit diesen erhöht, haben wir eine Anwendung entwickelt, welche Lernaufgaben in den Entsperrprozess von Smartphones integriert. Da die Authentifizierung auf dem Mobilgerät eine häufig durchgeführte Aktion ist, welche keinen weiteren Mehrwert bietet, begrüßten unsere Studienteilnehmenden die Idee, den Prozess für die Durchführung kurzer und einfacher Lerninteraktionen zu nutzen. Ergebnisse aus einer vergleichenden Nutzerstudie haben gezeigt, dass die Einbettung von Aufgaben in den Entsperrprozess zu signifikant mehr Interaktionen mit den Lerninhalten führt, ohne dass die Lernqualität beeinträchtigt wird. Wir haben außerdem eine Methode untersucht, welche die Messung von Sprachverständnis in die digitalen Lese- und Höraktivitäten der Nutzer*innen einbettet. Mittels physiologischer Messungen als implizite Eingabe können wir in Laborstudien zuverlässig unbekannte Wörter erkennen. Die Aufdeckung solcher Wissenslücken kann genutzt werden, um in-situ Untestützung bereitzustellen und um personalisierte Lerninhalte zu generieren, welche auf die Interessen und das Wissensniveau der Nutzer*innen zugeschnitten sind. Um Memory Cues als Konzept für die Unterstützung der Aufgabenfortsetzung nach Unterbrechungen zu untersuchen, haben wir eine theoretische Literaturanalyse von bestehenden Anwendungen um zwei Forschungsarbeiten erweitert, welche vielversprechende Designkonzepte umsetzen und evaluieren. Wir haben gezeigt, dass die Präsentation von Memory Cues die subjektive User Experience verbessert, wenn der Nutzer die Lernaktivität nach einer Unterbrechung fortsetzt. Eine Folgestudie stellt einen Ausblick auf die Generalisierbarkeit von Memory Cues dar, welcher über den Tellerrand des Anwendungsfalls Sprachenlernen hinausschaut. Wir haben beobachtet, dass der Nutzen von Memory Cues für das Reflektieren über gelernte Inhalte stark von dem Design der Cues abhängt, insbesondere von der Granularität der präsentierten Informationen. Wir schätzen interaktive Cues zur spezifischen Gedächtnisaktivierung (z.B. durch Mehrfachauswahlfragen) als einen vielversprechenden Unterstützungsansatz ein, welcher individuelle Mikrolerneinheiten im Alltag verknüpfen könnte. Die Werkzeuge und Anwendungen, die in dieser Arbeit beschrieben werden, sind ein Startpunkt für das Design von Anwendungen, welche das Lernen in Alltagssituationen unterstützen. Wir erweitern das Verständnis, welches wir von Lernverhalten im geschäftigen Alltagsleben haben und heben den Einfluss von Unterbrechungen in diesem hervor. Während sich diese Arbeit hauptsächlich auf das Lernen von Sprachen fokussiert, haben die vorgestellten Konzepte und Methoden das Potential auf andere Bereiche übertragen zu werden, beispielsweise das Lernen von MINT Themen. Wir reflektieren über die Grenzen der präsentierten Konzepte und skizzieren Perspektiven für zukünftige Forschungsarbeiten, welche sich die Allgegenwärtigkeit von mobilen Endgeräten zur Gestaltung von Lernanwendungen für den Alltag zunutze machen

Towards a mood sensitive integrated development environment to enhance the performance of programmers

This thesis was submitted for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy and awarded by Brunel University.The aim of the research was to analyze the possibility of developing an Integrated Development Environment (IDE) that could improve a programmer‘s performance by considering their current mood. Various experiments were conducted to study this idea. However, the impact of moods on programmer performance was initially examined in the literature. Based on this, a Cognitive Programming Task Model (CPTM) was developed showing that various cognitive functions and programming activities are interrelated. A second model derived from the literature, the Cognitive Mood Model (CMM), suggested that moods are also interrelated with various cognitive functions. Combining these two models indirectly suggests a relation between moods and programming tasks, which was presented as the Mood Programming Model (MPM). As direct empirical support was lacking for this relation, two experiments were conducted to study the effect mood could have on performance in a debug task. Validated mood-inducing movie clips were used to induce specific moods along two-mood dimensions: valence and arousal. The first study was conducted online. The results showed that arousal is a significant factor when considering programmer performance whereas valence was found to have no significant effect. The second study was a continuation study to validate the findings from the first study within lab conditions. The results were not able to confirm the findings of the first experiment. The reasons for these findings were explained accordingly. As mood was found to have an effect on a programmer‘s coding and debugging performance, this factor might be considered when developing a support system. The next step in the research was therefore to consider mood measuring in a non-interruptive way. The next two experiments were based around the hypothesis that ―moods can be measured from the keyboard and mouse interaction of the computer user‖. In the first experiment an application was installed on participants‘ computers to record their key presses and mouse clicks in a log file. Their self reported moods in intervals of 20 minutes were also stored in the same file over an average period of eight days. Correlations between participants‘ self reported moods and their keyboard and mouse use revealed that it might be possible to measure moods of the some of the participants. The second experiment took place in the lab, where participants were asked to perform programming like tasks while listening to ii mood inducing background music. Their moods were measured with a Galvanic Skin Response (GSR) meter whereas key presses and mouse clicks again were recorded in log files. The correlations between GSR measurements and keyboard and mouse interaction validated the findings of the experiment in the field that it might be possible to measure the mood of some users from their computer use. Analyzing participants‘ personality traits showed dutifulness and self discipline as indicators that a person‘s mood correlates with his/her interaction behaviour. Considering that mood has an effect on programmer performance and that it might be possible to measure mood in a non-intrusive manner, the last question to focus on was whether a computer-generated intervention could change a programmer‘s mood and consequently improve their performance. In the final experiment programmers had to dry run algorithms for 16 minutes with the expectation that a level of boredom would set in. After this the video clip instructed them to participate in some physical exercises. Participants continued tracing algorithms for 8 minutes after the intervention. Results showed that the mood change after the intervention coincided with a programmers improved ability to provide the correct output of the algorithms. Together these findings lay the foundation for developing an IDE that can measure the programmer mood in a non-intrusive way and make effective interventions to improve programmer performance