Concatenative speech synthesis: a Framework for Reducing Perceived Distortion when using the TD-PSOLA Algorithm

This thesis presents the design and evaluation of an approach to concatenative speech synthesis using the Titne-Domain Pitch-Synchronous OverLap-Add (I'D-PSOLA) signal processing algorithm. Concatenative synthesis systems make use of pre-recorded speech segments stored in a speech corpus. At synthesis time, the `best' segments available to synthesise the new utterances are chosen from the corpus using a process known as unit selection. During the synthesis process, the pitch and duration of these segments may be modified to generate the desired prosody. The TD-PSOLA algorithm provides an efficient and essentially successful solution to perform these modifications, although some perceptible distortion, in the form of `buzzyness', may be introduced into the speech signal. Despite the popularity of the TD-PSOLA algorithm, little formal research has been undertaken to address this recognised problem of distortion. The approach in the thesis has been developed towards reducing the perceived distortion that is introduced when TD-PSOLA is applied to speech. To investigate the occurrence of this distortion, a psychoacoustic evaluation of the effect of pitch modification using the TD-PSOLA algorithm is presented. Subjective experiments in the form of a set of listening tests were undertaken using word-level stimuli that had been manipulated using TD-PSOLA. The data collected from these experiments were analysed for patterns of co- occurrence or correlations to investigate where this distortion may occur. From this, parameters were identified which may have contributed to increased distortion. These parameters were concerned with the relationship between the spectral content of individual phonemes, the extent of pitch manipulation, and aspects of the original recordings. Based on these results, a framework was designed for use in conjunction with TD-PSOLA to minimise the possible causes of distortion. The framework consisted of a novel speech corpus design, a signal processing distortion measure, and a selection process for especially problematic phonemes. Rather than phonetically balanced, the corpus is balanced to the needs of the signal processing algorithm, containing more of the adversely affected phonemes. The aim is to reduce the potential extent of pitch modification of such segments, and hence produce synthetic speech with less perceptible distortion. The signal processingdistortion measure was developed to allow the prediction of perceptible distortion in pitch-modified speech. Different weightings were estimated for individual phonemes,trained using the experimental data collected during the listening tests.The potential benefit of such a measure for existing unit selection processes in a corpus-based system using TD-PSOLA is illustrated. Finally, the special-case selection process was developed for highly problematic voiced fricative phonemes to minimise the occurrence of perceived distortion in these segments. The success of the framework, in terms of generating synthetic speech with reduced distortion, was evaluated. A listening test showed that the TD-PSOLA balanced speech corpus may be capable of generating pitch-modified synthetic sentences with significantly less distortion than those generated using a typical phonetically balanced corpus. The voiced fricative selection process was also shown to produce pitch-modified versions of these phonemes with less perceived distortion than a standard selection process. The listening test then indicated that the signal processing distortion measure was able to predict the resulting amount of distortion at the sentence-level after the application of TD-PSOLA, suggesting that it may be beneficial to include such a measure in existing unit selection processes. The framework was found to be capable of producing speech with reduced perceptible distortion in certain situations, although the effects seen at the sentence-level were less than those seen in the previous investigative experiments that made use of word-level stimuli. This suggeststhat the effect of the TD-PSOLA algorithm cannot always be easily anticipated due to the highly dynamic nature of speech, and that the reduction of perceptible distortion in TD-PSOLA-modified speech remains a challenge to the speech community

Concatenative speech synthesis : a framework for reducing perceived distortion when using the TD-PSOLA algorithm

This thesis presents the design and evaluation of an approach to concatenative speech synthesis using the Titne-Domain Pitch-Synchronous OverLap-Add (I'D-PSOLA) signal processing algorithm. Concatenative synthesis systems make use of pre-recorded speech segments stored in a speech corpus. At synthesis time, the `best' segments available to synthesise the new utterances are chosen from the corpus using a process known as unit selection. During the synthesis process, the pitch and duration of these segments may be modified to generate the desired prosody. The TD-PSOLA algorithm provides an efficient and essentially successful solution to perform these modifications, although some perceptible distortion, in the form of `buzzyness', may be introduced into the speech signal. Despite the popularity of the TD-PSOLA algorithm, little formal research has been undertaken to address this recognised problem of distortion. The approach in the thesis has been developed towards reducing the perceived distortion that is introduced when TD-PSOLA is applied to speech. To investigate the occurrence of this distortion, a psychoacoustic evaluation of the effect of pitch modification using the TD-PSOLA algorithm is presented. Subjective experiments in the form of a set of listening tests were undertaken using word-level stimuli that had been manipulated using TD-PSOLA. The data collected from these experiments were analysed for patterns of co- occurrence or correlations to investigate where this distortion may occur. From this, parameters were identified which may have contributed to increased distortion. These parameters were concerned with the relationship between the spectral content of individual phonemes, the extent of pitch manipulation, and aspects of the original recordings. Based on these results, a framework was designed for use in conjunction with TD-PSOLA to minimise the possible causes of distortion. The framework consisted of a novel speech corpus design, a signal processing distortion measure, and a selection process for especially problematic phonemes. Rather than phonetically balanced, the corpus is balanced to the needs of the signal processing algorithm, containing more of the adversely affected phonemes. The aim is to reduce the potential extent of pitch modification of such segments, and hence produce synthetic speech with less perceptible distortion. The signal processingdistortion measure was developed to allow the prediction of perceptible distortion in pitch-modified speech. Different weightings were estimated for individual phonemes,trained using the experimental data collected during the listening tests.The potential benefit of such a measure for existing unit selection processes in a corpus-based system using TD-PSOLA is illustrated. Finally, the special-case selection process was developed for highly problematic voiced fricative phonemes to minimise the occurrence of perceived distortion in these segments. The success of the framework, in terms of generating synthetic speech with reduced distortion, was evaluated. A listening test showed that the TD-PSOLA balanced speech corpus may be capable of generating pitch-modified synthetic sentences with significantly less distortion than those generated using a typical phonetically balanced corpus. The voiced fricative selection process was also shown to produce pitch-modified versions of these phonemes with less perceived distortion than a standard selection process. The listening test then indicated that the signal processing distortion measure was able to predict the resulting amount of distortion at the sentence-level after the application of TD-PSOLA, suggesting that it may be beneficial to include such a measure in existing unit selection processes. The framework was found to be capable of producing speech with reduced perceptible distortion in certain situations, although the effects seen at the sentence-level were less than those seen in the previous investigative experiments that made use of word-level stimuli. This suggeststhat the effect of the TD-PSOLA algorithm cannot always be easily anticipated due to the highly dynamic nature of speech, and that the reduction of perceptible distortion in TD-PSOLA-modified speech remains a challenge to the speech community.EThOS - Electronic Theses Online ServiceGBUnited Kingdo

Prosody Modifications for Voice Conversion

Generally defined, speech modification is the process of changing certain perceptual properties of speech while leaving other properties unchanged. Among the many types of speech information that may be altered are rate of articulation, pitch and formant characteristics.Modifying the speech parameters like pitch, duration and strength of excitation by desired factor is termed as prosody modification. In this thesis prosody modifications for voice conversion framework are presented. Among all the speech modifications for prosody two things are important firstly modification of duartion and pauses (Time scale modification) in a speech utterance and secondly modification of the pitch(pitch scale modification).Prosody modification involves changing the pitch and duration of speech without affecting the message and naturalness.In this work time scale and pitch scale modifications of speech are discussed using two methods Time Domain Pitch Synchronous Overlapped-Add (TD-PSOLA) and epoch based approach.In order to apply desired speech modifications TD-PSOLA discussed in this thesis works directly on speech in time domian although there are many variations of TD-PSOLA.The epoch based approach involves modifications of LP-residual

자동 운율 복제를 위한 모음 길이와 기본 주파수 예측

학위논문 (석사)-- 서울대학교 대학원 : 인문대학 협동과정 인지과학전공, 2018. 8. 정민화.The use of computers to help people improve their pronunciation skills of a foreign language has rapidly increased in the last decades. Majority of such Computer-Assisted Pronunciation Training (CAPT) systems have been focused on teaching correct pronunciation of segments only, however, while prosody received much less attention. One of the new approaches to prosody training is self-imitation learning. Prosodic features from a native utterance are transplanted onto learners own speech, and given back as corrective feedback. The main drawback is that this technique requires two identical sets of native and non-native utterances, which makes its actual implementation cumbersome and inflexible. As a preliminary research towards developing a new method of prosody transplantation, the first part of the study surveys previous related works and points out their advantages and drawbacks. We also compare prosodic systems of Korean and English, point out major areas of mistakes that Korean learners of English tend to do, and then we analyze acoustic features that this mistakes are correlated with. We suggest that transplantation of vowel duration and fundamental frequency will be the most effective for self-imitation learning by Korean speakers of English. The second part of this study introduces a new proposed model for prosody transplantation. Instead of transplanting acoustic values from a pre-recorded utterance, we suggest to use a deep neural network (DNN) based system to predict them instead. Three different models are built and described: baseline recurrent neural network (RNN), long short-term memory (LSTM) model and gated recurrent unit (GRU) model. The models were trained on Boston University Radio Speech Corpus, using a minimal set of relevant input features. The models were compared with each other, as well as with state-of-the-art prosody prediction systems from speech synthesis research. Implementation of the proposed prediction model in automatic prosody transplantation is described and the results are analyzed. A perceptual evaluation by native speakers was carried out. Accentedness and comprehensibility ratings of modified and original non-native utterances were compared with each other. The results showed that duration transplantation can lead to the improvements in comprehensibility score. This study lays the groundwork for a fully automatic self-imitation prosody training system and its results can be used to help Korean learners master problematic areas of English prosody, such as sentence stress.Chapter 1. Introduction . 10 1.1 Background. 10 1.2 Research Objective 12 1.3 Research Outline. 15 Chapter 2. Related Works. 16 2.1 Self-imitation Prosody Training. 16 2.1.1 Prosody Transplantation Methods . 18 2.1.2 Effects of Prosody Transplantation on Accentedness Rating 23 2.1.3 Effects of Self-Imitation Learning on Proficiency Rating 26 2.2 Prosody of Korean-accented English Speech 28 2.2.1 Prosodic Systems of Korean and English 28 2.2.2 Common Prosodic Mistakes. 29 2.3 Deep Learning Based Prosody Prediction 34 2.3.1 Deep Learning . 34 2.3.2 Recurrent Neural Networks 35 2.3.2 The Long Short-Term Memory Architecture. 37 2.3.3 Gated Recurrent Units. 39 2.3.4 Prosody Prediction Models 40 Chapter 3. Vowel Duration and Fundamental Frequency Prediction Model 43 3.1 Data 43 3.2. Input Feature Selection. 45 3.3 System Architecture and Training 56 3.4 Results and Evaluation 63 3.4.1 Objective Metrics. 63 3.4.2 Vowel Duration Prediction Models Results. 65 3.4.2 Fundamental Frequency Prediction Models Results 68 3.4.3 Comparison with other models . 68 Chapter 4. Automatic Prosody Transplantation 72 4.1 Data 72 4.2 Transplantation Method. 74 4.3 Perceptual Evaluation 79 4.4 Results 80 Chapter 5. Conclusion. 82 5.1 Summary 82 5.2 Contribution 84 5.3 Limitations 85 5.4 Recommendations for Future Study. 85 References 88 Appendix 96Maste

Speech synthesis based on a harmonic model

The wide range of potential commercial applications for a com puter system capable of automatically converting text to speech (TTS) has stimulated decades of research. One of the currently most successful approaches to synthesising speech, concatenative TTS synthesis, combines prerecorded speech units to build full utterances. However, th e prosody of the stored units is often not consistent with that of the target utterance and m ust be altered. Furthermore, several types of mismatch can occur at unit boundaries and must be smoothed. Thus, pitch and time-scale modification techniques as well as smoothing algorithms play a critical role in all concatenative-based systems. This thesis presents the developm ent of a concatenative TTS system based on a harm onic model and incorporating new pitch and time-scaling as well as smoothing algorithms. Experim ent has shown our system capable of both very high quality prosodic modification and synthesis. Results com pare very favourably with those of existing state-of-the-art systems

Time-domain concatenative text-to-speech synthesis.

A concatenation framework for time-domain concatenative speech synthesis (TDCSS) is presented and evaluated. In this framework, speech segments are extracted from CV, VC, CVC and CC waveforms, and abutted. Speech rhythm is controlled via a single duration parameter, which specifies the initial portion of each stored waveform to be output. An appropriate choice of segmental durations reduces spectral discontinuity problems at points of concatenation, thus reducing reliance upon smoothing procedures. For text-to-speech considerations, a segmental timing system is described, which predicts segmental durations at the word level, using a timing database and a pattern matching look-up algorithm. The timing database contains segmented words with associated duration values, and is specific to an actual inventory of concatenative units. Segmental duration prediction accuracy improves as the timing database size increases. The problem of incomplete timing data has been addressed by using `default duration' entries in the database, which are created by re-categorising existing timing data according to articulation manner. If segmental duration data are incomplete, a default duration procedure automatically categorises the missing speech segments according to segment class. The look-up algorithm then searches the timing database for duration data corresponding to these re-categorised segments. The timing database is constructed using an iterative synthesis/adjustment technique, in which a `judge' listens to synthetic speech and adjusts segmental durations to improve naturalness. This manual technique for constructing the timing database has been evaluated. Since the timing data is linked to an expert judge's perception, an investigation examined whether the expert judge's perception of speech naturalness is representative of people in general. Listening experiments revealed marked similarities between an expert judge's perception of naturalness and that of the experimental subjects. It was also found that the expert judge's perception remains stable over time. A synthesis/adjustment experiment found a positive linear correlation between segmental durations chosen by an experienced expert judge and duration values chosen by subjects acting as expert judges. A listening test confirmed that between 70% and 100% intelligibility can be achieved with words synthesised using TDCSS. In a further test, a TDCSS synthesiser was compared with five well-known text-to-speech synthesisers, and was ranked fifth most natural out of six. An alternative concatenation framework (TDCSS2) was also evaluated, in which duration parameters specify both the start point and the end point of the speech to be extracted from a stored waveform and concatenated. In a similar listening experiment, TDCSS2 stimuli were compared with five well-known text-tospeech synthesisers, and were ranked fifth most natural out of six

Text-Independent Voice Conversion

This thesis deals with text-independent solutions for voice conversion. It first introduces the use of vocal tract length normalization (VTLN) for voice conversion. The presented variants of VTLN allow for easily changing speaker characteristics by means of a few trainable parameters. Furthermore, it is shown how VTLN can be expressed in time domain strongly reducing the computational costs while keeping a high speech quality. The second text-independent voice conversion paradigm is residual prediction. In particular, two proposed techniques, residual smoothing and the application of unit selection, result in essential improvement of both speech quality and voice similarity. In order to apply the well-studied linear transformation paradigm to text-independent voice conversion, two text-independent speech alignment techniques are introduced. One is based on automatic segmentation and mapping of artificial phonetic classes and the other is a completely data-driven approach with unit selection. The latter achieves a performance very similar to the conventional text-dependent approach in terms of speech quality and similarity. It is also successfully applied to cross-language voice conversion. The investigations of this thesis are based on several corpora of three different languages, i.e., English, Spanish, and German. Results are also presented from the multilingual voice conversion evaluation in the framework of the international speech-to-speech translation project TC-Star

Articulatory-based Speech Processing Methods for Foreign Accent Conversion

The objective of this dissertation is to develop speech processing methods that enable without altering their identity. We envision accent conversion primarily as a tool for pronunciation training, allowing non-native speakers to hear their native-accented selves. With this application in mind, we present two methods of accent conversion. The first assumes that the voice quality/identity of speech resides in the glottal excitation, while the linguistic content is contained in the vocal tract transfer function. Accent conversion is achieved by convolving the glottal excitation of a non-native speaker with the vocal tract transfer function of a native speaker. The result is perceived as 60 percent less accented, but it is no longer identified as the same individual. The second method of accent conversion selects segments of speech from a corpus of non-native speech based on their acoustic or articulatory similarity to segments from a native speaker. We predict that articulatory features provide a more speaker-independent representation of speech and are therefore better gauges of linguistic similarity across speakers. To test this hypothesis, we collected a custom database containing simultaneous recordings of speech and the positions of important articulators (e.g. lips, jaw, tongue) for a native and non-native speaker. Resequencing speech from a non-native speaker based on articulatory similarity with a native speaker achieved a 20 percent reduction in accent. The approach is particularly appealing for applications in pronunciation training because it modifies speech in a way that produces realistically achievable changes in accent (i.e., since the technique uses sounds already produced by the non-native speaker). A second contribution of this dissertation is the development of subjective and objective measures to assess the performance of accent conversion systems. This is a difficult problem because, in most cases, no ground truth exists. Subjective evaluation is further complicated by the interconnected relationship between accent and identity, but modifications of the stimuli (i.e. reverse speech and voice disguises) allow the two components to be separated. Algorithms to measure objectively accent, quality, and identity are shown to correlate well with their subjective counterparts

Voice source characterization for prosodic and spectral manipulation

The objective of this dissertation is to study and develop techniques to decompose the speech signal into its two main components: voice source and vocal tract. Our main efforts are on the glottal pulse analysis and characterization. We want to explore the utility of this model in different areas of speech processing: speech synthesis, voice conversion or emotion detection among others. Thus, we will study different techniques for prosodic and spectral manipulation. One of our requirements is that the methods should be robust enough to work with the large databases typical of speech synthesis. We use a speech production model in which the glottal flow produced by the vibrating vocal folds goes through the vocal (and nasal) tract cavities and its radiated by the lips. Removing the effect of the vocal tract from the speech signal to obtain the glottal pulse is known as inverse filtering. We use a parametric model fo the glottal pulse directly in the source-filter decomposition phase. In order to validate the accuracy of the parametrization algorithm, we designed a synthetic corpus using LF glottal parameters reported in the literature, complemented with our own results from the vowel database. The results show that our method gives satisfactory results in a wide range of glottal configurations and at different levels of SNR. Our method using the whitened residual compared favorably to this reference, achieving high quality ratings (Good-Excellent). Our full parametrized system scored lower than the other two ranking in third place, but still higher than the acceptance threshold (Fair-Good). Next we proposed two methods for prosody modification, one for each of the residual representations explained above. The first method used our full parametrization system and frame interpolation to perform the desired changes in pitch and duration. The second method used resampling on the residual waveform and a frame selection technique to generate a new sequence of frames to be synthesized. The results showed that both methods are rated similarly (Fair-Good) and that more work is needed in order to achieve quality levels similar to the reference methods. As part of this dissertation, we have studied the application of our models in three different areas: voice conversion, voice quality analysis and emotion recognition. We have included our speech production model in a reference voice conversion system, to evaluate the impact of our parametrization in this task. The results showed that the evaluators preferred our method over the original one, rating it with a higher score in the MOS scale. To study the voice quality, we recorded a small database consisting of isolated, sustained Spanish vowels in four different phonations (modal, rough, creaky and falsetto) and were later also used in our study of voice quality. Comparing the results with those reported in the literature, we found them to generally agree with previous findings. Some differences existed, but they could be attributed to the difficulties in comparing voice qualities produced by different speakers. At the same time we conducted experiments in the field of voice quality identification, with very good results. We have also evaluated the performance of an automatic emotion classifier based on GMM using glottal measures. For each emotion, we have trained an specific model using different features, comparing our parametrization to a baseline system using spectral and prosodic characteristics. The results of the test were very satisfactory, showing a relative error reduction of more than 20% with respect to the baseline system. The accuracy of the different emotions detection was also high, improving the results of previously reported works using the same database. Overall, we can conclude that the glottal source parameters extracted using our algorithm have a positive impact in the field of automatic emotion classification