1,429 research outputs found
A Higher Bachmann-Howard Principle
We present a higher well-ordering principle which is equivalent (over
Simpson's set theoretic version of ) to the existence of
transitive models of Kripke-Platek set theory, and thus to
-comprehension. This is a partial solution to a conjecture of
Montalb\'an and Rathjen: partial in the sense that our well-ordering principle
is less constructive than demanded in the conjecture.Comment: This paper is no longer up to date: It is superseded by the author's
PhD thesis (available at http://etheses.whiterose.ac.uk/20929/) and the
streamlined presentation in arXiv:1809.06759. In contrast to the present
abstract, we have now found a computable version of our well-ordering
principle. Thus the conjecture by Montalb\'an and Rathjen can be considered
as fully solve
Constructive set theory and Brouwerian principles
The paper furnishes realizability models of constructive Zermelo-Fraenkel set theory, CZF, which also validate Brouwerian principles such as the axiom of continuous choice (CC), the fan theorem (FT), and monotone bar induction (BIM), and thereby determines the proof-theoretic strength of CZF augmented by these principles. The upshot is that CZF+CC+FT possesses the same strength as CZF, or more precisely, that CZF+CC+FTis conservative over CZF for 02 statements of arithmetic, whereas the addition of a restricted version of bar induction to CZF (called decidable bar induction, BID) leads to greater proof-theoretic strength in that CZF+BID proves the consistency of CZF
Reverse mathematics and well-ordering principles
The paper is concerned with generally Pi^1_2 sentences of the form 'if X is well ordered then f(X) is well ordered', where f is a standard proof theoretic function from ordinals to ordinals. It has turned out that a statement of this form is often equivalent to the existence of countable coded omega-models for a particular theory T_f whose consistency can be proved by means of a cut elimination theorem in infinitary logic which crucially involves the function f. To illustrate this theme, we shall focus on the well-known psi-function which figures prominently in so-called predicative proof theory. However, the approach taken here lends itself to generalization in that the techniques we employ can be applied to many other proof-theoretic functions associated with cut elimination theorems. In this paper we show that the statement 'if X is well ordered then 'X0 is well ordered' is equivalent to ATR0. This was first proved by Friedman, Montalban and Weiermann [7] using recursion-theoretic and combinatorial methods. The proof given here is proof-theoretic, the main techniques being Schuette's method of proof search (deduction chains) [13], generalized to omega logic, and cut elimination for infinitary ramified analysis
Transfinite Update Procedures for Predicative Systems of Analysis
We present a simple-to-state, abstract computational problem, whose solution implies the 1-consistency of various systems of predicative Analysis and offers a way of extracting witnesses from classical proofs. In order to state the problem, we formulate the concept of transfinite update procedure, which extends Avigad\u27s notion of update procedure to the transfinite and can be seen as an axiomatization of learning as it implicitly appears in various computational interpretations of predicative Analysis. We give iterative and bar recursive solutions to the problem
- …