Web attack risk awareness with lessons learned from high interaction honeypots

Tese de mestrado, Segurança Informática, Universidade de Lisboa, Faculdade de Ciências, 2009Com a evolução da web 2.0, a maioria das empresas elabora negócios através da Internet usando aplicações web. Estas aplicações detêm dados importantes com requisitos cruciais como confidencialidade, integridade e disponibilidade. A perda destas propriedades influencia directamente o negócio colocando-o em risco. A percepção de risco providencia o necessário conhecimento de modo a agir para a sua mitigação. Nesta tese foi concretizada uma colecção de honeypots web de alta interacção utilizando diversas aplicações e sistemas operativos para analisar o comportamento do atacante. A utilização de ambientes de virtualização assim como ferramentas de monitorização de honeypots amplamente utilizadas providencia a informação forense necessária para ajudar a comunidade de investigação no estudo do modus operandi do atacante, armazenando os últimos exploits e ferramentas maliciosas, e a desenvolver as necessárias medidas de protecção que lidam com a maioria das técnicas de ataque. Utilizando a informação detalhada de ataque obtida com os honeypots web, o comportamento do atacante é classificado entre diferentes perfis de ataque para poderem ser analisadas as medidas de mitigação de risco que lidam com as perdas de negócio. Diferentes frameworks de segurança são analisadas para avaliar os benefícios que os conceitos básicos de segurança dos honeypots podem trazer na resposta aos requisitos de cada uma e a consequente mitigação de risco.With the evolution of web 2.0, the majority of enterprises deploy their business over the Internet using web applications. These applications carry important data with crucial requirements such as confidentiality, integrity and availability. The loss of those properties influences directly the business putting it at risk. Risk awareness provides the necessary know-how on how to act to achieve its mitigation. In this thesis a collection of high interaction web honeypots is deployed using multiple applications and diverse operating systems in order to analyse the attacker behaviour. The use of virtualization environments along with widely used honeypot monitoring tools provide the necessary forensic information that helps the research community to study the modus operandi of the attacker gathering the latest exploits and malicious tools and to develop adequate safeguards that deal with the majority of attacking techniques. Using the detailed attacking information gathered with the web honeypots, the attacking behaviour will be classified across different attacking profiles to analyse the necessary risk mitigation safeguards to deal with business losses. Different security frameworks commonly used by enterprises are analysed to evaluate the benefits of the honeypots security concepts in responding to each framework’s requirements and consequently mitigating the risk

DEFINING, MEASURING, AND ANALYZING DEFENSIBILITY IN THE DEFENSIVE CYBER OPERATIONS CONTEXT

When talking about cyber systems, both researchers and decision makers have used the term "defensibility" widely, but there is no universal definition for it and no method to observe and measure it. This study examines how defensibility can be defined in a defensive cyber operations context, what critical factors constitute it, and how those factors could be measured. This is done by first examining doctrine and research to create a framework of meaning for defensibility. Second, the study proposes seven fundamental capabilities that a defender needs to be able to perform in defensive cyber operations and a set of system attributes that affect those capabilities. Finally, a set of measures for those attributes is proposed to allow defensibility to be observed and measured. The results of this study are a definition of defensibility for the defensive cyber operations context, a list of system attributes that constitute its defensibility, and a set of associated measurements for these attributes. Using these, it is possible to analyze the defensibility of a system to indicate what restrictions a defender might have when conducting operations in the system and the areas where the system needs to improve. This work is the first step in building defensibility into a useful tool that highlights the needs of a defensive actor who conducts dynamic defensive operations in a system, versus the needs of an actor who implements static measures to increase cyber security.Löjtnant, Swedish NavyApproved for public release. Distribution is unlimited

Wide spectrum attribution: Using deception for attribution intelligence in cyber attacks

Modern cyber attacks have evolved considerably. The skill level required to conduct a cyber attack is low. Computing power is cheap, targets are diverse and plentiful. Point-and-click crimeware kits are widely circulated in the underground economy, while source code for sophisticated malware such as Stuxnet is available for all to download and repurpose. Despite decades of research into defensive techniques, such as firewalls, intrusion detection systems, anti-virus, code auditing, etc, the quantity of successful cyber attacks continues to increase, as does the number of vulnerabilities identified. Measures to identify perpetrators, known as attribution, have existed for as long as there have been cyber attacks. The most actively researched technical attribution techniques involve the marking and logging of network packets. These techniques are performed by network devices along the packet journey, which most often requires modification of existing router hardware and/or software, or the inclusion of additional devices. These modifications require wide-scale infrastructure changes that are not only complex and costly, but invoke legal, ethical and governance issues. The usefulness of these techniques is also often questioned, as attack actors use multiple stepping stones, often innocent systems that have been compromised, to mask the true source. As such, this thesis identifies that no publicly known previous work has been deployed on a wide-scale basis in the Internet infrastructure. This research investigates the use of an often overlooked tool for attribution: cyber de- ception. The main contribution of this work is a significant advancement in the field of deception and honeypots as technical attribution techniques. Specifically, the design and implementation of two novel honeypot approaches; i) Deception Inside Credential Engine (DICE), that uses policy and honeytokens to identify adversaries returning from different origins and ii) Adaptive Honeynet Framework (AHFW), an introspection and adaptive honeynet framework that uses actor-dependent triggers to modify the honeynet envi- ronment, to engage the adversary, increasing the quantity and diversity of interactions. The two approaches are based on a systematic review of the technical attribution litera- ture that was used to derive a set of requirements for honeypots as technical attribution techniques. Both approaches lead the way for further research in this field

Enabling an Anatomic View to Investigate Honeypot Systems: A Survey

A honeypot is a type of security facility deliberately created to be probed, attacked, and compromised. It is often used for protecting production systems by detecting and deflecting unauthorized accesses. It is also useful for investigating the behavior of attackers, and in particular, unknown attacks. For the past 17 years plenty of effort has been invested in the research and development of honeypot techniques, and they have evolved to be an increasingly powerful means of defending against the creations of the blackhat community. In this paper, by studying a wide set of honeypots, the two essential elements of honeypots—the decoy and the captor—are captured and presented, together with two abstract organizational forms—independent and cooperative—where these two elements can be integrated. A novel decoy and captor (D-C) based taxonomy is proposed for the purpose of studying and classifying the various honeypot techniques. An extensive set of independent and cooperative honeypot projects and research that cover these techniques is surveyed under the taxonomy framework. Furthermore, two subsets of features from the taxonomy are identified, which can greatly influence the honeypot performances. These two subsets of features are applied to a number of typical independent and cooperative honeypots separately in order to validate the taxonomy and predict the honeypot development trends

Mecanismos dinâmicos de segurança para redes softwarizadas e virtualizadas

The relationship between attackers and defenders has traditionally been asymmetric, with attackers having time as an upper hand to devise an exploit that compromises the defender. The push towards the Cloudification of the world makes matters more challenging, as it lowers the cost of an attack, with a de facto standardization on a set of protocols. The discovery of a vulnerability now has a broader impact on various verticals (business use cases), while previously, some were in a segregated protocol stack requiring independent vulnerability research. Furthermore, defining a perimeter within a cloudified system is non-trivial, whereas before, the dedicated equipment already created a perimeter. This proposal takes the newer technologies of network softwarization and virtualization, both Cloud-enablers, to create new dynamic security mechanisms that address this asymmetric relationship using novel Moving Target Defense (MTD) approaches. The effective use of the exploration space, combined with the reconfiguration capabilities of frameworks like Network Function Virtualization (NFV) and Management and Orchestration (MANO), should allow for adjusting defense levels dynamically to achieve the required security as defined by the currently acceptable risk. The optimization tasks and integration tasks of this thesis explore these concepts. Furthermore, the proposed novel mechanisms were evaluated in real-world use cases, such as 5G networks or other Network Slicing enabled infrastructures.A relação entre atacantes e defensores tem sido tradicionalmente assimétrica, com os atacantes a terem o tempo como vantagem para conceberem uma exploração que comprometa o defensor. O impulso para a Cloudificação do mundo torna a situação mais desafiante, pois reduz o custo de um ataque, com uma padronização de facto sobre um conjunto de protocolos. A descoberta de uma vulnerabilidade tem agora um impacto mais amplo em várias verticais (casos de uso empresarial), enquanto anteriormente, alguns estavam numa pilha de protocolos segregados que exigiam uma investigação independente das suas vulnerabilidades. Além disso, a definição de um perímetro dentro de um sistema Cloud não é trivial, enquanto antes, o equipamento dedicado já criava um perímetro. Esta proposta toma as mais recentes tecnologias de softwarização e virtualização da rede, ambas facilitadoras da Cloud, para criar novos mecanismos dinâmicos de segurança que incidem sobre esta relação assimétrica utilizando novas abordagens de Moving Target Defense (MTD). A utilização eficaz do espaço de exploração, combinada com as capacidades de reconfiguração de frameworks como Network Function Virtualization (NFV) e Management and Orchestration (MANO), deverá permitir ajustar dinamicamente os níveis de defesa para alcançar a segurança necessária, tal como definida pelo risco actualmente aceitável. As tarefas de optimização e de integração desta tese exploram estes conceitos. Além disso, os novos mecanismos propostos foram avaliados em casos de utilização no mundo real, tais como redes 5G ou outras infraestruturas de Network Slicing.Programa Doutoral em Engenharia Informátic

A conceptual framework for cyber counterintelligence

Abstract :D.Com (Computer Science

Context-Aware Network Security.

The rapid growth in malicious Internet activity, due to the rise of threats like automated worms, viruses, and botnets, has driven the development of tools designed to protect host and network resources. One approach that has gained significant popularity is the use of network based security systems. These systems are deployed on the network to detect, characterize and mitigate both new and existing threats. Unfortunately, these systems are developed and deployed in production networks as generic systems and little thought has been paid to customization. Even when it is possible to customize these devices, the approaches for customization are largely manual or ad hoc. Our observation of the production networks suggest that these networks have significant diversity in end-host characteristics, threat landscape, and traffic behavior -- a collection of features that we call the security context of a network. The scale and diversity in security context of production networks make manual or ad hoc customization of security systems difficult. Our thesis is that automated adaptation to the security context can be used to significantly improve the performance and accuracy of network-based security systems. In order to evaluate our thesis, we explore a system from three broad categories of network-based security systems: known threat detection, new threat detection, and reputation-based mitigation. For known threat detection, we examine a signature-based intrusion detection system and show that the system performance improves significantly if it is aware of the signature set and the traffic characteristics of the network. Second, we explore a large collection of honeypots (or honeynet) that are used to detect new threats. We show that operating system and application configurations in the network impact honeynet accuracy and adapting to the surrounding network provides a significantly better view of the network threats. Last, we apply our context-aware approach to a reputation-based system for spam blacklist generation and show how traffic characteristics on the network can be used to significantly improve its accuracy. We conclude with the lessons learned from our experiences adapting to network security context and the future directions for adapting network-based security systems to the security context.Ph.D.Computer Science & EngineeringUniversity of Michigan, Horace H. Rackham School of Graduate Studieshttp://deepblue.lib.umich.edu/bitstream/2027.42/64745/1/sushant_1.pd

The Cooperative Defense Overlay Network: A Collaborative Automated Threat Information Sharing Framework for a Safer Internet

With the ever-growing proliferation of hardware and software-based computer security exploits and the increasing power and prominence of distributed attacks, network and system administrators are often forced to make a difficult decision: expend tremendous resources on defense from sophisticated and continually evolving attacks from an increasingly dangerous Internet with varying levels of success; or expend fewer resources on defending against common attacks on "low hanging fruit," hoping to avoid the less common but incredibly devastating zero-day worm or botnet attack. Home networks and small organizations are usually forced to choose the latter option and in so doing are left vulnerable to all but the simplest of attacks. While automated tools exist for sharing information about network-based attacks, this sharing is typically limited to administrators of large networks and dedicated security-conscious users, to the exclusion of smaller organizations and novice home users. In this thesis we propose a framework for a cooperative defense overlay network (CODON) in which participants with varying technical abilities and resources can contribute to the security and health of the internet via automated crowdsourcing, rapid information sharing, and the principle of collateral defense