Evaluation and comparison of Landsat 8, Sentinel-2 and Deimos-1 remote sensing indices for assessing burn severity in Mediterranean fire-prone ecosystems

P. 137-144The development of improved spatial and spectral resolution sensors provides new opportunities to assess burn severity more accurately. This study evaluates the ability of remote sensing indices derived from three remote sensing sensors (i.e., Landsat 8 OLI/TIRS, Sentinel-2 MSI and Deimos-1 SLIM-6-22) to assess burn severity (site, vegetation and soil burn severity). As a case study, we used a megafire (9,939 ha) that occurred in a Mediterranean ecosystem in northwestern Spain. Remote sensing indices included seven reflective, two thermal and four mixed indices, which were derived from each satellite and were validated with field burn severity metrics obtained from CBI index. Correlation patterns of field burn severity and remote sensing indices were relatively consistent across the different sensors. Additionally, regardless of the sensor, indices that incorporated SWIR bands (i.e., NBR-based indices), exceed those using red and NIR bands, and thermal and mixed indices. High resolution Sentinel-2 imagery only slightly improved the performance of indices based on NBR compared to Landsat 8. The dNDVI index from Landsat 8 and Sentinel-2 images showed relatively similar correlation values to NBR-based indices for site and soil burn severity, but showed limitations using Deimos-1. In general, mono-temporal and relativized indices better correlated with vegetation burn severity in heterogeneous systems than differenced indices. This study showed good potential for Landsat 8 OLI/TIRS and Sentinel-2 MSI for burn severity assessment in fire-prone heterogeneous ecosystems, although we highlight the need for further evaluation of Deimos-1 SLIM-6-22 in different fire scenarios, especially using bi-temporal indices.S

Mapping Soil Burn Severity at Very High Spatial Resolution from Unmanned Aerial Vehicles

ArtículoThe evaluation of the effect of burn severity on forest soils is essential to determine the impact of wildfires on a range of key ecological processes, such as nutrient cycling and vegetation recovery. The main objective of this study was to assess the potentiality of different spectral products derived from RGB and multispectral imagery collected by unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs) at very high spatial resolution for discriminating spatial variations in soil burn severity after a heterogeneous wildfire. In the case study, we chose a mixed-severity fire that occurred in the northwest (NW) of the Iberian Peninsula (Spain) in 2019 that affected 82.74 ha covered by three different types of forests, each dominated by Pinus pinaster, Pinus sylvestris, and Quercus pyrenaica. We evaluated soil burn severity in the field 1 month after the fire using the Composite Burn Soil Index (CBSI), as well as a pool of five individual indicators (ash depth, ash cover, fine debris cover, coarse debris cover, and unstructured soil depth) of easy interpretation. Simultaneously, we operated an unmanned aerial vehicle to obtain RGB and multispectral postfire images, allowing for deriving six spectral indices. Then, we explored the relationship between spectral indices and field soil burn severity metrics by means of univariate proportional odds regression models. These models were used to predict CBSI categories, and classifications were validated through confusion matrices. Results indicated that multispectral indices outperformed RGB indices when assessing soil burn severity, being more strongly related to CBSI than to individual indicators. The Normalized Difference Water Index (NDWI) was the best-performing spectral index for modelling CBSI (R2cv = 0.69), showing the best ability to predict CBSI categories (overall accuracy = 0.83). Among the individual indicators of soil burn severity, ash depth was the one that achieved the best results, specifically when it was modelled from NDWI (R2cv = 0.53). This work provides a useful background to design quick and accurate assessments of soil burn severity to be implemented immediately after the fire, which is a key factor to identify priority areas for emergency actions after forest fires.S

Radar and multispectral remote sensing data accurately estimate vegetation vertical structure diversity as a fire resilience indicator

The structural complexity of plant communities contributes to maintaining the ecosystem functioning in fire-prone landscapes and plays a crucial role in driving ecological resilience to fire. The objective of this study was to evaluate the resilience to fire off several plant communities with reference to the temporal evolution of their vertical structural diversity (VSD) estimated from the data fusion of C-band synthetic aperture radar (SAR) backscatter (Sentinel-1) and multispectral remote sensing reflectance (Sentinel-2) in a burned landscape of the western Mediterranean Basin. We estimated VSD in the field 1 and 2 years after fire using Shannon’s index as a measure of vertical heterogeneity in vegetation structure from the vegetation cover in several strata, both in burned and unburned control plots. Random forest (RF) was used to model VSD in the control (analogous to prefire scenario) and burned plots (1 year after fire) using as predictors (i) Sentinel-1 VV and VH backscatter coefficients and (ii) surface reflectance of Sentinel-2 bands. The transferability of the RF model from 1 to 2 years after wildfire was also evaluated. We generated VSD prediction maps across the study site for the prefire scenario and 1 to 4 years postfire. RF models accurately explained VSD in unburned control plots (R2 = 87.68; RMSE = 0.16) and burned plots 1 year after fire (R2 = 80.48; RMSE = 0.13). RF model transferability only involved a reduction in the VSD predictive capacity from 0.13 to 0.20 in terms of RMSE. The VSD of each plant community 4 years after the fire disturbance was significantly lower than in the prefire scenario. Plant communities dominated by resprouter species featured significantly higher VSD recovery values than communities dominated by facultative or obligate seeders. Our results support the applicability of SAR and multispectral data fusion for monitoring VSD as a generalizable resilience indicator in fire-prone landscapes.SIEuropean Regional Development Fund (ERDF)Spanish Ministry of Economy and CompetitivenessRegional Government of Castilla and LeónBritish Ecological Societ

PLS-PM analysis of forest fires using remote sensing tools. The case of Xurés in the Transboundary Biosphere Reserve

Forest fires have environmental, social and economic impacts in many areas. Various factors related to territory directly influence both the number and the surface area of each fire. The link between different variables (climate, social and environmental) in the risk of fire and in the characteristics of fires is studied here through Partial Least Squares - Path Models. In addition, images from the Sentinel-2 sensor and geographic information systems are used to create a cartographic base of fires in the Transboundary Biosphere Reserve of Galicia and the Site of Community Importance of Xurés (Galicia) between 2015 and 2020. In all, seven variables are analyzed in this study area using the partial least squares-path modeling method: climate, topography, land use, type of environmental protection, the anthropogenic factor, fire defense, and fire data (severity and area). The parameters for each variable are used to obtain weights and thus determine the importance of each one. The areas where the problem of forest fires is greatest are those with the greatest environmental protection. Up to 31% of the surface area of the Natura 2000 Network was burned in the 6-year study period. Topography and land use are also shown to be relevant factors in the effects of forest fires in this territory. By contrast, higher population density and the development of infrastructures such as roads and water tanks mitigate the impact of fires. The problem of forest fires encompasses many variables that need to be studied. By contextualizing each study area as far as possible, specific measures to prevent and reduce damage can be drawn up.Agencia Estatal de Investigación | Ref. PCI2020–120705-2Financiado para publicación en acceso aberto: Universidade de Vigo/CISU

Automatic mapping of burned areas using Landsat 8 time-series images in Google Earth engine: a case study from Iran

Due to the natural conditions and inappropriate management responses, large part of plains and forests in Iran have been burned in recent years. Given the increasing availability of open-access satellite images and open-source software packages, we developed a fast and cost-effective remote sensing methodology for characterizing burned areas for the entire country of Iran. We mapped the fire-affected areas using a post-classification supervised method and Landsat 8 time-series images. To this end, the Google Earth Engine (GEE) and Google Colab computing services were used to facilitate the downloading and processing of images as well as allowing for effective implementation of the algorithms. In total, 13 spectral indices were calculated using Landsat 8 images and were added to the nine original bands of Landsat 8. The training polygons of the burned and unburned areas were accurately distinguished based on the information acquired from the Iranian Space Agency (ISA), Sentinel-2 images, and Fire Information for Resource Management System (FIRMS) products. A combination of Genetic Algorithm (GA) and Neural Network (NN) approaches was then implemented to specify 19 optimal features out of the 22 bands. The 19 optimal bands were subsequently applied to two classifiers of NN and Random Forest (RF) in the timespans of 1 January 2019 to 30 December 2020 and of 1 January 2021 to 30 September 2021. The overall classification accuracies of 94% and 96% were obtained for these two classifiers, respectively. The omission and commission errors of both classifiers were also less than 10%, indicating the promising capability of the proposed methodology in detecting the burned areas. To detect the burned areas caused by the wildfire in 2021, the image differencing method was used as well. The resultant models were finally compared to the MODIS fire products over 10 sampled polygons of the burned areas. Overall, the models had a high accuracy in detecting the burned areas in terms of shape and perimeter, which can be further implicated for potential prevention strategies of endangered biodiversity.Peer ReviewedPostprint (published version

The relationship between fire severity and burning efficiency for estimating wildfire emissions in Mediterranean forests

Forests are exposed to changing climatic conditions reflected by increasing drought and heat waves that increase the risk of wildfire ignition and spread. Climatic variables such as rain and wind as well as vegetation structure, land configuration and forest management practices are all factors that determine the burning potential of wildfires. The assessment of emissions released by vegetation combustion is essential for determining greenhouse gases and air pollutants. The estimation of wildfire-related emissions depends on factors such as the type and fraction of fuel (i.e., live biomass, ground litter, dead wood) consumed by the fire in a given area, termed the burning efficiency. Most approaches estimate live burning efficiency from optical remote sensing data. This study used a data-driven method to estimate live burning efficiency in a Mediterranean area. Burning severity estimations from Landsat imagery (dNBR), which relate to fuel consumption, and quantitative field data from three national forest inventory data were combined to establish the relationship between burning severity and live burning efficiency. Several proxies explored these relationships based on dNBR interval classes, as well as regression models. The correlation results between live burning efficiency and dNBR for conifers (R = 0.63) and broad-leaved vegetation (R = 0.95) indicated ways for improving emissions estimations. Median estimations by severity class (low, moderate-low, moderate-high, and high) are provided for conifers (0 .44 − 0.81) and broad-leaves (0.64 − 0.86), and regression models for the live fraction of the tree canopy susceptible to burning (< 2 cm, 2 − 7 cm, > 7 branches, and leaves). The live burning efficiency values by severity class were higher than previous studies

Multitemporal mapping of post-fire land cover using multiplatform PRISMA hyperspectral and Sentinel-UAV multispectral data: Insights from case studies in Portugal and Italy

Wildfires have affected global forests and the Mediterranean area with increasing recurrency and intensity in the last years, with climate change resulting in reduced precipitations and higher temperatures. To assess the impact of wildfires on the environment, burned area mapping has become progressively more relevant. Initially carried out via field sketches, the advent of satellite remote sensing opened new possibilities, reducing the cost uncertainty and safety of the previous techniques. In the present study an experimental methodology was adopted to test the potential of advanced remote sensing techniques such as multispectral Sentinel-2, PRISMA hyperspectral satellite, and UAV (unmanned aerial vehicle) remotely-sensed data for the multitemporal mapping of burned areas by soil–vegetation recovery analysis in two test sites in Portugal and Italy. In case study one, innovative multiplatform data classification was performed with the correlation between Sentinel-2 RBR (relativized burn ratio) fire severity classes and the scene hyperspectral signature, performed with a pixel-by-pixel comparison leading to a converging classification. In the adopted methodology, RBR burned area analysis and vegetation recovery was tested for accordance with biophysical vegetation parameters (LAI, fCover, and fAPAR). In case study two, a UAV-sensed NDVI index was adopted for high-resolution mapping data collection. At a large scale, the Sentinel-2 RBR index proved to be efficient for burned area analysis, from both fire severity and vegetation recovery phenomena perspectives. Despite the elapsed time between the event and the acquisition, PRISMA hyperspectral converging classification based on Sentinel-2 was able to detect and discriminate different spectral signatures corresponding to different fire severity classes. At a slope scale, the UAV platform proved to be an effective tool for mapping and characterizing the burned area, giving clear advantage with respect to filed GPS mapping. Results highlighted that UAV platforms, if equipped with a hyperspectral sensor and used in a synergistic approach with PRISMA, would create a useful tool for satellite acquired data scene classification, allowing for the acquisition of a ground truth

Análisis de la severidad del incendio forestal suscitado en la Granja Porcón, a través de imágenes Sentinel - 2 – periodo 2019 - 2021, Cajamarca

La presente investigación se realizó en la Granja Porcón, con el objetivo de evaluar mediante imágenes Sentinel – 2 la severidad del incendio forestal suscitado en la Granja Porcón, en el Periodo 2019 – 2021, Cajamarca. Para lo cual se descargó y procesó imágenes satelitales en el software QGIS 3.10, con la finalidad de caracterizar las zonas forestales y calcular los índices espectrales: Índice Normalizado de Área quemada (NBR), Índice de Vegetación de Diferencia Normalizada (NDVI) e Índice de Vegetación Ajustado al Suelo (SAVI). La investigación fue de tipo aplicada, con enfoque cuantitativo, diseño no experimental transversal descriptivo. La población estuvo conformada por el área geográfica del distrito de Cajamarca, como muestra se tomó el área geográfica de la Granja Porcón, la cual abarca doce mil hectáreas aproximadamente. Obteniéndose como resultado tres clases de zonas forestales: zona de bosque, zona agrícola y zona sin vegetación, evidenciándose una expansión en el área de las dos primeras zonas, a causa de actividades antrópicas entre los años 2019 y 2021. Se concluye que el índice espectral NBR fue el que permitió identificar con mayor precisión el área siniestrada por el incendio forestal en la Granja Porcón

Automated and robust geometric and spectral fusion of multi-sensor, multi-spectral satellite images

Die in den letzten Jahrzehnten aufgenommenen Satellitenbilder zur Erdbeobachtung bieten eine ideale Grundlage für eine genaue Langzeitüberwachung und Kartierung der Erdoberfläche und Atmosphäre. Unterschiedliche Sensoreigenschaften verhindern jedoch oft eine synergetische Nutzung. Daher besteht ein dringender Bedarf heterogene Multisensordaten zu kombinieren und als geometrisch und spektral harmonisierte Zeitreihen nutzbar zu machen. Diese Dissertation liefert einen vorwiegend methodischen Beitrag und stellt zwei neu entwickelte Open-Source-Algorithmen zur Sensorfusion vor, die gründlich evaluiert, getestet und validiert werden. AROSICS, ein neuer Algorithmus zur Co-Registrierung und geometrischen Harmonisierung von Multisensor-Daten, ermöglicht eine robuste und automatische Erkennung und Korrektur von Lageverschiebungen und richtet die Daten an einem gemeinsamen Koordinatengitter aus. Der zweite Algorithmus, SpecHomo, wurde entwickelt, um unterschiedliche spektrale Sensorcharakteristika zu vereinheitlichen. Auf Basis von materialspezifischen Regressoren für verschiedene Landbedeckungsklassen ermöglicht er nicht nur höhere Transformationsgenauigkeiten, sondern auch die Abschätzung einseitig fehlender Spektralbänder. Darauf aufbauend wurde in einer dritten Studie untersucht, inwieweit sich die Abschätzung von Brandschäden aus Landsat mittels synthetischer Red-Edge-Bänder und der Verwendung dichter Zeitreihen, ermöglicht durch Sensorfusion, verbessern lässt. Die Ergebnisse zeigen die Effektivität der entwickelten Algorithmen zur Verringerung von Inkonsistenzen bei Multisensor- und Multitemporaldaten sowie den Mehrwert einer geometrischen und spektralen Harmonisierung für nachfolgende Produkte. Synthetische Red-Edge-Bänder erwiesen sich als wertvoll bei der Abschätzung vegetationsbezogener Parameter wie z. B. Brandschweregraden. Zudem zeigt die Arbeit das große Potenzial zur genaueren Überwachung und Kartierung von sich schnell entwickelnden Umweltprozessen, das sich aus einer Sensorfusion ergibt.Earth observation satellite data acquired in recent years and decades provide an ideal data basis for accurate long-term monitoring and mapping of the Earth's surface and atmosphere. However, the vast diversity of different sensor characteristics often prevents synergetic use. Hence, there is an urgent need to combine heterogeneous multi-sensor data to generate geometrically and spectrally harmonized time series of analysis-ready satellite data. This dissertation provides a mainly methodical contribution by presenting two newly developed, open-source algorithms for sensor fusion, which are both thoroughly evaluated as well as tested and validated in practical applications. AROSICS, a novel algorithm for multi-sensor image co-registration and geometric harmonization, provides a robust and automated detection and correction of positional shifts and aligns the data to a common coordinate grid. The second algorithm, SpecHomo, was developed to unify differing spectral sensor characteristics. It relies on separate material-specific regressors for different land cover classes enabling higher transformation accuracies and the estimation of unilaterally missing spectral bands. Based on these algorithms, a third study investigated the added value of synthesized red edge bands and the use of dense time series, enabled by sensor fusion, for the estimation of burn severity and mapping of fire damage from Landsat. The results illustrate the effectiveness of the developed algorithms to reduce multi-sensor, multi-temporal data inconsistencies and demonstrate the added value of geometric and spectral harmonization for subsequent products. Synthesized red edge information has proven valuable when retrieving vegetation-related parameters such as burn severity. Moreover, using sensor fusion for combining multi-sensor time series was shown to offer great potential for more accurate monitoring and mapping of quickly evolving environmental processes