Decentralized Estimation over Orthogonal Multiple-access Fading Channels in Wireless Sensor Networks - Optimal and Suboptimal Estimators

Optimal and suboptimal decentralized estimators in wireless sensor networks (WSNs) over orthogonal multiple-access fading channels are studied in this paper. Considering multiple-bit quantization before digital transmission, we develop maximum likelihood estimators (MLEs) with both known and unknown channel state information (CSI). When training symbols are available, we derive a MLE that is a special case of the MLE with unknown CSI. It implicitly uses the training symbols to estimate the channel coefficients and exploits the estimated CSI in an optimal way. To reduce the computational complexity, we propose suboptimal estimators. These estimators exploit both signal and data level redundant information to improve the estimation performance. The proposed MLEs reduce to traditional fusion based or diversity based estimators when communications or observations are perfect. By introducing a general message function, the proposed estimators can be applied when various analog or digital transmission schemes are used. The simulations show that the estimators using digital communications with multiple-bit quantization outperform the estimator using analog-and-forwarding transmission in fading channels. When considering the total bandwidth and energy constraints, the MLE using multiple-bit quantization is superior to that using binary quantization at medium and high observation signal-to-noise ratio levels

Distributed Location Estimation of a Moving Target Characterized by a Spatial Poisson Field

Wireless Sensor Networks (WSNs) are traditionally employed to collect spatial and temporal data characterizing various events. These data are then used to solve inference problems such as object detection, counting, classification, estimation and tracking. Distributed solutions provided by WSNs are often cost effective and characterized by high performance indices.;In this work, we model and simulate a distributed sensor network composed of radiation detectors and analyze its ability to make inferences. Radiation detectors are deployed over a known area. A radiological point source is positioned in the interior of the area. Detectors take measurements of the field generated by the point source and transmit them (without any interaction with one another) to a remotely installed super computer (called here Fusion Center) for a joint processing. To minimize consumption of resources such as power in the network and transmission bandwidth, the measurements are locally preprocessed prior to transmission. Our model assumes two Gaussian channels, observation and transmission. The first channel distorts data at the receiver end of each sensor during data acquisition. The second channel distorts data during transmission. Sensor measurements are modeled as an inhomogeneous spatial counting random process (Poisson process). The location of the radiological point source in the area and the strength of the field generated by the substance are unknown parameters. The goal of the FC is to estimate these parameters from the distributed measurements provided by the WSN. To find the distributed estimates, we adopt the Maximum Likelihood approach. This approach requires knowledge of the joint probability density function of the distributed measurements observed by the FC. Since the joint probability density of the data observed at the FC is nonlinear in unknown parameters, we propose an iterative approach to solve for the maximum likelihood estimates of these parameters. The solution is a combination of the Bisection and Secant approaches adjusted to seek solution in a multidimensional parameter space. The performance of the distributed estimator is measured in terms of the mean square error. It is analyzed with respect to various parameters of the WSN. We vary the following parameters of the network: (1) the number of sensors in the WSN, (2) signal to noise ratio in observation and transmission channels, (3) the strength of the original field, and (4) the number of quantization levels used by a sensor to convert an analog measurement into a digital signal. We also propose a distributed tracking algorithm for monitoring position of the object in real time

Distributed Detection and Estimation in Wireless Sensor Networks

Wireless sensor networks (WSNs) are typically formed by a large number of densely deployed, spatially distributed sensors with limited sensing, computing, and communication capabilities that cooperate with each other to achieve a common goal. In this dissertation, we investigate the problem of distributed detection, classification, estimation, and localization in WSNs. In this context, the sensors observe the conditions of their surrounding environment, locally process their noisy observations, and send the processed data to a central entity, known as the fusion center (FC), through parallel communication channels corrupted by fading and additive noise. The FC will then combine the received information from the sensors to make a global inference about the underlying phenomenon, which can be either the detection or classification of a discrete variable or the estimation of a continuous one.;In the domain of distributed detection and classification, we propose a novel scheme that enables the FC to make a multi-hypothesis classification of an underlying hypothesis using only binary detections of spatially distributed sensors. This goal is achieved by exploiting the relationship between the influence fields characterizing different hypotheses and the accumulated noisy versions of local binary decisions as received by the FC, where the influence field of a hypothesis is defined as the spatial region in its surrounding in which it can be sensed using some sensing modality. In the realm of distributed estimation and localization, we make four main contributions: (a) We first formulate a general framework that estimates a vector of parameters associated with a deterministic function using spatially distributed noisy samples of the function for both analog and digital local processing schemes. ( b) We consider the estimation of a scalar, random signal at the FC and derive an optimal power-allocation scheme that assigns the optimal local amplification gains to the sensors performing analog local processing. The objective of this optimized power allocation is to minimize the L 2-norm of the vector of local transmission powers, given a maximum estimation distortion at the FC. We also propose a variant of this scheme that uses a limited-feedback strategy to eliminate the requirement of perfect feedback of the instantaneous channel fading coefficients from the FC to local sensors through infinite-rate, error-free links. ( c) We propose a linear spatial collaboration scheme in which sensors collaborate with each other by sharing their local noisy observations. We derive the optimal set of coefficients used to form linear combinations of the shared noisy observations at local sensors to minimize the total estimation distortion at the FC, given a constraint on the maximum average cumulative transmission power in the entire network. (d) Using a novel performance measure called the estimation outage, we analyze the effects of the spatial randomness of the location of the sensors on the quality and performance of localization algorithms by considering an energy-based source-localization scheme under the assumption that the sensors are positioned according to a uniform clustering process

Distributed detection and estimation in wireless sensor networks: resource allocation, fusion rules, and network security

This thesis addresses the problem of detection of an unknown binary event. In particular, we consider centralized detection, distributed detection, and network security in wireless sensor networks (WSNs). The communication links among SNs are subject to limited SN transmit power, limited bandwidth (BW), and are modeled as orthogonal channels with path loss, flat fading and additive white Gaussian noise (AWGN). We propose algorithms for resource allocations, fusion rules, and network security. In the first part of this thesis, we consider the centralized detection and calculate the optimal transmit power allocation and the optimal number of quantization bits for each SN. The resource allocation is performed at the fusion center (FC) and it is referred as a centralized approach. We also propose a novel fully $distributed$ algorithm to address this resource allocation problem. What makes this scheme attractive is that the SNs share with their neighbors just their individual transmit power at the current states. Finally, the optimal soft fusion rule at the FC is derived. But as this rule requires a-priori knowledge that is difficult to attain in practice, suboptimal fusion rules are proposed that are realizable in practice. The second part considers a fully distributed detection framework and we propose a two-step distributed quantized fusion rule algorithm where in the first step the SNs collaborate with their neighbors through error-free, orthogonal channels. In the second step, local 1-bit decisions generated in the first step are shared among neighbors to yield a consensus. A binary hypothesis testing is performed at any arbitrary SN to optimally declare the global decision. Simulations show that our proposed quantized two-step distributed detection algorithm approaches the performance of the unquantized centralized (with a FC) detector and its power consumption is shown to be 50% less than the existing (unquantized) conventional algorithm. Finally, we analyze the detection performance of under-attack WSNs and derive attacking and defense strategies from both the Attacker and the FC perspective. We re-cast the problem as a minimax game between the FC and Attacker and show that the Nash Equilibrium (NE) exists. We also propose a new non-complex and efficient reputation-based scheme to identify these compromised SNs. Based on this reputation metric, we propose a novel FC weight computation strategy ensuring that the weights for the identified compromised SNs are likely to be decreased. In this way, the FC decides how much a SN should contribute to its final decision. We show that this strategy outperforms the existing schemes

A survey on gas leakage source detection and boundary tracking with wireless sensor networks

Gas leakage source detection and boundary tracking of continuous objects have received a significant research attention in the academic as well as the industries due to the loss and damage caused by toxic gas leakage in large-scale petrochemical plants. With the advance and rapid adoption of wireless sensor networks (WSNs) in the last decades, source localization and boundary estimation have became the priority of research works. In addition, an accurate boundary estimation is a critical issue due to the fast movement, changing shape, and invisibility of the gas leakage compared with the other single object detections. We present various gas diffusion models used in the literature that offer the effective computational approaches to measure the gas concentrations in the large area. In this paper, we compare the continuous object localization and boundary detection schemes with respect to complexity, energy consumption, and estimation accuracy. Moreover, this paper presents the research directions for existing and future gas leakage source localization and boundary estimation schemes with WSNs

Distributed Joint Sensor and Target Location Estimation

The area of wireless sensor networks (WSN) is a fast growing area and has a variety of applications such as environmental monitoring, health care, agricultural applications, and military applications. While this research area has been active since 1980s, new applications bring new constraints, and these lead to new open problems. This thesis approaches one of them. It focuses on the problem of target location estimation with limited knowledge about sensor locations in a WSN. Sensors in a WSN are randomly deployed over a known area. The true locations of the sensors are unknown, but each sensor node is equipped with positioning technolgy system such as GPS generating noisy measurements of the true unknown location. A target is modeled as a point source generating a spatial parametric signal or field. The shape of the parametric field is known, but the location of the point source is unknown. The sensors monitor the field and report their noisy measurements to a base station called Fusion Center (FC). The measurements are wirelessly transmitted to the FC via Additive White Gaussian Noise (AWGN) channels. We assume two cases of transmission channel in this thesis. In the first case, the observed data are modulated using a linear analog modulation such as amplitude. In the second case, the observed data are quantized to M quantization levels and then transmitted to the FC using a digital modulation scheme such as ON-OFF Keying (OOK). Each sensor transmits two sets of data: (1) noisy measurements of the field and (2) the measurements of the sensor position provided by its positioning system. Given noisy measurements of the field and noisy measurements of sensor locations, the task of the FC is to find the location of the point source. The FC applies the Maximum Likelihood estimation approach to solve for unknown parameters. In this thesis, the numerical solution is due to the Bisection method that iteratively estimates the location of the point source and the location of sensors and alternates these two steps. The field generated by a point source is modeled as a Gaussian bell function. The measurements of sensor location are assumed to be drawn from a two-dimensional Gaussian distribution with the true location of a sensor as its mean and known covariance matrix. The performance of the proposed solution is measured in terms of the square error (SE) between the true and estimated location of the point source. The MS is analyzed as a function of many parameters of the WSN, FC and parametric field. A comparison with a baseline case, when the locations of sensors are known to the FC, is made

Distributed detection, localization, and estimation in time-critical wireless sensor networks

In this thesis the problem of distributed detection, localization, and estimation (DDLE) of a stationary target in a fusion center (FC) based wireless sensor network (WSN) is considered. The communication process is subject to time-critical operation, restricted power and bandwidth (BW) resources operating over a shared communication channel Buffering from Rayleigh fading and phase noise. A novel algorithm is proposed to solve the DDLE problem consisting of two dependent stages: distributed detection and distributed estimation. The WSN performs distributed detection first and based on the global detection decision the distributed estimation stage is performed. The communication between the SNs and the FC occurs over a shared channel via a slotted Aloha MAC protocol to conserve BW. In distributed detection, hard decision fusion is adopted, using the counting rule (CR), and sensor censoring in order to save power and BW. The effect of Rayleigh fading on distributed detection is also considered and accounted for by using distributed diversity combining techniques where the diversity combining is among the sensor nodes (SNs) in lieu of having the processing done at the FC. Two distributed techniques are proposed: the distributed maximum ratio combining (dMRC) and the distributed Equal Gain Combining (dEGC). Both techniques show superior detection performance when compared to conventional diversity combining procedures that take place at the FC. In distributed estimation, the segmented distributed localization and estimation (SDLE) framework is proposed. The SDLE enables efficient power and BW processing. The SOLE hinges on the idea of introducing intermediate parameters that are estimated locally by the SNs and transmitted to the FC instead of the actual measurements. This concept decouples the main problem into a simpler set of local estimation problems solved at the SNs and a global estimation problem solved at the FC. Two algorithms are proposed for solving the local problem: a nonlinear least squares (NLS) algorithm using the variable projection (VP) method and a simpler gird search (GS) method. Also, Four algorithms are proposed to solve the global problem: NLS, GS, hyperspherical intersection method (HSI), and robust hyperspherical intersection (RHSI) method. Thus, the SDLE can be solved through local and global algorithm combinations. Five combinations are tied: NLS2 (NLS-NLS), NLS-HSI, NLS-RHSI, GS2, and GS-N LS. It turns out that the last algorithm combination delivers the best localization and estimation performance. In fact , the target can be localized with less than one meter error. The SNs send their local estimates to the FC over a shared channel using the slotted-Aloha MAC protocol, which suits WSNs since it requires only one channel. However, Aloha is known for its relatively high medium access or contention delay given the medium access probability is poorly chosen. This fact significantly hinders the time-critical operation of the system. Hence, multi-packet reception (MPR) is used with slotted Aloha protocol, in which several channels are used for contention. The contention delay is analyzed for slotted Aloha with and without MPR. More specifically, the mean and variance have been analytically computed and the contention delay distribution is approximated. Having theoretical expressions for the contention delay statistics enables optimizing both the medium access probability and the number of MPR channels in order to strike a trade-off between delay performance and complexity

Distributed Detection and Estimation in Wireless Sensor Networks: Resource Allocation, Fusion Rules, and Network Security

This thesis addresses the problem of detection of an unknown binary event. In particular, we consider centralized detection, distributed detection, and network security in wireless sensor networks (WSNs). The communication links among SNs are subject to limited SN transmit power, limited bandwidth (BW), and are modeled as orthogonal channels with path loss, flat fading and additive white Gaussian noise (AWGN). We propose algorithms for resource allocations, fusion rules, and network security. In the first part of this thesis, we consider the centralized detection and calculate the optimal transmit power allocation and the optimal number of quantization bits for each SN. The resource allocation is performed at the fusion center (FC) and it is referred as a $centralized$ approach. We also propose a novel fully $distributed$ algorithm to address this resource allocation problem. What makes this scheme attractive is that the SNs share with their neighbors just their individual transmit power at the current states. Finally, the optimal soft fusion rule at the FC is derived. But as this rule requires a-priori knowledge that is difficult to attain in practice, suboptimal fusion rules are proposed that are realizable in practice. The second part considers a fully distributed detection framework and we propose a two-step distributed quantized fusion rule algorithm where in the first step the SNs collaborate with their neighbors through error-free, orthogonal channels. In the second step, local 1-bit decisions generated in the first step are shared among neighbors to yield a consensus. A binary hypothesis testing is performed at any arbitrary SN to optimally declare the global decision. Simulations show that our proposed quantized two-step distributed detection algorithm approaches the performance of the unquantized centralized (with a FC) detector and its power consumption is shown to be 50% less than the existing (unquantized) conventional algorithm. Finally, we analyze the detection performance of under-attack WSNs and derive attacking and defense strategies from both the Attacker and the FC perspective. We re-cast the problem as a minimax game between the FC and Attacker and show that the Nash Equilibrium (NE) exists. We also propose a new non-complex and efficient reputation-based scheme to identify these compromised SNs. Based on this reputation metric, we propose a novel FC weight computation strategy ensuring that the weights for the identified compromised SNs are likely to be decreased. In this way, the FC decides how much a SN should contribute to its final decision. We show that this strategy outperforms the existing schemes

Distributed Detection and Estimation in Wireless Sensor Networks: Resource Allocation, Fusion Rules, and Network Security

This thesis addresses the problem of detection of an unknown binary event. In particular, we consider centralized detection, distributed detection, and network security in wireless sensor networks (WSNs). The communication links among SNs are subject to limited SN transmit power, limited bandwidth (BW), and are modeled as orthogonal channels with path loss, flat fading and additive white Gaussian noise (AWGN). We propose algorithms for resource allocations, fusion rules, and network security. In the first part of this thesis, we consider the centralized detection and calculate the optimal transmit power allocation and the optimal number of quantization bits for each SN. The resource allocation is performed at the fusion center (FC) and it is referred as a $centralized$ approach. We also propose a novel fully $distributed$ algorithm to address this resource allocation problem. What makes this scheme attractive is that the SNs share with their neighbors just their individual transmit power at the current states. Finally, the optimal soft fusion rule at the FC is derived. But as this rule requires a-priori knowledge that is difficult to attain in practice, suboptimal fusion rules are proposed that are realizable in practice. The second part considers a fully distributed detection framework and we propose a two-step distributed quantized fusion rule algorithm where in the first step the SNs collaborate with their neighbors through error-free, orthogonal channels. In the second step, local 1-bit decisions generated in the first step are shared among neighbors to yield a consensus. A binary hypothesis testing is performed at any arbitrary SN to optimally declare the global decision. Simulations show that our proposed quantized two-step distributed detection algorithm approaches the performance of the unquantized centralized (with a FC) detector and its power consumption is shown to be 50% less than the existing (unquantized) conventional algorithm. Finally, we analyze the detection performance of under-attack WSNs and derive attacking and defense strategies from both the Attacker and the FC perspective. We re-cast the problem as a minimax game between the FC and Attacker and show that the Nash Equilibrium (NE) exists. We also propose a new non-complex and efficient reputation-based scheme to identify these compromised SNs. Based on this reputation metric, we propose a novel FC weight computation strategy ensuring that the weights for the identified compromised SNs are likely to be decreased. In this way, the FC decides how much a SN should contribute to its final decision. We show that this strategy outperforms the existing schemes

On Distributed Estimation for Resource Constrained Wireless Sensor Networks

We study Distributed Estimation (DES) problem, where several agents observe a noisy version of an underlying unknown physical phenomena (which is not directly observable), and transmit a compressed version of their observations to a Fusion Center (FC), where collective data is fused to reconstruct the unknown. One of the most important applications of Wireless Sensor Networks (WSNs) is performing DES in a field to estimate an unknown signal source. In a WSN battery powered geographically distributed tiny sensors are tasked with collecting data from the field. Each sensor locally processes its noisy observation (local processing can include compression, dimension reduction, quantization, etc) and transmits the processed observation over communication channels to the FC, where the received data is used to form a global estimate of the unknown source such that the Mean Square Error (MSE) of the DES is minimized. The accuracy of DES depends on many factors such as intensity of observation noises in sensors, quantization errors in sensors, available power and bandwidth of the network, quality of communication channels between sensors and the FC, and the choice of fusion rule in the FC. Taking into account all of these contributing factors and implementing a DES system which minimizes the MSE and satisfies all constraints is a challenging task. In order to probe into different aspects of this challenging task we identify and formulate the following three problems and address them accordingly: 1- Consider an inhomogeneous WSN where the sensors\u27 observations is modeled linear with additive Gaussian noise. The communication channels between sensors and FC are orthogonal power and bandwidth-constrained erroneous wireless fading channels. The unknown to be estimated is a Gaussian vector. Sensors employ uniform multi-bit quantizers and BPSK modulation. Given this setup, we ask: what is the best fusion rule in the FC? what is the best transmit power and quantization rate (measured in bits per sensor) allocation schemes that minimize the MSE? In order to answer these questions, we derive some upper bounds on global MSE and through minimizing those bounds, we propose various resource allocation schemes for the problem, through which we investigate the effect of contributing factors on the MSE. 2- Consider an inhomogeneous WSN with an FC which is tasked with estimating a scalar Gaussian unknown. The sensors are equipped with uniform multi-bit quantizers and the communication channels are modeled as Binary Symmetric Channels (BSC). In contrast to former problem the sensors experience independent multiplicative noises (in addition to additive noise). The natural question in this scenario is: how does multiplicative noise affect the DES system performance? how does it affect the resource allocation for sensors, with respect to the case where there is no multiplicative noise? We propose a linear fusion rule in the FC and derive the associated MSE in closed-form. We propose several rate allocation schemes with different levels of complexity which minimize the MSE. Implementing the proposed schemes lets us study the effect of multiplicative noise on DES system performance and its dynamics. We also derive Bayesian Cramer-Rao Lower Bound (BCRLB) and compare the MSE performance of our porposed methods against the bound. As a dual problem we also answer the question: what is the minimum required bandwidth of the network to satisfy a predetermined target MSE? 3- Assuming the framework of Bayesian DES of a Gaussian unknown with additive and multiplicative Gaussian noises involved, we answer the following question: Can multiplicative noise improve the DES performance in any case/scenario? the answer is yes, and we call the phenomena as \u27enhancement mode\u27 of multiplicative noise. Through deriving different lower bounds, such as BCRLB,Weiss-Weinstein Bound (WWB), Hybrid CRLB (HCRLB), Nayak Bound (NB), Yatarcos Bound (YB) on MSE, we identify and characterize the scenarios that the enhancement happens. We investigate two situations where variance of multiplicative noise is known and unknown. We also compare the performance of well-known estimators with the derived bounds, to ensure practicability of the mentioned enhancement modes