Mechanistic analytical modeling of superscalar in-order processor performance

Superscalar in-order processors form an interesting alternative to out-of-order processors because of their energy efficiency and lower design complexity. However, despite the reduced design complexity, it is nontrivial to get performance estimates or insight in the application--microarchitecture interaction without running slow, detailed cycle-level simulations, because performance highly depends on the order of instructions within the application’s dynamic instruction stream, as in-order processors stall on interinstruction dependences and functional unit contention. To limit the number of detailed cycle-level simulations needed during design space exploration, we propose a mechanistic analytical performance model that is built from understanding the internal mechanisms of the processor. The mechanistic performance model for superscalar in-order processors is shown to be accurate with an average performance prediction error of 3.2% compared to detailed cycle-accurate simulation using gem5. We also validate the model against hardware, using the ARM Cortex-A8 processor and show that it is accurate within 10% on average. We further demonstrate the usefulness of the model through three case studies: (1) design space exploration, identifying the optimum number of functional units for achieving a given performance target; (2) program--machine interactions, providing insight into microarchitecture bottlenecks; and (3) compiler--architecture interactions, visualizing the impact of compiler optimizations on performance

The "MIND" Scalable PIM Architecture

MIND (Memory, Intelligence, and Network Device) is an advanced parallel computer architecture for high performance computing and scalable embedded processing. It is a Processor-in-Memory (PIM) architecture integrating both DRAM bit cells and CMOS logic devices on the same silicon die. MIND is multicore with multiple memory/processor nodes on each chip and supports global shared memory across systems of MIND components. MIND is distinguished from other PIM architectures in that it incorporates mechanisms for efficient support of a global parallel execution model based on the semantics of message-driven multithreaded split-transaction processing. MIND is designed to operate either in conjunction with other conventional microprocessors or in standalone arrays of like devices. It also incorporates mechanisms for fault tolerance, real time execution, and active power management. This paper describes the major elements and operational methods of the MIND architecture

Scalable hardware memory disambiguation

This dissertation deals with one of the long-standing problems in Computer Architecture – the problem of memory disambiguation. Microprocessors typically reorder memory instructions during execution to improve concurrency. Such microprocessors use hardware memory structures for memory disambiguation, known as LoadStore Queues (LSQs), to ensure that memory instruction dependences are satisfied even when the memory instructions execute out-of-order. A typical LSQ implementation (circa 2006) holds all in-flight memory instructions in a physically centralized LSQ and performs a fully associative search on all buffered instructions to ensure that memory dependences are satisfied. These LSQ implementations do not scale because they use large, fully associative structures, which are known to be slow and power hungry. The increasing trend towards distributed microarchitectures further exacerbates these problems. As on-chip wire delays increase and high-performance processors become necessarily distributed, centralized structures such as the LSQ can limit scalability. This dissertation describes techniques to create scalable LSQs in both centralized and distributed microarchitectures. The problems and solutions described in this thesis are motivated and validated by real system designs. The dissertation starts with a description of the partitioned primary memory system of the TRIPS processor, of which the LSQ is an important component, and then through a series of optimizations describes how the power, area, and centralization problems of the LSQ can be solved with minor performance losses (if at all) even for large number of in flight memory instructions. The four solutions described in this dissertation — partitioning, filtering, late binding and efficient overflow management — enable power-, area-efficient, distributed and scalable LSQs, which in turn enable aggressive large-window processors capable of simultaneously executing thousands of instructions. To mitigate the power problem, we replaced the power-hungry, fully associative search with a power-efficient hash table lookup using a simple address-based Bloom filter. Bloom filters are probabilistic data structures used for testing set membership and can be used to quickly check if an instruction with the same data address is likely to be found in the LSQ without performing the associative search. Bloom filters typically eliminate more than 80% of the associative searches and they are highly effective because in most programs, it is uncommon for loads and stores to have the same data address and be in execution simultaneously. To rectify the area problem, we observe the fact that only a small fraction of all memory instructions are dependent, that only such dependent instructions need to be buffered in the LSQ, and that these instructions need to be in the LSQ only for certain parts of the pipelined execution. We propose two mechanisms to exploit these observations. The first mechanism, area filtering, is a hardware mechanism that couples Bloom filters and dependence predictors to dynamically identify and buffer only those instructions which are likely to be dependent. The second mechanism, late binding, reduces the occupancy and hence size of the LSQ. Both of these optimizations allows the number of LSQ slots to be reduced by up to one-half compared to a traditional organization without any performance degradation. Finally, we describe a new decentralized LSQ design for handling LSQ structural hazards in distributed microarchitectures. Decentralization of LSQs, and to a large extent distributed microarchitectures with memory speculation, has proved to be impractical because of the high performance penalties associated with the mechanisms for dealing with hazards. To solve this problem, we applied classic flow-control techniques from interconnection networks for handling resource con- flicts. The first method, memory-side buffering, buffers the overflowing instructions in a separate buffer near the LSQs. The second scheme, execution-side NACKing, sends the overflowing instruction back to the issue window from which it is later re-issued. The third scheme, network buffering, uses the buffers in the interconnection network between the execution units and memory to hold instructions when the LSQ is full, and uses virtual channel flow control to avoid deadlocks. The network buffering scheme is the most robust of all the overflow schemes and shows less than 1% performance degradation due to overflows for a subset of SPEC CPU 2000 and EEMBC benchmarks on a cycle-accurate simulator that closely models the TRIPS processor. The techniques proposed in this dissertation are independent, architectureneutral and their cumulative benefits result in LSQs that can be partitioned at a fine granularity and have low design complexity. Each of these partitions selectively buffers only memory instructions with true dependences and can be closely coupled with the execution units thus minimizing power, area, and latency. Such LSQ designs with near-ideal characteristics are well suited for microarchitectures with thousands of instructions in-flight and may enable even more aggressive microarchitectures in the future.Computer Science

The dynamic simultaneous multithreaded processor

This dissertation investigates diverse techniques to support multithreading in modern high performance processors. The mechanisms studied expand the architecture of a high performance superscalar processor to control efficiently the interaction between software-controlled and hardware-controlled multithreading. Additionally, dynamic speculative mechanisms are proposed to exploit thread-level-parallelism (TLP) and instruction-level-parallelism (ILP) on a Simultaneous Multithreading (SMT) architecture. First, the hybrid multithreaded execution model is discussed. This model combines software-controlled multithreading with hardware support for efficient context switching and thread scheduling. A thread scheduling technique called set scheduling is introduced and its impact on the overall performance is described. An analytical model of the hybrid multithreaded execution is developed and validated by simulation. Through stochastic simulation, we find that the application of the hybrid multithreaded execution model results in higher processor utilization than traditional software-controlled multithreading. Next, in the main part of this dissertation, a new architecture is proposed: the Dynamic Simultaneous Multithreading (DSMT) processor. In this architecture, multiple threads are identified and created speculatively at runtime without compiler help. Subsequently, a SMT processor core executes those threads. The performance of a DSMT processor was evaluated with a new execution-driven simulator developed specifically for the purpose. Our experimental results based on simulation show that DSMT architecture has very good potential to improve SMT processor's performance when there is only a single task available for execution

Investigation of a simultaneous multithreaded architecture

Many enhancements have been made to the traditional general purpose load-store computer architectures. Among the enhancements are memory hierarchy improvements, branch prediction, and multiple issue processors. A major problem that exists with current microprocessor design is the disparity in the much larger increase in speed of the CPU versus the moderate increase in speed accessing main memory. The simultaneous multithreaded architecture is an extension of the single-threaded architecture that helps hide the performance penalty created by long-latency instructions, branch mispredictions, and memory accesses. Simultaneous multithreaded architectures use a more flexible parallelism, which takes advantage of both instruction-level, and thread-level parallelism. The goal of this project was to design, simulate, and analyze a model of a simultaneous multithreaded architecture in order to evaluate design alternatives. The simulator was created by modifying a version of the Simple Scalar toolset, developed at the University of Wisconsin. The simulations provide documentation for an overall system performance improvement of a simulta neous multithreaded architecture. In early simulation results, performed with the same number of functional units, an improvement in the number of instructions per cycle (IPC) of between 43% and 58% was found using four threads versus a single thread. The horizontal waste rate, which measures the number of unused issue slots, was reduced between 35% and 46%. The vertical waste rate, which measures the percentage- of unused issue cycles (no issue slots used in a cycle), was reduced between 46% and 61%. These results are derived from a set of four sample programs. It was also found that increasing the number of certain functional units did not improve performance, whereas increasing the number of other types of functional units did have a significant positive impact on performance

Banked microarchitectures for complexity-effective superscalar microprocessors

Thesis (Ph. D.)--Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Dept. of Electrical Engineering and Computer Science, 2006.Includes bibliographical references (p. 95-99).High performance superscalar microarchitectures exploit instruction-level parallelism (ILP) to improve processor performance by executing instructions out of program order and by speculating on branch instructions. Monolithic centralized structures with global communications, including issue windows and register files, are used to buffer in-flight instructions and to maintain machine state. These structures scale poorly to greater issue widths and deeper pipelines, as they must support simultaneous global accesses from all active instructions. The lack of scalability is exacerbated in future technologies, which have increasing global interconnect delay and a much greater emphasis on reducing both switching and leakage power. However, these fully orthogonal structures are over-engineered for typical use. Banked microarchitectures that consist of multiple interleaved banks of fewer ported cells can significantly reduce power, area, and latency of these structures.(cont.) Although banked structures exhibit a minor performance penalty, significant reductions in delay and power can potentially be used to increase clock rate and lead to more complexity-effective designs. There are two main contributions in this thesis. First, a speculative control scheme is proposed to simplify the complicated control logic that is involved in managing a less-ported banked register file for high-frequency superscalar processors. Second, the RingScalar architecture, a complexity-effective out-of-order superscalar microarchitecture, based on a ring topology of banked structures, is introduced and evaluated.by Jessica Hui-Chun Tseng.Ph.D

Hierarchical architecture design and simulation environment

The Hierarchical Architectural design and Simulation Environment (HASE)is intended as a flexible tool for computer architects who wish to experiment with alternative architectural configurations and design parameters. HASE is both a design environment and a simulator. Architecture components are described by a hierarchical library of objects defined in terms of an object oriented simulation language. HASE instantiates these objects to simulate and animate the execution of a computer architecture. An event trace generated by the simulator therefore describes the interaction between architecture components, for example, fetch stages, address and data buses, sequencers, instruction buffers and register files. The objects can model physical components at different abstraction levels, eg. PMS (processor memory switch), ISP (instruction set processor) and RTL (register transfer level). HASE applies the concepts of inheritance, encapsulation and polymorphism associated with object orientation, to simplify the design and implementation of an architecture simulation that models component operations at different abstraction levels. For example, HASE can probe the performance of a processor's floating point unit, executing a multiplication operation, at a lower level of abstraction, i.e. the RTL, whilst simulating remaining architecture components at a PMS level of abstraction. By adopting this approach, HASE returns a more meaningful and relevant event trace from an architecture simulation. Furthermore, an animator visualises the simulation's event trace to clarify the collaborations and interactions between architecture components. The prototype version of HASE is based on GSS (Graphical Support System), and DEMOS (Discrete Event Modelling On Simula)

An efficient design space exploration framework to optimize power-efficient heterogeneous many-core multi-threading embedded processor architectures

By the middle of this decade, uniprocessor architecture performance had hit a roadblock due to a combination of factors, such as excessive power dissipation due to high operating frequencies, growing memory access latencies, diminishing returns on deeper instruction pipelines, and a saturation of available instruction level parallelism in applications. An attractive and viable alternative embraced by all the processor vendors was multi-core architectures where throughput is improved by using micro-architectural features such as multiple processor cores, interconnects and low latency shared caches integrated on a single chip. The individual cores are often simpler than uniprocessor counterparts, use hardware multi-threading to exploit thread-level parallelism and latency hiding and typically achieve better performance-power figures. The overwhelming success of the multi-core microprocessors in both high performance and embedded computing platforms motivated chip architects to dramatically scale the multi-core processors to many-cores which will include hundreds of cores on-chip to further improve throughput. With such complex large scale architectures however, several key design issues need to be addressed. First, a wide range of micro- architectural parameters such as L1 caches, load/store queues, shared cache structures and interconnection topologies and non-linear interactions between them define a vast non-linear multi-variate micro-architectural design space of many-core processors; the traditional method of using extensive in-loop simulation to explore the design space is simply not practical. Second, to accurately evaluate the performance (measured in terms of cycles per instruction (CPI)) of a candidate design, the contention at the shared cache must be accounted in addition to cycle-by-cycle behavior of the large number of cores which superlinearly increases the number of simulation cycles per iteration of the design exploration. Third, single thread performance does not scale linearly with number of hardware threads per core and number of cores due to memory wall effect. This means that at every step of the design process designers must ensure that single thread performance is not unacceptably slowed down while increasing overall throughput. While all these factors affect design decisions in both high performance and embedded many-core processors, the design of embedded processors required for complex embedded applications such as networking, smart power grids, battlefield decision-making, consumer electronics and biomedical devices to name a few, is fundamentally different from its high performance counterpart because of the need to consider (i) low power and (ii) real-time operations. This implies the design objective for embedded many-core processors cannot be to simply maximize performance, but improve it in such a way that overall power dissipation is minimized and all real-time constraints are met. This necessitates additional power estimation models right at the design stage to accurately measure the cost and reliability of all the candidate designs during the exploration phase. In this dissertation, a statistical machine learning (SML) based design exploration framework is presented which employs an execution-driven cycle- accurate simulator to accurately measure power and performance of embedded many-core processors. The embedded many-core processor domain is Network Processors (NePs) used to processed network IP packets. Future generation NePs required to operate at terabits per second network speeds captures all the aspects of a complex embedded application consisting of shared data structures, large volume of compute-intensive and data-intensive real-time bound tasks and a high level of task (packet) level parallelism. Statistical machine learning (SML) is used to efficiently model performance and power of candidate designs in terms of wide ranges of micro-architectural parameters. The method inherently minimizes number of in-loop simulations in the exploration framework and also efficiently captures the non-linear interactions between the micro-architectural design parameters. To ensure scalability, the design space is partitioned into (i) core-level micro-architectural parameters to optimize single core architectures subject to the real-time constraints and (ii) shared memory level micro- architectural parameters to explore the shared interconnection network and shared cache memory architectures and achieves overall optimality. The cost function of our exploration algorithm is the total power dissipation which is minimized, subject to the constraints of real-time throughput (as determined from the terabit optical network router line-speed) required in IP packet processing embedded application