Optimal Control Design for Multiterminal HVDC

This thesis proposes an optimal-control based design for distributed frequency control in multi-terminal high voltage direct current (MTDC) systems. The current power grid has become overstressed by rapid growth in the demand for electric power and penetration of renewable energy. To address these challenges, MTDC technology has been developed, which has the potential to increase the flexibility and reliability of power transmission in the grid. Several control strategies have been proposed to regulate the MTDC system and its interaction with connected AC systems. However, all the existing control strategies are based on proportional and integral (PI) control with predetermined controller structures. The objective of the thesis is to first determine if existing control structures are optimal, and if improved controller structures can be developed.The thesis proposes a general framework to determine the optimal structure for the control system in MTDC transmission through optimal feedback control. The proposed method is validated and demonstrated using an example of frequency control in a MTDC system connecting five AC areas

Control of multi-terminal HVDC networks towards wind power integration: A review

© 2015 Elsevier Ltd. More interconnections among countries and synchronous areas are foreseen in order to fulfil the EU 2050 target on the renewable generation share. One proposal to accomplish this challenging objective is the development of the so-called European SuperGrid. Multi-terminal HVDC networks are emerging as the most promising technologies to develop such a concept. Moreover, multi-terminal HVDC grids are based on highly controllable devices, which may allow not only transmitting power, but also supporting the AC grids to ensure a secure and stable operation. This paper aims to present an overview of different control schemes for multi-terminal HVDC grids, including the control of the power converters and the controls for power sharing and the provision of ancillary services. This paper also analyses the proposed modifications of the existing control schemes to manage high participation shares of wind power generation in multi-terminal grids.Postprint (author's final draft

Modeling and Control of High-Voltage Direct-Current Transmission Systems: From Theory to Practice and Back

The problem of modeling and control of multi-terminal high-voltage direct-current transmission systems is addressed in this paper, which contains five main contributions. First, to propose a unified, physically motivated, modeling framework - based on port-Hamiltonian representations - of the various network topologies used in this application. Second, to prove that the system can be globally asymptotically stabilized with a decentralized PI control, that exploits its passivity properties. Close connections between the proposed PI and the popular Akagi's PQ instantaneous power method are also established. Third, to reveal the transient performance limitations of the proposed controller that, interestingly, is shown to be intrinsic to PI passivity-based control. Fourth, motivated by the latter, an outer-loop that overcomes the aforementioned limitations is proposed. The performance limitation of the PI, and its drastic improvement using outer-loop controls, are verified via simulations on a three-terminals benchmark example. A final contribution is a novel formulation of the power flow equations for the centralized references calculation

Multi-terminal HVDC grids with inertia mimicry capability

The high-voltage multi-terminal dc (MTDC) systems are foreseen to experience an important development in the next years. Currently, they have appeared to be a prevailing technical and economical solution for harvesting offshore wind energy. In this study, inertia mimicry capability is added to a voltage-source converter-HVDC grid-side station in an MTDC grid connected to a weak ac grid, which can have low inertia or even operate as an islanded grid. The presented inertia mimicry control is integrated in the generalised voltage droop strategy implemented at the primary level of a two-layer hierarchical control structure of the MTDC grid to provide higher flexibility, and thus controllability to the network. Besides, complete control framework from the operational point of view is developed to integrate the low-level control of the converter stations in the supervisory control centre of the MTDC grid. A scaled laboratory test results considering the international council on large electric systems (CIGRE) B4 MTDC grid demonstrate the good performance of the converter station when it is connected to a weak islanded ac grid.Peer ReviewedPostprint (author's final draft

DC Network Model Based on VSC-HVDC System

The recent developments in high power rated Voltage Source Converters (VSCs) and the control strategies have resulted in their successful application in HVDC transmission systems, which have become an attractive option for renewable energy applications or for distribution power in large metropolitan areas. A 153th order multiple-input multiple-output (MIMO) small-signal model of DC network model based on VSC-HVDC system and controls is developed in state-space form within MATLAB. The optimum values of the controller gains are selected by analyzing the root locus of the analytical model. The developed small-signal detailed models are linearized and implemented in MATLAB. The validity and accuracy of the proposed models are verified against nonlinear PSCAD/ EMTDC and a summary of the model structure and controls is presented in detailed. Confirmation of the effectiveness of optimization gains is done by simulating the modelled system in MATLAB and PSCAD software. There simulation results performed with very good matching is confirmed in the time domain. It is the most detailed model currently available

Power Flow Control in Multi-Terminal HVDC Grids Using a Serial-Parallel DC Power Flow Controller

© 2013 IEEE. Multi-terminal HVDC (MT-HVDC) grids have no capability of power flow control in a self-sufficient manner. To address this important issue, utilization of dc-dc high power and high-voltage converters is motivated. However, proposing suitable partial-rated dc-dc converters as well as their suitable modeling and control in both primary and secondary control layers as well as the stability analysis are the existing challenges that should be alleviated beforehand. This paper addresses the control of power flow problem through the application of a power converter with a different connection configuration, namely, serial parallel dc power flow controller (SPDC-PFC). The SPDC-PFC input is the transmission line voltage, and its output is transmission line current. Therefore, employing a full-power dc-dc converter is avoided as a merit. Additionally, in this paper, the common two-layer MT-HVDC grid control framework comprised of primary and secondary layers is efficiently modified in order to integrate the SPDC-PFC. A differential direct voltage versus active power droop control scheme is applied to the SPDC-PFC at the local control layer, guaranteeing dynamic stability, while an extended dc power-flow routine - integrating the SPDC-PFC - is developed at the secondary control layer to ensure the static stability of the entire MT-HVDC grid. The proposed control framework enables the SPDC-PFC to regulate the flow of current/power in the envisioned HVDC transmission line. From the static and dynamic simulation results conducted on the test CIGRE B4 MT-HVDC grid, successful operation of the proposed SPDC-PFC and control solutions are demonstrated by considering power flow control action. In more detail, the SPDC-PFC successfully regulates the compensated lines' power to the desired reference both in static and dynamic simulations by introducing suitable compensation voltages. In addition, good dynamic performance under both SPDC-PFC power reference and wind power-infeed change is observed

Multiterminal HVDC transmissions systems for offshore wind

Offshore wind is emerging as one of the future energy vectors. Offshore wind power plants locations provide more strong and constant wind speed that allows to extract more power compared to onshore locations. In addition, as wind turbine components transportation is less restricted to terrestrial infrastructure, bigger and more powerful wind turbines can be installed offshore. In Europe, 1,567 MW of offshore wind power was installed in 2013. It represents the 14\% of the total wind power installed in Europe. Offshore wind power plants near the shore can be connected to the main grid by means of conventional AC technology. However, if these wind farms are installed further than 80-100 km, the use of AC equipment is economically infeasible due to reactive power issues. In these applications, HVDC system based on static converters can be used. The projects build and commissioned nowadays are based on point-to-point connections, where, each wind farm or wind farm clusters are connected to the terrestrial grid individually. Consequently, these lines might be understood as an extension of the AC system. If different offshore wind farms are interconnected between them and connected at the same time to different AC systems, for example, different countries, the DC grid is created. This scenario creates one of the most important challenges in the electrical power system since its creation, more than 100 years ago. The most relevant challenges to be addressed are the stability and operation of the DC grid and the integration and interaction with the AC grid. This thesis addresses various aspects related to the future Multiterminal-HVDC systems for transmission of offshore wind power. First, the voltage control and the system operations are discussed and verified by means of emulations using an HVDC scaled experimental platform built for this purpose. Voltage stability might be endangered during contingencies due to the different inertia time constant of the AC and the DC system. DC systems only have the inertia of the capacitors compared to synchronous machines rotating masses of the AC systems. Therefore, in faulty conditions the power transmitted through the DC system must be reduced quickly and efficiently. For this reason, in this thesis a coordinated power reduction algorithm taking advantage of Dynamic Braking Resistors (DBR) connected to onshore converter stations and the ability of the power plants to reduce the generated power is presented. From the AC and DC grids integration point of view, the connection point between the offshore grid and the AC grid might be located remotely leading to a connection with a reduced Short Circuit Ratio (SCR). In the literature, several issues regarding the connection of transistor-based power converters to weak AC grid have been reported. In this thesis am advanced control for Voltage Source Converters connected to weak grids is presented and tested by means of simulations. From the AC and DC grids interactions, the voltage stability is not enough to operate a DC grid. Transport System Operators (TSO) operates the power flow through the cables and the power exchanged between by the power converters. In this thesis, a novel hierarchical power flow control method is presented. The aim of the proposed power flow control is to obtain the desired power flows changing the voltage control set-points while the system stability is ensured. Finally, a control procedure for offshore wind farms based on Squirrel Cage Induction Generators connected to a single power converter is introduced.L'energia eòlica marina emergeix com un dels vectors energètics del futur. Les localitzacions eòliques marines proporcionen vens més forts i constants que les terrestres, cosa que permet extreure més potència. A més a més, els aerogeneradors marins poden ser més grans i més potents ja que es redueixen les limitacions de gàlib existent en les infraestructures terrestres. A tall d'exemple, l'any 2013 a Europa es van instal.lar 1.567 MW de potència eòlica marina, cosa que representa un 14\% de la potència eòlica instal.lada a Europa. Els parcs eòlics marins poden ser connectats a la xarxa elèctrica terrestre utilitzant emparamenta convencional de corrent alterna, però quan la distancia amb la costa excedeix els 80-100 km l'ús d'aquesta tecnologia es torna econòmicament inviable degut a l'energia reactiva generada en els conductors. Per solucionar aquest problema, s'emparen els sistemes en corrent continua basats en convertidors estàtics. Els projectes construïts o projectats a dia d'avui es basen en esquemes de connexió punt-a-punt, on, cada parc eòlic o agrupació de parcs eòlics es troba connectat a la xara terrestre individualment. En conseqüència, l'operació d'aquestes línies es pot considerar com una extensió de la xarxa d'alterna. Però, si s'interconnecten diferents parc eòlics amb diferents xarxes terrestres d'alterna (per exemple, diferents països) en corrent continua, s'obtenen xarxes en corrent continua. Aquest nou escenari crea un dels majors reptes des de la creació dels sistema elèctric de potencia, ara fa més de 100 anys. Entre aquests reptes hi ha l'estabilitat i l'operació dels sistemes en corrent contínua i la seva integració i coexistència amb les xarxes en corrent alterna. En la present tesis s'han estudiat diferents aspectes dels futurs sistemes multi terminal en alta tensió en corrent contínua (HVDC, en anglès) per la transmissió de potencia generada mitjançant parcs eòlics marins. Primerament, es descriu el control de tensió i els modes d'operació dels sistemes multi terminal i es verifiquen en una plataforma experimental construïda per aquest propòsit. L'estabilitat de tensió dels sistemes en corrent continua, es pot veure afectada durant una falta a la xarxa d'alterna degut a la reduïda inèrcia dels sistemes multi terminal, només formada pels condensadors dels convertidors i els cables. Així la potència que no pot injectar a la xarxa ha de ser reduïda de forma ràpida i eficient. Per això, en aquesta tesis es presenta un sistema coordinat de reducció de potència que utilitza la resistència de frenat dels convertidors de connexió a la xarxa i els mètodes de reducció de potència dels parcs eòlics. Des del punt de vista de la integració de les xarxes en continua i en alterna, el punt d'interconnexió pot estar localitzat llunys dels grans centres de generació, la qual cosa implica tenir una potència de curtcircuit molt reduïda. En la bibliografia científica s'han descrit diverses problemàtiques a l'hora de connectar un convertidor de commutació forçada a les xarxes dèbils. Per tal de pal.liar aquests inconvenients, en aquesta tesis es presenta un algorisme avançat de connexió de convertidors a xarxes dèbils basat en control vectorial. Des del punt de vista de les interaccions i interoperabilitat dels sistemes en corrent alterna i continua, no n'hi ha suficient en garantir l'estabilitat, ja que el propòsit finals dels operadors de xarxa és fer fluir una potencia a traves de la xarxa per tal de satisfer la demanda. Per aquest propòsit en aquesta tesis es presenta un control jeràrquic de control del flux de potència que fixa el flux de potència a traves d'una xarxa multi terminal canviant les consignes del control primari, tot assegurant l'estabilitat del sistema. Per tancar la tesis, es presenta un nou controlador per parcs eòlics basats en aerogeneradors de gàbia d'esquirol controlats per un sol convertidor

Primary and secondary power control of multiterminal HVDC grids

Postprint (published version

Distributed Primary Frequency Control through Multi-Terminal HVDC Transmission Systems

This paper presents a decentralized controller for sharing primary AC frequency control reserves through a multi-terminal HVDC grid. By using Lyapunov arguments, the proposed controller is shown to stabilize the equilibrium of the closed-loop system consisting of the interconnected AC and HVDC grids, given any positive controller gains. The static control errors resulting from the proportional controller are quantified and bounded by analyzing the equilibrium of the closed-loop system. The proposed controller is applied to a test grid consisting of three asynchronous AC areas interconnected by an HVDC grid, and its effectiveness is validated through simulation