Exploring the Existing and Unknown Side Effects of Privacy Preserving Data Mining Algorithms

The data mining sanitization process involves converting the data by masking the sensitive data and then releasing it to public domain. During the sanitization process, side effects such as hiding failure, missing cost and artificial cost of the data were observed. Privacy Preserving Data Mining (PPDM) algorithms were developed for the sanitization process to overcome information loss and yet maintain data integrity. While these PPDM algorithms did provide benefits for privacy preservation, they also made sure to solve the side effects that occurred during the sanitization process. Many PPDM algorithms were developed to reduce these side effects. There are several PPDM algorithms created based on different PPDM techniques. However, previous studies have not explored or justified why non-traditional side effects were not given much importance. This study reported the findings of the side effects for the PPDM algorithms in a newly created web repository. The research methodology adopted for this study was Design Science Research (DSR). This research was conducted in four phases, which were as follows. The first phase addressed the characteristics, similarities, differences, and relationships of existing side effects. The next phase found the characteristics of non-traditional side effects. The third phase used the Privacy Preservation and Security Framework (PPSF) tool to test if non-traditional side effects occur in PPDM algorithms. This phase also attempted to find additional unknown side effects which have not been found in prior studies. PPDM algorithms considered were Greedy, POS2DT, SIF_IDF, cpGA2DT, pGA2DT, sGA2DT. PPDM techniques associated were anonymization, perturbation, randomization, condensation, heuristic, reconstruction, and cryptography. The final phase involved creating a new online web repository to report all the side effects found for the PPDM algorithms. A Web repository was created using full stack web development. AngularJS, Spring, Spring Boot and Hibernate frameworks were used to build the web application. The results of the study implied various PPDM algorithms and their side effects. Additionally, the relationship and impact that hiding failure, missing cost, and artificial cost have on each other was also understood. Interestingly, the side effects and their relationship with the type of data (sensitive or non-sensitive or new) was observed. As the web repository acts as a quick reference domain for PPDM algorithms. Developing, improving, inventing, and reporting PPDM algorithms is necessary. This study will influence researchers or organizations to report, use, reuse, or develop better PPDM algorithms

Large-scale Wireless Local-area Network Measurement and Privacy Analysis

The edge of the Internet is increasingly becoming wireless. Understanding the wireless edge is therefore important for understanding the performance and security aspects of the Internet experience. This need is especially necessary for enterprise-wide wireless local-area networks (WLANs) as organizations increasingly depend on WLANs for mission- critical tasks. To study a live production WLAN, especially a large-scale network, is a difficult undertaking. Two fundamental difficulties involved are (1) building a scalable network measurement infrastructure to collect traces from a large-scale production WLAN, and (2) preserving user privacy while sharing these collected traces to the network research community. In this dissertation, we present our experience in designing and implementing one of the largest distributed WLAN measurement systems in the United States, the Dartmouth Internet Security Testbed (DIST), with a particular focus on our solutions to the challenges of efficiency, scalability, and security. We also present an extensive evaluation of the DIST system. To understand the severity of some potential trace-sharing risks for an enterprise-wide large-scale wireless network, we conduct privacy analysis on one kind of wireless network traces, a user-association log, collected from a large-scale WLAN. We introduce a machine-learning based approach that can extract and quantify sensitive information from a user-association log, even though it is sanitized. Finally, we present a case study that evaluates the tradeoff between utility and privacy on WLAN trace sanitization

Contribution to privacy-enhancing tecnologies for machine learning applications

For some time now, big data applications have been enabling revolutionary innovation in every aspect of our daily life by taking advantage of lots of data generated from the interactions of users with technology. Supported by machine learning and unprecedented computation capabilities, different entities are capable of efficiently exploiting such data to obtain significant utility. However, since personal information is involved, these practices raise serious privacy concerns. Although multiple privacy protection mechanisms have been proposed, there are some challenges that need to be addressed for these mechanisms to be adopted in practice, i.e., to be “usable” beyond the privacy guarantee offered. To start, the real impact of privacy protection mechanisms on data utility is not clear, thus an empirical evaluation of such impact is crucial. Moreover, since privacy is commonly obtained through the perturbation of large data sets, usable privacy technologies may require not only preservation of data utility but also efficient algorithms in terms of computation speed. Satisfying both requirements is key to encourage the adoption of privacy initiatives. Although considerable effort has been devoted to design less “destructive” privacy mechanisms, the utility metrics employed may not be appropriate, thus the wellness of such mechanisms would be incorrectly measured. On the other hand, despite the advent of big data, more efficient approaches are not being considered. Not complying with the requirements of current applications may hinder the adoption of privacy technologies. In the first part of this thesis, we address the problem of measuring the effect of k-anonymous microaggregation on the empirical utility of microdata. We quantify utility accordingly as the accuracy of classification models learned from microaggregated data, evaluated over original test data. Our experiments show that the impact of the de facto microaggregation standard on the performance of machine-learning algorithms is often minor for a variety of data sets. Furthermore, experimental evidence suggests that the traditional measure of distortion in the community of microdata anonymization may be inappropriate for evaluating the utility of microaggregated data. Secondly, we address the problem of preserving the empirical utility of data. By transforming the original data records to a different data space, our approach, based on linear discriminant analysis, enables k-anonymous microaggregation to be adapted to the application domain of data. To do this, first, data is rotated (projected) towards the direction of maximum discrimination and, second, scaled in this direction, penalizing distortion across the classification threshold. As a result, data utility is preserved in terms of the accuracy of machine learned models for a number of standardized data sets. Afterwards, we propose a mechanism to reduce the running time for the k-anonymous microaggregation algorithm. This is obtained by simplifying the internal operations of the original algorithm. Through extensive experimentation over multiple data sets, we show that the new algorithm gets significantly faster. Interestingly, this remarkable speedup factor is achieved with no additional loss of data utility.Les aplicacions de big data impulsen actualment una accelerada innovació aprofitant la gran quantitat d’informació generada a partir de les interaccions dels usuaris amb la tecnologia. Així, qualsevol entitat és capaç d'explotar eficientment les dades per obtenir utilitat, emprant aprenentatge automàtic i capacitats de còmput sense precedents. No obstant això, sorgeixen en aquest escenari serioses preocupacions pel que fa a la privacitat dels usuaris ja que hi ha informació personal involucrada. Tot i que s'han proposat diversos mecanismes de protecció, hi ha alguns reptes per a la seva adopció en la pràctica, és a dir perquè es puguin utilitzar. Per començar, l’impacte real d'aquests mecanismes en la utilitat de les dades no esta clar, raó per la qual la seva avaluació empírica és important. A més, considerant que actualment es manegen grans volums de dades, una privacitat usable requereix, no només preservació de la utilitat de les dades, sinó també algoritmes eficients en temes de temps de còmput. És clau satisfer tots dos requeriments per incentivar l’adopció de mesures de privacitat. Malgrat que hi ha diversos esforços per dissenyar mecanismes de privacitat menys "destructius", les mètriques d'utilitat emprades no serien apropiades, de manera que aquests mecanismes de protecció podrien estar sent incorrectament avaluats. D'altra banda, tot i l’adveniment del big data, la investigació existent no s’enfoca molt en millorar la seva eficiència. Lamentablement, si els requisits de les aplicacions actuals no es satisfan, s’obstaculitzarà l'adopció de tecnologies de privacitat. A la primera part d'aquesta tesi abordem el problema de mesurar l'impacte de la microagregació k-Gnónima en la utilitat empírica de microdades. Per això, quantifiquem la utilitat com la precisió de models de classificació obtinguts a partir de les dades microagregades. i avaluats sobre dades de prova originals. Els experiments mostren que l'impacte de l’algoritme de rmicroagregació estàndard en el rendiment d’algoritmes d'aprenentatge automàtic és usualment menor per a una varietat de conjunts de dades avaluats. A més, l’evidència experimental suggereix que la mètrica tradicional de distorsió de les dades seria inapropiada per avaluar la utilitat empírica de dades microagregades. Així també estudiem el problema de preservar la utilitat empírica de les dades a l'ésser anonimitzades. Transformant els registres originaIs de dades en un espai de dades diferent, el nostre enfocament, basat en anàlisi de discriminant lineal, permet que el procés de microagregació k-anònima s'adapti al domini d’aplicació de les dades. Per això, primer, les dades són rotades o projectades en la direcció de màxima discriminació i, segon, escalades en aquesta direcció, penalitzant la distorsió a través del llindar de classificació. Com a resultat, la utilitat de les dades es preserva en termes de la precisió dels models d'aprenentatge automàtic en diversos conjunts de dades. Posteriorment, proposem un mecanisme per reduir el temps d'execució per a la microagregació k-anònima. Això s'aconsegueix simplificant les operacions internes de l'algoritme escollit Mitjançant una extensa experimentació sobre diversos conjunts de dades, vam mostrar que el nou algoritme és bastant més ràpid. Aquesta acceleració s'aconsegueix sense que hi ha pèrdua en la utilitat de les dades. Finalment, en un enfocament més aplicat, es proposa una eina de protecció de privacitat d'individus i organitzacions mitjançant l'anonimització de dades sensibles inclosos en logs de seguretat. Es dissenyen diferents mecanismes d'anonimat per implementar-los en base a la definició d'una política de privacitat, en el context d'un projecte europeu que té per objectiu construir un sistema de seguretat unificat

Contribution to privacy-enhancing tecnologies for machine learning applications

For some time now, big data applications have been enabling revolutionary innovation in every aspect of our daily life by taking advantage of lots of data generated from the interactions of users with technology. Supported by machine learning and unprecedented computation capabilities, different entities are capable of efficiently exploiting such data to obtain significant utility. However, since personal information is involved, these practices raise serious privacy concerns. Although multiple privacy protection mechanisms have been proposed, there are some challenges that need to be addressed for these mechanisms to be adopted in practice, i.e., to be “usable” beyond the privacy guarantee offered. To start, the real impact of privacy protection mechanisms on data utility is not clear, thus an empirical evaluation of such impact is crucial. Moreover, since privacy is commonly obtained through the perturbation of large data sets, usable privacy technologies may require not only preservation of data utility but also efficient algorithms in terms of computation speed. Satisfying both requirements is key to encourage the adoption of privacy initiatives. Although considerable effort has been devoted to design less “destructive” privacy mechanisms, the utility metrics employed may not be appropriate, thus the wellness of such mechanisms would be incorrectly measured. On the other hand, despite the advent of big data, more efficient approaches are not being considered. Not complying with the requirements of current applications may hinder the adoption of privacy technologies. In the first part of this thesis, we address the problem of measuring the effect of k-anonymous microaggregation on the empirical utility of microdata. We quantify utility accordingly as the accuracy of classification models learned from microaggregated data, evaluated over original test data. Our experiments show that the impact of the de facto microaggregation standard on the performance of machine-learning algorithms is often minor for a variety of data sets. Furthermore, experimental evidence suggests that the traditional measure of distortion in the community of microdata anonymization may be inappropriate for evaluating the utility of microaggregated data. Secondly, we address the problem of preserving the empirical utility of data. By transforming the original data records to a different data space, our approach, based on linear discriminant analysis, enables k-anonymous microaggregation to be adapted to the application domain of data. To do this, first, data is rotated (projected) towards the direction of maximum discrimination and, second, scaled in this direction, penalizing distortion across the classification threshold. As a result, data utility is preserved in terms of the accuracy of machine learned models for a number of standardized data sets. Afterwards, we propose a mechanism to reduce the running time for the k-anonymous microaggregation algorithm. This is obtained by simplifying the internal operations of the original algorithm. Through extensive experimentation over multiple data sets, we show that the new algorithm gets significantly faster. Interestingly, this remarkable speedup factor is achieved with no additional loss of data utility.Les aplicacions de big data impulsen actualment una accelerada innovació aprofitant la gran quantitat d’informació generada a partir de les interaccions dels usuaris amb la tecnologia. Així, qualsevol entitat és capaç d'explotar eficientment les dades per obtenir utilitat, emprant aprenentatge automàtic i capacitats de còmput sense precedents. No obstant això, sorgeixen en aquest escenari serioses preocupacions pel que fa a la privacitat dels usuaris ja que hi ha informació personal involucrada. Tot i que s'han proposat diversos mecanismes de protecció, hi ha alguns reptes per a la seva adopció en la pràctica, és a dir perquè es puguin utilitzar. Per començar, l’impacte real d'aquests mecanismes en la utilitat de les dades no esta clar, raó per la qual la seva avaluació empírica és important. A més, considerant que actualment es manegen grans volums de dades, una privacitat usable requereix, no només preservació de la utilitat de les dades, sinó també algoritmes eficients en temes de temps de còmput. És clau satisfer tots dos requeriments per incentivar l’adopció de mesures de privacitat. Malgrat que hi ha diversos esforços per dissenyar mecanismes de privacitat menys "destructius", les mètriques d'utilitat emprades no serien apropiades, de manera que aquests mecanismes de protecció podrien estar sent incorrectament avaluats. D'altra banda, tot i l’adveniment del big data, la investigació existent no s’enfoca molt en millorar la seva eficiència. Lamentablement, si els requisits de les aplicacions actuals no es satisfan, s’obstaculitzarà l'adopció de tecnologies de privacitat. A la primera part d'aquesta tesi abordem el problema de mesurar l'impacte de la microagregació k-Gnónima en la utilitat empírica de microdades. Per això, quantifiquem la utilitat com la precisió de models de classificació obtinguts a partir de les dades microagregades. i avaluats sobre dades de prova originals. Els experiments mostren que l'impacte de l’algoritme de rmicroagregació estàndard en el rendiment d’algoritmes d'aprenentatge automàtic és usualment menor per a una varietat de conjunts de dades avaluats. A més, l’evidència experimental suggereix que la mètrica tradicional de distorsió de les dades seria inapropiada per avaluar la utilitat empírica de dades microagregades. Així també estudiem el problema de preservar la utilitat empírica de les dades a l'ésser anonimitzades. Transformant els registres originaIs de dades en un espai de dades diferent, el nostre enfocament, basat en anàlisi de discriminant lineal, permet que el procés de microagregació k-anònima s'adapti al domini d’aplicació de les dades. Per això, primer, les dades són rotades o projectades en la direcció de màxima discriminació i, segon, escalades en aquesta direcció, penalitzant la distorsió a través del llindar de classificació. Com a resultat, la utilitat de les dades es preserva en termes de la precisió dels models d'aprenentatge automàtic en diversos conjunts de dades. Posteriorment, proposem un mecanisme per reduir el temps d'execució per a la microagregació k-anònima. Això s'aconsegueix simplificant les operacions internes de l'algoritme escollit Mitjançant una extensa experimentació sobre diversos conjunts de dades, vam mostrar que el nou algoritme és bastant més ràpid. Aquesta acceleració s'aconsegueix sense que hi ha pèrdua en la utilitat de les dades. Finalment, en un enfocament més aplicat, es proposa una eina de protecció de privacitat d'individus i organitzacions mitjançant l'anonimització de dades sensibles inclosos en logs de seguretat. Es dissenyen diferents mecanismes d'anonimat per implementar-los en base a la definició d'una política de privacitat, en el context d'un projecte europeu que té per objectiu construir un sistema de seguretat unificat.Postprint (published version

Cybersecurity issues in software architectures for innovative services

The recent advances in data center development have been at the basis of the widespread success of the cloud computing paradigm, which is at the basis of models for software based applications and services, which is the "Everything as a Service" (XaaS) model. According to the XaaS model, service of any kind are deployed on demand as cloud based applications, with a great degree of flexibility and a limited need for investments in dedicated hardware and or software components. This approach opens up a lot of opportunities, for instance providing access to complex and widely distributed applications, whose cost and complexity represented in the past a significant entry barrier, also to small or emerging businesses. Unfortunately, networking is now embedded in every service and application, raising several cybersecurity issues related to corruption and leakage of data, unauthorized access, etc. However, new service-oriented architectures are emerging in this context, the so-called services enabler architecture. The aim of these architectures is not only to expose and give the resources to these types of services, but it is also to validate them. The validation includes numerous aspects, from the legal to the infrastructural ones e.g., but above all the cybersecurity threats. A solid threat analysis of the aforementioned architecture is therefore necessary, and this is the main goal of this thesis. This work investigate the security threats of the emerging service enabler architectures, providing proof of concepts for these issues and the solutions too, based on several use-cases implemented in real world scenarios

Exploiting Input Sanitization for Regex Denial of Service

Web services use server-side input sanitization to guard against harmful input. Some web services publish their sanitization logic to make their client interface more usable, e.g., allowing clients to debug invalid requests locally. However, this usability practice poses a security risk. Specifically, services may share the regexes they use to sanitize input strings — and regex-based denial of service (ReDoS) is an emerging threat. Although prominent service outages caused by ReDoS have spurred interest in this topic, we know little about the degree to which live web services are vulnerable to ReDoS. In this paper, we conduct the first black-box study measuring the extent of ReDoS vulnerabilities in live web services. We apply the Consistent Sanitization Assumption: that client-side sanitization logic, including regexes, is consistent with the sanitization logic on the server-side. We identify a service’s regex-based input sanitization in its HTML forms or its API, find vulnerable regexes among these regexes, craft ReDoS probes, and pinpoint vulnerabilities. We analyzed the HTML forms of 1,000 services and the APIs of 475 services. Of these, 355 services publish regexes; 17 services publish unsafe regexes; and 6 services are vulnerable to ReDoS through their APIs (6 domains; 15 subdomains). Both Microsoft and Amazon Web Services patched their web services as a result of our disclosure. Since these vulnerabilities were from API specifications, not HTML forms, we proposed a ReDoS defense for a popular API validation library, and our patch has been merged. To summarize: in client-visible sanitization logic, some web services advertise ReDoS vulnerabilities in plain sight. Our results motivate short-term patches and long-term fundamental solutions

Automatic privacy and utility evaluation of anonymized documents via deep learning

Text anonymization methods are evaluated by comparing their outputs with human-based anonymizations through standard information retrieval (IR) metrics. On the one hand, the residual disclosure risk is quantified with the recall metric, which gives the proportion of re-identifying terms successfully detected by the anonymization algorithm. On the other hand, the preserved utility is measured with the precision metric, which accounts the proportion of masked terms that were also annotated by the human experts. Nevertheless, because these evaluation metrics were meant for information retrieval rather than privacy-oriented tasks, they suffer from several drawbacks. First, they assume a unique ground truth, and this does not hold for text anonymization, where several masking choices could be equally valid to prevent re-identification. Second, annotation-based evaluation relies on human judgements, which are inherently subjective and may be prone to errors. Finally, both metrics weight terms uniformly, thereby ignoring the fact that the influence on the disclosure risk or on utility preservation of some terms may be much larger than of others. To overcome these drawbacks, in this thesis we propose two novel methods to evaluate both the disclosure risk and the utility preserved in anonymized texts. Our approach leverages deep learning methods to perform this evaluation automatically, thereby not requiring human annotations. For assessing disclosure risks, we propose using a re-identification attack, which we define as a multi-class classification task built on top of state-of-the art language models. To make it feasible, the attack has been designed to capture the means and computational resources expected to be available at the attacker's end. For utility assessment, we propose a method that measures the information loss incurred during the anonymization process, which relies on a neural masked language modeling. We illustrate the effectiveness of our methods by evaluating the disclosure risk and retained utility of several well-known techniques and tools for text anonymization on a common dataset. Empirical results show significant privacy risks for all of them (including manual anonymization) and consistently proportional utility preservation

Trading Indistinguishability-based Privacy and Utility of Complex Data

The collection and processing of complex data, like structured data or infinite streams, facilitates novel applications. At the same time, it raises privacy requirements by the data owners. Consequently, data administrators use privacy-enhancing technologies (PETs) to sanitize the data, that are frequently based on indistinguishability-based privacy definitions. Upon engineering PETs, a well-known challenge is the privacy-utility trade-off. Although literature is aware of a couple of trade-offs, there are still combinations of involved entities, privacy definition, type of data and application, in which we miss valuable trade-offs. In this thesis, for two important groups of applications processing complex data, we study (a) which indistinguishability-based privacy and utility requirements are relevant, (b) whether existing PETs solve the trade-off sufficiently, and (c) propose novel PETs extending the state-of-the-art substantially in terms of methodology, as well as achieved privacy or utility. Overall, we provide four contributions divided into two parts. In the first part, we study applications that analyze structured data with distance-based mining algorithms. We reveal that an essential utility requirement is the preservation of the pair-wise distances of the data items. Consequently, we propose distance-preserving encryption (DPE), together with a general procedure to engineer respective PETs by leveraging existing encryption schemes. As proof of concept, we apply it to SQL log mining, useful for database performance tuning. In the second part, we study applications that monitor query results over infinite streams. To this end, -event differential privacy is state-of-the-art. Here, PETs use mechanisms that typically add noise to query results. First, we study state-of-the-art mechanisms with respect to the utility they provide. Conducting the so far largest benchmark that fulfills requirements derived from limitations of prior experimental studies, we contribute new insights into the strengths and weaknesses of existing mechanisms. One of the most unexpected, yet explainable result, is a baseline supremacy. It states that one of the two baseline mechanisms delivers high or even the best utility. A natural follow-up question is whether baseline mechanisms already provide reasonable utility. So, second, we perform a case study from the area of electricity grid monitoring revealing two results. First, achieving reasonable utility is only possible under weak privacy requirements. Second, the utility measured with application-specific utility metrics decreases faster than the sanitization error, that is used as utility metric in most studies, suggests. As a third contribution, we propose a novel differential privacy-based privacy definition called Swellfish privacy. It allows tuning utility beyond incremental -event mechanism design by supporting time-dependent privacy requirements. Formally, as well as by experiments, we prove that it increases utility significantly. In total, our thesis contributes substantially to the research field, and reveals directions for future research