Real-time and fault tolerance in distributed control software

Closed loop control systems typically contain multitude of spatially distributed sensors and actuators operated simultaneously. So those systems are parallel and distributed in their essence. But mapping this parallelism onto the given distributed hardware architecture, brings in some additional requirements: safe multithreading, optimal process allocation, real-time scheduling of bus and network resources. Nowadays, fault tolerance methods and fast even online reconfiguration are becoming increasingly important. All those often conflicting requirements, make design and implementation of real-time distributed control systems an extremely difficult task, that requires substantial knowledge in several areas of control and computer science. Although many design methods have been proposed so far, none of them had succeeded to cover all important aspects of the problem at hand. [1] Continuous increase of production in embedded market, makes a simple and natural design methodology for real-time systems needed more then ever

Dynamic Loop Scheduling Using MPI Passive-Target Remote Memory Access

Scientific applications often contain large computationally-intensive parallel loops. Loop scheduling techniques aim to achieve load balanced executions of such applications. For distributed-memory systems, existing dynamic loop scheduling (DLS) libraries are typically MPI-based, and employ a master-worker execution model to assign variably-sized chunks of loop iterations. The master-worker execution model may adversely impact performance due to the master-level contention. This work proposes a distributed chunk-calculation approach that does not require the master-worker execution scheme. Moreover, it considers the novel features in the latest MPI standards, such as passive-target remote memory access, shared-memory window creation, and atomic read-modify-write operations. To evaluate the proposed approach, five well-known DLS techniques, two applications, and two heterogeneous hardware setups have been considered. The DLS techniques implemented using the proposed approach outperformed their counterparts implemented using the traditional master-worker execution model

Loop Coalescing and Scheduling for Barrier MIMD Architectures

Barrier MIMDs are asynchronous Multiple Instruction stream Multiple Data stream architectures capable of parallel execution of variable execution time instructions and arbitrary control flow (e.g., while loops and calls); however, they differ from conventional MlMDs in that the need for run-time synchronization is significantly reduced. This work considers the problem of scheduling nested loop structures on a barrier MIMD. The basic approach employs loop coalescing, a technique for transforming a multiply-nested loop into a single loop. Loop coalescing is extended to nested triangular loops, in which inner loop bounds are functions of outer loop indices. Also, a more efficient scheme to generate the original loop indices from the coalesced index is proposed for the case of constant loop bounds. These results are general, and can be applied to extend previous work using loop coalescing techniques. We concentrate on using loop coalescing for scheduling barrier MIMDs, and show how previous work in loop transformations [Wol89], [Pol88] and linear scheduling theory [ShF88], rShO901 cart be applied to this problem

Enhancing Productivity and Performance Portability of General-Purpose Parallel Programming

This work focuses on compiler and run-time techniques for improving the productivity and the performance portability of general-purpose parallel programming. More specifically, we focus on shared-memory task-parallel languages, where the programmer explicitly exposes parallelism in the form of short tasks that may outnumber the cores by orders of magnitude. The compiler, the run-time, and the platform (henceforth the system) are responsible for harnessing this unpredictable amount of parallelism, which can vary from none to excessive, towards efficient execution. The challenge arises from the aspiration to support fine-grained irregular computations and nested parallelism. This work is even more ambitious by also aspiring to lay the foundations to efficiently support declarative code, where the programmer exposes all available parallelism, using high-level language constructs such as parallel loops, reducers or futures. The appeal of declarative code is twofold for general-purpose programming: it is often easier for the programmer who does not have to worry about the granularity of the exposed parallelism, and it achieves better performance portability by avoiding overfitting to a small range of platforms and inputs for which the programmer is coarsening. Furthermore, PRAM algorithms, an important class of parallel algorithms, naturally lend themselves to declarative programming, so supporting it is a necessary condition for capitalizing on the wealth of the PRAM theory. Unfortunately, declarative codes often expose such an overwhelming number of fine-grained tasks that existing systems fail to deliver performance. Our contributions can be partitioned into three components. First, we tackle the issue of coarsening, which declarative code leaves to the system. We identify two goals of coarsening and advocate tackling them separately, using static compiler transformations for one and dynamic run-time approaches for the other. Additionally, we present evidence that the current practice of burdening the programmer with coarsening either leads to codes with poor performance-portability, or to a significantly increased programming effort. This is a ``show-stopper'' for general-purpose programming. To compare the performance portability among approaches, we define an experimental framework and two metrics, and we demonstrate that our approaches are preferable. We close the chapter on coarsening by presenting compiler transformations that automatically coarsen some types of very fine-grained codes. Second, we propose Lazy Scheduling, an innovative run-time scheduling technique that infers the platform load at run-time, using information already maintained. Based on the inferred load, Lazy Scheduling adapts the amount of available parallelism it exposes for parallel execution and, thus, saves parallelism overheads that existing approaches pay. We implement Lazy Scheduling and present experimental results on four different platforms. The results show that Lazy Scheduling is vastly superior for declarative codes and competitive, if not better, for coarsened codes. Moreover, Lazy Scheduling is also superior in terms of performance-portability, supporting our thesis that it is possible to achieve reasonable efficiency and performance portability with declarative codes. Finally, we also implement Lazy Scheduling on XMT, an experimental manycore platform developed at the University of Maryland, which was designed to support codes derived from PRAM algorithms. On XMT, we manage to harness the existing hardware support for scheduling flat parallelism to compose it with Lazy Scheduling, which supports nested parallelism. In the resulting hybrid scheduler, the hardware and software work in synergy to overcome each other's weaknesses. We show the performance composability of the hardware and software schedulers, both in an abstract cost model and experimentally, as the hybrid always performs better than the software scheduler alone. Furthermore, the cost model is validated by using it to predict if it is preferable to execute a code sequentially, with outer parallelism, or with nested parallelism, depending on the input, the available hardware parallelism and the calling context of the parallel code

Exploiting iteration-level parallelism in declarative programs

In order to achieve viable parallel processing three basic criteria must be met: (1) the system must provide a programming environment which hides the details of parallel processing from the programmer; (2) the system must execute efficiently on the given hardware; and (3) the system must be economically attractive.The first criterion can be met by providing the programmer with an implicit rather than explicit programming paradigm. In this way ali of the synchronization and distribution are handled automatically. To meet the second criterion, the system must perform synchronization and distribution in such a way that the available computing resources are used to their utmost. And to meet the third criterion, the system must not require esoteric or expensive hardware to achieve efficient utilization.This dissertation reports on the Process-Oriented Dataflow System (PODS), which meets all of the above criteria. PODS uses a hybrid von Neumann-Dataflow model of computation supported by an automatic partitioning and distribution scheme. The new partitioning and distribution algorithm is presented along with the underlying principles. Four new mechanisms for distribution are presented: (1) a distributed array allocation operator for data distribution; (2) a distributed L operator for code distribution; (3) a range filter for restriction index ranges for different PEs; and (4) a specialized apply operator for functional parallelism.Simulations show that PODS balances communication overhead with distributed processing to achieve efficient parallel execution on distributed memory multiprocessors. This is partially due to a new software array caching scheme, called remote caching, which greatly reduces the amount of remote memory reads. PODS is designed to use off-the-shelf components, with no specialized hardware. In this way a real PODS machine can be built quickly and cost effectively. The system is currently being retargeted to the Intel iPSC/2 so that it can be run on commercially available equipment

Automatic Parallelization of Database Queries

Although automatic parallelization of conventional language programs is now widely accepted, relatively little emphasis has been placed on automatic parallelization of database query programs (sometimes referred to as “multiple queries” ). In this paper, we discuss the unique problems associated with automatic parallelization of database programs. From this discussion, we derive a complete approach to automatic parallelization of database programs. Beside integrating a number of existing techniques, our approach relies heavily on several new concepts, including the concepts of “algorithm-level” analysis and hybrid static/dynamic scheduling

Hardware Barrier Synchronization: Static Barrier MIMD (SBM)

In this paper, we give the design, and performance analysis, of a new, highly efficient, synchronization mechanism called “Static Barrier MIMD” or “SBM.” Unlike traditional barrier synchronization, the proposed barriers are designed to facilitate the use of static (compile-time) code scheduling for eliminating some synchronizations. For this reason, our barrier hardware is more general than most hardware barrier mechanisms, allowing any subset of the processors to participate in each barrier. Since code scheduling typically operates on fine-grain parallelism, it is also vital that barriers be able to execute in a small number of clock ticks. The SBM is actually only one of two new classes of barrier machines proposed to facilitate static code scheduling; the other architecture is the “Dynamic Barrier MIMD,” or “DBM,” which is described in a companion paper1. The DBM differs from the SBM in that the DBM employs more complex hardware to make the system less dependent on the precision of the static analysis and code scheduling; for example, an SBM cannot efficiently manage simultaneous execution of independent parallel programs, whereas a DBM can

Exploiting iteration-level parallelism in dataflow programs

The term "dataflow" generally encompasses three distinct aspects of computation - a data-driven model of computation, a functional/declarative programming language, and a special-purpose multiprocessor architecture. In this paper we decouple the language and architecture issues by demonstrating that declarative programming is a suitable vehicle for the programming of conventional distributed-memory multiprocessors.This is achieved by appling several transformations to the compiled declarative program to achieve iteration-level (rather than instruction-level) parallelism. The transformations first group individual instructions into sequential light-weight processes, and then insert primitives to: (1) cause array allocation to be distributed over multiple processors, (2) cause computation to follow the data distribution by inserting an index filtering mechanism into a given loop and spawning a copy of it on all PEs; the filter causes each instance of that loop to operate on a different subrange of the index variable.The underlying model of computation is a dataflow/von Neumann hybrid in that exection within a process is control-driven while the creation, blocking, and activation of processes is data-driven.The performance of this process-oriented dataflow system (PODS) is demonstrated using the hydrodynamics simulation benchmark called SIMPLE, where a 19-fold speedup on a 32-processor architecture has been achieved

Tiling Optimization For Nested Loops On Gpus

Optimizing nested loops has been considered as an important topic and widely studied in parallel programming. With the development of GPU architectures, the performance of these computations can be significantly boosted with the massively parallel hardware. General matrix-matrix multiplication is a typical example where executing such an algorithm on GPUs outperforms the performance obtained on other multicore CPUs. However, achieving ideal performance on GPUs usually requires a lot of human effort to manage the massively parallel computation resources. Therefore, the efficient implementation of optimizing nested loops on GPUs became a popular topic in recent years. We present our work based on the tiling strategy in this dissertation to address three kinds of popular problems. Different kinds of computations bring in different latency issues where dependencies in the computation may result in insufficient parallelism and the performance of computations without dependencies may be degraded due to intensive memory accesses. In this thesis, we tackle the challenges for each kind of problem and believe that other computations performed in nested loops can also benefit from the presented techniques. We improve a parallel approximation algorithm for the problem of scheduling jobs on parallel identical machines to minimize makespan with a high-dimensional tiling method. The algorithm is designed and optimized for solving this kind of problem efficiently on GPUs. Because the algorithm is based on a higher-dimensional dynamic programming approach, where dimensionality refers to the number of variables in the dynamic programming equation characterizing the problem, the existing implementation suffers from the pain of dimensionality and cannot fully utilize GPU resources. We design a novel data-partitioning technique to accelerate the higher-dimensional dynamic programming component of the algorithm. Both the load imbalance and exceeding memory capacity issues are addressed in our GPU solution. We present performance results to demonstrate how our proposed design improves the GPU utilization and makes it possible to solve large higher-dimensional dynamic programming problems within the limited GPU memory. Experimental results show that the GPU implementation achieves up to 25X speedup compared to the best existing OpenMP implementation. In addition, we focus on optimizing wavefront parallelism on GPUs. Wavefront parallelism is a well-known technique for exploiting the concurrency of applications that execute nested loops with uniform data dependencies. Recent research on such applications, which range from sequence alignment tools to partial differential equation solvers, has used GPUs to benefit from the massively parallel computing resources. Wavefront parallelism faces the load imbalance issue because the parallelism is passing along the diagonal. The tiling method has been introduced as a popular solution to address this issue. However, the use of hyperplane tiles increases the cost of synchronization and leads to poor data locality. In this paper, we present a highly optimized implementation of the wavefront parallelism technique that harnesses the GPU architecture. A balanced workload and maximum resource utilization are achieved with an extremely low synchronization overhead. We design the kernel configuration to significantly reduce the minimum number of synchronizations required and also introduce an inter-block lock to minimize the overhead of each synchronization. We evaluate the performance of our proposed technique for four different applications: Sequence Alignment, Edit Distance, Summed-Area Table, and 2DSOR. The performance results demonstrate that our method achieves speedups of up to six times compared to the previous best-known hyperplane tiling-based GPU implementation. Finally, we extend the hyperplane tiling to high order 2D stencil computations. Unlike wavefront parallelism that has dependence in the spatial dimension, dependence remains only across two adjacent time steps along the temporal dimension in stencil computations. Even if the no-dependence property significantly increases the parallelism obtained in the spatial dimensions, full parallelism may not be efficient on GPUs. Due to the limited cache capacity owned by each streaming multiprocessor, full parallelism can be obtained on global memory only, which has high latency to access. Therefore, the tiling technique can be applied to improve the memory efficiency by caching the small tiled blocks. Because the widely studied tiling methods, like overlapped tiling and split tiling, have considerable computation overhead caused by load imbalance or extra operations, we propose a time skewed tiling method, which is designed upon the GPU architecture. We work around the serialized computation issue and coordinate the intra-tile parallelism and inter-tile parallelism to minimize the load imbalance caused by pipelined processing. Moreover, we address the high-order stencil computations in our development, which has not been comprehensively studied. The proposed method achieves up to 3.5X performance improvement when the stencil computation is performed on a Moore neighborhood pattern