The CLEAR 2007 Evaluation

Abstract. This paper is a summary of the 2007 CLEAR Evaluation on the Classification of Events, Activities, and Relationships which took place in early 2007 and culminated with a two-day workshop held in May 2007. CLEAR is an international effort to evaluate systems for the perception of people, their activities, and interactions. In its second year, CLEAR has developed a following from the computer vision and speech communities, spawning a more multimodal perspective of research eval-uation. This paper describes the evaluation tasks, including metrics and databases used, and discusses the results achieved. The CLEAR 2007 tasks comprise person, face, and vehicle tracking, head pose estimation, as well as acoustic scene analysis. These include subtasks performed in the visual, acoustic and audio-visual domains for meeting room and surveillance data.

Audiovisual head orientation estimation with particle filtering in multisensor scenarios

This article presents a multimodal approach to head pose estimation of individuals in environments equipped with multiple cameras and microphones, such as SmartRooms or automatic video conferencing. Determining the individuals head orientation is the basis for many forms of more sophisticated interactions between humans and technical devices and can also be used for automatic sensor selection (camera, microphone) in communications or video surveillance systems. The use of particle filters as a unified framework for the estimation of the head orientation for both monomodal and multimodal cases is proposed. In video, we estimate head orientation from color information by exploiting spatial redundancy among cameras. Audio information is processed to estimate the direction of the voice produced by a speaker making use of the directivity characteristics of the head radiation pattern. Furthermore, two different particle filter multimodal information fusion schemes for combining the audio and video streams are analyzed in terms of accuracy and robustness. In the first one, fusion is performed at a decision level by combining each monomodal head pose estimation, while the second one uses a joint estimation system combining information at data level. Experimental results conducted over the CLEAR 2006 evaluation database are reported and the comparison of the proposed multimodal head pose estimation algorithms with the reference monomodal approaches proves the effectiveness of the proposed approach.Postprint (published version

Multi-speaker tracking from an audio-visual sensing device

Compact multi-sensor platforms are portable and thus desirable for robotics and personal-assistance tasks. However, compared to physically distributed sensors, the size of these platforms makes person tracking more difficult. To address this challenge, we propose a novel 3D audio-visual people tracker that exploits visual observations (object detections) to guide the acoustic processing by constraining the acoustic likelihood on the horizontal plane defined by the predicted height of a speaker. This solution allows the tracker to estimate, with a small microphone array, the distance of a sound. Moreover, we apply a color-based visual likelihood on the image plane to compensate for misdetections. Finally, we use a 3D particle filter and greedy data association to combine visual observations, color-based and acoustic likelihoods to track the position of multiple simultaneous speakers. We compare the proposed multimodal 3D tracker against two state-of-the-art methods on the AV16.3 dataset and on a newly collected dataset with co-located sensors, which we make available to the research community. Experimental results show that our multimodal approach outperforms the other methods both in 3D and on the image plane

Multimodal Probabilistic Person Tracking and Identification in Smart Spaces

In this thesis, a new methodology is introduced for the multimodal tracking and identification of multiple persons by seeking and integrating reliable ID cues whenever they become observable. The method opportunistically integrates person-specific identification cues that can only sparsely be observed for each person over time and keeps track of the location of identified persons while ID cues are not available

Face pose estimation in monocular images

People use orientation of their faces to convey rich, inter-personal information. For example, a person will direct his face to indicate who the intended target of the conversation is. Similarly in a conversation, face orientation is a non-verbal cue to listener when to switch role and start speaking, and a nod indicates that a person has understands, or agrees with, what is being said. Further more, face pose estimation plays an important role in human-computer interaction, virtual reality applications, human behaviour analysis, pose-independent face recognition, driver s vigilance assessment, gaze estimation, etc. Robust face recognition has been a focus of research in computer vision community for more than two decades. Although substantial research has been done and numerous methods have been proposed for face recognition, there remain challenges in this field. One of these is face recognition under varying poses and that is why face pose estimation is still an important research area. In computer vision, face pose estimation is the process of inferring the face orientation from digital imagery. It requires a serious of image processing steps to transform a pixel-based representation of a human face into a high-level concept of direction. An ideal face pose estimator should be invariant to a variety of image-changing factors such as camera distortion, lighting condition, skin colour, projective geometry, facial hairs, facial expressions, presence of accessories like glasses and hats, etc. Face pose estimation has been a focus of research for about two decades and numerous research contributions have been presented in this field. Face pose estimation techniques in literature have still some shortcomings and limitations in terms of accuracy, applicability to monocular images, being autonomous, identity and lighting variations, image resolution variations, range of face motion, computational expense, presence of facial hairs, presence of accessories like glasses and hats, etc. These shortcomings of existing face pose estimation techniques motivated the research work presented in this thesis. The main focus of this research is to design and develop novel face pose estimation algorithms that improve automatic face pose estimation in terms of processing time, computational expense, and invariance to different conditions

Camera-based estimation of student's attention in class

Two essential elements of classroom lecturing are the teacher and the students. This human core can easily be lost in the overwhelming list of technological supplements aimed at improving the teaching/learning experience. We start from the question of whether we can formulate a technological intervention around the human connection, and find indicators which would tell us when the teacher is not reaching the audience. Our approach is based on principles of unobtrusive measurements and social signal processing. Our assumption is that students with different levels of attention will display different non-verbal behaviour during the lecture. Inspired by information theory, we formulated a theoretical background for our assumptions around the idea of synchronization between the sender and receiver, and between several receivers focused on the same sender. Based on this foundation we present a novel set of behaviour metrics as the main contribution. By using a camera-based system to observe lectures, we recorded an extensive dataset in order to verify our assumptions. In our first study on motion, we found that differences in attention are manifested on the level of audience movement synchronization. We formulated the measure of ``motion lag'' based on the idea that attentive students would have a common behaviour pattern. For our second set of metrics we explored ways to substitute intrusive eye-tracking equipment in order to record gaze information of the entire audience. To achieve this we conducted an experiment on the relationship between head orientation and gaze direction. Based on acquired results we formulated an improved model of gaze uncertainty than the ones currently used in similar studies. In combination with improvements on head detection and pose estimation, we extracted measures of audience head and gaze behaviour from our remote recording system. From the collected data we found that synchronization between student's head orientation and teacher's motion serves as a reliable indicator of the attentiveness of students. To illustrate the predictive power of our features, a supervised-learning model was trained achieving satisfactory results at predicting student's attention

Acoustic event detection and localization using distributed microphone arrays

Automatic acoustic scene analysis is a complex task that involves several functionalities: detection (time), localization (space), separation, recognition, etc. This thesis focuses on both acoustic event detection (AED) and acoustic source localization (ASL), when several sources may be simultaneously present in a room. In particular, the experimentation work is carried out with a meeting-room scenario. Unlike previous works that either employed models of all possible sound combinations or additionally used video signals, in this thesis, the time overlapping sound problem is tackled by exploiting the signal diversity that results from the usage of multiple microphone array beamformers. The core of this thesis work is a rather computationally efficient approach that consists of three processing stages. In the first, a set of (null) steering beamformers is used to carry out diverse partial signal separations, by using multiple arbitrarily located linear microphone arrays, each of them composed of a small number of microphones. In the second stage, each of the beamformer output goes through a classification step, which uses models for all the targeted sound classes (HMM-GMM, in the experiments). Then, in a third stage, the classifier scores, either being intra- or inter-array, are combined using a probabilistic criterion (like MAP) or a machine learning fusion technique (fuzzy integral (FI), in the experiments). The above-mentioned processing scheme is applied in this thesis to a set of complexity-increasing problems, which are defined by the assumptions made regarding identities (plus time endpoints) and/or positions of sounds. In fact, the thesis report starts with the problem of unambiguously mapping the identities to the positions, continues with AED (positions assumed) and ASL (identities assumed), and ends with the integration of AED and ASL in a single system, which does not need any assumption about identities or positions. The evaluation experiments are carried out in a meeting-room scenario, where two sources are temporally overlapped; one of them is always speech and the other is an acoustic event from a pre-defined set. Two different databases are used, one that is produced by merging signals actually recorded in the UPC¿s department smart-room, and the other consists of overlapping sound signals directly recorded in the same room and in a rather spontaneous way. From the experimental results with a single array, it can be observed that the proposed detection system performs better than either the model based system or a blind source separation based system. Moreover, the product rule based combination and the FI based fusion of the scores resulting from the multiple arrays improve the accuracies further. On the other hand, the posterior position assignment is performed with a very small error rate. Regarding ASL and assuming an accurate AED system output, the 1-source localization performance of the proposed system is slightly better than that of the widely-used SRP-PHAT system, working in an event-based mode, and it even performs significantly better than the latter one in the more complex 2-source scenario. Finally, though the joint system suffers from a slight degradation in terms of classification accuracy with respect to the case where the source positions are known, it shows the advantage of carrying out the two tasks, recognition and localization, with a single system, and it allows the inclusion of information about the prior probabilities of the source positions. It is worth noticing also that, although the acoustic scenario used for experimentation is rather limited, the approach and its formalism were developed for a general case, where the number and identities of sources are not constrained