41 research outputs found
Polarization in the land distribution, land use and land cover change in the Amazon
O objetivo deste artigo é apresentar a polarização da estrutura fundiária como uma expressão mais completa das dinâmicas fundiárias, do uso-cobertura da terra e, consequentemente, do meio rural na Amazônia do que modelos explicativos que enfatizam o êxodo rural e a consolidação de grandes estabelecimentos agropecuários. Os dados foram coletados em levantamento realizado no entorno de Santarém-PA, em 2003, nos locais de 587 lotes rurais selecionados aleatoriamente por amostragem estratificada de 5.086 lotes existentes em mapas da década de 1970. O georreferenciamento permitiu comparar a estrutura fundiária nos dois momentos e relacionar variáveis sociodemográficas e biofísicas dos estabelecimentos encontrados. Detectou-se concentração fundiária, corroborando o documentado por outros autores em outras porções da Amazônia. No entanto, a perspectiva adotada revela que a variação na estrutura fundiária não se limitou ao aparecimento de estabelecimentos maiores, com 200 hectares ou mais, mas se deu também pela divisão dos lotes originais em estabelecimentos com menos de cinco hectares, muitos das quais sem uso agropecuário, em contrapartida à redução de estabelecimentos entre cinco e 200 ha. As especificidades de cada grupo de estabelecimentos com relação ao uso-cobertura da terra e a distribuição da população chamam a atenção para a necessidade de se buscar modelos explicativos - seja da perspectiva socioeconômica, demográfica ou ambiental - que não se fixem exclusivamente em um único processo, grupo de pessoas ou de estabelecimentos.The objective of this article is to present Polarization of Agrarian Structure as a single, more complete representation than models emphasizing rural exodus and consolidation of land into large agropastoral enterprises of the dynamics of changing land distribution, land use / cover, and thus the rural milieu of Amazonia. Data were collected in 2003 using social surveys on a sample of 587 lots randomly selected from among 5,086 lots on a cadastral map produced in the 1970s. Georeferencing of current property boundaries in the location of these previously demarcated lots allows us to relate sociodemographic and biophysical variables of the surveyed properties to the changes in boundaries that have occurred since the 1970s. As have other authors in other Amazonian regions, we found concentration of land ownership into larger properties. The approach we took, however, showed that changes in the distribution of land ownership is not limited to the appearance of larger properties, those with 200 ha or more; there also exists substantial division of earlier lots into properties with fewer than five hectares, many without any agropastoral use. These two trends are juxtaposed against the decline in establishments with between five and 200 ha. The variation across groups in land use / land cover and population distribution shows the necessity of developing conceptual models, whether from socioeconomic, demographic or environmental perspectives, look beyond a single group of people or properties
Enforcement Evasion Highlights Need for Better Satellite‐Based Forest Governance
Our recent article, “Are Brazil’s Deforesters Avoiding Detection?” demonstrated that focusing illegal deforestation enforcement on the subset of forest monitored by the flagship PRODES system has caused PRODES to capture a declining share of deforestation in the Brazilian Amazon. Deforesters may be purposively seeking out forests not monitored for enforcement. Addressing the problem would help Brazil maintain a cutting‐edge forest governance model worthy of transfer to other nations. Two commentaries questioned our decision to investigate solely PRODES and not additional government monitoring systems. We focused on PRODES because it is the most salient deforestation monitoring system. Other key deforestation monitoring systems are all either limited to the same monitoring footprint as PRODES, not used for enforcement, or are rarely used for measuring forest loss in the Brazilian Amazon. We do agree with the commentaries that Brazil’s new satellite monitoring protocol for greenhouse gas emissions estimation is critical progress of the type we were advocating in our original article.Peer Reviewedhttps://deepblue.lib.umich.edu/bitstream/2027.42/138285/1/conl12379_am.pdfhttps://deepblue.lib.umich.edu/bitstream/2027.42/138285/2/conl12379.pd
Recent cropping frequency, expansion, and abandonment in Mato Grosso, Brazil had selective land characteristics
This letter uses satellite remote sensing to examine patterns of cropland expansion, cropland abandonment, and changing cropping frequency in Mato Grosso, Brazil from 2001 to 2011. During this period, Mato Grosso emerged as a globally important center of agricultural production. In 2001, 3.3 million hectares of mechanized agriculture were cultivated in Mato Grosso, of which 500 000 hectares had two commercial crops per growing season (double cropping). By 2011, Mato Grosso had 5.8 million hectares of mechanized agriculture, of which 2.9 million hectares were double cropped. We found these agricultural changes to be selective with respect to land attributes —significant differences (p \u3c 0.001) existed between the land attributes of agriculture versus nonagriculture, single cropping versus double cropping, and expansion versus abandonment. Many of the land attributes (elevation, slope, maximum temperature, minimum temperature, initial soy transport costs, and soil) that were associated with an increased likelihood of expansion were associated with a decreased likelihood of abandonment (p \u3c 0.001). While land similar to agriculture and double cropping in 2001 was much more likely to be developed for agriculture than all other land, new cropland shifted to hotter, drier, lower locations that were more isolated from agricultural infrastructure (p \u3c 0.001). The scarcity of high quality remaining agricultural land available for agricultural expansion in Mato Grosso could be contributing to the slowdown in agricultural expansion observed there over 2006 to 2011. Land use policy analyses should control for land scarcity constraints on agricultural expansion
Minha vida é andar por esse país...: a emigração recente no semiárido setentrional, políticas sociais e meio ambiente
Biofuels: Environmental Consequences and Interactions with Changing Land Use: Chapter 12
The International SCOPE Biofuels Project gratefully acknowledges support from the United Nations Foundation, Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft, the David & Lucile Packard Foundation, UNEP, the Cornell Center for a Sustainable Future, the Biogeochemistry & Biocomplexity Initiative at Cornell University, an endowment provided to Cornell University by David R. Atkinson, and the Wuppertal Institute for Climate, Environment, and Energy
A Second Act in Rural Migration in Western Pará: Rural Out-Migration and the Legacy of Amazon Colonization
In this research we consider rural out-migration from two study sites in western Pará in the Amazon Basin. Here we argue that out-migration is strongly influenced by historical context, and by the legacy institutions associated with each site’s period of colonization. We support our argument with longitudinal survey data collected from the rural surroundings of Altamira and Santarém. Our data suggest that rural out-migration is significantly higher from Altamira, the more recently colonized study site. They also indicate that measures of wealth, including access to cattle, property, and housing, artifacts of the institutional periods under which the two study sites were first founded, now exhibit highly divergent influences on migration decisions. We then argue that the varying institutional and historical contexts that once shaped in-migration into the eastern Amazon Basin are now reshaping present day out-migration from the region
Polarization in the land distribution, land use and land cover change in the Amazon
In this paper a method for increasing the resolution of census data is tested and presented, by aggregating the data onto a regular grid. The methodology consists of (1) the aggregation of households, represented by their geographical coordinates obtained by the 2007 Population Count, carried out by the Brazilian Census Office (IBGE) and, (2) the unbundling of the data by census tracts on the basis of proportionality. The grids obtained were used to estimate the resident population of 114 conservation units in Brazilian Legal Amazon, all of them instituted in or before 2006. The intention was to test this methodology on territorial units that follow neither the official political-administrative boundaries of states and cities, nor the boundaries designed by IBGE for collecting data. The methodology also contributes to the study of populations living in protected areas, due to the scarcity of population estimates in the conservation units. The results showed a population of 325,398 inhabitants in the selected units, 297,693 of whom were in units for Sustainable Use and 27,705 in Permanent Protection units. Adjoining areas have an estimated joint population of 1,020,237. Despite the limitations involved in using the 2007 Population Count, the aggregating of data into grids would seem to be a promising methodology in view of the improvements in IBGE's use of geotechnology. The grid minimizes problems that come up in the use of administrative units or census data and may represent an approach that can be applied usefully in demography and other areas of knowledge.O objetivo deste artigo é apresentar a polarização da estrutura fundiária como uma expressão mais completa das dinâmicas fundiárias, do uso-cobertura da terra e, consequentemente, do meio rural na Amazônia do que modelos explicativos que enfatizam o êxodo rural e a consolidação de grandes estabelecimentos agropecuários. Os dados foram coletados em levantamento realizado no entorno de Santarém-PA, em 2003, nos locais de 587 lotes rurais selecionados aleatoriamente por amostragem estratificada de 5.086 lotes existentes em mapas da década de 1970. O georreferenciamento permitiu comparar a estrutura fundiária nos dois momentos e relacionar variáveis sociodemográficas e biofísicas dos estabelecimentos encontrados. Detectou-se concentração fundiária, corroborando o documentado por outros autores em outras porções da Amazônia. No entanto, a perspectiva adotada revela que a variação na estrutura fundiária não se limitou ao aparecimento de estabelecimentos maiores, com 200 hectares ou mais, mas se deu também pela divisão dos lotes originais em estabelecimentos com menos de cinco hectares, muitos das quais sem uso agropecuário, em contrapartida à redução de estabelecimentos entre cinco e 200 ha. As especificidades de cada grupo de estabelecimentos com relação ao uso-cobertura da terra e a distribuição da população chamam a atenção para a necessidade de se buscar modelos explicativos – seja da perspectiva socioeconômica, demográfica ou ambiental – que não se fixem exclusivamente em um único processo, grupo de pessoas ou de estabelecimentos.412223232Amaral, S., Monteiro, A.M.V., Camara, G., Quintanilha, J.A., Estimativa da distribuição espacial da população na Amazônia brasileira com o uso de sensoriamento remoto orbital: Contribuições das imagens CCD/CBERS no caso do município de Marabá-PA (2005) Anais, pp. 765-773. , In: XII SIMPÓSIO BRASILEIRO DE SENSORIAMENTO REMOTO, 2005, Goiânia. São José dos Campos: InpeBacker, L., The geostat project: Part of an international effort to build an IISS? (2008) Anais, , In: EUROPEAN FORUM FOR GEOSTATISTICS WORKSHOP, 2008, Bled, SloveniaBenatti, J., Unidades de conservação e as populações tradicionais: Uma análise jurídica da realidade brasileira (1999) Novos Cadernos NAEA, 2 (2). , Pará, dez(1967) Autoriza o Poder Executivo a instituir a Fundação Instituto Brasileiro de Geografia e Estatística e dá outras providências., , BRASIL. Decreto Lei n. 161, de 13 de fevereiro de 1967. Brasília(1968) Dispõe sobre a obrigatoriedade de prestação de informações estatísticas e dá outras providências., , BRASIL. Lei n. 5.534, de 14 de novembro de 1968. Brasília(2000) Institui o Sistema Nacional de Unidades de Conservação da Natureza do Brasil (SNUC)., , BRASIL. Lei no 9.985, de 18 de julho de 2000. Brasília(2002) Regulamenta artigos da Lei n. 9.985, de 18 de julho de 2000, que dispõe sobre o Sistema Nacional de Unidades de Conservação da Natureza-SNUC, e dá outras providências., , BRASIL. Decreto no 4.340, de 22 de agosto de 2002. Brasília(2007) Institui a Política Nacional de Desenvolvimento Sustentável dos Povos e Comunidades Tradicionais., , BRASIL. Decreto no 6.040, de 7 de fevereiro de 2007. BrasíliaConama-Conselho Nacional do Meio Ambiente (1990) Resolução n. 013, , BRASIL. de 06/12/1990. Dispõe sobre a área circundante, num raio de 10 (dez) quilômetros, das Unidades de Conservação. BrasíliaConama-Conselho Nacional do Meio Ambiente (2010) Resolução n. 428, , BRASIL. de 17/12/2010. Dispõe, no âmbito do licenciamento ambiental sobre a autorização do órgão responsável pela administração da Unidade de Conservação (UC), de que trata o § 3o do artigo 36 da Lei n. 9.985 de 18 de julho de 2000, bem como sobre a ciência do órgão responsável pela administração da UC no caso de licenciamento ambiental de empreendimentos não sujeitos a EIA-RIMA e dá outras providências. BrasíliaCadastro Nacional de Unidades de Conservação, , http://www.mma.gov.br/sitio/index.php?ido=conteudo.monta&idEstrutura=119, BRASIL. Ministério do Meio Ambiente. S.d. Disponível em: Acesso em: 20 dez. 2011Bueno, M.C.D., Dagnino, R., População em unidades de conservação da Amazônia Legal: Estimativas a partir da Contagem Populacional 2007 (2011) Dinâmicas demográficas e ambiente, pp. 85-103. , In: D'Antona, A. O.CARMO, R. L. (Orgs.). Campinas: Nepo/UnicampDa Carneiro Cunha, M., Almeida, M., Populações tradicionais e conservação ambiental (2009) Cultura com aspas, pp. 277-300. , In: CARNEIRO DA CUNHA, M. Cosac NaifyCoelho, M., Cunha, L., Monteiro, M., Unidades de conservação: Populações, recursos e territórios. Abordagens da geografia e da ecologia política (2009) Unidades de conservação: Abordagens e características geográficas, , In: GUERRA, A.COELHO, M. (Orgs.). Rio de Janeiro: Bertrand BrasilD'Antona, A.O., (2003) Garantir a terra, garantia da Terra?, , Reservas Extrativistas na Amazônia Legal Brasileira. Tese (Doutorado em Ciências Sociais), Universidade Estadual de Campinas, CampinasD'Antona, A.O., Bueno, M.C.D., Dagnino, R., Using regular grids for spatial distribution of census data for population and environment studies in Brazil (2011) Anais, , In: POPULATION ASSOCIATION OF AMERICA ANNUAL MEETING PROGRAM, 2011, Washington. Washington: PAADe Sherbinin, A., (2002) A CIESIN thematic guide to social science applications of remote sensing, , New York: Center for International Earth Science Information Network (CIESIN) of Columbia UniversityDeichmann, U., Balk, D., Yetman, G., (2001) Transforming population data for interdisciplinary usages: From census to grid, , http://sedac.ciesin.columbia.edu/plue/gpw/GPWdocumentation.pdf, Documentação do Grid Population of the Word-GPW, versão 2, Disponível em: Acesso em: abr. 2010(2006) The modifiable areas unit problem, , ESPON-European Spatial Planning Observation Network. Final Report. LuxembourgGallego, F.J., A population density grid of the European Union (2010) Population and Environment, 31 (6). , New YorkGallego, F.J., A downscaled population density map of the EU from commune data and land cover information (2009) Anais, , In: PROCEEDINGS OF THE NEW TECHNIQUES AND TECHNOLOGIES FOR STATISTICS SEMINAR-NTTS, 2009, BelgiumGisbert, F.J.G., Marti, I.C., Cartografía y demografía: Una grid de población para la Comunitat Valenciana (2011) Estadistica Espanola, 53 (176)Goodchild, M.F., Anselin, L., Deichmann, U., A Framework for the Areal Interpolation of Socioeconomic Data (1993) Environment and Planning A, 25, pp. 383-397Hogan, D.J., D'Antona, A.O., Carmo, R.L., Dinâmica demográfica recente da Amazônia (2008) Amazônia: Natureza e sociedade em transformação, , In: BATISTELA, M.MORAN, E.ALVES, D. (Orgs.). São Paulo: EduspGeoestatísticas de Recursos Naturais da Amazônia Legal (2003) Estudos e Pesquisas-Informação Geográfica, (8). , http://www.ibge.gov.br/home/geociencias/recursosnaturais/diagnosticos_levantamentos/amazonia_legal/amazonia_legal.pdf, IBGE. Rio de Janeiro, [reeditado em formato digital em 2011]. Disponível em: Acesso em: 15 jul. 2011(2008) Contagem da População 2007-Agregado por setores censitários, , IBGE. Documentação do Arquivo. Rio de Janeiro(2008) Censos 2007: Inovações e impactos nos sistemas de informações estatísticas e geográficas do Brasil, , IBGE. Rio de Janeiro(2009) Censo Demográfico 2010: Os primeiros passos, , IBGE. Rio de Janeiro(2010) Base Cartográfica Contínua do Brasil, ao Milionésimo-BCIM, , IBGE. Versão 3.04. Rio de Janeiro(2011) Censo 2010-Sinopse do Censo Demográfico 2010., , IBGE. Rio de JaneiroKampel, S.A., (2004) Geoinformação para estudos demográficos: Representação espacial de dados de população na Amazônia Brasileira, , Tese (Doutorado)-Departamento de Engenharia de Transportes, Escola Politécnica da Universidade de São Paulo, São PauloLandim, P.M.B., (2000) Introdução aos métodos de estimação espacial para confecção de mapas., , DGA, IGCE, Unesp/Rio Claro, Lab. Geomatemática, (Texto didático, 02)Langford, M., Unwin, D.J., Generating and mapping population density surfaces within a Geographical Information System (1995) The Cartographic Journal, 31, pp. 21-26Martin, D., Mapping population data from zone centroid locations (1989) Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, 8 (14), pp. 90-97Martin, D., An assessment of surface and zonal models of population (1996) International Journal of Geographical Information Systems, 10, pp. 973-989Martin, D., Tate, N.J., Langford, M., Refining population surface models: Experiments with Northern Ireland Census Data (2000) Transactions in GIS, 4, pp. 343-360Mennis, J., Generating surface models of population using dasymetric mapping (2003) The Professional Geographer, 55 (1), pp. 31-42Mennis, J., Using geographic information systems to create and analyze statistical surfaces of population and risk for environmental justice analysis (2002) Social Science Quarterly, 83 (1), pp. 281-297Mennis, J., Hultgren, T., Intelligent dasymetric mapping and its application to areal interpolation (2006) Cartography and Geographic Information Science, 33 (3), pp. 179-194Mennis, J., Intelligent dasymetric mapping and its comparison with other areal interpolation techniques (2006) Anais, , In: PROCEEDINGS OF AUTOCARTO 2006, VancouverMilego, R., Ramos, M.J., Disaggregation of socioeconomic data into a regular grid: Results of the methodology testing phase (2010) Anais, , In: ESPON DATABASE 2013, UAB, 2010, Bellaterra, EspanhaOpenshaw, S., Openshaw, C., (1997) Artificial intelligence in geography, , Chichester: John WileyOpenshaw, S., (1984) The modifiable areal unit problem, , Norwich: Geo Books, (Concepts and Techniques in Modern Geography, n. 38)Pozzi, F., Small, C., Yetman, G., Modeling the distribution of human population with nighttime satellite imagery and gridded population of the world (2003) Earth Observation Magazine, 12 (4), pp. 24-30Reibel, M., Geographic information systems and spatial data processing in demography: A review (2007) Population Research and Policy Review, 26 (5-6)Production and dissemination of grid data since the 1970 Census in Finland (2010) Anais, , STATISTICS FINLAND. In: CONFERENCE OF EUROPEAN STATISTICIANS, 2010. Paris. ParisStromgren, M., Holm, E., (2010) Using downscaled population in local data generation: A country-level examination, , ESPON Technical ReportTammisto, R., Merging national population grids (bottom-up approach) into a European dataset (2007) Anais, , In: GIS FOR STATISTICS, 2007, Luxembourg. LuxembourgTobler, W.R., Linear operators applied to areal data (1975) Display and analysis of areal data, pp. 14-38. , In: DAVIS, J. C.McCULLAGH, M. J. (Eds.). London: WileyTobler, W.R., Smooth pychnophylactic interpolation for geographical regions (1979) Journal of the American Statistical Association, 74 (367), pp. 519-530Thurstain-Goodwin, M., Unwin, D., Defining and delineating the central areas of towns for statistical monitoring using continuous surface representations (2000) Transactions in GIS, 4, pp. 305-317(2009) Handbook on geospatial infrastructure in support of census activities, , UNITED NATIONS. New York, (Studies in Methods, Series F, n. 103)(2000) Handbook on geographic information systems and digital mapping, , UNITED NATIONS. New York, (Studies in Methods, Series F, n. 79)West, P.C., Brechin, S.R., (1991) Resident peoples and national parks: Social dilemmas and strategies in international conservation, , (Eds.). Tucson: The University of Arizona PressYoo, E., Kyriakidis, P.C., Tobler, W., Reconstructing population density surfaces from areal data: A comparison of tobler's pycnophylactic interpolation method and area-to-point kriging (2010) Geographical Analysis, 42, pp. 78-98The objective of this article is to present Polarization of Agrarian Structure as a single, more complete representation than models emphasizing rural exodus and consolidation of land into large agropastoral enterprises of the dynamics of changing land distribution, land use / cover, and thus the rural milieu of Amazonia. Data were collected in 2003 using social surveys on a sample of 587 lots randomly selected from among 5,086 lots on a cadastral map produced in the 1970s. Georeferencing of current property boundaries in the location of these previously demarcated lots allows us to relate sociodemographic and biophysical variables of the surveyed properties to the changes in boundaries that have occurred since the 1970s. As have other authors in other Amazonian regions, we found concentration of land ownership into larger properties. The approach we took, however, showed that changes in the distribution of land ownership is not limited to the appearance of larger properties, those with 200 ha or more; there also exists substantial division of earlier lots into properties with fewer than five hectares, many without any agropastoral use. These two trends are juxtaposed against the decline in establishments with between five and 200 ha. The variation across groups in land use / land cover and population distribution shows the necessity of developing conceptual models, whether from socioeconomic, demographic or environmental perspectives, look beyond a single group of people or properties
Eco-certification and greening the Brazilian soy and corn supply chains
Garrett et al ’s recent letter (2013 Environ. Res. Lett. 8 044055) shows the trade value of Brazil’s production of non-genetically modified (GM) crops, and argues that production for this niche market laid the foundation for the expansion of a variety of non-GM and eco-certification systems. We argue that the conditions underlying the development and perpetuation of the non-GM certification systems are transient. The expansion of soy production has dampened the conditions that promoted the dominance of non-GM soy in the region. The state at the heart of the production of conventional soy, Mato Grosso, already has transitioned to almost 90% GM soy in the most recent agricultural season. The continued viability of eco-certification systems depends on strengthening institutions on the demand side, and ensuring farm-level costs on the supply side match price premiums reaching the farm level
Estratégia para amostragem da população e da paisagem em pesquisas sobre uso e cobertura da terra Estrategia para muestreo de la población y del paisaje en investigaciones sobre uso y cobertura de la tierra Strategy for a sampling of the population and the land structure in studies on the use, covering and domestic units of the land
Este artigo apresenta a estratégia usada em uma pesquisa realizada em Santarém - PA, em 2003, para amostrar lotes delimitados em mapas do Incra e as unidades domésticas ali existentes, de modo a capturar as mudanças populacionais e ambientais na escala das propriedades rurais e na da região. A amostra foi selecionada conforme a distribuição dos lotes ao longo de quatro eixos rodoviários relacionados a distintos processos de ocupação. Em cada um dos eixos foram selecionadas aleatoriamente 20 células com 9km². Em cada uma delas, foram selecionados aleatoriamente os lotes que deveriam ser visitados. No campo, entrevistaram-se todas as unidades domésticas existentes em cada um dos lotes selecionados. Descreve-se a amostragem por segmentação sucessiva da área de estudo, destacando-se como os dados resultantes podem ser usados diferentemente nas escalas das unidades domésticas, dos lotes e da região, conforme as questões e variáveis de interesse.<br>Este artículo presenta la estrategia usada en una investigación realizada en Santarém - PA, en 2003, para mostrar lotes delimitados en mapas del Incra [Instituto Nacional de Colonización y Reforma Agraria] y las unidades domésticas allí existentes, de modo de captar los cambios poblacionales y ambientales en la escala de las propiedades rurales y en la de la región. La muestra fue seleccionada de acuerdo a la distribución de los lotes a lo largo de cuatro ejes viales relacionados a distintos procesos de ocupación. En cada uno de los ejes fueron seleccionadas aleatoriamente 20 células con 9km2. En cada una de ellas, fueron seleccionados aleatoriamente los lotes que deberían ser visitados. En el área establecida, se entrevistaron todas las unidades domésticas existentes en cada uno de los lotes seleccionados. Se describe el muestreo por segmentación sucesiva del área de estudio, destacándose, como los datos resultantes pueden ser usados de forma diferente en las escalas de las unidades domésticas, de los lotes y de la región, de acuerdo a los aspectos y a las variables de interés.<br>This article describes the strategy used in a study carried out in Santarém, State of Pará, Brazil, in 2003, to sample plots represented on maps produced by the Brazilian Government's Land Reform Department (INCRA). The purpose of this sampling strategy is to describe demographic and environmental changes on the scale of the rural landholdings and on a regional scale. The sample was chosen according to the distribution of plots of land along four different roads that underwent different processes of occupation. Twenty cells of 9km2 each were chosen at random along each road and, in each direction, plots were chosen to be visited. In the field work, persons at all the domestic units existing in each of the plots selected were interviewed. Sampling carried out by successive segmentation of the area of study is described, as well as the way in which the resulting data can be used differently on the scales of domestic units, plots of land, and regions, according to the questions and variables of interest