The Specific Allocation Fund (Dak): Mechanisms and Uses

Research team smeru: syaikhu usman, m. sulton mawardi, adri poesoro, asep suryahadi griffith university: charles sampford translator: kate weatherley editor: budhi adrianto abstract this study aims to analyze the management of the specific allocation fund (dak). the three largest dak-recipient sectors are the focus of the study: education, health, and roads infrastructure. the study sample areas are four districts. this paper was compiled based on the results of in-depth interviews and focus group discussions with various stakeholders as well as analysis of dak policy and secondary data. the main objective of dak is to reduce interregional inequalities in public services. we came across policies in dire need of national uniformity but that still allow variation on some aspects. conversely, we found some enforced national uniformity in policies that should have provided rooms for variations to accommodate regional specific conditions. in practice, regional governments have become passive recipients of dak grants. the attitudes of regional government towards the dak allocation process indicate a general feeling that the central government is not transparent. furthermore, it is evident that coordination and communication surrounding dak management between agencies are still limited. based on the above findings, we recommend a new paradigm where the central government is suggested to decentralize the authority for the allocation, coordination, and monitoring of district/city use of dak to provincial governments. keywords: specific allocation fund, education, health, roads infrastructure, new paradig

'Education, education, education' : legal, moral and clinical

This article brings together Professor Donald Nicolson's intellectual interest in professional legal ethics and his long-standing involvement with law clinics both as an advisor at the University of Cape Town and Director of the University of Bristol Law Clinic and the University of Strathclyde Law Clinic. In this article he looks at how legal education may help start this process of character development, arguing that the best means is through student involvement in voluntary law clinics. And here he builds upon his recent article which argues for voluntary, community service oriented law clinics over those which emphasise the education of students

Cultural specificity versus institutional universalism: a critique of the National Integrity System (NIS) methodology

This article provides an assessment and critique of the National Integrity System approach and methodology, informed by the experience of conducting an NIS review in Cambodia. It explores four key issues that potentially undermine the relevance and value of NIS reports for developing democracies: the narrowly conceived institutional approach underpinning the NIS methodology; the insufficient appreciation of cultural distinctiveness; a failure properly to conceptualise and articulate the very notion of ‘integrity’; and an over emphasis on compliance-based approaches to combating corruption at the expense of the positive promotion of integrity. The article seeks to offer some pointers to how the NIS approach could be adapted to broaden its conceptualisation of institutions and integrity, and thereby provide reports that are more theoretically informed as well as being more constructive and actionable

Evolving norms of protection: China, Libya and the problem of intervention in armed conflict

This article examines the influence of civilian protection norms on China’s response to the 2011 crisis in Libya. It argues that Responsibility to Protect—an emerging norm commonly associated with the Libyan case—did not play a major role in China’s abstention on Resolution 1973 (2011) authorizing international intervention in Libya. For China, Responsibility to Protect is merely a concept and could not serve as the basis for intervention. Instead, Protection of Civilians in Armed Conflict, as a normative foundation for civilian protection endorsed by China, offers a more appropriate lens for understanding China’s vote. Protection of Civilians, however, does not accommodate China’s unprecedented evacuation of Chinese nationals from Libya. This operation proceeded from a third logic of Protection of Nationals Abroad, which poses dilemmas for China’s strict adherence to the principles of sovereignty and non-interference and brings to bear domestic interests and notions of protection

Effective Tax Rates: Marginal, Average and Cumulative

This paper argues that the effects of high EMTRs are not limited to the small number of workers whose last dollar of income falls within the well known high rates. Indeed all lower income earners face what are termed “cumulative effective tax rates” in excess of the current top marginal rate. This article will argue that most of the popular directions for tax reform tend to exacerbate the problem. Even those initiatives which are specifically designed to reduce effective marginal tax rates frequently merely shift the peaks of effective rates, leaving the averages unchanged for most.