Economic comparison between Hospital at Home and traditional hospitalization using a simulation-based approach

International audienceHospital at Home (HAH) is a concept slowly expanding over time. At first this type of organization was used to accomplish low-technical tasks. The main objective was to increase bed availability in hospitals for new patients. Nowadays, HAH structures are able to undertake more technical complex care such as (but not limited to) end-of-life care, chemotherapy and rehabilitation. The purpose of this paper is to propose a new methodology to make an unbiased economic comparison between HAH structures and traditional hospitalization. This article accomplishes two main objectives: in the first part the authors propose a comprehensive literature review dealing with the comparison between traditional hospital and home care structures from an economic standpoint, showing that results are highly dependent on initial conditions of the study (patient health state, territory settings, bio-medical parameters); in the second part the authors propose an unbiased economic comparison approach between health care provided in traditional hospital and home care network using formal modelling with Petri nets and discrete event simulation. As an example for the comparison a multi-session treatment is proposed. Various scenarios are tested to ensure that results will be maintained even if initial conditions change. Relevant performance indicators used for comparison are economic costs from the point of view of the insurance and economic costs related to the consumption of resources

Conception des structures de soins à domicile

La question de l'accès au soin est cruciale dans notre société moderne. Un effet évident de la demande accrue de services de santé est l'augmentation du taux d'occupation dans les hôpitaux. La principale différence entre la dispensation de soins à l'hôpital et au domicile est la suivante: le patient doit se déplacer et toutes les ressources nécessaires à son traitement se trouvent dans le même endroit, tandis que dans les soins délivrés au domicile, les ressources doivent être déplacées au chevet du patient. Il existe plusieurs défis afin de pouvoir réaliser ce changement. Dans cette thèse nous traitons trois problèmes importants dans la conception des structures de soins à domicile. D abord, la localisation des structures en minimisant les coûts logistiques, où nous développons trois modèles incluant différentes caractéristiques comme du système de santé comme les coûts liés aux déplacements des ressources, la variation de la demande dans le temps et l existence et évolution des ressource libérales. Ces modèles nous permettent de proposer des localisations robustes dans le temps tout en assurant une couverture maximale et en minimisant les coûts. La deuxième problématique consiste au choix des activités et couverture épidémiologique et spatiale en tenant compte différentes activités et types de ressources, les autorisations pour réaliser les pathologies et la couverture. Deux modèles développés nous ont permis montrer les effets sur l affectation de la demande et le dimensionnement de ressources induits par changements dans les coûts des libéraux, salaires et d autorisation de servir la demande. Le troisième problème et celui du dimensionnement de ressources avec incertitudes de demande (volume, épidémiologique et géographique) et le modèle proposé tient compte du problème sous-jacent de déplacement des ressources à l aide d une estimation de la tournée réalisée.The issue of access to heamthcare is crucial in our modern society. One obvious effect of the augmentation of healthcare services demand is the increasing occupancy rates in hospitals. The main difference between the provision of care at the hospital and at home is as follows: the patient is at hospital and all the resources necessary for its treatment are in the same place, while in the care delivered at home, resources must be moved to the bedside. There are several challenges in order to achieve this change. In this thesis we address three important issues in the design of structures of home care. First, the location of structures minimizing logistics costs, where we develop three models with different features such as traveling costs of resources, changes in demand over time and evolution of freelance resources. These models allow us to provide robust location over time while ensuring maximum coverage and minimizing costs. The second issue is the choice of activities, epidemiological and spatial coverage, taking into account different types of activities and resources, permissions to serve some pathologies and coverage. Two models developed allow us to show the effects on the demand allocation and resources planning induced by changes in the costs of freelance professionals and authorization to serve some pathologies. The third problem is the dimensioning of resources with demand uncertainty (volume, epidemiological and geographical) and the proposed model takes into account the underlying problem of moving resources using an estimate of the routes performed.ST ETIENNE-ENS des Mines (422182304) / SudocSudocFranceF

Conception des structures de soins à domicile

The issue of access to heamthcare is crucial in our modern society. One obvious effect of the augmentation of healthcare services demand is the increasing occupancy rates in hospitals. The main difference between the provision of care at the hospital and at home is as follows: the patient is at hospital and all the resources necessary for its treatment are in the same place, while in the care delivered at home, resources must be moved to the bedside. There are several challenges in order to achieve this change. In this thesis we address three important issues in the design of structures of home care. First, the location of structures minimizing logistics costs, where we develop three models with different features such as traveling costs of resources, changes in demand over time and evolution of freelance resources. These models allow us to provide robust location over time while ensuring maximum coverage and minimizing costs. The second issue is the choice of activities, epidemiological and spatial coverage, taking into account different types of activities and resources, permissions to serve some pathologies and coverage. Two models developed allow us to show the effects on the demand allocation and resources planning induced by changes in the costs of freelance professionals and authorization to serve some pathologies. The third problem is the dimensioning of resources with demand uncertainty (volume, epidemiological and geographical) and the proposed model takes into account the underlying problem of moving resources using an estimate of the routes performed.La question de l'accès au soin est cruciale dans notre société moderne. Un effet évident de la demande accrue de services de santé est l'augmentation du taux d'occupation dans les hôpitaux. La principale différence entre la dispensation de soins à l'hôpital et au domicile est la suivante: le patient doit se déplacer et toutes les ressources nécessaires à son traitement se trouvent dans le même endroit, tandis que dans les soins délivrés au domicile, les ressources doivent être déplacées au chevet du patient. Il existe plusieurs défis afin de pouvoir réaliser ce changement. Dans cette thèse nous traitons trois problèmes importants dans la conception des structures de soins à domicile. D’abord, la localisation des structures en minimisant les coûts logistiques, où nous développons trois modèles incluant différentes caractéristiques comme du système de santé comme les coûts liés aux déplacements des ressources, la variation de la demande dans le temps et l’existence et évolution des ressource libérales. Ces modèles nous permettent de proposer des localisations robustes dans le temps tout en assurant une couverture maximale et en minimisant les coûts. La deuxième problématique consiste au choix des activités et couverture épidémiologique et spatiale en tenant compte différentes activités et types de ressources, les autorisations pour réaliser les pathologies et la couverture. Deux modèles développés nous ont permis montrer les effets sur l’affectation de la demande et le dimensionnement de ressources induits par changements dans les coûts des libéraux, salaires et d’autorisation de servir la demande. Le troisième problème et celui du dimensionnement de ressources avec incertitudes de demande (volume, épidémiologique et géographique) et le modèle proposé tient compte du problème sous-jacent de déplacement des ressources à l’aide d’une estimation de la tournée réalisée

Design of healthcare at home structures

La question de l'accès au soin est cruciale dans notre société moderne. Un effet évident de la demande accrue de services de santé est l'augmentation du taux d'occupation dans les hôpitaux. La principale différence entre la dispensation de soins à l'hôpital et au domicile est la suivante: le patient doit se déplacer et toutes les ressources nécessaires à son traitement se trouvent dans le même endroit, tandis que dans les soins délivrés au domicile, les ressources doivent être déplacées au chevet du patient. Il existe plusieurs défis afin de pouvoir réaliser ce changement. Dans cette thèse nous traitons trois problèmes importants dans la conception des structures de soins à domicile. D’abord, la localisation des structures en minimisant les coûts logistiques, où nous développons trois modèles incluant différentes caractéristiques comme du système de santé comme les coûts liés aux déplacements des ressources, la variation de la demande dans le temps et l’existence et évolution des ressource libérales. Ces modèles nous permettent de proposer des localisations robustes dans le temps tout en assurant une couverture maximale et en minimisant les coûts. La deuxième problématique consiste au choix des activités et couverture épidémiologique et spatiale en tenant compte différentes activités et types de ressources, les autorisations pour réaliser les pathologies et la couverture. Deux modèles développés nous ont permis montrer les effets sur l’affectation de la demande et le dimensionnement de ressources induits par changements dans les coûts des libéraux, salaires et d’autorisation de servir la demande. Le troisième problème et celui du dimensionnement de ressources avec incertitudes de demande (volume, épidémiologique et géographique) et le modèle proposé tient compte du problème sous-jacent de déplacement des ressources à l’aide d’une estimation de la tournée réalisée.The issue of access to heamthcare is crucial in our modern society. One obvious effect of the augmentation of healthcare services demand is the increasing occupancy rates in hospitals. The main difference between the provision of care at the hospital and at home is as follows: the patient is at hospital and all the resources necessary for its treatment are in the same place, while in the care delivered at home, resources must be moved to the bedside. There are several challenges in order to achieve this change. In this thesis we address three important issues in the design of structures of home care. First, the location of structures minimizing logistics costs, where we develop three models with different features such as traveling costs of resources, changes in demand over time and evolution of freelance resources. These models allow us to provide robust location over time while ensuring maximum coverage and minimizing costs. The second issue is the choice of activities, epidemiological and spatial coverage, taking into account different types of activities and resources, permissions to serve some pathologies and coverage. Two models developed allow us to show the effects on the demand allocation and resources planning induced by changes in the costs of freelance professionals and authorization to serve some pathologies. The third problem is the dimensioning of resources with demand uncertainty (volume, epidemiological and geographical) and the proposed model takes into account the underlying problem of moving resources using an estimate of the routes performed

Home health-care network design: Location and configuration of home health-care centers

International audienceHome Health-Care (HHC) is a concept slowly expanding over time, introduced to reduce pressure on inpatient hospital beds by providing care to patients at home. Nowadays, HHC centers are able to undertake more technical complex care such as (but not limited to) end-of-life care, chemotherapy and rehabilitation. This article accomplishes two main objectives: (i) design a home health-care network by locating HHC centers across a territory, taking into account medical demand and costs of resources and facilities; (ii) optimally manage the activities of HHC centers by deciding on the outsourcing of critical processes for patient care. Two mixed-integer linear programs are proposed to solve these problems and propose strategic and tactical decisions. A practical case study is proposed on the Loire department (France) with various scenarios to test the robustness of the model depending on demand variation. The proposed method gives efficient plans for designing and managing HHC centers with cost-efficient solutions on both strategic and tactical level

Heuristic approaches for a special simultaneous pickup and delivery problem with time windows in home health care industry

International audienceThe problem studied in our work arisen from a real application of home health care company in France. The home health care company must complete pickup and delivery tasks to satisfy the demands of customers (the patients receive home health care). The requirements can be partitioned into four types: delivering medicines from companys depot or hospital to patients home, and picking up materials from patients home to the lab or return to the companys depot. Each patient may require various pickup services and various delivery services, simultaneously. Meanwhile, there are time window constraints for lab, hospital and each patient. The objective of the company is to determine a set of vehicle routes with minimal costs, satisfying all the constraints. We build two mathematical formulations for this complex problem, and propose heuristic approaches to solve this problem. Computational experiments on some test instances are presented

Healthcare at home facility location allocation problem

International audienceThis article presents the healthcare at home (HAH) facility location-allocation problem, introducing new decisions: (i) location of facilities in a region, (ii) assignment of demand to HAH companies, (iii) authorization for delivering some specific care and (iv) allocation of resources. HAH became popular in developed country because they offer flexible services to patients at home while decreasing the number of hospitalized patients. This study is motivated by the two statements: (i) increasing demand for healthcare services such as palliative care due to an ageing population, and (ii) increasing costs in traditional hospitalization due to new economic regulation (fee for service basis, "Tarification à l'activité"). The proposed problem is NP-Hard (multi-period, multi-resource, multi-facility location-allocation problem). Instances derived from real case study (HAH network of Rhone-Alps region) of the problem are solved using the branch and bound procedure of IBM ILOG CPLE

Healthcare at home facility location allocation problem

International audienceThis article presents the healthcare at home (HAH) facility location-allocation problem, introducing new decisions: (i) location of facilities in a region, (ii) assignment of demand to HAH companies, (iii) authorization for delivering some specific care and (iv) allocation of resources. HAH became popular in developed country because they offer flexible services to patients at home while decreasing the number of hospitalized patients. This study is motivated by the two statements: (i) increasing demand for healthcare services such as palliative care due to an ageing population, and (ii) increasing costs in traditional hospitalization due to new economic regulation (fee for service basis, "Tarification à l'activité"). The proposed problem is NP-Hard (multi-period, multi-resource, multi-facility location-allocation problem). Instances derived from real case study (HAH network of Rhone-Alps region) of the problem are solved using the branch and bound procedure of IBM ILOG CPLE