Policy implications for familial searching

In the United States, several states have made policy decisions regarding whether and how to use familial searching of the Combined DNA Index System (CODIS) database in criminal investigations. Familial searching pushes DNA typing beyond merely identifying individuals to detecting genetic relatedness, an application previously reserved for missing persons identifications and custody battles. The intentional search of CODIS for partial matches to an item of evidence offers law enforcement agencies a powerful tool for developing investigative leads, apprehending criminals, revitalizing cold cases and exonerating wrongfully convicted individuals. As familial searching involves a range of logistical, social, ethical and legal considerations, states are now grappling with policy options for implementing familial searching to balance crime fighting with its potential impact on society. When developing policies for familial searching, legislators should take into account the impact of familial searching on select populations and the need to minimize personal intrusion on relatives of individuals in the DNA database. This review describes the approaches used to narrow a suspect pool from a partial match search of CODIS and summarizes the economic, ethical, logistical and political challenges of implementing familial searching. We examine particular US state policies and the policy options adopted to address these issues. The aim of this review is to provide objective background information on the controversial approach of familial searching to inform policy decisions in this area. Herein we highlight key policy options and recommendations regarding effective utilization of familial searching that minimize harm to and afford maximum protection of US citizens

Perspectives of Women in Prostitution diversion program on DNA Collection for a High-Risk DNA Database

DNA can be collected from women at high risk of violent crime as a pre-emptive biometric for post-mortem identification. We conducted focus groups with women in a prostitution diversion program that offers pre-emptive DNA collection. In general, the women supported the program but voiced concern for law enforcement collecting DNA. These data provide insights into the challenges of collecting DNA from women whom law enforcement might consider alternately to be victims or vilified. Hearing the voices of these women provides the forensic community an opportunity to design programs to minimize harm and maximize utility of DNA for victim identification

Cómo afrontar los retos del intercambio de datos sobre el ADN

Las barreras administrativas y éticas del intercambio de datos sobre el ADN para la identificación de los migrantes encontrados a lo largo de la frontera entre Estados Unidos y México evidencian lo necesarias que son unas soluciones a largo plazo y unos procesos sostenibles

Managing Incidental Genomic Findings in Clinical Trials: Fulfillment of the Principle of Justice

<p>Managing Incidental Genomic Findings in Clinical Trials: Fulfillment of the Principle of Justice</p

Missense mutations in TENM4, a regulator of axon guidance and central myelination, cause essential tremor

Essential tremor (ET) is a common movement disorder with an estimated prevalence of 5% of the population aged over 65 years. In spite of intensive efforts, the genetic architecture of ET remains unknown. We used a combination of whole-exome sequencing and targeted resequencing in three ET families. In vitro and in vivo experiments in oligodendrocyte precursor cells and zebrafish were performed to test our findings. Whole-exome sequencing revealed a missense mutation in TENM4 segregating in an autosomal-dominant fashion in an ET family. Subsequent targeted resequencing of TENM4 led to the discovery of two novel missense mutations. Not only did these two mutations segregate with ET in two additional families, but we also observed significant over transmission of pathogenic TENM4 alleles across the three families. Consistent with a dominant mode of inheritance, in vitro analysis in oligodendrocyte precursor cells showed that mutant proteins mislocalize. Finally, expression of human mRNA harboring any of three patient mutations in zebrafish embryos induced defects in axon guidance, confirming a dominant-negative mode of action for these mutations. Our genetic and functional data, which is corroborated by the existence of a Tenm4 knockout mouse displaying an ET phenotype, implicates TENM4 in ET. Together with previous studies of TENM4 in model organisms, our studies intimate that processes regulating myelination in the central nervous system and axon guidance might be significant contributors to the genetic burden of this disorde

Biallelic variants in LIG3 cause a novel mitochondrial neurogastrointestinal encephalomyopathy

none67si: Abnormal gut motility is a feature of several mitochondrial encephalomyopathies, and mutations in genes such as TYMP and POLG, have been linked to these rare diseases. The human genome encodes three DNA ligases, of which only one, ligase III (LIG3), has a mitochondrial splice variant and is crucial for mitochondrial health. We investigated the effect of reduced LIG3 activity and resulting mitochondrial dysfunction in seven patients from three independent families, who showed the common occurrence of gut dysmotility and neurological manifestations reminiscent of mitochondrial neurogastrointestinal encephalomyopathy. DNA from these patients was subjected to whole exome sequencing. In all patients, compound heterozygous variants in a new disease gene, LIG3, were identified. All variants were predicted to have a damaging effect on the protein. The LIG3 gene encodes the only mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) ligase and therefore plays a pivotal role in mtDNA repair and replication. In vitro assays in patient-derived cells showed a decrease in LIG3 protein levels and ligase activity. We demonstrated that the LIG3 gene defects affect mtDNA maintenance, leading to mtDNA depletion without the accumulation of multiple deletions as observed in other mitochondrial disorders. This mitochondrial dysfunction is likely to cause the phenotypes observed in these patients. The most prominent and consistent clinical signs were severe gut dysmotility and neurological abnormalities, including leukoencephalopathy, epilepsy, migraine, stroke-like episodes, and neurogenic bladder. A decrease in the number of myenteric neurons, and increased fibrosis and elastin levels were the most prominent changes in the gut. Cytochrome c oxidase (COX) deficient fibres in skeletal muscle were also observed. Disruption of lig3 in zebrafish reproduced the brain alterations and impaired gut transit in vivo. In conclusion, we identified variants in the LIG3 gene that result in a mitochondrial disease characterized by predominant gut dysmotility, encephalopathy, and neuromuscular abnormalities.This work was supported by Telethon Grant GGP15171 to E.B. and R.D.G. and by a donation from Kobe city to the Department of General Pediatrics, Kobe University Graduate School of Medicine (K550003302). S.C. was supported by a Dutch Cancer Foundation grant (KWF11011). V.C. and A.M. were supported by the Italian Ministry of Health (“Ricerca Corrente” funding). R.D.G. is the recipient of grants from University of Ferrara (FAR and FIR funds).openBonora, Elena; Chakrabarty, Sanjiban; Kellaris, Georgios; Tsutsumi, Makiko; Bianco, Francesca; Bergamini, Christian; Ullah, Farid; Isidori, Federica; Liparulo, Irene; Diquigiovanni, Chiara; Masin, Luca; Rizzardi, Nicola; Cratere, Mariapia Giuditta; Boschetti, Elisa; Papa, Valentina; Maresca, Alessandra; Cenacchi, Giovanna; Casadio, Rita; Martelli, Pierluigi; Matera, Ivana; Ceccherini, Isabella; Fato, Romana; Raiola, Giuseppe; Arrigo, Serena; Signa, Sara; Sementa, Angela Rita; Severino, Mariasavina; Striano, Pasquale; Fiorillo, Chiara; Goto, Tsuyoshi; Uchino, Shumpei; Oyazato, Yoshinobu; Nakamura, Hisayoshi; Mishra, Sushil K; Yeh, Yu-Sheng; Kato, Takema; Nozu, Kandai; Tanboon, Jantima; Morioka, Ichiro; Nishino, Ichizo; Toda, Tatsushi; Goto, Yu-Ichi; Ohtake, Akira; Kosaki, Kenjiro; Yamaguchi, Yoshiki; Nonaka, Ikuya; Iijima, Kazumoto; Mimaki, Masakazu; Kurahashi, Hiroki; Raams, Anja; MacInnes, Alyson; Alders, Mariel; Engelen, Marc; Linthorst, Gabor; de Koning, Tom; den Dunnen, Wilfred; Dijkstra, Gerard; van Spaendonck, Karin; van Gent, Dik C; Aronica, Eleonora M; Picco, Paolo; Carelli, Valerio; Seri, Marco; Katsanis, Nicholas; Duijkers, Floor A M; Taniguchi-Ikeda, Mariko; De Giorgio, RobertoBonora, Elena; Chakrabarty, Sanjiban; Kellaris, Georgios; Tsutsumi, Makiko; Bianco, Francesca; Bergamini, Christian; Ullah, Farid; Isidori, Federica; Liparulo, Irene; Diquigiovanni, Chiara; Masin, Luca; Rizzardi, Nicola; Cratere, Mariapia Giuditta; Boschetti, Elisa; Papa, Valentina; Maresca, Alessandra; Cenacchi, Giovanna; Casadio, Rita; Martelli, Pierluigi; Matera, Ivana; Ceccherini, Isabella; Fato, Romana; Raiola, Giuseppe; Arrigo, Serena; Signa, Sara; Sementa, Angela Rita; Severino, Mariasavina; Striano, Pasquale; Fiorillo, Chiara; Goto, Tsuyoshi; Uchino, Shumpei; Oyazato, Yoshinobu; Nakamura, Hisayoshi; Mishra, Sushil K; Yeh, Yu-Sheng; Kato, Takema; Nozu, Kandai; Tanboon, Jantima; Morioka, Ichiro; Nishino, Ichizo; Toda, Tatsushi; Goto, Yu-Ichi; Ohtake, Akira; Kosaki, Kenjiro; Yamaguchi, Yoshiki; Nonaka, Ikuya; Iijima, Kazumoto; Mimaki, Masakazu; Kurahashi, Hiroki; Raams, Anja; MacInnes, Alyson; Alders, Mariel; Engelen, Marc; Linthorst, Gabor; de Koning, Tom; den Dunnen, Wilfred; Dijkstra, Gerard; van Spaendonck, Karin; van Gent, Dik C; Aronica, Eleonora M; Picco, Paolo; Carelli, Valerio; Seri, Marco; Katsanis, Nicholas; Duijkers, Floor A M; Taniguchi-Ikeda, Mariko; De Giorgio, Robert

Perspectives on Genetic and Genomic Technologies in an Academic Medical Center: The Duke Experience

In this age of personalized medicine, genetic and genomic testing is expected to become instrumental in health care delivery, but little is known about its actual implementation in clinical practice. Methods. We surveyed Duke faculty and healthcare providers to examine the extent of genetic and genomic testing adoption. We assessed providers’ use of genetic and genomic testing options and indications in clinical practice, providers’ awareness of pharmacogenetic applications, and providers’ opinions on returning research-generated genetic test results to participants. Most clinician respondents currently use family history routinely in their clinical practice, but only 18 percent of clinicians use pharmacogenetics. Only two respondents correctly identified the number of drug package inserts with pharmacogenetic indications. We also found strong support for the return of genetic research results to participants. Our results demonstrate that while Duke healthcare providers are enthusiastic about genomic technologies, use of genomic tools outside of research has been limited. Respondents favor return of research-based genetic results to participants, but clinicians lack knowledge about pharmacogenetic applications. We identified challenges faced by this institution when implementing genetic and genomic testing into patient care that should inform a policy and education agenda to improve provider support and clinician-researcher partnerships