New trends in fast and high-resolution liquid chromatography: a critical comparison of existing approaches

Recent developments in chromatographic supports and instrumentation for liquid chromatography (LC) are enabling rapid and highly efficient separations. Various analytical strategies have been proposed, for example the use of silica-based monolithic supports, elevated mobile phase temperatures, and columns packed with sub-3μm superficially porous particles (fused core) or with sub-2μm porous particles for use in ultra-high-pressure LC (UHPLC). The purpose of this review is to describe and compare these approaches in terms of throughput and resolving power, using kinetic data gathered for compounds with molecular weights ranging between 200 and 1300g mol−1 in isocratic and gradient modes. This study demonstrates that the best analytical strategy should be selected on the basis of the analytical problem (e.g., isocratic vs. gradient, throughput vs. efficiency) and the properties of the analyte. UHPLC and fused-core technologies are quite promising for small-molecular-weight compounds, but increasing the mobile phase temperature is useful for larger molecules, for example peptides. Figure Recent progress in HPLC technology to increase throughput and resolving powe

Comparative study of recent wide-pore materials of different stationary phase morphology, applied for the reversed-phase analysis of recombinant monoclonal antibodies

Various recent wide-pore reversed-phase stationary phases were studied for the analysis of intact monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) of 150kDa and their fragments possessing sizes between 25 and 50kDa. Different types of column technology were evaluated, namely, a prototype silica-based inorganic monolith containing mesopores of ∼250Å and macropores of ∼ 1.1μm, a column packed with 3.6μm wide-pore core-shell particles possessing a wide pore size distribution with an average around 200Å and a column packed with fully porous 1.7μm particles having pore size of ∼300Å. The performance of these wide-pore materials was compared with that of a poly(styrene-divinyl benzene) organic monolithic column, with a macropore size of approximately 1μm but without mesopores (stagnant pores). A systematic investigation was carried out using model IgG1 and IgG2 mAbs, namely rituximab, panitumumab, and bevacizumab. Firstly, the recoveries of intact and reduced mAbs were compared on the two monolithic phases, and it appeared that adsorption was less pronounced on the organic monolith, probably due to the difference in chemistry (C18 versus phenyl) and the absence of mesopores (stagnant zones). Secondly, the kinetic performance was investigated in gradient elution mode for all columns. For this purpose, peak capacities per meter as well as peak capacities per time unit and per pressure unit (PPT) were calculated at various flow rates, to compare performance of columns with different dimensions. In terms of peak capacity per meter, the core-shell 3.6μm and fully porous 1.7μm columns outperformed the two monolithic phases, at a temperature of 60°C. However, when considering the PPT values, the core-shell 3.6μm column remained the best phase while the prototype silica-based monoliths became very interesting, mostly due to a very high permeability compared with the organic monolith. Therefore, these core-shell and silica-based monolith provided the fastest achievable separation. Finally, at the maximal working temperature of each column, the core-shell 3.6μm column was far better than the other one, because it is the only one stable up to 90°C. Lastly, the loading capacity was also measured on these four different phases. It appeared that the organic monolith was the less interesting and rapidly overloaded, due to the absence of mesopores. On the other hand, the loading capacity of prototype silica-based monolith was indeed reasonabl

High-Throughput Screening of Drugs of Abuse in Urine by Supported Liquid-Liquid Extraction and UHPLC Coupled to Tandem MS

A qualitative method, involving supported liquid-liquid extraction (SLE) and ultra high pressure liquid chromatography coupled to tandem mass spectrometry (UHPLC-MS-MS), was developed for the rapid tentative identification of various drugs of abuse in urine. In this study, 28 drugs and metabolites were covered by the screening procedure. Before analysis, urine samples were extracted by SLE and good extraction recoveries were obtained for most investigated compounds. The UHPLC strategy was then selected for the rapid separation of amphetamines, cocaine, opiates and related compounds in urine. Using columns packed with sub-2µm particles, analysis time was reduced down to 2min, while maintaining acceptable performance. Finally, the detection was by tandem MS operating in the single reaction monitoring (SRM) mode. The most intense transition was selected for the different drugs and SRM dwell times set at 5ms, to maintain sufficient data points across the narrow UHPLC peaks. The tentative identification of the drugs of interest, including amphetamines, opiates and cocaine, was based on both, retention times and mass spectrometry information. With the proposed method, limits of detection were estimated at about 1ngmL−1 and the applicability was assessed by successfully analyzing several samples of drug abusers. Finally, this study demonstrates the potential of UHPLC coupled to tandem MS for the rapid screening of drugs of abuse in urin

Analytical tools for the physicochemical profiling of drug candidates to predict absorption/distribution

The measurement of physicochemical properties at an early phase of drug discovery and development is crucial to reduce attrition rates due to poor biopharmaceutical properties. Among these properties, ionization, lipophilicity, solubility and permeability are mandatory to predict the pharmacokinetic behavior of NCEs (new chemical entities). Due to the high number of NCEs, the analytical tools used to measure these properties are automated and progressively adapted to high-throughput technologies. The present review is dedicated to experimental methods applied in the early drug discovery process for the determination of solubility, ionization constants, lipophilicity and permeability of small molecules. The principles and experimental conditions of the different methods are described, and important enhancements in terms of throughput are highlighted. Figure Scheme of the Drug Research Proces

Fast log P determination by ultra-high-pressure liquid chromatography coupled with UV and mass spectrometry detections

Ultra-high-pressure liquid chromatography (UHPLC) systems able to work with columns packed with sub-2μm particles offer very fast methods to determine the lipophilicity of new chemical entities. The careful development of the most suitable experimental conditions presented here will help medicinal chemists for high-throughput screening (HTS) log P oct measurements. The approach was optimized using a well-balanced set of 38 model compounds and a series of 28 basic compounds such as β-blockers, local anesthetics, piperazines, clonidine, and derivatives. Different organic modifiers and hybrid stationary phases packed with 1.7-μm particles were evaluated in isocratic as well as gradient modes, and the advantages and limitations of tested conditions pointed out. The UHPLC approach offered a significant enhancement over the classical HPLC methods, by a factor 50 in the lipophilicity determination throughput. The hyphenation of UHPLC with MS detection allowed a further increase in the throughput. Data and results reported herein prove that the UHPLC-MS method can represent a progress in the HTS-measurement of lipophilicity due to its speed (at least a factor of 500 with respect to HPLC approaches) and to an extended field of application. Figure The UHPLC approach described here greatly enhanced the time required for log P determination (5' min by compound using UV detection) and, at least, 8 compounds measured in a 5' run when Mass Spectrometry detection in used. These developments offer to medicinal chemists a high-throughput method to estimate the lipophilicity of NCE

Pharmaceutical Applications on Columns Packed with Sub-2 µm Particles

During the last few years, there has been a great interest in the development of fast liquid chromatography. Among the reported approaches, the reduction of the particle size to attain sub-2µm diameter represents a good solution for achieving both increased separation power and faster analysis time. This paper demonstrates the chromatographic performance of such supports using plateheight curves and reveals the possibility for obtaining ultra-fast or highly efficient separations, according to the column geometry and system pressure limitations. The stability of these columns is initially evaluated using a system suitability experiment. The chromatographic performance remains stable in terms of retention, efficiency, and pressure for more than 1700 injections with pressure conditions ranging from 200 to 800 bar. Several fast and ultra-fast pharmaceutical applications are reported. In isocratic mode, a 5- to 10-fold reduction in analysis time is obtained with limited influence on efficiency and resolution. The run time is further reduced by 30-fold with the shorter available columns (i.e., 30 mm length). In gradient mode, the separation of a complex mixture containing an active pharmaceutical compound and related impurities is significantly improved with column length equal to 100 mm, to increase peak capacity and resolutio

Transfer of heroin profiling method from conventional GC-MS to Fast-GC-MS and UHPLC-MS/MS

Peer reviewe

Quantification of glucuronidated and sulfated steroids in human urine by ultra-high pressure liquid chromatography quadrupole time-of-flight mass spectrometry

The urinary steroid profile is constituted by anabolic androgenic steroids, including testosterone and its relatives, that are extensively metabolized into phase II sulfated or glucuronidated steroids. The use of liquid chromatography coupled to mass spectrometry (LC-MS) is an issue for the direct analysis of conjugated steroids, which can be used as urinary markers of exogenous steroid administration in doping analysis, without hydrolysis of the conjugated moiety. In this study, a sensitive and selective ultra high-pressure liquid chromatography coupled to quadrupole time-of-flight mass spectrometer (UHPLC-QTOF-MS) method was developed to quantify major urinary metabolites simultaneously after testosterone intake. The sample preparation of the urine (1mL) was performed by solid-phase extraction on Oasis HLB sorbent using a 96-well plate format. The conjugated steroids were analyzed by UHPLC-QTOF-MSE with a single-gradient elution of 36min (including re-equilibration time) in the negative electrospray ionization mode. MSE analysis involved parallel alternating acquisitions of both low- and high-collision energy functions. The method was validated and applied to samples collected from a clinical study performed with a group of healthy human volunteers who had taken testosterone, which were compared with samples from a placebo group. Quantitative results were also compared to GC-MS and LC-MS/MS measurements, and the correlations between data were found appropriate. The acquisition of full mass spectra over the entire mass range with QTOF mass analyzers gives promise of the opportunity to extend the steroid profile to a higher number of conjugated steroids. Figure UHPLC-QTOF-MSE acquisition mode for DHEAG in urine sampl

Apparent efficiency of serially coupled columns in isocratic and gradient elution modes

The goal of this work was to understand the variation of apparent efficiency when serially coupling columns with identical stationary phase chemistries, but with differences in their kinetic performance. For this purpose, a mathematical treatment was developed both for isocratic and gradient modes to assess the change in plate numbers and peak widths when coupling arbitrary several columns. To validate the theory, experiments were also carried out using various mixtures of compounds, on columns packed with different particle sizes, to mimic highly efficient (new, not used) and poorly efficient columns (used one with many injections). Excellent agreement was found between measured and calculated peak widths. The average error in prediction was about 5% (which may be explained by the additional volume of the coupling tubes). In isocratic mode, the plate numbers are not additive when the coupled columns possess different efficiencies, and a limiting plate count value can be calculated depending on the efficiency and length of the individual columns. Theoretical efficiency limit can also be determined assuming one column in the row with infinite efficiency. In gradient elution mode, the columns’ order has a role (non-symmetrical system). When the last column has high enough efficiency, the gradient band compression effect may outperform the competing band broadening caused by dispersive and diffusive processes (peak sharpening). Therefore, in gradient mode, the columns should generally be sequentially placed according to their increasing efficiency

Alternative mobile phase additives for the characterization of protein biopharmaceuticals in liquid chromatography – Mass spectrometry

When analyzing large complex protein biopharmaceuticals, ion-pairing agents imparting low pH are widely used as mobile phase additives to improve the chromatographic performance. However, one of the most effective additives in RPLC and HILIC, trifluoroacetic acid (TFA), is known as a strong suppressor of the MS signal and limits its use in hyphenated techniques. In this study, we evaluated a wide range of acidic additives to find alternatives to TFA that provided comparable chromatographic performance and improved MS sensitivity. It was observed that stronger acidic additives were required for intact level analysis compared to subunit level analysis and that the additive nature had a larger impact on the chromatographic performance in HILIC mode compared to RPLC. Therefore, four additives were identified as valuable alternatives to TFA in RPLC mode, namely, difluoroacetic acid (DFA), dichloroacetic acid (DClAA), trichloroacetic acid (TClAA), and methanesulfonic acid (MSA). Only one of these additives provided acceptable performance in HILIC mode, namely, TClAA.After evaluation of the MS performance, TClAA was discarded due to the apparent loss of intensity in both RPLC-MS and HILIC-MS mode. Together, these results demonstrate that for HILIC-MS analysis TFA remains the gold standard additive. However, DFA was found as promising alternative to TFA for RPLC-MS analysis and could play an important role in the development of methods for the characterization of the increasingly complex protein biopharmaceuticals