Revisiting Actor Programming in C++

The actor model of computation has gained significant popularity over the last decade. Its high level of abstraction makes it appealing for concurrent applications in parallel and distributed systems. However, designing a real-world actor framework that subsumes full scalability, strong reliability, and high resource efficiency requires many conceptual and algorithmic additives to the original model. In this paper, we report on designing and building CAF, the "C++ Actor Framework". CAF targets at providing a concurrent and distributed native environment for scaling up to very large, high-performance applications, and equally well down to small constrained systems. We present the key specifications and design concepts---in particular a message-transparent architecture, type-safe message interfaces, and pattern matching facilities---that make native actors a viable approach for many robust, elastic, and highly distributed developments. We demonstrate the feasibility of CAF in three scenarios: first for elastic, upscaling environments, second for including heterogeneous hardware like GPGPUs, and third for distributed runtime systems. Extensive performance evaluations indicate ideal runtime behaviour for up to 64 cores at very low memory footprint, or in the presence of GPUs. In these tests, CAF continuously outperforms the competing actor environments Erlang, Charm++, SalsaLite, Scala, ActorFoundry, and even the OpenMPI.Comment: 33 page

Improving the Performance of User-level Runtime Systems for Concurrent Applications

Concurrency is an essential part of many modern large-scale software systems. Applications must handle millions of simultaneous requests from millions of connected devices. Handling such a large number of concurrent requests requires runtime systems that efficiently man- age concurrency and communication among tasks in an application across multiple cores. Existing low-level programming techniques provide scalable solutions with low overhead, but require non-linear control flow. Alternative approaches to concurrent programming, such as Erlang and Go, support linear control flow by mapping multiple user-level execution entities across multiple kernel threads (M:N threading). However, these systems provide comprehensive execution environments that make it difficult to assess the performance impact of user-level runtimes in isolation. This thesis presents a nimble M:N user-level threading runtime that closes this con- ceptual gap and provides a software infrastructure to precisely study the performance impact of user-level threading. Multiple design alternatives are presented and evaluated for scheduling, I/O multiplexing, and synchronization components of the runtime. The performance of the runtime is evaluated in comparison to event-driven software, system- level threading, and other user-level threading runtimes. An experimental evaluation is conducted using benchmark programs, as well as the popular Memcached application. The user-level runtime supports high levels of concurrency without sacrificing application performance. In addition, the user-level scheduling problem is studied in the context of an existing actor runtime that maps multiple actors to multiple kernel-level threads. In particular, two locality-aware work-stealing schedulers are proposed and evaluated. It is shown that locality-aware scheduling can significantly improve the performance of a class of applications with a high level of concurrency. In general, the performance and resource utilization of large-scale concurrent applications depends on the level of concurrency that can be expressed by the programming model. This fundamental effect is studied by refining and customizing existing concurrency models

Ray: A Distributed Execution Engine for the Machine Learning Ecosystem

In recent years, growing data volumes and more sophisticated computational procedures have greatly increased the demand for computational power. Machine learning and artificial intelligence applications, for example, are notorious for their computational requirements. At the same time, Moores law is ending and processor speeds are stalling. As a result, distributed computing has become ubiquitous. While the cloud makes distributed hardware infrastructure widely accessible and therefore offers the potential of horizontal scale, developing these distributed algorithms and applications remains surprisingly hard. This is due to the inherent complexity of concurrent algorithms, the engineering challenges that arise when communicating between many machines, the requirements like fault tolerance and straggler mitigation that arise at large scale and the lack of a general-purpose distributed execution engine that can support a wide variety of applications.In this thesis, we study the requirements for a general-purpose distributed computation model and present a solution that is easy to use yet expressive and resilient to faults. At its core our model takes familiar concepts from serial programming, namely functions and classes, and generalizes them to the distributed world, therefore unifying stateless and stateful distributed computation. This model not only supports many machine learning workloads like training or serving, but is also a good t for cross-cutting machine learning applications like reinforcement learning and data processing applications like streaming or graph processing. We implement this computational model as an open-source system called Ray, which matches or exceeds the performance of specialized systems in many application domains, while also offering horizontally scalability and strong fault tolerance properties

Reducing cache coherence traffic with a NUMA-aware runtime approach

Cache Coherent NUMA (ccNUMA) architectures are a widespread paradigm due to the benefits they provide for scaling core count and memory capacity. Also, the flat memory address space they offer considerably improves programmability. However, ccNUMA architectures require sophisticated and expensive cache coherence protocols to enforce correctness during parallel executions, which trigger a significant amount of on- and off-chip traffic in the system. This paper analyses how coherence traffic may be best constrained in a large, real ccNUMA platform comprising 288 cores through the use of a joint hardware/software approach. For several benchmarks, we study coherence traffic in detail under the influence of an added hierarchical cache layer in the directory protocol combined with runtime managed NUMA-aware scheduling and data allocation techniques to make most efficient use of the added hardware. The effectiveness of this joint approach is demonstrated by speedups of 3.14× to 9.97× and coherence traffic reductions of up to 99% in comparison to NUMA-oblivious scheduling and data allocation.This work has been supported by the Spanish Government (Severo Ochoa grants SEV2015-0493), by the Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation (contracts TIN2015-65316-P), by the Generalitat de Catalunya (contracts 2014-SGR-1051 and 2014-SGR-1272), by the RoMoL ERC Advanced Grant (GA 321253) and the European HiPEAC Network of Excellence. The Mont-Blanc project receives funding from the EU’s H2020 Framework Programme (H2020/2014-2020) under grant agreement no 671697. M. Moretó has been partially supported by the Ministry of Economy and Competitiveness under Juan de la Cierva postdoctoral fellowship number JCI-2012-15047. M. Casas is supported by the Secretary for Universities and Research of the Ministry of Economy and Knowledge of the Government of Catalonia and the Cofund programme of the Marie Curie Actions of the 7th R&D Framework Programme of the European Union (Contract 2013 BP B 00243).Peer ReviewedPostprint (author's final draft

Exploiting the structure of communication in actor systems

We propose a novel algorithm for minimizing communication costs of multi-threaded and distributed actor systems, to gain performance advantage by dynamically adapting to the structure of actor communication. We provide an implementation in Circo, an open source actor system, and show promising experimental results

React++: A Lightweight Actor Framework in C++

Distributed software remains susceptible to data races and poor scalability because of the widespread use of locks and other low-level synchronization primitives. Furthermore, using this programming approach is known to break encapsulation offered by object-oriented programming. Actors present an alternative model of concurrent computation by serving as building blocks with a higher level of abstraction. They encapsulate concurrent logic in their behaviors and rely only on asynchronous exchange of messages for synchronization, preventing a broad range of concurrent issues by eschewing locks. Existing actor frameworks often seem to focus on CPU-bound workloads and lack an actor-oriented I/O infrastructure. The purpose of this thesis is to investigate the scalability of user-space I/O operations carried out by actors. It presents an experimental actor framework named React++, with an M:N runtime for cooperative scheduling of actors and an integrated I/O subsystem. Load distribution is policy-driven and uses a variant of the randomized work-stealing algorithm. The evaluation of the framework is carried out in three stages. First, the efficiency of message delivery, scheduling and load balancing is assessed by a set of micro-benchmarks, where React++ retains a competitive score against several well-known actor frameworks. Next, a web server built on React++ is shown to be on par with its fastest event-driven counterparts in the TechEmpower plaintext benchmark. Finally, the runtime of an existing messaging library (ZeroMQ) is augmented with React++, replacing the backend and delegating all network I/O to actors without incurring any substantial overhead