Facilitating distributed generation in Australia - the opportunities and challenges of cogeneration

Stationary energy, predominately electricity and thermal energy production, is one of the largest sectors of primary energy consumption in industrialised countries. Electrification has delivered economic growth and improved standards of living while thermal energy provides comfort and sustains industrial growth. However, a range of economic, market, technological and environmental issues exist. In Australia, these include declining energy productivity and increasing energy prices, changing demand and usage patterns, accommodating emerging forms of electricity production and contribution to long-term climate change. Solutions to these issues include adoption of a mix of technical, regulatory and investmentrelated initiatives. In particular, the adoption of decentralised energy technologies, principally gas-fired cogeneration (also known as Combined Heat and Power or CHP) and solar photovoltaic (PV) appear to offer substantial technological and economic benefits over incumbent centralised technologies (especially, coal-fired generation). The adoption ofthese technologies may be enhanced by improved government incentives and regulatory reforms and a better appreciation of factors that influence the availability of investment capital. This study aims to identify the potential rate and extent of adoption of distributed generation in general and CHP in particular, by comparison with theoretical diffusion rates of other energy technologies. It seeks to expose and explore other factors which impact adoption, including supporting government policy and the need for demonstration to overcome technical risk. Finally, it examines the potential economic and environmental benefits associated with the large scale adoption of distributed energy technology. Through a mixture of literature review, analysis of a range of technical feasibility studies and a detailed case study, the extent to which distributed technologies may be adopted, and their financial, efficiency and environmental benefits are assessed. The analysis suggests that cogeneration is technically and economically feasible and is therefore a critical transition technology for the Australian stationary energy sector while distributed generation technologies in general, which are relatively mature and low risk, have the potential to substantially reduce emissions while also reducing costs and network and centralised generation investments

CCHP System Performance Based on Economic Analysis, Energy Conservation, and Emission Analysis

This chapter includes the basic configuration of combined cooling heat and power (CCHP) systems and provides performance analysis based on energy, economic and environmental consideration applicable to buildings. The performance parameter for energy savings measure used for the analysis is primary energy consumption (PEC) of CCHP system. Parameters used for economic analysis are the simple payback period (SPP), annual savings (AS), internal rate of return (IRR) and equivalent uniform annual savings (EUAS). The emissions savings are determined for carbon dioxide (CDE), nitrogen oxides (NOX), and methane (CH4). Economic, energy, and emission performance criteria have been utilized for three types prime movers in five different building types, consisting of a primary school, a restaurant, a small hotel, an outpatient clinic, and a small office building. Performance for economic analysis indicated that economic savings career, unlike ICE, which is preferable in terms of economic and energy savings, emission analysis shows that micro-turbine poses be observed for the ICE in all building types, and the micro-turbine in some building types. For all types of prime mover based CCHP systems, lower CO2 emission is observed for all building types. However, emission characteristics compared to other types of prime movers. Overall, CCHP system with optimum use of its appropriate prime movers can provide potential energy, economic and environmental benefit in buildings

Performance of micro gas turbine trigeneration system and photovoltaic hybrid based system in remote area applications

The technological advancements in power generation are primarily undertaken to overcome the drawbacks of conventional energy system while diversifying energy sources to ensure sustainability in future power generation. One of the alternatives proposed is to implement a hybrid system combining both photovoltaic and micro gas turbine in a trigeneration scheme, the PV-MGT(TGS) hybrid system. Basically, it is a distributed energy system that is capable of producing electricity, hot water and cooling air simultaneously. The system integrates various components including micro gas turbine, photovoltaic, heat exchanger, hot and chilled water storage, absorption chiller and auxiliaries’ components such as boiler and batteries. Although there were several studies conducted on analyzing the performances of PV-MGT(TGS) hybrid system for urban residential and office application, however, there is lack of existing studies describing performances of the respective system for remote area application. Thus, this research intended to analyze the performance of PV-MGT(TGS) hybrid system for remote area applications to ensure its feasibility for such applications. The main objectives of the research are to investigate the technical performances of PV-MGT(TGS) hybrid system for annual operation in remote area through simulations.as well as to analyze the energetic, economic and environmental performances of the hybrid system in a remote area application. The system is analyzed based on the performances obtained from an application-based simulation. Whereby, a resort located on Tioman Island is selected as the demand site. The energy data and weather data of the demand site are acquired through site visit survey, estimation tool and real-time monitoring system respectively. The mathematical model of each component in the hybrid system is derived from manufacturer’s data sheets, published experimental data and thermodynamic modeling. The simulations are performed in the Simulink® environment where the mathematical models, operation algorithms of the proposed dispatch strategy and collected data are integrated. The simulations are carried out on an hourly basis for 8760-hour period (1 Year). Subsequently, based on the simulation result, the energetic, economic and environmental performances of the hybrid system are evaluated through primary energy analysis, life cycle cost analysis and emission reduction index. The outcome of the research demonstrates that the PV-MGT(TGS) hybrid system are able to achieve 21.08% of primary energy saving than the conventional system throughout the year. It can be observed that the hybrid system achieved 81%, 57%, 75.6% of emission reduction of oxide of Nitrogen (NOx), carbon monoxide (CO) and carbon dioxide (CO2). as compared to the conventional system. However, the PV-MGT(TGS) hybrid system failed to achieve positive net profit under Life Cycle Cost Analysis

A PV/T and Heat Pump based trigeneration system model for residential applications

A solar trigeneration system, based on photovoltaic-thermal (PV/T) collectors, photovoltaic (PV) modules and a heat pump unit for heating and cooling, is modelled to forecast the thermal and electric yields of the system. The aim of the trigeneration system is to provide enough electricity, domestic hot water (DHW), heating and cooling power to meet the typical demand of an urban single family dwelling with limited roof area and allow the household to achieve a positive net energy status. The PV/T collectors and PV modules provide the electricity while the former also powers the DHW component of the trigeneration system. The heating and cooling components rely on a vapour compression cycle heat pump unit powered by electricity. In Fong et al. (2010), solar-powered electric compression refrigeration was found to have the most energy saving potential in subtropical climates. Thus, a heat pump based cooling system is a cost effective solution for residential applications in Lisbon,Portugal. Thus, according to the dwelling's location, construction details and energy demand patterns, the model computes the system's net results by comparing the dwelling demand with the trigeneration system supply. The paper presents a breakdown of the proposed trigeneration system model and describes each component briefly. Preliminary results produced by the model are presented and analysed in order to identify possible ways of improving the overall system performance

Operation optimization and dynamic simulation of cogeneration systems with thermal energy storage based on an innovative operation strategy for residential applications

The ever increasing energy consumption of buildings, and of harmful CO2 emission, which causes global warming, necessitate the urgent need of energy conservation. Moreover, because of relatively low combustion efficiency and no abatement measures, emission factors of various pollutants, especially the incomplete combustion products, from buildings are much higher than those in other sectors. For these reasons, energy efficiency in buildings is today a prime objective for energy policy at regional, national and international levels. Polygeneration systems, by generating two or more energy products in a single integrated process, can offer potential benefits to humanity and environment, reducing greenhouse-gas emissions, increasing decentralization of energy supply at lower cost, improving energy security, and avoiding energy losses from electricity transmission and distribution networks. Therefore, in recent years such kind of systems has attracted much interest in building and residential sector applications. However, to address sustainability issues properly, it is important to consider the complexity of polygeneration systems due to the interdependence between different energy products, different types of energy resources and energy conversion devices, as well as the inclusion of storage units. Therefore, polygeneration is mainly associated with generation optimization and related to decision making about production strategies of energy systems. The choice of the operational strategy to use has to be made taking into account the objectives to be achieved, the available devices, and the considered time-period, and often it can strongly depend on local energy policies in terms of costs of energy resources, and provided incentives. This thesis presents a novel approach for improving, from the economical point of view, the operation of polygeneration systems, represented by residential natural gas fuelled Combined Heat and Power (CHP) systems. Optimization problems are formulated to find the optimized operation schedule of the CHP systems prime mover, aimed at the maximization of the economic savings obtained from the CHP systems with respect to the separate generation of electricity and heat. The sustainability of such approach is evaluated by means of environmental impact assessments, and its effectiveness is demonstrated through a dynamic simulation

Optimisation of stand-alone hybrid energy systems for power and thermal loads

Stand-alone hybrid energy systems are an attractive option for remote communities without a connection to a main power grid. However, the intermittent nature of solar and other renewable sources adversely affects the reliability with which these systems respond to load demands. Hybridisation, achieved by combining renewables with combustion-based supplementary prime movers, improves the ability to meet electric load requirements. In addition, the waste heat generated from backup Internal Combustion Engines or Micro Gas Turbines can be used to satisfy local heating and cooling loads. As a result, there is an expectation that the overall efficiency and Greenhouse Gas Emissions of stand-alone systems can be significantly improved through waste heat recovery. The aims of this PhD project are to identify how incremental increases to the hardware complexity of hybridised stand-alone energy systems affect their cost, efficiency, and CO2 footprint. The research analyses a range of systems, from those designed to meet only power requirements to others satisfying power and heating (Combined Heat and Power), or power plus both heating and cooling (Combined Cooling, Heating, and Power). The majority of methods used focus on MATLAB-based Genetic Algorithms (GAs). The modelling deployed finds the optimal selection of hardware configurations which satisfy single- or multi-objective functions (i.e. Cost of Energy, energy efficiency, and exergy efficiency). This is done in the context of highly dynamic meteorological (e.g. solar irradiation) and load data (i.e. electric, heating, and cooling). Results indicate that the type of supplementary prime movers (ICEs or MGT) and their minimum starting thresholds have insignificant effects on COE but have some effects on Renewable Penetration (RP), Life Cycle Emissions (LCE), CO2 emissions, and waste heat generation when the system is sized meeting electric load only. However, the transient start-up time of supplementary prime movers and temporal resolution have no significant effects on sizing optimisation. The type of Power Management Strategies (Following Electric Load-FEL, and Following Electric and Following Thermal Load- FEL/FTL) affect overall Combined Heating and Power (CHP) efficiency and meeting thermal demand through recovered heat for a system meeting electric and heating load with response to a specific load meeting reliability (Loss of Power Supply Probability-LPSP). However, the PMS has marginal effects on COE. The Electric to Thermal Load Ratio (ETLR) has no effects on COE for PV/Batt/ICE but strongly affects PV/Batt/MGT-based hybridised CHP systems. The higher thermal than the electric loads lead to higher efficiency and better environmental footprint. Results from this study also indicate that for a stand-alone hybridised system operating under FEL/FTL type PMS, the power only system has lower cost compared to the CHP and the Combined Cooling, Heating, and Power (CCHP) systems. This occurs at the expense of overall energy and exergy efficiencies. Additionally, the relative magnitude of heating and cooling loads have insignificant effects on COE for PV/Batt/ICE-based system configurations, however this substantially affects PV/Batt/MGT-based hybridised CCHP systems. Although there are no significant changes in the overall energy efficiency of CCHP systems in relation to variations to heating and cooling loads, systems with higher heating demand than cooling demand lead to better environmental benefits and renewable penetration at the cost of Duty Factor. Results also reveal that the choice of objective functions do not affect the system optimisation significantly

Modelling environment for the design and optimisation of energy polygeneration systems

The optimal design and operation of an energy supply system is very important for the matching of the energy production and consumption especially in the residential-tertiary sector characterized by an energy demand with a high variability. The main objective of this thesis is to develop an optimisation environment for the preliminary design and analysis of polygeneration plants. The optimisation models are organized in different units represented by blocks that can be connected between each other to create the flowsheet of the polygeneration system. To characterize the energy demand in the residential and tertiary sector a graphic methodology has been developed to select typical energy demand days from a yearly energy demand profile. The environment developed has been applied to two case studies: a small scale polygeneration plant using a liquid desiccant system for air conditioning and a polygeneration plant connected to a district heating and cooling network

Prospects of distributed electricity generation and services based on small scale biomass systems in Ghana

Access to energy is crucial to human welfare; no residential, commercial or industrial activity can be conceived without energy supply. At the same time, current dependence on fossil fuels and their negative effects on global climate claim for urgent alternatives. The situation in Sub-Saharan Africa is poignant: over half of the population, mainly in rural areas, live without access to electricity services. Crop residues from farming communities in those areas are unused; while technology for electricity production from agricultural biomass is progressing, managing decentralised rural electricity projects is still a challenge, especially in developing countries like Ghana, given the variety and complexity of the factors conditioning biomass to energy supply chains. Such complexity has been previously formulated in academic exercises, but with limited practical applicability for energy planners, practitioners and investors. This research has deployed a holistic approach to biomass-to-energy planning, yet flexible to adapt to different regulatory scenarios and energy supply configurations. A qualitative framework has been developed, taking into consideration four critical components: social development, organisational/institutional, technical, and financial, with their respective metrics. Then, the framework has been applied to three real case study configurations in Ghana, involving primary data collection, sustainability modelling and discussion of the techno-economic feasibility results with policy makers and practitioners. The first configuration consists in decentralised power generation using crop residues from clustered smallholder farms in 14 districts in Ghana; the number of clustered farms, reference residue yields, and residue densities are determined to assess the distances within which it would be feasible to supply feedstock to biomass power plants. The findings show that a minimum of 22 to 54 larger (10 ha) farms would need to be clustered to enable an economically viable biomass supply to a 1000 kWe plant. Financial analyses indicate that such investment would not be viable under the current renewable feed-in-tariff rates in Ghana; increased tariff by 25% or subsidies from a minimum 30% of investment cost are needed to ensure viability using internal rate of return as an indicator. Carbon finance options are also discussed. The second configuration focuses on co- and tri-generation from clustered crop residues. Techno-economic results show that 600 kW and 1 MW biomass fuelled plants to generate power, heating (for cassava or maize drying) and cooling (to refrigerate tomatoes) are feasible, considering a minimum 20% yearly profit for investors’ equity. Additional income between 29 and 64 US $/tonne of crop residue would be possible for farmers if a minimum of 60% of the heat produced can be traded. The consideration of carbon financing under the most common traded prices has little impact on the project results; if more favourable schemes (like the Swedish carbon tax) are considered, the viability of co- and tri-generation plants run on agro residue can be possible even with a low level of residual heat sales. The third configuration analyses minigrid electricity generation and services based on biomass gasification in five Ghanaian communities. Results show that the projected electricity demand compares favourably with the potential supply from available crop residues. Project financing via 100% private funding would not be viable under current national uniform tariffs; however, by applying an end-user tariff equal to the current expenditure on electricity-equivalent uses in the communities, a subsidy of about 35% on initial investment would enable a private entrepreneur an internal rate of return of 15%, whereas a 60% subsidy could enable internal rate of return of 25%. The outcomes of this research have triggered the interest of Ghanaian and international policy makers, developers and private investors.L'accés a l'energia és crucial per al benestar humà, no es pot concebre cap activitat residencial, comercial o industrial sense subministrament d'energia. Alhora, la dependència actual dels combustibles fòssils i els seus efectes negatius sobre el clima global reclamen alternatives urgents. La situació a l'Àfrica Subsahariana és punyent: més de la meitat de la població, principalment rural, viu sense accés a serveis elèctrics. Tanmateix, en aquestes zones abunden les restes agrícoles. Tot i que la tecnologia per a la producció d'electricitat a partir de biomassa agrícola avança, la promoció de l’electrificació rural descentralitzada continua sent un repte, especialment en països en desenvolupament com Ghana, atesa la varietat i la complexitat de factors que condicionen l’aprofitament energètic de la biomassa. Aquesta complexitat s'ha tractat en exercicis acadèmics, però amb poca aplicabilitat pràctica per a planificadors d'energia, promotors i inversors. A fi de contribuir a una millor planificació i presa de decisions, aquesta Tesi desplega un marc integral d’anàlisi tenint en compte quatre components (desenvolupament social, organitzatiu/institucional, tècnic, i financer), flexible per adaptar-se a diferents configuracions de subministrament d'energia i escenaris reguladors. Aquest marc s'ha aplicat a tres casos reals a Ghana, recollint dades de camp, modelitzant la viabilitat tecno-econòmica i debatent els resultats amb promotors públics i privats. La primera configuració consisteix en la generació elèctrica a partir de restes agrícoles de petites plantacions rurals, en 14 districtes a Ghana, on s?ha determinat la biomassa disponible i la seva localització per calcular les distàncies màximes que permetrien la rendibilitat de petites centrals elèctriques. Els resultats indiquen que un mínim de 22 a 54 plantacions (de 10 ha. cadascuna) haurien d'agrupar-se per permetre un subministrament de biomassa econòmicament viable a una planta de 1000 kWe. Financerament aquesta inversió no seria viable amb les tarifes actuals d’injecció a xarxa; un increment d’aquesta tarifa en un 25%, o bé una subvenció mínima del 30% del cost d'inversió són necessàries per garantir la viabilitat. La segona configuració se centra en la co- i la tri-generació a partir de restes agrícoles. Els resultats de l’anàlisi tècnic-econòmica mostren que centrals de 600 kW i 1 MW per autogenerar electricitat, calor (per assecar mandioca o de blat de moro) i fred (per refrigerar tomàquets) són factibles, fins i tot aportant un retorn anual mínim del 20% per a inversors externs. A més de l’electricitat, en cas de poder vendre com a mínim un 60% de la calor produïda, es podria pagar entre 29 i 64 USD per tona de biomassa. La consideració de bons de carboni a preus habituals de mercat internacional té poc impacte en els resultats del projecte; si es consideren esquemes més favorables (com els bons de carboni a Suècia), la viabilitat de les plantes de co-i tri-generació a partir de restes agrícoles seria possible fins i tot amb un baix nivell de vendes de calor residual. La tercera configuració tracta el servei elèctric amb microxarxes basades en la gasificació de restes agrícoles de comunitats rurals. Els resultats de l’anàlisi en 5 comunitats mostren que el potencial de generació elèctrica a partir de la biomassa disponible supera la demanda elèctrica projectada. El finançament només a partir d’aportacions privades no seria viable amb les tarifes nacionals de consum elèctric actuals; en canvi, si s’aplica una tarifa de consum igual a la despesa actual en usos equivalents a l’electricitat (p.ex. llanternes i piles, bateries de cotxe), una subvenció del 35% sobre la inversió inicial permetria una taxa interna de retorn del 15% a inversors privats, mentre que un 60% la subvenció permetria una taxa interna de retorn del 25%.Els resultats d'aquesta investigació han estat considerats pels grups d'interès de Ghana dins de la formulació de polítiques i regulacions d'electrificació rural, i perspectives de trigeneració i els minigresos de biomassa també han desencadenat l'interès dels inversors privats internacionals i ghanesosPostprint (published version

Prospects of distributed electricity generation and services based on small scale biomass systems in Ghana

Access to energy is crucial to human welfare; no residential, commercial or industrial activity can be conceived without energy supply. At the same time, current dependence on fossil fuels and their negative effects on global climate claim for urgent alternatives. The situation in Sub-Saharan Africa is poignant: over half of the population, mainly in rural areas, live without access to electricity services. Crop residues from farming communities in those areas are unused; while technology for electricity production from agricultural biomass is progressing, managing decentralised rural electricity projects is still a challenge, especially in developing countries like Ghana, given the variety and complexity of the factors conditioning biomass to energy supply chains. Such complexity has been previously formulated in academic exercises, but with limited practical applicability for energy planners, practitioners and investors. This research has deployed a holistic approach to biomass-to-energy planning, yet flexible to adapt to different regulatory scenarios and energy supply configurations. A qualitative framework has been developed, taking into consideration four critical components: social development, organisational/institutional, technical, and financial, with their respective metrics. Then, the framework has been applied to three real case study configurations in Ghana, involving primary data collection, sustainability modelling and discussion of the techno-economic feasibility results with policy makers and practitioners. The first configuration consists in decentralised power generation using crop residues from clustered smallholder farms in 14 districts in Ghana; the number of clustered farms, reference residue yields, and residue densities are determined to assess the distances within which it would be feasible to supply feedstock to biomass power plants. The findings show that a minimum of 22 to 54 larger (10 ha) farms would need to be clustered to enable an economically viable biomass supply to a 1000 kWe plant. Financial analyses indicate that such investment would not be viable under the current renewable feed-in-tariff rates in Ghana; increased tariff by 25% or subsidies from a minimum 30% of investment cost are needed to ensure viability using internal rate of return as an indicator. Carbon finance options are also discussed. The second configuration focuses on co- and tri-generation from clustered crop residues. Techno-economic results show that 600 kW and 1 MW biomass fuelled plants to generate power, heating (for cassava or maize drying) and cooling (to refrigerate tomatoes) are feasible, considering a minimum 20% yearly profit for investors’ equity. Additional income between 29 and 64 US $/tonne of crop residue would be possible for farmers if a minimum of 60% of the heat produced can be traded. The consideration of carbon financing under the most common traded prices has little impact on the project results; if more favourable schemes (like the Swedish carbon tax) are considered, the viability of co- and tri-generation plants run on agro residue can be possible even with a low level of residual heat sales. The third configuration analyses minigrid electricity generation and services based on biomass gasification in five Ghanaian communities. Results show that the projected electricity demand compares favourably with the potential supply from available crop residues. Project financing via 100% private funding would not be viable under current national uniform tariffs; however, by applying an end-user tariff equal to the current expenditure on electricity-equivalent uses in the communities, a subsidy of about 35% on initial investment would enable a private entrepreneur an internal rate of return of 15%, whereas a 60% subsidy could enable internal rate of return of 25%. The outcomes of this research have triggered the interest of Ghanaian and international policy makers, developers and private investors.L'accés a l'energia és crucial per al benestar humà, no es pot concebre cap activitat residencial, comercial o industrial sense subministrament d'energia. Alhora, la dependència actual dels combustibles fòssils i els seus efectes negatius sobre el clima global reclamen alternatives urgents. La situació a l'Àfrica Subsahariana és punyent: més de la meitat de la població, principalment rural, viu sense accés a serveis elèctrics. Tanmateix, en aquestes zones abunden les restes agrícoles. Tot i que la tecnologia per a la producció d'electricitat a partir de biomassa agrícola avança, la promoció de l’electrificació rural descentralitzada continua sent un repte, especialment en països en desenvolupament com Ghana, atesa la varietat i la complexitat de factors que condicionen l’aprofitament energètic de la biomassa. Aquesta complexitat s'ha tractat en exercicis acadèmics, però amb poca aplicabilitat pràctica per a planificadors d'energia, promotors i inversors. A fi de contribuir a una millor planificació i presa de decisions, aquesta Tesi desplega un marc integral d’anàlisi tenint en compte quatre components (desenvolupament social, organitzatiu/institucional, tècnic, i financer), flexible per adaptar-se a diferents configuracions de subministrament d'energia i escenaris reguladors. Aquest marc s'ha aplicat a tres casos reals a Ghana, recollint dades de camp, modelitzant la viabilitat tecno-econòmica i debatent els resultats amb promotors públics i privats. La primera configuració consisteix en la generació elèctrica a partir de restes agrícoles de petites plantacions rurals, en 14 districtes a Ghana, on s?ha determinat la biomassa disponible i la seva localització per calcular les distàncies màximes que permetrien la rendibilitat de petites centrals elèctriques. Els resultats indiquen que un mínim de 22 a 54 plantacions (de 10 ha. cadascuna) haurien d'agrupar-se per permetre un subministrament de biomassa econòmicament viable a una planta de 1000 kWe. Financerament aquesta inversió no seria viable amb les tarifes actuals d’injecció a xarxa; un increment d’aquesta tarifa en un 25%, o bé una subvenció mínima del 30% del cost d'inversió són necessàries per garantir la viabilitat. La segona configuració se centra en la co- i la tri-generació a partir de restes agrícoles. Els resultats de l’anàlisi tècnic-econòmica mostren que centrals de 600 kW i 1 MW per autogenerar electricitat, calor (per assecar mandioca o de blat de moro) i fred (per refrigerar tomàquets) són factibles, fins i tot aportant un retorn anual mínim del 20% per a inversors externs. A més de l’electricitat, en cas de poder vendre com a mínim un 60% de la calor produïda, es podria pagar entre 29 i 64 USD per tona de biomassa. La consideració de bons de carboni a preus habituals de mercat internacional té poc impacte en els resultats del projecte; si es consideren esquemes més favorables (com els bons de carboni a Suècia), la viabilitat de les plantes de co-i tri-generació a partir de restes agrícoles seria possible fins i tot amb un baix nivell de vendes de calor residual. La tercera configuració tracta el servei elèctric amb microxarxes basades en la gasificació de restes agrícoles de comunitats rurals. Els resultats de l’anàlisi en 5 comunitats mostren que el potencial de generació elèctrica a partir de la biomassa disponible supera la demanda elèctrica projectada. El finançament només a partir d’aportacions privades no seria viable amb les tarifes nacionals de consum elèctric actuals; en canvi, si s’aplica una tarifa de consum igual a la despesa actual en usos equivalents a l’electricitat (p.ex. llanternes i piles, bateries de cotxe), una subvenció del 35% sobre la inversió inicial permetria una taxa interna de retorn del 15% a inversors privats, mentre que un 60% la subvenció permetria una taxa interna de retorn del 25%.Els resultats d'aquesta investigació han estat considerats pels grups d'interès de Ghana dins de la formulació de polítiques i regulacions d'electrificació rural, i perspectives de trigeneració i els minigresos de biomassa també han desencadenat l'interès dels inversors privats internacionals i ghaneso