Integrating and Ranking Uncertain Scientific Data

Mediator-based data integration systems resolve exploratory queries by joining data elements across sources. In the presence of uncertainties, such multiple expansions can quickly lead to spurious connections and incorrect results. The BioRank project investigates formalisms for modeling uncertainty during scientific data integration and for ranking uncertain query results. Our motivating application is protein function prediction. In this paper we show that: (i) explicit modeling of uncertainties as probabilities increases our ability to predict less-known or previously unknown functions (though it does not improve predicting the well-known). This suggests that probabilistic uncertainty models offer utility for scientific knowledge discovery; (ii) small perturbations in the input probabilities tend to produce only minor changes in the quality of our result rankings. This suggests that our methods are robust against slight variations in the way uncertainties are transformed into probabilities; and (iii) several techniques allow us to evaluate our probabilistic rankings efficiently. This suggests that probabilistic query evaluation is not as hard for real-world problems as theory indicates

Scalable Probabilistic Similarity Ranking in Uncertain Databases (Technical Report)

This paper introduces a scalable approach for probabilistic top-k similarity ranking on uncertain vector data. Each uncertain object is represented by a set of vector instances that are assumed to be mutually-exclusive. The objective is to rank the uncertain data according to their distance to a reference object. We propose a framework that incrementally computes for each object instance and ranking position, the probability of the object falling at that ranking position. The resulting rank probability distribution can serve as input for several state-of-the-art probabilistic ranking models. Existing approaches compute this probability distribution by applying a dynamic programming approach of quadratic complexity. In this paper we theoretically as well as experimentally show that our framework reduces this to a linear-time complexity while having the same memory requirements, facilitated by incremental accessing of the uncertain vector instances in increasing order of their distance to the reference object. Furthermore, we show how the output of our method can be used to apply probabilistic top-k ranking for the objects, according to different state-of-the-art definitions. We conduct an experimental evaluation on synthetic and real data, which demonstrates the efficiency of our approach

Doctor of Philosophy

dissertationWe are living in an age where data are being generated faster than anyone has previously imagined across a broad application domain, including customer studies, social media, sensor networks, and the sciences, among many others. In some cases, data are generated in massive quantities as terabytes or petabytes. There have been numerous emerging challenges when dealing with massive data, including: (1) the explosion in size of data; (2) data have increasingly more complex structures and rich semantics, such as representing temporal data as a piecewise linear representation; (3) uncertain data are becoming a common occurrence for numerous applications, e.g., scientific measurements or observations such as meteorological measurements; (4) and data are becoming increasingly distributed, e.g., distributed data collected and integrated from distributed locations as well as data stored in a distributed file system within a cluster. Due to the massive nature of modern data, it is oftentimes infeasible for computers to efficiently manage and query them exactly. An attractive alternative is to use data summarization techniques to construct data summaries, where even efficiently constructing data summaries is a challenging task given the enormous size of data. The data summaries we focus on in this thesis include the histogram and ranking operator. Both data summaries enable us to summarize a massive dataset to a more succinct representation which can then be used to make queries orders of magnitude more efficient while still allowing approximation guarantees on query answers. Our study has focused on the critical task of designing efficient algorithms to summarize, query, and manage massive data

Cleaning uncertain data for top-k queries

The information managed in emerging applications, such as sensor networks, location-based services, and data integration, is inherently imprecise. To handle data uncertainty, probabilistic databases have been recently developed. In this paper, we study how to quantify the ambiguity of answers returned by a probabilistic top-k query. We develop efficient algorithms to compute the quality of this query under the possible world semantics. We further address the cleaning of a probabilistic database, in order to improve top-k query quality. Cleaning involves the reduction of ambiguity associated with the database entities. For example, the uncertainty of a temperature value acquired from a sensor can be reduced, or cleaned, by requesting its newest value from the sensor. While this 'cleaning operation' may produce a better query result, it may involve a cost and fail. We investigate the problem of selecting entities to be cleaned under a limited budget. Particularly, we propose an optimal solution and several heuristics. Experiments show that the greedy algorithm is efficient and close to optimal. © 2013 IEEE.published_or_final_versio

The uncertain representation ranking framework for concept-based video retrieval

Concept based video retrieval often relies on imperfect and uncertain concept detectors. We propose a general ranking framework to define effective and robust ranking functions, through explicitly addressing detector uncertainty. It can cope with multiple concept-based representations per video segment and it allows the re-use of effective text retrieval functions which are defined on similar representations. The final ranking status value is a weighted combination of two components: the expected score of the possible scores, which represents the risk-neutral choice, and the scores’ standard deviation, which represents the risk or opportunity that the score for the actual representation is higher. The framework consistently improves the search performance in the shot retrieval task and the segment retrieval task over several baselines in five TRECVid collections and two collections which use simulated detectors of varying performance

Similarity processing in multi-observation data

Many real-world application domains such as sensor-monitoring systems for environmental research or medical diagnostic systems are dealing with data that is represented by multiple observations. In contrast to single-observation data, where each object is assigned to exactly one occurrence, multi-observation data is based on several occurrences that are subject to two key properties: temporal variability and uncertainty. When defining similarity between data objects, these properties play a significant role. In general, methods designed for single-observation data hardly apply for multi-observation data, as they are either not supported by the data models or do not provide sufficiently efficient or effective solutions. Prominent directions incorporating the key properties are the fields of time series, where data is created by temporally successive observations, and uncertain data, where observations are mutually exclusive. This thesis provides research contributions for similarity processing - similarity search and data mining - on time series and uncertain data. The first part of this thesis focuses on similarity processing in time series databases. A variety of similarity measures have recently been proposed that support similarity processing w.r.t. various aspects. In particular, this part deals with time series that consist of periodic occurrences of patterns. Examining an application scenario from the medical domain, a solution for activity recognition is presented. Finally, the extraction of feature vectors allows the application of spatial index structures, which support the acceleration of search and mining tasks resulting in a significant efficiency gain. As feature vectors are potentially of high dimensionality, this part introduces indexing approaches for the high-dimensional space for the full-dimensional case as well as for arbitrary subspaces. The second part of this thesis focuses on similarity processing in probabilistic databases. The presence of uncertainty is inherent in many applications dealing with data collected by sensing devices. Often, the collected information is noisy or incomplete due to measurement or transmission errors. Furthermore, data may be rendered uncertain due to privacy-preserving issues with the presence of confidential information. This creates a number of challenges in terms of effectively and efficiently querying and mining uncertain data. Existing work in this field either neglects the presence of dependencies or provides only approximate results while applying methods designed for certain data. Other approaches dealing with uncertain data are not able to provide efficient solutions. This part presents query processing approaches that outperform existing solutions of probabilistic similarity ranking. This part finally leads to the application of the introduced techniques to data mining tasks, such as the prominent problem of probabilistic frequent itemset mining.Viele Anwendungsgebiete, wie beispielsweise die Umweltforschung oder die medizinische Diagnostik, nutzen Systeme der Sensorüberwachung. Solche Systeme müssen oftmals in der Lage sein, mit Daten umzugehen, welche durch mehrere Beobachtungen repräsentiert werden. Im Gegensatz zu Daten mit nur einer Beobachtung (Single-Observation Data) basieren Daten aus mehreren Beobachtungen (Multi-Observation Data) auf einer Vielzahl von Beobachtungen, welche zwei Schlüsseleigenschaften unterliegen: Zeitliche Veränderlichkeit und Datenunsicherheit. Im Bereich der Ähnlichkeitssuche und im Data Mining spielen diese Eigenschaften eine wichtige Rolle. Gängige Lösungen in diesen Bereichen, die für Single-Observation Data entwickelt wurden, sind in der Regel für den Umgang mit mehreren Beobachtungen pro Objekt nicht anwendbar. Der Grund dafür liegt darin, dass diese Ansätze entweder nicht mit den Datenmodellen vereinbar sind oder keine Lösungen anbieten, die den aktuellen Ansprüchen an Lösungsqualität oder Effizienz genügen. Bekannte Forschungsrichtungen, die sich mit Multi-Observation Data und deren Schlüsseleigenschaften beschäftigen, sind die Analyse von Zeitreihen und die Ähnlichkeitssuche in probabilistischen Datenbanken. Während erstere Richtung eine zeitliche Ordnung der Beobachtungen eines Objekts voraussetzt, basieren unsichere Datenobjekte auf Beobachtungen, die sich gegenseitig bedingen oder ausschließen. Diese Dissertation umfasst aktuelle Forschungsbeiträge aus den beiden genannten Bereichen, wobei Methoden zur Ähnlichkeitssuche und zur Anwendung im Data Mining vorgestellt werden. Der erste Teil dieser Arbeit beschäftigt sich mit Ähnlichkeitssuche und Data Mining in Zeitreihendatenbanken. Insbesondere werden Zeitreihen betrachtet, welche aus periodisch auftretenden Mustern bestehen. Im Kontext eines medizinischen Anwendungsszenarios wird ein Ansatz zur Aktivitätserkennung vorgestellt. Dieser erlaubt mittels Merkmalsextraktion eine effiziente Speicherung und Analyse mit Hilfe von räumlichen Indexstrukturen. Für den Fall hochdimensionaler Merkmalsvektoren stellt dieser Teil zwei Indexierungsmethoden zur Beschleunigung von ähnlichkeitsanfragen vor. Die erste Methode berücksichtigt alle Attribute der Merkmalsvektoren, während die zweite Methode eine Projektion der Anfrage auf eine benutzerdefinierten Unterraum des Vektorraums erlaubt. Im zweiten Teil dieser Arbeit wird die Ähnlichkeitssuche im Kontext probabilistischer Datenbanken behandelt. Daten aus Sensormessungen besitzen häufig Eigenschaften, die einer gewissen Unsicherheit unterliegen. Aufgrund von Mess- oder übertragungsfehlern sind gemessene Werte oftmals unvollständig oder mit Rauschen behaftet. In diversen Szenarien, wie beispielsweise mit persönlichen oder medizinisch vertraulichen Daten, können Daten auch nachträglich von Hand verrauscht werden, so dass eine genaue Rekonstruktion der ursprünglichen Informationen nicht möglich ist. Diese Gegebenheiten stellen Anfragetechniken und Methoden des Data Mining vor einige Herausforderungen. In bestehenden Forschungsarbeiten aus dem Bereich der unsicheren Datenbanken werden diverse Probleme oftmals nicht beachtet. Entweder wird die Präsenz von Abhängigkeiten ignoriert, oder es werden lediglich approximative Lösungen angeboten, welche die Anwendung von Methoden für sichere Daten erlaubt. Andere Ansätze berechnen genaue Lösungen, liefern die Antworten aber nicht in annehmbarer Laufzeit zurück. Dieser Teil der Arbeit präsentiert effiziente Methoden zur Beantwortung von Ähnlichkeitsanfragen, welche die Ergebnisse absteigend nach ihrer Relevanz, also eine Rangliste der Ergebnisse, zurückliefern. Die angewandten Techniken werden schließlich auf Problemstellungen im probabilistischen Data Mining übertragen, um beispielsweise das Problem des Frequent Itemset Mining unter Berücksichtigung des vollen Gehalts an Unsicherheitsinformation zu lösen

Non-Compositional Term Dependence for Information Retrieval

Modelling term dependence in IR aims to identify co-occurring terms that are too heavily dependent on each other to be treated as a bag of words, and to adapt the indexing and ranking accordingly. Dependent terms are predominantly identified using lexical frequency statistics, assuming that (a) if terms co-occur often enough in some corpus, they are semantically dependent; (b) the more often they co-occur, the more semantically dependent they are. This assumption is not always correct: the frequency of co-occurring terms can be separate from the strength of their semantic dependence. E.g. "red tape" might be overall less frequent than "tape measure" in some corpus, but this does not mean that "red"+"tape" are less dependent than "tape"+"measure". This is especially the case for non-compositional phrases, i.e. phrases whose meaning cannot be composed from the individual meanings of their terms (such as the phrase "red tape" meaning bureaucracy). Motivated by this lack of distinction between the frequency and strength of term dependence in IR, we present a principled approach for handling term dependence in queries, using both lexical frequency and semantic evidence. We focus on non-compositional phrases, extending a recent unsupervised model for their detection [21] to IR. Our approach, integrated into ranking using Markov Random Fields [31], yields effectiveness gains over competitive TREC baselines, showing that there is still room for improvement in the very well-studied area of term dependence in IR

Rhetorical relations for information retrieval

Typically, every part in most coherent text has some plausible reason for its presence, some function that it performs to the overall semantics of the text. Rhetorical relations, e.g. contrast, cause, explanation, describe how the parts of a text are linked to each other. Knowledge about this socalled discourse structure has been applied successfully to several natural language processing tasks. This work studies the use of rhetorical relations for Information Retrieval (IR): Is there a correlation between certain rhetorical relations and retrieval performance? Can knowledge about a document's rhetorical relations be useful to IR? We present a language model modification that considers rhetorical relations when estimating the relevance of a document to a query. Empirical evaluation of different versions of our model on TREC settings shows that certain rhetorical relations can benefit retrieval effectiveness notably (> 10% in mean average precision over a state-of-the-art baseline)