Comparison of laryngoscopic, glottal and vibratory parameters among Estill qualities – Case study

Estill Voice Training (EVT) is an effective educational system for developing and controlling distinct voice qualities used in contemporary commercial singing. EVT teaches six vocal qualities that differ at 13 levels. This study aims to investigate whether the distinct vocal qualities taught by EVT can be systematically differentiated based on laryngoscopic observations and vocal fold oscillation parameters. To investigate the differences in six EVT qualities, laryngeal dimensions and glottal area waveform parameters were measured in a single female subject who performed it in one-octave scale. Glottis Analysis Tools (GAT) were used to measure these parameters and phonovibrograms were obtained from the analysis. The resulting data were subjected to factor analysis to identify the systematic differences between EVT qualities. High-speed videolaryngoscopy analysis revealed a significant influence of vocal qualities on vocal fold oscillations. The factor analysis of the data identified three factors based on laryngeal dimension and four factors derived from GAT parameters. The first GAT factor was influenced by posterior adduction and distinguished belt quality from other qualities, suggesting a significant influence of the aryepiglottic sphincter. The second GAT factor contained parameters derived from glottal length and amplitude, suggesting a relationship not only with vocal registers but also with laryngeal height. The third GAT factor was best related to body-cover figure and phonation type (membranous medialization), while the fourth GAT factor was related to the amplitude-length-ratio. These findings suggest that vocal fold oscillations can be used to distinguish between Estill voice qualities

The influence of the position of the laryngeal endoscope laryngeal on videokymography

Videokymography is a new high-speed imaging technique to investigate vocal fold vibration. The system has been considered useful in the analysis of irregular signals, making it possible to observe left-right asymmetries, open quotient, propagation of mucosal waves, and movement of the upper and lower margins. The aim of the present study was to verify the correspondence of the videokymographic images with larynx exposition angle variation. Three Brazilian adult female subjects, with no vocal complains, were evaluated. Videokymographic images were obtained with the laryngeal endoscope 90o positioned on the measuring line, perpendicular to the glottal axis - zero degree, during a sustained ae vowel, using habitual frequency and intensity. The procedure was repeated twice and adjusted by rotating the camera in fifteen degrees from the perpendicular line to the right and to the left. The results showed clear differences depending on the position of the endoscope, suggesting the standardization of laryngeal exposition to interpretate videokymographic images correctly.A videoquimografia é considerada a mais recente tecnologia na semiologia avançada da laringe. A videoquimografia utiliza-se de tecnologia digital para a análise ultra-rápida da vibração das pregas vocais. A imagem apresentada é a referência de uma única linha, representando um estreito segmento horizontal da imagem laríngea. A videoquimografia avalia todos os tipos de irregularidades de vibração, identifica pequenas assimetrias esquerda-direita, diferenças no quociente de abertura ao longo das pregas vocais, propagação lateral da onda mucosa e movimentação das margens superior e inferior da onda de mucosa das pregas vocais. O objetivo do presente estudo foi verificar a correspondência das imagens obtidas na videoquimografia, com variação do ângulo de exposição da laringe em relação ao telescópio. Foram analisados três indivíduos do sexo feminino, sem queixa vocal. As imagens videoquimográficas foram registradas com o telescópio laríngeo de 90o posicionado na linha média, perpendicular à glote - zero grau, durante a emissão de uma vogal sustentada é, em freqüência e intensidade habituais. O procedimento foi repetido mais duas vezes, porém com rotação de quinze graus do telescópio, no sentido horário, deslocando-se o laringoscópio à direita da linha média do paciente e, no sentido anti-horário, à esquerda. Os resultados obtidos indicaram diferenças evidentes nas imagens obtidas, o que demanda uma padronização da exposição laríngea para a interpretação da videoquimografia.Universidade Federal de São Paulo (UNIFESP) EPM ORLUNIFESP CFFa CEVCentro de Estudos da Voz de São Paulo Curso de Especialização do CEVUniversidade Federal de São Paulo (UNIFESP) Escola Paulista de Medicina Otorrinolaringologia e Cirurgia de cabeça e pescoçoUNIFESP, EPM, ORLUNIFESP, CFFa CEVUNIFESP, EPM, Otorrinolaringologia e Cirurgia de cabeça e pescoçoSciEL

A high-speed laryngoscopic investigation of aryepiglottic trilling

Six aryepiglottic trills with varied laryngeal parameters were recorded using high-speed laryngoscopy to investigate the nature of the oscillatory behavior of the upper margin of the epilaryngeal tube. Image analysis techniques were applied to extract data about the patterns of aryepiglottic fold oscillation, with a focus on the oscillatory frequencies of the folds. The acoustic impact of aryepiglottic trilling is also considered, along with possible interactions between the aryepiglottic vibration and vocal fold vibration during the voiced trill. Overall, aryepiglottic trilling is deemed to be correctly labeled as a trill in phonetic terms, while also acting as a means to alter the quality of voicing to be auditorily harsh. In terms of its characterization, aryepiglottic vibration is considerably irregular, but it shows indications of contributing quasi-harmonic excitation of the vocal tract, particularly noticeable under conditions of glottal voicelessness. Aryepiglottic vibrations appear to be largely independent of glottal vibration in terms of oscillatory frequency but can be increased in frequency by increasing overall laryngeal constriction. There is evidence that aryepiglottic vibration induces an alternating vocal fold vibration pattern. It is concluded that aryepiglottic trilling, like ventricular phonation, should be regarded as a complex, if highly irregular, sound source

Assessment of vocal fold mobility using dynamic magnetic resonance imaging and ultrasound in healthy volunteers

Purpose: To verify the value of dynamic magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) sequences, fast field echo (FFE), and balanced gradient echo (true fast imaging with steady-state free precession - TRUFI) in the evaluation of vocal fold mobility in healthy volunteers, against ultrasound examination (US) as the reference test. Material and methods: Vocal fold mobility in 35 healthy volunteers (age 20-59 years, 20 women and 15 men) with no history of laryngeal disorders and neck surgeries was determined by means of US and MRI during normal breathing and phonation of the "hiiii" sound. US images were used to determine the glottic angles. During MRI two dynamic sequences, fast field echo and balanced gradient echo, were applied to determine the minimum and maximum values of the glottic angles, along with the rima glottidis area, separately for the right and left compartments. Due to differences in larynx anatomy, the abovementioned parameters were analysed separately for women and men. Results: No significant differences were observed between the glottic angle values obtained during US and dynamic MRI (FFE and TRUFI sequences). Regardless of the dynamic MRI sequence used, a positive correlation was found between the maximum values of glottic angle and the rima glottidis area. This correlation was strong and statistically significant among men, but not in women. Conclusions: Dynamic MRI of vocal folds using FFE and TRUFI sequence is an accurate method for the objective evaluation of rima glottidis width

Acoustic and videoendoscopic techniques to improve voice assessment via relative fundamental frequency

Quantitative measures of laryngeal muscle tension are needed to improve assessment and track clinical progress. Although relative fundamental frequency (RFF) shows promise as an acoustic estimate of laryngeal muscle tension, it is not yet transferable to the clinic. The purpose of this work was to refine algorithmic estimation of RFF, as well as to enhance the knowledge surrounding the physiological underpinnings of RFF. The first study used a large database of voice samples collected from 227 speakers with voice disorders and 256 typical speakers to evaluate the effects of fundamental frequency estimation techniques and voice sample characteristics on algorithmic RFF estimation. By refining fundamental frequency estimation using the Auditory Sawtooth Waveform Inspired Pitch Estimator—Prime (Auditory-SWIPE′) algorithm and accounting for sample characteristics via the acoustic measure, pitch strength, algorithmic errors related to the accuracy and precision of RFF were reduced by 88.4% and 17.3%, respectively. The second study sought to characterize the physiological factors influencing acoustic outputs of RFF estimation. A group of 53 speakers with voice disorders and 69 typical speakers each produced the utterance, /ifi/, while simultaneous recordings were collected using a microphone and flexible nasendoscope. Acoustic features calculated via the microphone signal were examined in reference to the physiological initiation and termination of vocal fold vibration. The features that corresponded with these transitions were then implemented into the RFF algorithm, leading to significant improvements in the precision of the RFF algorithm to reflect the underlying physiological mechanisms for voicing offsets (p < .001, V = .60) and onsets (p < .001, V = .54) when compared to manual RFF estimation. The third study further elucidated the physiological underpinnings of RFF by examining the contribution of vocal fold abduction to RFF during intervocalic voicing offsets. Vocal fold abductory patterns were compared to RFF values in a subset of speakers from the second study, comprising young adults, older adults, and older adults with Parkinson’s disease. Abductory patterns were not significantly different among the three groups; however, vocal fold abduction was observed to play a significant role in measures of RFF at voicing offset. By improving algorithmic estimation and elucidating aspects of the underlying physiology affecting RFF, this work adds to the utility of RFF for use in conjunction with current clinical techniques to assess laryngeal muscle tension.2021-09-29T00:00:00