Exact and Approximated Log Alignments for Processes with Inter-case Dependencies

The execution of different cases of a process is often restricted by inter-case dependencies through e.g., queueing or shared resources. Various high-level Petri net formalisms have been proposed that are able to model and analyze coevolving cases. In this paper, we focus on a formalism tailored to conformance checking through alignments, which introduces challenges related to constraints the model should put on interacting process instances and on resource instances and their roles. We formulate requirements for modeling and analyzing resource-constrained processes, compare several Petri net extensions that allow for incorporating inter-case constraints. We argue that the Resource Constrained $\nu$-net is an appropriate formalism to be used the context of conformance checking, which traditionally aligns cases individually failing to expose deviations on inter-case dependencies. We provide formal mathematical foundations of the globally aligned event log based on theory of partially ordered sets and propose an approximation technique based on the composition of individually aligned cases that resolves inter-case violations locally

Executable system architecting using systems modeling language in conjunction with Colored Petri Nets - a demonstration using the GEOSS network centric system

Models and simulation furnish abstractions to manage complexities allowing engineers to visualize the proposed system and to analyze and validate system behavior before constructing it. Unified Modeling Language (UML) and its systems engineering extension, Systems Modeling Language (SysML), provide a rich set of diagrams for systems specification. However, the lack of executable semantics of such notations limits the capability of analyzing and verifying defined specifications. This research has developed an executable system architecting framework based on SysML-CPN transformation, which introduces dynamic model analysis into SysML modeling by mapping SysML notations to Colored Petri Net (CPN), a graphical language for system design, specification, simulation, and verification. A graphic user interface was also integrated into the CPN model to enhance the model-based simulation. A set of methodologies has been developed to achieve this framework. The aim is to investigate system wide properties of the proposed system, which in turn provides a basis for system reconfiguration --Abstract, page iii

Täpne ja tõhus protsessimudelite automaatne koostamine sündmuslogidest

Töötajate igapäevatöö koosneb tegevustest, mille eesmärgiks on teenuste pakkumine või toodete valmistamine. Selliste tegevuste terviklikku jada nimetatakse protsessiks. Protsessi kvaliteet ja efektiivsus mõjutab otseselt kliendi kogemust – tema arvamust ja hinnangut teenusele või tootele. Kliendi kogemus on eduka ettevõtte arendamise oluline tegur, mis paneb ettevõtteid järjest rohkem pöörama tähelepanu oma protsesside kirjeldamisele, analüüsimisele ja parendamisele. Protsesside kirjeldamisel kasutatakse tavaliselt visuaalseid vahendeid, sellisel kujul koostatud kirjeldust nimetatakse protsessimudeliks. Kuna mudeli koostaja ei suuda panna kirja kõike erandeid, mis võivad reaalses protsessis esineda, siis ei ole need mudelid paljudel juhtudel terviklikud. Samuti on probleemiks suur töömaht - inimese ajakulu protsessimudeli koostamisel on suur. Protsessimudelite automaatne koostamine (protsessituvastus) võimaldab genereerida protsessimudeli toetudes tegevustega seotud andmetele. Protsessituvastus aitab meil vähendada protsessimudeli loomisele kuluvat aega ja samuti on tulemusena tekkiv mudel (võrreldes käsitsi tehtud mudeliga) kvaliteetsem. Protsessituvastuse tulemusel loodud mudeli kvaliteet sõltub nii algandmete kvaliteedist kui ka protsessituvastuse algoritmist. Antud doktoritöös anname ülevaate erinevatest protsessituvastuse algoritmidest. Toome välja puudused ja pakume välja uue algoritmi Split Miner. Võrreldes olemasolevate algoritmidega on Splint Miner kiirem ja annab tulemuseks kvaliteetsema protsessimudeli. Samuti pakume välja uue lähenemise automaatselt koostatud protsessimudeli korrektsuse hindamiseks, mis on võrreldes olemasolevate meetoditega usaldusväärsem. Doktoritöö näitab, kuidas kasutada optimiseerimise algoritme protsessimudeli korrektsuse suurendamiseks.Everyday, companies’ employees perform activities with the goal of providing services (or products) to their customers. A sequence of such activities is known as business process. The quality and the efficiency of a business process directly influence the customer experience. In a competitive business environment, achieving a great customer experience is fundamental to be a successful company. For this reason, companies are interested in identifying their business processes to analyse and improve them. To analyse and improve a business process, it is generally useful to first write it down in the form of a graphical representation, namely a business process model. Drawing such process models manually is time-consuming because of the time it takes to collect detailed information about the execution of the process. Also, manually drawn process models are often incomplete because it is difficult to uncover every possible execution path in the process via manual data collection. Automated process discovery allows business analysts to exploit process' execution data to automatically discover process models. Discovering high-quality process models is extremely important to reduce the time spent enhancing them and to avoid mistakes during process analysis. The quality of an automatically discovered process model depends on both the input data and the automated process discovery application that is used. In this thesis, we provide an overview of the available algorithms to perform automated process discovery. We identify deficiencies in existing algorithms, and we propose a new algorithm, called Split Miner, which is faster and consistently discovers more accurate process models than existing algorithms. We also propose a new approach to measure the accuracy of automatically discovered process models in a fine-grained manner, and we use this new measurement approach to optimize the accuracy of automatically discovered process models.https://www.ester.ee/record=b530061

Verification of soundness and other properties of business processes

In this thesis we focus on improving current modeling and verification techniques for complex business processes. The objective of the thesis is to consider several aspects of real-life business processes and give specific solutions to cope with their complexity. In particular, we address verification of a proper termination property for workflows, called generalized soundness. We give a new decision procedure for generalized soundness that improves the original decision procedure. The new decision procedure reports on the decidability status of generalized soundness and returns a counterexample in case the workflow net is not generalized sound. We report on experimental results obtained with the prototype implementation we made and describe how to verify large workflows compositionally, using reduction rules. Next, we concentrate on modeling and verification of adaptive workflows — workflows that are able to change their structure at runtime, for instance when some exceptional events occur. In order to model the exception handling properly and allow structural changes of the system in a modular way, we introduce a new class of nets, called adaptive workflow nets. Adaptive workflow nets are a special type of Nets in Nets and they allow for creation, deletion and transformation of net tokens at runtime and for two types of synchronizations: synchronization on proper termination and synchronization on exception. We define some behavioral properties of adaptive workflow nets: soundness and circumspectness and employ an abstraction to reduce the verification of these properties to the verification of behavioral properties of a finite state abstraction. Further, we study how formal methods can help in understanding and designing business processes. We investigate this for the extended event-driven process chains (eEPCs), a popular industrial business process language used in the ARIS Toolset. Several semantics have been proposed for EPCs. However, most of them concentrated solely on the control flow. We argue that other aspects of business processes must also be taken into account in order to analyze eEPCs and propose a semantics that takes data and time information from eEPCs into account. Moreover, we provide a translation of eEPCs to Timed Colored Petri nets in order to facilitate verification of eEPCs. Finally, we discuss modeling issues for business processes whose behavior may depend on the previous behavior of the process, history which is recorded by workflow management systems as a log. To increase the precision of models with respect to modeling choices depending on the process history, we introduce history-dependent guards. The obtained business processes are called historydependent processes.We introduce a logic, called LogLogics for the specification of guards based on a log of a current running process and give an evaluation algorithm for such guards. Moreover, we show how these guards can be used in practice and define LogLogics patterns for properties that occur most commonly in practice

A Visual Language for Composable Simulation Scenarios

Modeling and Simulation plays an important role in how the Air Force trains and fights, Scenarios are used in simulation to give users the ability to specify entities and behaviors that should be simulated by a model: however, building and understanding scenarios can be a difficult and time-consuming process, furthermore, as composable simulations become more prominent, the need for a common descriptor for simulation scenarios has become evident. In order to reduce the complexity of creating and understanding simulation scenarios, a visual language was created, The research on visual languages presented in this thesis examines methods of visually specifying the high-level behavior of entities in scenarios and how to represent the hierarchy of the entities in scenarios. Through a study of current behavior specification techniques and the properties of mission-level simulation scenarios, Simulation Behavior Specification Diagrams (SBSD) were developed to represent the behavior of entities in scenarios, Additionally, the information visualization technique of treemaps was adapted to represent the hierarchy of entities in scenarios, After completing case studies on scenarios for the OneSAF simulation model, SBSDs and the application of treemaps to scenarios was considered successful, SBSD diagrams accurately represented the behavior of entities in the simulation scenarios and through software can be converted into code for use by simulation models, The treemap displayed the hierarchy of the entities along with information about the relative size of the entities when applied to simulation scenarios

A bibliography on formal methods for system specification, design and validation

Literature on the specification, design, verification, testing, and evaluation of avionics systems was surveyed, providing 655 citations. Journal papers, conference papers, and technical reports are included. Manual and computer-based methods were employed. Keywords used in the online search are listed

A graph based process model measurement framework using scheduling theory

Software development processes, as a means of ensuring software quality and productivity, have been widely accepted within the software development community; software process modeling, on the other hand, continues to be a subject of interest in the research community. Even with organizations that have achieved higher SEI maturity levels, processes are by and large described in documents and reinforced as guidelines or laws governing software development activities. The lack of industry-wide adaptation of software process modeling as part of development activities can be attributed to two major reasons: lack of forecast power in the (software) process modeling and lack of integration mechanism for the described process to seamlessly interact with daily development activities. This dissertation describes a research through which a framework has been established where processes can be manipulated, measured, and dynamically modified by interacting with project management techniques and activities in an integrated process modeling environment, thus closing the gap between process modeling and software development. In this research, processes are described using directed graphs, similar to the techniques with CPM. This way, the graphs can be manipulated visually while the properties of the graphs-can be used to check their validity. The partial ordering and the precedence relationship of the tasks in the graphs are similar to the one studied in other researches [Delcambre94] [Mills96]. Measurements of the effectiveness of the processes are added in this research. These measurements provide bases for the judgment when manipulating the graphs to produce or modify a process. Software development can be considered as activities related to three sets: a set of tasks (τ), a set of resources (ρ), and a set of constraints (y). The process, P, is then a function of all the sets interacting with each other: P = {τ, ρ, y). The interactions of these sets can be described in terms of different machine models using scheduling theory. While trying to produce an optimal solution satisfying a set of prescribed conditions using the analytical method would lead to a practically non-feasible formulation, many heuristic algorithms in scheduling theory combined with manual manipulation of the tasks can help to produce a reasonable good process, the effectiveness of which is reflected through a set of measurement criteria, in particular, the make-span, the float, and the bottlenecks. Through an integrated process modeling environment, these measurements can be obtained in real time, thus providing a feedback loop during the process execution. This feedback loop is essential for risk management and control

The Design of Graphical Process Modeling Languages: from Free Composition to Modular Construction

Un Process Modeling Language (PML) grafico \ue8 un linguaggio specializzato per la modellazione di sistemi software in termini di processi. Tale linguaggio \ue8 detto grafico perch\ue8 la rappresentazione principale dei modelli consiste in diagrammi ottenuti combinando costrutti grafici e componenti precedentemente definiti. Un Process-Aware Information System (PAIS) \ue8 un sistema software guidato da modelli di processi con lo scopo di coordinare e supportare gli agenti nello svolgimento delle loro attivit\ue0. Tale sistema \ue8 responsabile della gestione simulatanea di diverse istanze di processo e del bilanciamento delle risorse disponibili. Un PML \ue8 l'interfaccia principale di un PAIS ed un aspetto fondamentale della sua progettazione, poich\ue8 \ue8 utilizzato da utenti finali, consulenti, e sviluppatori al fine di comprendere, implementare ed eseguire processi complessi. L'utilizzo di tecnologie PAIS pu\uf2 essere considerevolmente limitato dalle carenze di un PML nel descrivere casi complessi. Lo scopo principale della tesi \ue8 migliorare la progettazione di PML grafici al fine di costruire PAIS pi\uf9 efficaci. Tale obiettivo \ue8 perseguito attraverso tre percorsi interconnessi: per prima cosa, i PMLs esistenti e la loro teoria sottostante sono stati analizzati al fine di individuare pregi e difetti; successivamente, una tecnica di verifica molto diffusa in questo campo \ue8 stata consolidata ed estesa con una nuova tecnica per la correzione automatica di processi. Infine, una diversa soluzione per il design di PMLs \ue8 stata esplorata attraverso la definizione di un nuovo linguaggio, chiamato NestFlow, che migliora la modularit\ue0 e la comprensibilit\ue0 attraverso l'adozione di un approccio strutturato alla modellazione di processi. Un approccio modulare \ue8 possible solo se gli aspetti legati ai dati sono accettati come aspetto primario nel design di un PML. NestFlow cerca di semplificare l'attivit\ue0 di modellazione fornendo un insieme integrato di costrutti di control-flow e data-flow, promuovendo i secondi come aspetti principali nella modellazione di processi.A graphical Process Modeling Language (PML) is a language tailored for modeling software systems by means of process models. It is said to be graphical because the primary representation of models are diagrams obtained combining visual constructs and previously defined components. Graphical PMLs are interesting as they open the design space to new geometric representations of complex interrelated aspects like concurrency and interaction. A Process-Aware Information System (PAIS) is a software system driven by explicit process models with the aim to coordinate and support agents in performing their activities. It is responsible for managing several process model instances at the same time balancing the available resources. A PML is the primary interface of a PAIS and a main concern in its design, because it is used by end-users, consultants, and developers for understanding, implementing and enacting complex processes. The adoption of PAIS technology may be severely limited by the weakness of PMLs in describing complex use cases. The overall aim of this thesis is to improve the design of graphical PMLs in order to engineer more effective PAISs. This goal is pursued following three intertwined paths: firstly, mainstream PMLs and their theoretical foundations are analyzed for exposing their features and limits; secondly, a widespread PML verification method is consolidated and then extended with a novel technique for automating process correction; finally, an alternative PML design solution is explored through a proof-of-concept language, called NestFlow, that improves both modularity and comprehensibility by providing a more structured modeling approach. A modular approach is only possible if data-flow dependencies are accepted as a main concern in PML design. NestFlow tries to ease the modeling activity by providing a comprehensive set of tightly integrated control-flow and data-flow constructs, promoting the latter as first-class citizens in process modeling