Memory Subsystem Optimization Techniques for Modern High-Performance General-Purpose Processors

abstract: General-purpose processors propel the advances and innovations that are the subject of humanity’s many endeavors. Catering to this demand, chip-multiprocessors (CMPs) and general-purpose graphics processing units (GPGPUs) have seen many high-performance innovations in their architectures. With these advances, the memory subsystem has become the performance- and energy-limiting aspect of CMPs and GPGPUs alike. This dissertation identifies and mitigates the key performance and energy-efficiency bottlenecks in the memory subsystem of general-purpose processors via novel, practical, microarchitecture and system-architecture solutions. Addressing the important Last Level Cache (LLC) management problem in CMPs, I observe that LLC management decisions made in isolation, as in prior proposals, often lead to sub-optimal system performance. I demonstrate that in order to maximize system performance, it is essential to manage the LLCs while being cognizant of its interaction with the system main memory. I propose ReMAP, which reduces the net memory access cost by evicting cache lines that either have no reuse, or have low memory access cost. ReMAP improves the performance of the CMP system by as much as 13%, and by an average of 6.5%. Rather than the LLC, the L1 data cache has a pronounced impact on GPGPU performance by acting as the bandwidth filter for the rest of the memory subsystem. Prior work has shown that the severely constrained data cache capacity in GPGPUs leads to sub-optimal performance. In this thesis, I propose two novel techniques that address the GPGPU data cache capacity problem. I propose ID-Cache that performs effective cache bypassing and cache line size selection to improve cache capacity utilization. Next, I propose LATTE-CC that considers the GPU’s latency tolerance feature and adaptively compresses the data stored in the data cache, thereby increasing its effective capacity. ID-Cache and LATTE-CC are shown to achieve 71% and 19.2% speedup, respectively, over a wide variety of GPGPU applications. Complementing the aforementioned microarchitecture techniques, I identify the need for system architecture innovations to sustain performance scalability of GPG- PUs in the face of slowing Moore’s Law. I propose a novel GPU architecture called the Multi-Chip-Module GPU (MCM-GPU) that integrates multiple GPU modules to form a single logical GPU. With intelligent memory subsystem optimizations tailored for MCM-GPUs, it can achieve within 7% of the performance of a similar but hypothetical monolithic die GPU. Taking a step further, I present an in-depth study of the energy-efficiency characteristics of future MCM-GPUs. I demonstrate that the inherent non-uniform memory access side-effects form the key energy-efficiency bottleneck in the future. In summary, this thesis offers key insights into the performance and energy-efficiency bottlenecks in CMPs and GPGPUs, which can guide future architects towards developing high-performance and energy-efficient general-purpose processors.Dissertation/ThesisDoctoral Dissertation Computer Science 201

Adaptive memory-side last-level GPU caching

Emerging GPU applications exhibit increasingly high computation demands which has led GPU manufacturers to build GPUs with an increasingly large number of streaming multiprocessors (SMs). Providing data to the SMs at high bandwidth puts significant pressure on the memory hierarchy and the Network-on-Chip (NoC). Current GPUs typically partition the memory-side last-level cache (LLC) in equally-sized slices that are shared by all SMs. Although a shared LLC typically results in a lower miss rate, we find that for workloads with high degrees of data sharing across SMs, a private LLC leads to a significant performance advantage because of increased bandwidth to replicated cache lines across different LLC slices. In this paper, we propose adaptive memory-side last-level GPU caching to boost performance for sharing-intensive workloads that need high bandwidth to read-only shared data. Adaptive caching leverages a lightweight performance model that balances increased LLC bandwidth against increased miss rate under private caching. In addition to improving performance for sharing-intensive workloads, adaptive caching also saves energy in a (co-designed) hierarchical two-stage crossbar NoC by power-gating and bypassing the second stage if the LLC is configured as a private cache. Our experimental results using 17 GPU workloads show that adaptive caching improves performance by 28.1% on average (up to 38.1%) compared to a shared LLC for sharing-intensive workloads. In addition, adaptive caching reduces NoC energy by 26.6% on average (up to 29.7%) and total system energy by 6.1% on average (up to 27.2%) when configured as a private cache. Finally, we demonstrate through a GPU NoC design space exploration that a hierarchical two-stage crossbar is both more power- and area-efficient than full and concentrated crossbars with the same bisection bandwidth, thus providing a low-cost cooperative solution to exploit workload sharing behavior in memory-side last-level caches

Improving the Performance and Energy Efficiency of GPGPU Computing through Adaptive Cache and Memory Management Techniques

Department of Computer Science and EngineeringAs the performance and energy efficiency requirement of GPGPUs have risen, memory management techniques of GPGPUs have improved to meet the requirements by employing hardware caches and utilizing heterogeneous memory. These techniques can improve GPGPUs by providing lower latency and higher bandwidth of the memory. However, these methods do not always guarantee improved performance and energy efficiency due to the small cache size and heterogeneity of the memory nodes. While prior works have proposed various techniques to address this issue, relatively little work has been done to investigate holistic support for memory management techniques. In this dissertation, we analyze performance pathologies and propose various techniques to improve memory management techniques. First, we investigate the effectiveness of advanced cache indexing (ACI) for high-performance and energy-efficient GPGPU computing. Specifically, we discuss the designs of various static and adaptive cache indexing schemes and present implementation for GPGPUs. We then quantify and analyze the effectiveness of the ACI schemes based on a cycle-accurate GPGPU simulator. Our quantitative evaluation shows that ACI schemes achieve significant performance and energy-efficiency gains over baseline conventional indexing scheme. We also analyze the performance sensitivity of ACI to key architectural parameters (i.e., capacity, associativity, and ICN bandwidth) and the cache indexing latency. We also demonstrate that ACI continues to achieve high performance in various settings. Second, we propose IACM, integrated adaptive cache management for high-performance and energy-efficient GPGPU computing. Based on the performance pathology analysis of GPGPUs, we integrate state-of-the-art adaptive cache management techniques (i.e., cache indexing, bypassing, and warp limiting) in a unified architectural framework to eliminate performance pathologies. Our quantitative evaluation demonstrates that IACM significantly improves the performance and energy efficiency of various GPGPU workloads over the baseline architecture (i.e., 98.1% and 61.9% on average, respectively) and achieves considerably higher performance than the state-of-the-art technique (i.e., 361.4% at maximum and 7.7% on average). Furthermore, IACM delivers significant performance and energy efficiency gains over the baseline GPGPU architecture even when enhanced with advanced architectural technologies (e.g., higher capacity, associativity). Third, we propose bandwidth- and latency-aware page placement (BLPP) for GPGPUs with heterogeneous memory. BLPP analyzes the characteristics of a application and determines the optimal page allocation ratio between the GPU and CPU memory. Based on the optimal page allocation ratio, BLPP dynamically allocate pages across the heterogeneous memory nodes. Our experimental results show that BLPP considerably outperforms the baseline and state-of-the-art technique (i.e., 13.4% and 16.7%) and performs similar to the static-best version (i.e., 1.2% difference), which requires extensive offline profiling.clos

Intra-cluster coalescing to reduce GPU NoC pressure

GPUs continue to increase the number of streaming multiprocessors (SMs) to provide increasingly higher compute capabilities. To construct a scalable crossbar network-on-chip (NoC) that connects the SMs to the memory controllers, a cluster structure is introduced in modern GPUs in which several SMs are grouped together to share a network port. Because of network port sharing, clustered GPUs face severe NoC congestion, which creates a critical performance bottleneck. In this paper, we target redundant network traffic to mitigate GPU NoC congestion. In particular, we observe that in many GPU-compute applications, different SMs in a cluster access shared data. Issuing redundant requests to access the same memory location wastes valuable NoC bandwidth - we find on average 19.4% (and up to 48%) of the requests to be redundant. To reduce redundant NoC traffic, we propose intracluster coalescing (ICC) to merge memory requests from different SMs in a cluster. Our evaluation results show that ICC achieves an average performance improvement of 9.7% (and up to 33%) over a conventional design

Intra-cluster coalescing and distributed-block scheduling to reduce GPU NoC pressure

GPUs continue to boost the number of streaming multiprocessors (SMs) to provide increasingly higher compute capabilities. To construct a scalable crossbar network-on-chip (NoC) that connects the SMs to the memory controllers, a cluster structure is introduced in modern GPUs in which several SMs are grouped together to share a network port. Because of network port sharing, clustered GPUs face severe NoC congestion, which creates a critical performance bottleneck. In this paper, we target redundant network traffic to mitigate GPU NoC congestion. In particular, we observe that in many GPU-compute applications, different SMs in a cluster access shared data. Sending redundant requests to access the same memory location wastes valuable NoC bandwidth-we find on average 19 percent (and up to 48 percent) of the requests to be redundant. To remove redundant NoC traffic, we propose distributed-block scheduling, intra-cluster coalescing (ICC) and the coalesced cache (CC) to coalesce L1 cache misses within and across SMs in a cluster, respectively. Our evaluation results show that distributed-block scheduling, ICC and CC are complementary and improve both performance and energy consumption. We report an average performance improvement of 15 percent (and up to 67 percent) while at the same time reducing system energy by 6 percent (and up to 19 percent) and improving the energy-delay product (EDP) by 19 percent on average (and up to 53 percent), compared to state-of-the-art distributed CTA scheduling

CD-Xbar : a converge-diverge crossbar network for high-performance GPUs

Modern GPUs feature an increasing number of streaming multiprocessors (SMs) to boost system throughput. How to construct an efficient and scalable network-on-chip (NoC) for future high-performance GPUs is particularly critical. Although a mesh network is a widely used NoC topology in manycore CPUs for scalability and simplicity reasons, it is ill-suited to GPUs because of the many-to-few-to-many traffic pattern observed in GPU-compute workloads. Although a crossbar NoC is a natural fit, it does not scale to large SM counts while operating at high frequency. In this paper, we propose the converge-diverge crossbar (CD-Xbar) network with round-robin routing and topology-aware concurrent thread array (CTA) scheduling. CD-Xbar consists of two types of crossbars, a local crossbar and a global crossbar. A local crossbar converges input ports from the SMs into so-called converged ports; the global crossbar diverges these converged ports to the last-level cache (LLC) slices and memory controllers. CD-Xbar provides routing path diversity through the converged ports. Round-robin routing and topology-aware CTA scheduling balance network traffic among the converged ports within a local crossbar and across crossbars, respectively. Compared to a mesh with the same bisection bandwidth, CD-Xbar reduces NoC active silicon area and power consumption by 52.5 and 48.5 percent, respectively, while at the same time improving performance by 13.9 percent on average. CD-Xbar performs within 2.9 percent of an idealized fully-connected crossbar. We further demonstrate CD-Xbar's scalability, flexibility and improved performance perWatt (by 17.1 percent) over state-of-the-art GPU NoCs which are highly customized and non-scalable

AN ARCHITECTURE EVALUATION AND IMPLEMENTATION OF A SOFT GPGPU FOR FPGAs

Embedded and mobile systems must be able to execute a variety of different types of code, often with minimal available hardware. Many embedded systems now come with a simple processor and an FPGA, but not more energy-hungry components, such as a GPGPU. In this dissertation we present FlexGrip, a soft architecture which allows for the execution of GPGPU code on an FPGA without the need to recompile the design. The architecture is optimized for FPGA implementation to effectively support the conditional and thread-based execution characteristics of GPGPU execution without FPGA design recompilation. This architecture supports direct CUDA compilation to a binary which is executable on the FPGA-based GPGPU. Our architecture is customizable, thus providing the FPGA designer with a selection of GPGPU cores which display performance versus area tradeoffs. This dissertation describes the FlexGrip architecture in detail and showcases the benefits by evaluating the design for a collection of five standard CUDA benchmarks which are compiled using standard GPGPU compilation tools. Speedups of 23x, on average, versus a MicroBlaze microprocessor are achieved for designs which take advantage of the conditional execution capabilities offered by FlexGrip. We also show FlexGrip can achieve an 80% average reduction of dynamic energy versus the MicroBlaze microprocessor. The dissertation furthers discussion by exploring application-customized versions of the soft GPGPU, thus exploiting the overlay architecture. We expand the architecture to multiple processors per GPGPU and optimizing away features which are not needed by certain classes of applications. These optimizations, which include the effective use of block RAMs and DSP blocks, are critical to the performance of FlexGrip. By implementing a 2 GPGPU design, we show speedups of 44x on average versus a MicroBlaze microprocessor. Application-customized versions of the soft GPGPU can be used to further reduce dynamic energy consumption by an average of 14%. To complete this thesis, we augmented a GPGPU cycle accurate simulator to emulate FlexGrip and evaluate different levels of cache design spaces. We show performance increases for select benchmarks, however, we also show that 64% and 45% of benchmarks exhibited performance decreases when L1D cache was enabled for the 1 SMP and 2 SMP configurations, and only one benchmark showed performance improvement when the L2 cache was enabled