An evaluation of intrusive instrumental intelligibility metrics

Instrumental intelligibility metrics are commonly used as an alternative to listening tests. This paper evaluates 12 monaural intrusive intelligibility metrics: SII, HEGP, CSII, HASPI, NCM, QSTI, STOI, ESTOI, MIKNN, SIMI, SIIB, and $\text{sEPSM}^\text{corr}$. In addition, this paper investigates the ability of intelligibility metrics to generalize to new types of distortions and analyzes why the top performing metrics have high performance. The intelligibility data were obtained from 11 listening tests described in the literature. The stimuli included Dutch, Danish, and English speech that was distorted by additive noise, reverberation, competing talkers, pre-processing enhancement, and post-processing enhancement. SIIB and HASPI had the highest performance achieving a correlation with listening test scores on average of $\rho=0.92$ and $\rho=0.89$, respectively. The high performance of SIIB may, in part, be the result of SIIBs developers having access to all the intelligibility data considered in the evaluation. The results show that intelligibility metrics tend to perform poorly on data sets that were not used during their development. By modifying the original implementations of SIIB and STOI, the advantage of reducing statistical dependencies between input features is demonstrated. Additionally, the paper presents a new version of SIIB called $\text{SIIB}^\text{Gauss}$, which has similar performance to SIIB and HASPI, but takes less time to compute by two orders of magnitude.Comment: Published in IEEE/ACM Transactions on Audio, Speech, and Language Processing, 201

Speech enhancement for robust automatic speech recognition: Evaluation using a baseline system and instrumental measures

Automatic speech recognition in everyday environments must be robust to significant levels of reverberation and noise. One strategy to achieve such robustness is multi-microphone speech enhancement. In this study, we present results of an evaluation of different speech enhancement pipelines using a state-of-the-art ASR system for a wide range of reverberation and noise conditions. The evaluation exploits the recently released ACE Challenge database which includes measured multichannel acoustic impulse responses from 7 different rooms with reverberation times ranging from 0.33 s to 1.34 s. The reverberant speech is mixed with ambient, fan and babble noise recordings made with the same microphone setups in each of the rooms. In the first experiment performance of the ASR without speech processing is evaluated. Results clearly indicate the deleterious effect of both noise and reverberation. In the second experiment, different speech enhancement pipelines are evaluated with relative word error rate reductions of up to 82%. Finally, the ability of selected instrumental metrics to predict ASR performance improvement is assessed. The best performing metric, Short-Time Objective Intelligibility Measure, is shown to have a Pearson correlation coefficient of 0.79, suggesting that it is a useful predictor of algorithm performance in these tests

Automatic speech-to-background ratio selection to maintain speech intelligibility in broadcasts using an objective intelligibility metric

While mixing, sound producers and audio professionals empirically set the speech-to-background ratio (SBR) based on rules of thumb and their own perception of sounds. There is no guarantee that the speech content will be intelligible for the general population consuming content over a wide variety of devices, however. In this study, an approach to automatically determine the appropriate SBR for a scene using an objective intelligibility metric is introduced. The model-estimated SBR needed for a preset minimum intelligibility level was compared to the listener-preferred SBR for a range of background sounds. It was found that an extra gain added to the model estimation is needed even for listeners with normal hearing. This gain is needed so an audio scene can be auditioned with comfort and without compromising the sound effects contributed by the background. When the background introduces little informational masking, the extra gain holds almost constant across the various background sounds. However, a larger gain is required for a background that induces informational masking, such as competing speech. The results from a final subjective rating study show that the model-estimated SBR with the additional gain, yields the same listening experience as the SBR preferred by listeners

Oesophageal speech: enrichment and evaluations

167 p.After a laryngectomy (i.e. removal of the larynx) a patient can no more speak in a healthy laryngeal voice. Therefore, they need to adopt alternative methods of speaking such as oesophageal speech. In this method, speech is produced using swallowed air and the vibrations of the pharyngo-oesophageal segment, which introduces several undesired artefacts and an abnormal fundamental frequency. This makes oesophageal speech processing difficult compared to healthy speech, both auditory processing and signal processing. The aim of this thesis is to find solutions to make oesophageal speech signals easier to process, and to evaluate these solutions by exploring a wide range of evaluation metrics.First, some preliminary studies were performed to compare oesophageal speech and healthy speech. This revealed significantly lower intelligibility and higher listening effort for oesophageal speech compared to healthy speech. Intelligibility scores were comparable for familiar and non-familiar listeners of oesophageal speech. However, listeners familiar with oesophageal speech reported less effort compared to non-familiar listeners. In another experiment, oesophageal speech was reported to have more listening effort compared to healthy speech even though its intelligibility was comparable to healthy speech. On investigating neural correlates of listening effort (i.e. alpha power) using electroencephalography, a higher alpha power was observed for oesophageal speech compared to healthy speech, indicating higher listening effort. Additionally, participants with poorer cognitive abilities (i.e. working memory capacity) showed higher alpha power.Next, using several algorithms (preexisting as well as novel approaches), oesophageal speech was transformed with the aim of making it more intelligible and less effortful. The novel approach consisted of a deep neural network based voice conversion system where the source was oesophageal speech and the target was synthetic speech matched in duration with the source oesophageal speech. This helped in eliminating the source-target alignment process which is particularly prone to errors for disordered speech such as oesophageal speech. Both speaker dependent and speaker independent versions of this system were implemented. The outputs of the speaker dependent system had better short term objective intelligibility scores, automatic speech recognition performance and listener preference scores compared to unprocessed oesophageal speech. The speaker independent system had improvement in short term objective intelligibility scores but not in automatic speech recognition performance. Some other signal transformations were also performed to enhance oesophageal speech. These included removal of undesired artefacts and methods to improve fundamental frequency. Out of these methods, only removal of undesired silences had success to some degree (1.44 \% points improvement in automatic speech recognition performance), and that too only for low intelligibility oesophageal speech.Lastly, the output of these transformations were evaluated and compared with previous systems using an ensemble of evaluation metrics such as short term objective intelligibility, automatic speech recognition, subjective listening tests and neural measures obtained using electroencephalography. Results reveal that the proposed neural network based system outperformed previous systems in improving the objective intelligibility and automatic speech recognition performance of oesophageal speech. In the case of subjective evaluations, the results were mixed - some positive improvement in preference scores and no improvement in speech intelligibility and listening effort scores. Overall, the results demonstrate several possibilities and new paths to enrich oesophageal speech using modern machine learning algorithms. The outcomes would be beneficial to the disordered speech community

Learning-Based Reference-Free Speech Quality Assessment for Normal Hearing and Hearing Impaired Applications

Accurate speech quality measures are highly attractive and beneficial in the design, fine-tuning, and benchmarking of speech processing algorithms, devices, and communication systems. Switching from narrowband telecommunication to wideband telephony is a change within the telecommunication industry which provides users with better speech quality experience but introduces a number of challenges in speech processing. Noise is the most common distortion on audio signals and as a result there have been a lot of studies on developing high performance noise reduction algorithms. Assistive hearing devices are designed to decrease communication difficulties for people with loss of hearing. As the algorithms within these devices become more advanced, it becomes increasingly crucial to develop accurate and robust quality metrics to assess their performance. Objective speech quality measurements are more attractive compared to subjective assessments as they are cost-effective and subjective variability is eliminated. Although there has been extensive research on objective speech quality evaluation for narrowband speech, those methods are unsuitable for wideband telephony. In the case of hearing-impaired applications, objective quality assessment is challenging as it has to be capable of distinguishing between desired modifications which make signals audible and undesired artifacts. In this thesis a model is proposed that allows extracting two sets of features from the distorted signal only. This approach which is called reference-free (nonintrusive) assessment is attractive as it does not need access to the reference signal. Although this benefit makes nonintrusive assessments suitable for real-time applications, more features need to be extracted and smartly combined to provide comparable accuracy as intrusive metrics. Two feature vectors are proposed to extract information from distorted signals and their performance is examined in three studies. In the first study, both feature vectors are trained on various portions of a noise reduction database for normal hearing applications. In the second study, the same investigation is performed on two sets of databases acquired through several hearing aids. Third study examined the generalizability of the proposed metrics on benchmarking four wireless remote microphones in a variety of environmental conditions. Machine learning techniques are deployed for training the models in the three studies. The studies show that one of the feature sets is robust when trained on different portions of the data from different databases and it also provides good quality prediction accuracy for both normal hearing and hearing-impaired applications

Recurrent neural networks for multi-microphone speech separation

This thesis takes the classical signal processing problem of separating the speech of a target speaker from a real-world audio recording containing noise, background interference — from competing speech or other non-speech sources —, and reverberation, and seeks data-driven solutions based on supervised learning methods, particularly recurrent neural networks (RNNs). Such speech separation methods can inject robustness in automatic speech recognition (ASR) systems and have been an active area of research for the past two decades. We particularly focus on applications where multi-channel recordings are available. Stand-alone beamformers cannot simultaneously suppress diffuse-noise and protect the desired signal from any distortions. Post-filters complement the beamformers in obtaining the minimum mean squared error (MMSE) estimate of the desired signal. Time-frequency (TF) masking — a method having roots in computational auditory scene analysis (CASA) — is a suitable candidate for post-filtering, but the challenge lies in estimating the TF masks. The use of RNNs — in particular the bi-directional long short-term memory (BLSTM) architecture — as a post-filter estimating TF masks for a delay-and-sum beamformer (DSB) — using magnitude spectral and phase-based features — is proposed. The data—recorded in 4 challenging realistic environments—from the CHiME-3 challenge is used. Two different TF masks — Wiener filter and log-ratio — are identified as suitable targets for learning. The separated speech is evaluated based on objective speech intelligibility measures: short-term objective intelligibility (STOI) and frequency-weighted segmental SNR (fwSNR). The word error rates (WERs) as reported by the previous state-of-the-art ASR back-end — when fed with the test data of the CHiME-3 challenge — are interpreted against the objective scores for understanding the relationships of the latter with the former. Overall, a consistent improvement in the objective scores brought in by the RNNs is observed compared to that of feed-forward neural networks and a baseline MVDR beamformer