28 research outputs found
Model checking for linear temporal logic: An efficient implementation
This report provides evidence to support the claim that model checking for linear temporal logic (LTL) is practically efficient. Two implementations of a linear temporal logic model checker is described. One is based on transforming the model checking problem into a satisfiability problem; the other checks an LTL formula for a finite model by computing the cross-product of the finite state transition graph of the program with a structure containing all possible models for the property. An experiment was done with a set of mutual exclusion algorithms and tested safety and liveness under fairness for these algorithms
Advancing the knowledge of local health care policy through the growth machine thesis.
A disciplined-configurative case study design was carried out to explore whether a growth machine exists and shapes local healthcare policy in Louisville. A historical analysis first explored whether a growth machine existed in Louisville in the past and shaped healthcare policy. Second, a network analysis was used to identify the recent contours of the Louisville growth machine. Third, qualitative interviews were conducted with central individuals as indicated by the social network analysis to assess the degree to which local healthcare policy is shaped and driven by the growth machine. The results show that Louisville has consistently had a growth machine which has shaped the limited local healthcare politics and policy allowed by the higher levels of government. The Federal Government\u27s policy to require pluralistic boards of average consumers on public health agencies actually has detached the growth machine as the local power structure from those agencies. The growth machine has not always had consensus due to differing growth agendas as demonstrated by the construction of Southwest Hospital, the break up of the University of Louisville Hospital management consortium, and the reorganization of the Louisville Medical Center Development Corporation. Regardless the growth machine has generally been able to keep the general public out of such decisions and in vi turn find new ways to be unified in the name of growth. Local government in Louisville was and continues to be a supportive player versus dominant player in the growth machine in local healthcare politics and has not been the driver of local healthcare policy
Legal knowledge-based systems: new directions in system design
This thesis examines and critiques the concept of 'legal knowledge-based’ systems. Work on legal knowledge-based systems is dominated by work in 'artificial intelligence and law’. It seeks to automate the application of law and to automate the solution of legal problems. Automation however, has proved elusive. In contrast to such automation, this thesis proposes the creation of legal knowledge-based systems based on the concept of augmentation of legal work. Focusing on systems that augment legal work opens new possibilities for system creation and use. To inform how systems might augment legal work, this thesis examines philosophy, psychology and legal theory for information they provide on how processes of legal reasoning operate. It is argued that, in contrast to conceptions of law adopted in artificial intelligence and law, 'sensemaking' provides a useful perspective with which to create systems. It is argued that visualisation, and particularly diagrams, are an important and under considered element of reasoning and that producing systems that support diagramming of processes of legal reasoning would provide useful support for legal work. This thesis reviews techniques for diagramming aspects of sensemaking. In particular this thesis examines standard methods for diagramming arguments and methods for diagramming reasoning. These techniques are applied in the diagramming of legal judgments. A review is conducted of systems that have been constructed to support the construction of diagrams of argument and reasoning. Drawing upon these examinations, this thesis highlights the necessity of appropriate representations for supporting reasoning. The literature examining diagramming for reasoning support provides little discussion of appropriate representations. This thesis examines theories of representation for insight they can provide into the design of appropriate representations. It is concluded that while the theories of representation that are examined do not determine what amounts to a good representation, guidelines for the design and choice of representations can be distilled. These guidelines cannot map the class of legal knowledge-based systems that augment legal sensemaking, they can however, be used to explore this class and to inform construction of systems
Resources, autonomy and strategy : perceptions of competitive advantage in the UK automotive components industry.
Theory building in strategic management has traditionally suffered from strong
demarcation lines. The case of the resource-based view of firm (RBV) which has
emerged as an alternative approach to industry-based explanations of how
organisations develop and sustain competitive advantage, particularly
demonstrates this divide. Since then, these alternative views of competitive
advantage have often been portrayed as mutually exclusive antagonists.
This study sets out to examine the perceptions of strategic managers in the UK
automotive components industry in relation to these two competing schools of
thought which advocate advantage through resources (RBV) or advantage through
residence (industry approaches). This industry has been chosen due to the clear
potential for industry structure and internal competencies to influence competitive
advantage. Using quantitative techniques, data from senior managers is analysed
in order to establish the extent to which the views of industry practitioners
converge or diverge with the theoretical or anecdotal offerings of the strategy
literature.
The findings of this thesis suggest that a complex hybrid of perceptions tends to
prevail among respondents from the industry. This can be attributed to historical,
operational and supply chain factors. Furthermore, the study finds that the lexicon
of competitive advantage and the priorities of resources advocated in the literature
are not shared by strategists in the industry. Accordingly, the study finds, strategic
management theory in relation to the resource-based view requires further
research using the methodology developed in this thesis as a foundation