Parallelizing Sequential Programs With Statistical Accuracy Tests

We present QuickStep, a novel system for parallelizing sequential programs. QuickStep deploys a set of parallelization transformations that together induce a search space of candidate parallel programs. Given a sequential program, representative inputs, and an accuracy requirement, QuickStep uses performance measurements, profiling information, and statistical accuracy tests on the outputs of candidate parallel programs to guide its search for a parallelizationthat maximizes performance while preserving acceptable accuracy. When the search completes, QuickStep produces an interactive report that summarizes the applied parallelization transformations, performance, and accuracy results for the automatically generated candidate parallel programs. In our envisioned usage scenarios, the developer examines this report to evaluate the acceptability of the final parallelization and to obtain insight into how the original sequential program responds to different parallelization strategies. Itis also possible for the developer (or even a user of the program who has no software development expertise whatsoever) to simply use the best parallelization out of the box without examining the report or further investigating the parallelization. Results from our benchmark set of applications show that QuickStep can automatically generate accurate and efficient parallel programs---the automatically generated parallel versions of five of our six benchmark applications run between 5.0 and 7.7 times faster on 8 cores than the original sequential versions. Moreover, a comparison with the Intel icc compiler highlights how QuickStep can effectively parallelize applications with features (such as the use of modern object-oriented programming constructs or desirable parallelizations with infrequent but acceptable data races) that place them inherently beyond the reach of standard approaches

ParaSCAN: A Static Profiler to Help Parallelization

Parallelizing software often starts by profiling to identify program paths that are worth parallelizing. Static profiling techniques, e.g. hot paths, can be used to identify parallelism opportunities for programs that lack representative inputs and in situations where dynamic techniques aren\u27t applicable, e.g. parallelizing compilers and refactoring tools. Existing static techniques for identification of hot paths rely on path frequencies. Relying on path frequencies alone isn\u27t sufficient for identifying parallelism opportunities. We propose a novel automated approach for static profiling that combines both path frequencies and computational weight of the paths. We apply our technique called ParaSCAN to parallelism recommendation, where it is highly effective. Our results demonstrate that ParaSCAN\u27s recommendations cover all the parallelism manually identified by experts with 85% accuracy and in some cases also identifies parallelism missed by the experts

Quantifying the benefits of SPECint distant parallelism in simultaneous multithreading architectures

We exploit the existence of distant parallelism that future compilers could detect and characterise its performance under simultaneous multithreading architectures. By distant parallelism we mean parallelism that cannot be captured by the processor instruction window and that can produce threads suitable for parallel execution in a multithreaded processor. We show that distant parallelism can make feasible wider issue processors by providing more instructions from the distant threads, thus better exploiting the resources from the processor in the case of speeding up single integer applications. We also investigate the necessity of out-of-order processors in the presence of multiple threads of the same program. It is important to notice at this point that the benefits described are totally orthogonal to any other architectural techniques targeting a single thread.Peer ReviewedPostprint (published version

XARK: an extensible framework for automatic recognition of computational kernels

This is a post-peer-review, pre-copyedit version of an article published in ACM Transactions on Programming Languages and Systems. The final authenticated version is available online at: http://dx.doi.org/10.1145/1391956.1391959[Abstract] The recognition of program constructs that are frequently used by software developers is a powerful mechanism for optimizing and parallelizing compilers to improve the performance of the object code. The development of techniques for automatic recognition of computational kernels such as inductions, reductions and array recurrences has been an intensive research area in the scope of compiler technology during the 90's. This article presents a new compiler framework that, unlike previous techniques that focus on specific and isolated kernels, recognizes a comprehensive collection of computational kernels that appear frequently in full-scale real applications. The XARK compiler operates on top of the Gated Single Assignment (GSA) form of a high-level intermediate representation (IR) of the source code. Recognition is carried out through a demand-driven analysis of this high-level IR at two different levels. First, the dependences between the statements that compose the strongly connected components (SCCs) of the data-dependence graph of the GSA form are analyzed. As a result of this intra-SCC analysis, the computational kernels corresponding to the execution of the statements of the SCCs are recognized. Second, the dependences between statements of different SCCs are examined in order to recognize more complex kernels that result from combining simpler kernels in the same code. Overall, the XARK compiler builds a hierarchical representation of the source code as kernels and dependence relationships between those kernels. This article describes in detail the collection of computational kernels recognized by the XARK compiler. Besides, the internals of the recognition algorithms are presented. The design of the algorithms enables to extend the recognition capabilities of XARK to cope with new kernels, and provides an advanced symbolic analysis framework to run other compiler techniques on demand. Finally, extensive experiments showing the effectiveness of XARK for a collection of benchmarks from different application domains are presented. In particular, the SparsKit-II library for the manipulation of sparse matrices, the Perfect benchmarks, the SPEC CPU2000 collection and the PLTMG package for solving elliptic partial differential equations are analyzed in detail.Ministeiro de Educación y Ciencia; TIN2004-07797-C02Ministeiro de Educación y Ciencia; TIN2007-67537-C03Xunta de Galicia; PGIDIT05PXIC10504PNXunta de Galicia; PGIDIT06PXIB105228P

A Novel Compiler Support for Automatic Parallelization on Multicore Systems

[Abstract] The widespread use of multicore processors is not a consequence of significant advances in parallel programming. In contrast, multicore processors arise due to the complexity of building power-efficient, high-clock-rate, single-core chips. Automatic parallelization of sequential applications is the ideal solution for making parallel programming as easy as writing programs for sequential computers. However, automatic parallelization remains a grand challenge due to its need for complex program analysis and the existence of unknowns during compilation. This paper proposes a new method for converting a sequential application into a parallel counterpart that can be executed on current multicore processors. It hinges on an intermediate representation based on the concept of domain-independent kernel (e.g., assignment, reduction, recurrence). Such kernel-centric view hides the complexity of the implementation details, enabling the construction of the parallel version even when the source code of the sequential application contains different syntactic variations of the computations (e.g., pointers, arrays, complex control flows). Experiments that evaluate the effectiveness and performance of our approach with respect to state-of-the-art compilers are also presented. The benchmark suite consists of synthetic codes that represent common domain-independent kernels, dense/sparse linear algebra and image processing routines, and full-scale applications from SPEC CPU2000.[Resumen] El uso generalizado de procesadores multinúcleo no es consecuencia de avances significativos en programación paralela. Por el contrario, los procesadores multinúcleo surgen debido a la complejidad de construir chips mononúcleo que sean eficiente energéticamente y tengan altas velocidades de reloj. La paralelización automática de aplicaciones secuenciales es la solución ideal para hacer la programación paralela tan fácil como escribir programas para ordenadores secuenciales. Sin embargo, la paralelización automática continua a ser un gran reto debido a su necesidad de complejos análisis del programa y la existencia de incógnitas durante la compilación. Este artículo propone un nuevo método para convertir una aplicación secuencial en su contrapartida paralela que pueda ser ejecutada en los procesadores multinúcleo actuales. Este método depende de una representación intermedia basada en el concepto de núcleos independientes del dominio (p. ej., asignación, reducción, recurrencia). Esta visión centrada en núcleos oculta la complejidad de los detalles de implementación, permitiendo la construcción de la versión paralela incluso cuando el código fuente de la aplicación secuencial contiene diferentes variantes de las computaciones (p. ej., punteros, arrays, flujos de control complejos). Se presentan experimentos que evalúan la efectividad y el rendimiento de nuestra aproximación con respecto al estado del arte. La serie programas de prueba consiste en códigos sintéticos que representan núcleos independientes del dominio comunes, rutinas de álgebra lineal densa/dispersa y de procesamiento de imagen, y aplicaciones completas del SPEC CPU2000.[Resumo] O uso xeralizado de procesadores multinúcleo non é consecuencia de avances significativos en programación paralela. Pola contra, os procesadores multinúcleo xurden debido á complexidade de construir chips mononúcleo que sexan eficientes enerxéticamente e teñan altas velocidades de reloxo. A paralelización automática de aplicacións secuenciais é a solución ideal para facer a programación paralela tan sinxela como escribir programas para ordenadores secuenciais. Sen embargo, a paralelización automática continua a ser un gran reto debido a súa necesidade de complexas análises do programa e a existencia de incógnitas durante a compilación. Este artigo propón un novo método para convertir unha aplicación secuencias na súa contrapartida paralela que poida ser executada nos procesadores multinúcleo actuais. Este método depende dunha representación intermedia baseada no concepto dos núcleos independentes do dominio (p. ex., asignación, reducción, recurrencia). Esta visión centrada en núcleos oculta a complexidade dos detalles de implementación, permitindo a construcción da versión paralela incluso cando o código fonte da aplicación secuencial contén diferentes variantes das computacións (p. ex., punteiros, arrays, fluxos de control complejo). Preséntanse experimentos que evalúan a efectividade e o rendemento da nosa aproximación con respecto ao estado da arte. A serie de programas de proba consiste en códigos sintéticos que representan núcleos independentes do dominio comunes, rutinas de álxebra lineal densa/dispersa e de procesamento de imaxe, e aplicacións completas do SPEC CPU2000.Ministerio de Economía y Competitividad; TIN2010-16735Ministerio de Educación y Cultura; AP2008-0101

Ithemal: Accurate, Portable and Fast Basic Block Throughput Estimation using Deep Neural Networks

Predicting the number of clock cycles a processor takes to execute a block of assembly instructions in steady state (the throughput) is important for both compiler designers and performance engineers. Building an analytical model to do so is especially complicated in modern x86-64 Complex Instruction Set Computer (CISC) machines with sophisticated processor microarchitectures in that it is tedious, error prone, and must be performed from scratch for each processor generation. In this paper we present Ithemal, the first tool which learns to predict the throughput of a set of instructions. Ithemal uses a hierarchical LSTM--based approach to predict throughput based on the opcodes and operands of instructions in a basic block. We show that Ithemal is more accurate than state-of-the-art hand-written tools currently used in compiler backends and static machine code analyzers. In particular, our model has less than half the error of state-of-the-art analytical models (LLVM's llvm-mca and Intel's IACA). Ithemal is also able to predict these throughput values just as fast as the aforementioned tools, and is easily ported across a variety of processor microarchitectures with minimal developer effort.Comment: Published at 36th International Conference on Machine Learning (ICML) 201

Automatic Parallelization of Affine Loops using Dependence and Cache analysis in a Binary Rewriter

Today, nearly all general-purpose computers are parallel, but nearly all software running on them is serial. Bridging this disconnect by manually rewriting source code in parallel is prohibitively expensive. Automatic parallelization technology is therefore an attractive alternative. We present a method to perform automatic parallelization in a binary rewriter. The input to the binary rewriter is the serial binary executable program and the output is a parallel binary executable. The advantages of parallelization in a binary rewriter versus a compiler include (i) compatibility with all compilers and languages; (ii) high economic feasibility from avoiding repeated compiler implementation; (iii) applicability to legacy binaries; and (iv) applicability to assembly-language programs. Adapting existing parallelizing compiler methods that work on source code to work on binary programs instead is a significant challenge. This is primarily because symbolic and array index information used in existing compiler parallelizers is not available in a binary. We show how to adapt existing parallelization methods to achieve equivalent parallelization from a binary without such information. We have also designed a affine cache reuse model that works inside a binary rewriter building on the parallelization techniques. It quantifies cache reuse in terms of the number of cache lines that will be required when a loop dimension is considered for the innermost position in a loop nest. This cache metric can be used to reason about affine code that results when affine code is transformed using affine transformations. Hence, it can be used to evaluate candidate transformation sequences to improve run-time directly from a binary. Results using our x86 binary rewriter called SecondWrite on a suite of dense- matrix regular programs from Polybench suite of benchmarks shows an geomean speedup of 6.81X from binary and 8.9X from source with 8 threads compared to the input serial binary on a x86 Xeon E5530 machine; and 8.31X from binary and 9.86X from source with 24 threads compared to the input serial binary on a x86 E7450 machine. Such regular loops are an important component of scientific and multi- media workloads, and are even present to a limited extent in otherwise non-regular programs. Further in this thesis we present a novel algorithm that enhances the past techniques significantly for loops with unknown loop bounds by guessing the loop bounds using only the memory expressions present in a loop. It then inserts run-time checks to see if these guesses were indeed correct and if correct executes the parallel version of the loop, else the serial version executes. These techniques are applied to the large affine benchmarks in SPEC2006 and OMP2001 and unlike previous methods the speedups from binary are as good as from source. We also present results on the number of loops parallelized directly from a binary with and without this algorithm. Among the 8 affine benchmarks among these suites, the best existing binary parallelization method achieves an geo-mean speedup of 1.33X, whereas our method achieves a speedup of 2.96X. This is close to the speedup from source code of 2.8X

Percolation-based compiling for evaluation of parallelism and hardware design trade-offs

This thesis investigates parallelism and hardware design trade-offs of parallel and pipelined architectures. To explore these trade-offs we developed a retargetable compiler based on a set of powerful code transformations called Percolation Scheduling (PS) that map programs with real-time constraints and/or massive time requirements onto synchronous, parallel, high-performance or semi-custom architectures.High-performance is achieved through extraction of application inherent fine-grain parallelism and the use of a suitable architecture. Exploiting fine-grain parallelism is a critical part of exploiting all of the parallelism available in a given program, particularly since highly irregular forms of parallelism are often not visible at coarser levels and since the use of low-level parallelism has a multiplicative effect on the overall performance.To extract substantial parallelism from both the hardware and the compiler, we use a clean, highly parallel VLIW-like architecture that is synchronous, has multiple functional units and has a single program counter. The use of a hazard-free and homogeneous architecture does not result only in a better VLSI design but also considerably increases the compiler's ability to produce better code. To further enhance parallelism we modified the uni-cycle VLIW model and extended the transformations such that pipelined units that provide extra parallelism are used.Another approach presented is of resource constrained scheduling (RCS). Since the RCS problem is known to be NP-hard, in practice it may be solved only by a heuristic approach. We argue that using the heuristic after extraction of the unlimited-resources schedule may yield better results than if the heuristic has been applied at the beginning of the scheduling process.Through a series of benchmarks we evaluate hardware design trade-offs and show that speed-ups on average of one order of magnitude are feasible with sufficient functional units. However, when resources are limited we show that the number of functional units needed may be optimized for a particular suite of application programs