1,448 research outputs found
Operational Semantics of Resolution and Productivity in Horn Clause Logic
This paper presents a study of operational and type-theoretic properties of
different resolution strategies in Horn clause logic. We distinguish four
different kinds of resolution: resolution by unification (SLD-resolution),
resolution by term-matching, the recently introduced structural resolution, and
partial (or lazy) resolution. We express them all uniformly as abstract
reduction systems, which allows us to undertake a thorough comparative analysis
of their properties. To match this small-step semantics, we propose to take
Howard's System H as a type-theoretic semantic counterpart. Using System H, we
interpret Horn formulas as types, and a derivation for a given formula as the
proof term inhabiting the type given by the formula. We prove soundness of
these abstract reduction systems relative to System H, and we show completeness
of SLD-resolution and structural resolution relative to System H. We identify
conditions under which structural resolution is operationally equivalent to
SLD-resolution. We show correspondence between term-matching resolution for
Horn clause programs without existential variables and term rewriting.Comment: Journal Formal Aspect of Computing, 201
Structural Resolution with Co-inductive Loop Detection
A way to combine co-SLD style loop detection with structural resolution was
found and is introduced in this work, to extend structural resolution with
co-induction. In particular, we present the operational semantics, called
co-inductive structural resolution, of this novel combination and prove its
soundness with respect to the greatest complete Herbrand model.Comment: In Proceedings CoALP-Ty'16, arXiv:1709.0419
Productive Corecursion in Logic Programming
Logic Programming is a Turing complete language. As a consequence, designing
algorithms that decide termination and non-termination of programs or decide
inductive/coinductive soundness of formulae is a challenging task. For example,
the existing state-of-the-art algorithms can only semi-decide coinductive
soundness of queries in logic programming for regular formulae. Another, less
famous, but equally fundamental and important undecidable property is
productivity. If a derivation is infinite and coinductively sound, we may ask
whether the computed answer it determines actually computes an infinite
formula. If it does, the infinite computation is productive. This intuition was
first expressed under the name of computations at infinity in the 80s. In
modern days of the Internet and stream processing, its importance lies in
connection to infinite data structure processing.
Recently, an algorithm was presented that semi-decides a weaker property --
of productivity of logic programs. A logic program is productive if it can give
rise to productive derivations. In this paper we strengthen these recent
results. We propose a method that semi-decides productivity of individual
derivations for regular formulae. Thus we at last give an algorithmic
counterpart to the notion of productivity of derivations in logic programming.
This is the first algorithmic solution to the problem since it was raised more
than 30 years ago. We also present an implementation of this algorithm.Comment: Paper presented at the 33nd International Conference on Logic
Programming (ICLP 2017), Melbourne, Australia, August 28 to September 1, 2017
16 pages, LaTeX, no figure
Structural resolution for abstract compilation of object-oriented languages
We propose abstract compilation for precise static type analysis of
object-oriented languages based on coinductive logic programming. Source code
is translated to a logic program, then type-checking and inference problems
amount to queries to be solved with respect to the resulting logic program. We
exploit a coinductive semantics to deal with infinite terms and proofs produced
by recursive types and methods. Thanks to the recent notion of structural
resolution for coinductive logic programming, we are able to infer very precise
type information, including a class of irrational recursive types causing
non-termination for previously considered coinductive semantics. We also show
how to transform logic programs to make them satisfy the preconditions for the
operational semantics of structural resolution, and we prove this step does not
affect the semantics of the logic program.Comment: In Proceedings CoALP-Ty'16, arXiv:1709.0419
Logic Programming: Context, Character and Development
Logic programming has been attracting increasing interest in recent years. Its first realisation in the form of PROLOG demonstrated concretely that Kowalski's view of computation as controlled deduction could be implemented with tolerable efficiency, even on existing computer architectures. Since that time logic programming research has intensified. The majority of computing professionals have remained unaware of the developments, however, and for some the announcement that PROLOG had been selected as the core language for the Japanese 'Fifth Generation' project came as a total surprise. This thesis aims to describe the context, character and development of logic programming. It explains why a radical departure from existing software practices needs to be seriously discussed; it identifies the characteristic features of logic programming, and the practical realisation of these features in current logic programming systems; and it outlines the programming methodology which is proposed for logic programming. The problems and limitations of existing logic programming systems are described and some proposals for development are discussed. The thesis is in three parts. Part One traces the development of programming since the early days of computing. It shows how the problems of software complexity which were addressed by the 'structured programming' school have not been overcome: the software crisis remains severe and seems to require fundamental changes in software practice for its solution. Part Two describes the foundations of logic programming in the procedural interpretation of Horn clauses. Fundamental to logic programming is shown to be the separation of the logic of an algorithm from its control. At present, however, both the logic and the control aspects of logic programming present problems; the first in terms of the extent of the language which is used, and the second in terms of the control strategy which should be applied in order to produce solutions. These problems are described and various proposals, including some which have been incorporated into implemented systems, are described. Part Three discusses the software development methodology which is proposed for logic programming. Some of the experience of practical applications is related. Logic programming is considered in the aspects of its potential for parallel execution and in its relationship to functional programming, and some possible criticisms of the problem-solving potential of logic are described. The conclusion is that although logic programming inevitably has some problems which are yet to be solved, it seems to offer answers to several issues which are at the heart of the software crisis. The potential contribution of logic programming towards the development of software should be substantial
- …