Privacy and trustworthiness management in moving object environments

The use of location-based services (LBS) (e.g., Intel\u27s Thing Finder) is expanding. Besides the traditional centralized location-based services, distributed ones are also emerging due to the development of Vehicular Ad-hoc Networks (VANETs), a dynamic network which allows vehicles to communicate with one another. Due to the nature of the need of tracking users\u27 locations, LBS have raised increasing concerns on users\u27 location privacy. Although many research has been carried out for users to submit their locations anonymously, the collected anonymous location data may still be mapped to individuals when the adversary has related background knowledge. To improve location privacy, in this dissertation, the problem of anonymizing the collected location datasets is addressed so that they can be published for public use without violating any privacy concerns. Specifically, a privacy-preserving trajectory publishing algorithm is proposed that preserves high data utility rate. Moreover, the scalability issue is tackled in the case the location datasets grows gigantically due to continuous data collection as well as increase of LBS users by developing a distributed version of our trajectory publishing algorithm which leveraging the MapReduce technique. As a consequence of users being anonymous, it becomes more challenging to evaluate the trustworthiness of messages disseminated by anonymous users. Existing research efforts are mainly focused on privacy-preserving authentication of users which helps in tracing malicious vehicles only after the damage is done. However, it is still not sufficient to prevent malicious behavior from happening in the case where attackers do not care whether they are caught later on. Therefore, it would be more effective to also evaluate the content of the message. In this dissertation, a novel information-oriented trustworthiness evaluation is presented which enables each individual user to evaluate the message content and make informed decisions --Abstract, page iii

Towards trajectory anonymization: a generalization-based approach

Trajectory datasets are becoming popular due to the massive usage of GPS and locationbased services. In this paper, we address privacy issues regarding the identification of individuals in static trajectory datasets. We first adopt the notion of k-anonymity to trajectories and propose a novel generalization-based approach for anonymization of trajectories. We further show that releasing anonymized trajectories may still have some privacy leaks. Therefore we propose a randomization based reconstruction algorithm for releasing anonymized trajectory data and also present how the underlying techniques can be adapted to other anonymity standards. The experimental results on real and synthetic trajectory datasets show the effectiveness of the proposed techniques

SoK: Differentially Private Publication of Trajectory Data

Trajectory analysis holds many promises, from improvements in traffic management to routing advice or infrastructure development. However, learning users\u27 paths is extremely privacy-invasive. Therefore, there is a necessity to protect trajectories such that we preserve the global properties, useful for analysis, while specific and private information of individuals remains inaccessible. Trajectories, however, are difficult to protect, since they are sequential, highly dimensional, correlated, bound to geophysical restrictions, and easily mapped to semantic points of interest. This paper aims to establish a systematic framework on protective masking and synthetic-generation measures for trajectory databases with syntactic and differentially private (DP) guarantees, including also utility properties, derived from ideas and limitations of existing proposals. To reach this goal, we systematize the utility metrics used throughout the literature, deeply analyze the DP granularity notions, explore and elaborate on the state of the art on privacy-enhancing mechanisms and their problems, and expose the main limitations of DP notions in the context of trajectories

SoK: differentially private publication of trajectory data

Trajectory analysis holds many promises, from improvements in traffic management to routing advice or infrastructure development. However, learning users’ paths is extremely privacy-invasive. Therefore, there is a necessity to protect trajectories such that we preserve the global properties, useful for analysis, while specific and private information of individuals remains inaccessible. Trajectories, however, are difficult to protect, since they are sequential, highly dimensional, correlated, bound to geophysical restrictions, and easily mapped to semantic points of interest. This paper aims to establish a systematic framework on protective masking measures for trajectory databases with differentially private (DP) guarantees, including also utility properties, derived from ideas and limitations of existing proposals. To reach this goal, we systematize the utility metrics used throughout the literature, deeply analyze the DP granularity notions, explore and elaborate on the state of the art on privacy-enhancing mechanisms and their problems, and expose the main limitations of DP notions in the context of trajectories.We would like to thank the reviewers and shepherd for their useful comments and suggestions in the improvement of this paper. Javier Parra-Arnau is the recipient of a “Ramón y Cajal” fellowship funded by the Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation. This work also received support from “la Caixa” Foundation (fellowship code LCF/BQ/PR20/11770009), the European Union’s H2020 program (Marie Skłodowska-Curie grant agreement № 847648) from the Government of Spain under the project “COMPROMISE” (PID2020-113795RB-C31/AEI/10.13039/501100011033), and from the BMBF project “PROPOLIS” (16KIS1393K). The authors at KIT are supported by KASTEL Security Research Labs (Topic 46.23 of the Helmholtz Association) and Germany’s Excellence Strategy (EXC 2050/1 ‘CeTI’; ID 390696704).Peer ReviewedPostprint (published version

A Survey and Experimental Study on Privacy-Preserving Trajectory Data Publishing

Trajectory data has become ubiquitous nowadays, which can benefit various real-world applications such as traffic management and location-based services. However, trajectories may disclose highly sensitive information of an individual including mobility patterns, personal profiles and gazetteers, social relationships, etc, making it indispensable to consider privacy protection when releasing trajectory data. Ensuring privacy on trajectories demands more than hiding single locations, since trajectories are intrinsically sparse and high-dimensional, and require to protect multi-scale correlations. To this end, extensive research has been conducted to design effective techniques for privacy-preserving trajectory data publishing. Furthermore, protecting privacy requires carefully balance two metrics: privacy and utility. In other words, it needs to protect as much privacy as possible and meanwhile guarantee the usefulness of the released trajectories for data analysis. In this survey, we provide a comprehensive study and a systematic summarization of existing protection models, privacy and utility metrics for trajectories developed in the literature. We also conduct extensive experiments on two real-life public trajectory datasets to evaluate the performance of several representative privacy protection models, demonstrate the trade-off between privacy and utility, and guide the choice of the right privacy model for trajectory publishing given certain privacy and utility desiderata

Location Privacy in the Era of Big Data and Machine Learning

Location data of individuals is one of the most sensitive sources of information that once revealed to ill-intended individuals or service providers, can cause severe privacy concerns. In this thesis, we aim at preserving the privacy of users in telecommunication networks against untrusted service providers as well as improving their privacy in the publication of location datasets. For improving the location privacy of users in telecommunication networks, we consider the movement of users in trajectories and investigate the threats that the query history may pose on location privacy. We develop an attack model based on the Viterbi algorithm termed as Viterbi attack, which represents a realistic privacy threat in trajectories. Next, we propose a metric called transition entropy that helps to evaluate the performance of dummy generation algorithms, followed by developing a robust dummy generation algorithm that can defend users against the Viterbi attack. We compare and evaluate our proposed algorithm and metric on a publicly available dataset published by Microsoft, i.e., Geolife dataset. For privacy preserving data publishing, an enhanced framework for anonymization of spatio-temporal trajectory datasets termed the machine learning based anonymization (MLA) is proposed. The framework consists of a robust alignment technique and a machine learning approach for clustering datasets. The framework and all the proposed algorithms are applied to the Geolife dataset, which includes GPS logs of over 180 users in Beijing, China