Analyzing the divide between FPGA academic and commercial results

The pinnacle of success for academic work is often achieved by having impact on commercial products. In order to have a successful transfer bridge, academic evaluation flows need to provide representative results of similar quality to commercial flows. A majority of publications in FPGA research use the same set of known academic CAD tools and benchmarks to evaluate new architecture and tool ideas. However, it is not clear whether the claims in academic publications based on these tools and benchmarks translate to real benefits in commercial products. In this work we compare the latest Xilinx commercial tools and products with these well-known academic tools to identify the gap in the major figures of merit. Our results show that there is a significant 2.2X gap in speed-performance for similar process technology. We have also identified the area-efficiency and runtime divide between commercial and academic tools to be 5% and 2.2X, respectively. We show that it is possible to improve portions of the academic flow such as ABC logic optimization to match the quality of commercial tools at the expense of additional runtime. Our results also show that depth reduction, which is often used as the main figure of merit for logic optimization papers does not translate to post-routing timing improvements. We finally discuss the differences between academic and commercial benchmark designs. We explain the main differences and trends that may influence the topic choice and conclusions of academic research. This work emphasizes how difficult it is to identify the relevant FPGA academic work that can provide meaningful benefits for commercial products

Fast Adjustable NPN Classification Using Generalized Symmetries

NPN classification of Boolean functions is a powerful technique used in many logic synthesis and technology mapping tools in FPGA design flows. Computing the canonical form of a function is the most common approach of Boolean function classification. In this paper, a novel algorithm for computing NPN canonical form is proposed. By exploiting symmetries under different phase assignments and higher-order symmetries of Boolean functions, the search space of NPN canonical form computation is pruned and the runtime is dramatically reduced. The algorithm can be adjusted to be a slow exact algorithm or a fast heuristic algorithm with lower quality. For exact classification, the proposed algorithm achieves a 30× speedup compared to a state-of-the-art algorithm. For heuristic classification, the proposed algorithm has similar performance as the state-of-the-art algorithm with a possibility to trade runtime for quality

A Best-Fit Mapping Algorithm to Facilitate ESOP-Decomposition in Clifford+T Quantum Network Synthesis

Currently, there is a large research interest and a significant economical effort to build the first practical quantum computer. Such quantum computers promise to exceed the capabilities of conventional computers in fields such as computational chemistry, machine learning and cryptanalysis. Automated methods to map logic designs to quantum networks are crucial to fully realizing this dream, however, existing methods can be expensive both in computational time as well as in the size of the resultant quantum networks. This work introduces an efficient method to map reversible single-target gates into a universal set of quantum gates (Clifford+T). This mapping method is called best-fit mapping and aims at reducing the cost of the resulting quantum network. It exploits k-LUT mapping and the existence of clean ancilla qubits to decompose a large single-target gate into a set of smaller single-target gates. In addition this work proposes a post-synthesis optimization method to reduce the cost of the final quantum network, based on two cost-minimization properties. Results show a cost reduction for the synthesized EPFL benchmark up to 53% in the number T gates

Logic Synthesis for Established and Emerging Computing

Logic synthesis is an enabling technology to realize integrated computing systems, and it entails solving computationally intractable problems through a plurality of heuristic techniques. A recent push toward further formalization of synthesis problems has shown to be very useful toward both attempting to solve some logic problems exactly--which is computationally possible for instances of limited size today--as well as creating new and more powerful heuristics based on problem decomposition. Moreover, technological advances including nanodevices, optical computing, and quantum and quantum cellular computing require new and specific synthesis flows to assess feasibility and scalability. This review highlights recent progress in logic synthesis and optimization, describing models, data structures, and algorithms, with specific emphasis on both design quality and emerging technologies. Example applications and results of novel techniques to established and emerging technologies are reported

The IPS fidelity scale as a guideline to implement Supported Employment

info:eu-repo/semantics/publishe

Exploiting Satisfiability Solvers for Efficient Logic Synthesis

Logic synthesis is an important part of electronic design automation (EDA) flows, which enable the implementation of digital systems. As the design size and complexity increase, the data structures and algorithms for logic synthesis must adapt and improve in order to keep pace and to maintain acceptable runtime and high-quality results. Large circuits were often represented using binary decision diagrams (BDDs) that were rapidly adopted by logic synthesis tools beginning in the 1980s. Nowadays, BDD-based algorithms are still enhanced, but the possibilities for improvement are somewhat saturated after some 35 years of research. Alternatively, the first EDA applications that exploit Boolean satisfiability (SAT) were developed in the 1990s. Despite the worst-case exponential runtime of SAT solvers, rapid progress in their performance enabled the creation of efficient SAT-based algorithms. Yet, logic synthesis started using SAT solvers more diffusely only in the last decade. Therefore, thorough research is still required both for exploiting SAT solvers and for encoding logic synthesis problems into SAT. Our main goal in this thesis is to facilitate and promote the further integration of SAT solvers into EDA by proposing and evaluating novel SAT-based algorithms that can be used as building blocks in logic synthesis tools. First, we propose a rapid algorithm for LEXSAT, which generates satisfying assignments in lexicographic order. We show that LEXSAT can bring canonicity, which guarantees the generation of unique results, when using SAT solvers in EDA applications. Next, we present a new SAT-based algorithm that progressively generates irredundant sums of products (SOPs), which still play a crucial role in many logic synthesis tools. Using LEXSAT, for the first time, we can generate canonical SAT-based SOPs that, much like BDD-based SOPs, are unique for a given function and variable order but could relax canonicity in order to improve speed and scalability. Unlike BDDs, due to its progressive nature, our algorithm can generate partial SOPs for applications that can work with incomplete circuit functionality. It is noteworthy that both LEXSAT and the SAT-based SOPs are applicable beyond logic synthesis and EDA. Finally, we focus on resubstitution, which reimplements a given Boolean function as a new function that depends on a set of existing functions called divisors. We propose the carving interpolation algorithm that, unlike the traditional Craig interpolation, forces the use of a specific divisor as an input of the new function. This is particularly useful for global circuit restructuring and for some synthesis-based engineering change order (ECO) algorithms. Furthermore, we compare two existing SAT-based methodologies for resubstitution, which are used for post-mapping logic optimisation. The first methodology combines SAT-based functional dependency checking and Craig interpolation that are also used for our carving interpolation; the second methodology is based on cube enumeration and is similar to the SAT-based SOP generation. The initial implementations of our novel SAT-based algorithms offer either better performance or new features, or both, compared to their state-of-the-art versions. As the results indicate, a further thorough development of SAT-based algorithms for logic synthesis, like the one performed for BDDs in the past, can help overcome existing limitations and keep up with growing designs and design complexity