OPTIMIZATION APPROACHES TO AIRLINE INDUSTRY CHALLENGES: Airline Schedule Planning and Recovery

The airline industry has a long history of developing and applying optimization approaches to their myriad of scheduling problems, including designing flight schedules that maximize profitability while satisfying rules related to aircraft maintenance; generating cost-minimizing, feasible work schedules for pilots and flight attendants; and identifying implementable, low-cost changes to aircraft and crew schedules as disruptions render the planned schedule inoperable. The complexities associated with these problems are immense, including long-and short-term planning horizons; and multiple resources including aircraft, crews, and passengers, all operating over shared airspace and airport capacity. Optimization approaches have played an important role in overcoming this complexity and providing effective aircraft and crew schedules. Historical optimization-based approaches, however, often involve a sequential process, first generating aircraft schedules and then generating crew schedules. Decisions taken in the first steps of the process limit those that are possible in subsequent steps, resulting in overall plans that, while feasible, are typically sub-optimal. To mitigate the myopic effects of sequential solutions, researchers have developed extended models that begin to integrate som

The Integrated Aircraft Routing and Crew Pairing Problem: ILP Based Formulations

Minimization of cost is very important in airline as great profit is an important objective for any airline system. One way to minimize the costs in airline is by developing an integrated planning process. Airline planning consists of many difficult operational decision problems including aircraft routing and crew pairing problems. These two sub-problems, though interrelated in practice, are usually solved sequentially leading to suboptimal solutions. We propose an integrated aircraft routing and crew pairing problem model, one approach to generate the feasible aircraft routes and crew pairs, followed by three approaches to solve the integrated model. The integrated aircraft routing and crew scheduling problem is to determine a minimum cost aircraft routes and crew schedules while each flight leg is covered by one aircraft and one crew. The first approach is an integer programming solution method, the second formulation is developed in a way to lend itself to be used efficiently by Dantzig Wolfe decomposition whereas the third one is formulated as a Benders decomposition method. Encouraging results are obtained when tested on four types of aircraft based on local flights in Malaysia for one week flight cycle

Methods for Improving Robustness and Recovery in Aviation Planning.

In this dissertation, we develop new methods for improving robustness and recovery in aviation planning. In addition to these methods, the contributions of this dissertation include an in-depth analysis of several mathematical modeling approaches and proof of their structural equivalence. Furthermore, we analyze several decomposition approaches, the difference in their complexity and the required computation time to provide insight into selecting the most appropriate formulation for a particular problem structure. To begin, we provide an overview of the airline planning process, including the major components such as schedule planning, fleet assignment and crew planning approaches. Then, in the first part of our research, we use a recursive simulation-based approach to evaluate a flight schedule's overall robustness, i.e. its ability to withstand propagation delays. We then use this analysis as the groundwork for a new approach to improve the robustness of an airline's maintenance plan. Specifically, we improve robustness by allocating maintenance rotations to those aircraft that will most likely benefit from the assignment. To assess the effectiveness of our approach, we introduce a new metric, maintenance reachability, which measures the robustness of the rotations assigned to aircraft. Subsequently, we develop a mathematical programming approach to improve the maintenance reachability of this assignment. In the latter part of this dissertation, we transition from the planning to the recovery phase. On the day-of-operations, disruptions often take place and change aircraft rotations and their respective maintenance assignments. In recovery, we focus on creating feasible plans after such disruptions have occurred. We divide our recovery approach into two phases. In the first phase, we solve the Maintenance Recovery Problem (MRP), a computationally complex, short-term, non-recurrent recovery problem. This research lays the foundation for the second phase, in which we incorporate recurrence, i.e. the property that scheduling one maintenance event has a direct implication on the deadlines for subsequent maintenance events, into the recovery process. We recognize that scheduling the next maintenance event provides implications for all subsequent events, which further increases the problem complexity. We illustrate the effectiveness of our methods under various objective functions and mathematical programming approaches.Ph.D.Industrial & Operations EngineeringUniversity of Michigan, Horace H. Rackham School of Graduate Studieshttp://deepblue.lib.umich.edu/bitstream/2027.42/91539/1/mlapp_1.pd

Large-scale mixed integer optimization approaches for scheduling airline operations under irregularity

Perhaps no single industry has benefited more from advancements in computation, analytics, and optimization than the airline industry. Operations Research (OR) is now ubiquitous in the way airlines develop their schedules, price their itineraries, manage their fleet, route their aircraft, and schedule their crew. These problems, among others, are well-known to industry practitioners and academics alike and arise within the context of the planning environment which takes place well in advance of the date of departure. One salient feature of the planning environment is that decisions are made in a frictionless environment that do not consider perturbations to an existing schedule. Airline operations are rife with disruptions caused by factors such as convective weather, aircraft failure, air traffic control restrictions, network effects, among other irregularities. Substantially less work in the OR community has been examined within the context of the real-time operational environment. While problems in the planning and operational environments are similar from a mathematical perspective, the complexity of the operational environment is exacerbated by two factors. First, decisions need to be made in as close to real-time as possible. Unlike the planning phase, decision-makers do not have hours of time to return a decision. Secondly, there are a host of operational considerations in which complex rules mandated by regulatory agencies like the Federal Administration Association (FAA), airline requirements, or union rules. Such restrictions often make finding even a feasible set of re-scheduling decisions an arduous task, let alone the global optimum. The goals and objectives of this thesis are found in Chapter 1. Chapter 2 provides an overview airline operations and the current practices of disruption management employed at most airlines. Both the causes and the costs associated with irregular operations are surveyed. The role of airline Operations Control Center (OCC) is discussed in which serves as the real-time decision making environment that is important to understand for the body of this work. Chapter 3 introduces an optimization-based approach to solve the Airline Integrated Recovery (AIR) problem that simultaneously solves re-scheduling decisions for the operating schedule, aircraft routings, crew assignments, and passenger itineraries. The methodology is validated by using real-world industrial data from a U.S. hub-and-spoke regional carrier and we show how the incumbent approach can dominate the incumbent sequential approach in way that is amenable to the operational constraints imposed by a decision-making environment. Computational effort is central to the efficacy of any algorithm present in a real-time decision making environment such as an OCC. The latter two chapters illustrate various methods that are shown to expedite more traditional large-scale optimization methods that are applicable a wide family of optimization problems, including the AIR problem. Chapter 4 shows how delayed constraint generation and column generation may be used simultaneously through use of alternate polyhedra that verify whether or not a given cut that has been generated from a subset of variables remains globally valid. While Benders' decomposition is a well-known algorithm to solve problems exhibiting a block structure, one possible drawback is slow convergence. Expediting Benders' decomposition has been explored in the literature through model reformulation, improving bounds, and cut selection strategies, but little has been studied how to strengthen a standard cut. Chapter 5 examines four methods for the convergence may be accelerated through an affine transformation into the interior of the feasible set, generating a split cut induced by a standard Benders' inequality, sequential lifting, and superadditive lifting over a relaxation of a multi-row system. It is shown that the first two methods yield the most promising results within the context of an AIR model.PhDCommittee Co-Chair: Clarke, John-Paul; Committee Co-Chair: Johnson, Ellis; Committee Member: Ahmed, Shabbir; Committee Member: Clarke, Michael; Committee Member: Nemhauser, Georg

Approaches to Incorporating Robustness into Airline Scheduling

The airline scheduling process used by major airlines today aims to develop opti- mal schedules which maximize revenue. However, these schedules are often far from \optimal" once deployed in the real world because they do not accurately take into account possible weather, air tra c control (ATC), and other disruptions that can occur during operation. The resulting ight delays and cancellations can cause sig- ni cant revenue loss, not to mention service disruptions and customer dissatisfaction. A novel approach to addressing this problem is to design schedules that are robust to schedule disruptions and can be degraded at any airport location or in any region with minimal impact on the entire schedule. This research project suggests new methods for creating more robust airline schedules which can be easily recovered in the face of irregular operations. We show how to create multiple optimal solutions to the Aircraft Routing problem and suggest how to evaluate robustness of those solutions. Other potential methods for increasing robustness of airline schedules are reviewed.NASA grant NAG1-218

An Optimisation Framework for Airline Fleet Maintenance Scheduling with Tail Assignment Considerations

Fierce competition between airlines has led to the need of minimising the operating costs while also ensuring quality of service. Given the large proportion of operating costs dedicated to aircraft maintenance, cooperation between airlines and their respective maintenance provider is paramount. In this research, we propose a framework to develop commercially viable and maintenance feasible flight and maintenance schedules. Such framework involves two multi-objective mixed integer linear programming (MMILP) formulations and an iterative algorithm. The first formulation, the airline fleet maintenance scheduling (AMS) with violations, minimises the number of maintenance regulation violations and the number of not airworthy aircraft; subject to limited workshop resources and current maintenance regulations on individual aircraft flying hours. The second formulation, the AMS with tail assignment (TA) allows aircraft to be assigned to different flights. In this case, subject to similar constraints as the first formulation, six lexicographically ordered objective functions are minimised. Namely, the number of violations, maximum resource level, number of tail reassignments, number of maintenance interventions, overall resource usage, and the amount of maintenance required by each aircraft at the end of the planning horizon. The iterative algorithm ensures fast computational times while providing good quality solutions. Additionally, by tracking aircraft and using precise flying hours between maintenance opportunities, we ensure that the aircraft are airworthy at all times. Computational tests on real flight schedules over a 30-day planning horizon show that even with multiple airlines and workshops (16000 flights, 529 aircraft, 8 maintenance workshops) our solution approach can construct near-optimal maintenance schedules within minutes

Optimisation of scheduling and routing for offshore wind farm maintenance

The growing increase in the size and scope of offshore wind farms motivates the need for industry to have access to mathematical tools that reduce costs by efficiently performing daily operations and maintenance activities. Key offshore activities require the transportation of technicians to and within offshore wind farms to complete corrective and preventive maintenance tasks to keep turbines operating efficiently. We provide a new deterministic mixed integer linear programming formulation for deciding the optimal vessel routes for transporting technicians around a wind farm and the scheduling of crew transfers, by minimising downtime, travel and technician costs. The model contains sufficient flexibility to account for multiple vessels, shifts and task profiles, whilst being able to prioritise and omit tasks in environments containing limited resources. Computational experiments are performed which quantify and confirm the impact of key instance characteristics such as technician availability, task profiles and weather conditions. We implement and evaluate the impact of a novel industry safety constraint. The complexity of larger instances motivates a second continuous time formulation, in which preventive maintenance again requires no minimum duration of work before it can provide benefit. We employ a specific decomposition structure to take advantage of variable preventive maintenance and utilise an adaptive large neighbourhood search procedure to solve instances. We evaluate several distinct acceptance criteria in conjunction with random and adaptive operator selection to determine the best option for our model. We produce a statistical model of offshore weather conditions to help quantify the likelihood of limited vessel accessibility to offshore wind farms. We model the joint distribution of key meteorological and oceanographic variables over time whilst accounting for seasonal trends using multivariate kernel density estimation. Our method generates alternative metocean realisations from historical data and reproduces the important long term persistence statistics of good and adverse offshore conditions