Investigation of Shadow Matching for GNSS Positioning in Urban Canyons

All travel behavior of people in urban areas relies on knowing their position. Obtaining position has become increasingly easier thanks to the vast popularity of ‘smart’ mobile devices. The main and most accurate positioning technique used in these devices is global navigation satellite systems (GNSS). However, the poor performance of GNSS user equipment in urban canyons is a well-known problem and it is particularly inaccurate in the cross-street direction. The accuracy in this direction greatly affects many applications, including vehicle lane identification and high-accuracy pedestrian navigation. Shadow matching is a new technique that helps solve this problem by integrating GNSS constellation geometries and information derived from 3D models of buildings. This study brings the shadow matching principle from a simple mathematical model, through experimental proof of concept, system design and demonstration, algorithm redesign, comprehensive experimental tests, real-time demonstration and feasibility assessment, to a workable positioning solution. In this thesis, GNSS performance in urban canyons is numerically evaluated using 3D models. Then, a generic two-phase 6-step shadow matching system is proposed, implemented and tested against both geodetic and smartphone-grade GNSS receivers. A Bayesian technique-based shadow matching is proposed to account for NLOS and diffracted signal reception. A particle filter is designed to enable multi-epoch kinematic positioning. Finally, shadow matching is adapted and implemented as a mobile application (app), with feasibility assessment conducted. Results from the investigation confirm that conventional ranging-based GNSS is not adequate for reliable urban positioning. The designed shadow matching positioning system is demonstrated complementary to conventional GNSS in improving urban positioning accuracy. Each of the three generations of shadow matching algorithm is demonstrated to provide better positioning performance, supported by comprehensive experiments. In summary, shadow matching has been demonstrated to significantly improve urban positioning accuracy; it shows great potential to revolutionize urban positioning from street level to lane level, and possibly meter level

Urban Positioning on a Smartphone: Real-time Shadow Matching Using GNSS and 3D City Models

The performance of global navigation satellite system (GNSS) user equipment in urban canyons is particularly poor in the cross-street direction. This is because more signals are blocked by buildings in the cross-street direction than along the street [1]. To address this problem, shadow matching has been proposed to improve cross-street positioning from street-level to lane-level (meters-level) accuracy using 3D city models. This is a new positioning method that uses the city model to predict which satellites are visible from different locations and then compares this with the measured satellite visibility to determine position [2]. In previous work, we have demonstrated shadow matching using GPS and GLONASS data recorded using a geodetic GNSS receiver in Central London, achieving a cross-street position accuracy within 5m 89% of the time [3]. This paper describes the first real-time implementation of shadow matching on a smartphone capable of receiving both GPS and GLONASS. The typical processing time for the system to provide a solution was between 1 and 2 seconds. On average, the cross-street position accuracy from shadow matching was a factor of four better than the phone’s conventional GNSS position solution. A number of groups have also used 3D city models to predict and, in some cases, correct non-line-of-sight reception [4-6]. However, to our knowledge, this paper reports the first ever demonstration of any 3D-model-aided GNSS positioning technique in real time, as opposed to using recorded GNSS data. When it comes to real-time positioning on a smartphone, various obstacles exist including lower-grade GNSS receivers, limited availability of computational power, memory, and battery power. To tackle these problems, in this work, an efficient smartphone-based shadow-matching positioning system was designed. The system was then implemented in an app (i.e. application or software) on the Android operating system, the most common operating system for smartphones. The app has been developed in Java using Eclipse, a software development environment (SDE). It was built on Standard Android platform 4.0.3, using the Android Application programming interface (API) to retrieve information from the GNSS chip. The new positioning system does not require any additional hardware or real-time rendering of 3D scenes. Instead, a grid of building boundaries is computed in advance and stored within the phone. This grid could also be downloaded from the network on demand. Shadow matching is therefore both power-efficient and cost-effective. Experimental testing was performed in Central London using a Samsung Galaxy S3 smartphone. This receives both GPS and GLONASS satellites and has an assisted GNSS (AGNSS) capability. A 3D city model of the Aldgate area of central London, supplied by ZMapping Ltd, was used. Four experimental locations with different building topologies were selected on Fenchurch Street, a dense urban area. Using the Android app developed in this work, real-time shadow-matching positioning was performed over 6 minutes at each site with a new position solution computed every 5 seconds using both GPS and GLONASS observations were used for real-time positioning. The measurement data was also recorded at 1-second intervals for later analysis. Various criteria are applied to access the new system and compare it with the conventional GNSS positioning results. The experimental results show that the proposed system outperforms the conventional GNSS positioning solution, reducing the mean absolute deviation of the cross-street positioning error from 14.81 m to 3.33 m, with a 77.5 percentage reduction. The feasibility of deploying the new system on a larger scale is also discussed from three perspectives: the availability of 3D city models and satellite information, data storage and transfer requirements, and demand from applications. This meters-level across-street accuracy in urban areas benefits a variety of applications from Intelligent Transportation Systems (ITS) and land navigation systems for automated lane identification to step-by-step guidance for the visually impaired and for tourists, location-based advertisement (LBA) for targeting suitable consumers and many other location-based services (LBS). The system is also expandable to work with Galileo and Beidou (Compass) in the future, with potentially improved performance. In the future, the shadow-matching system can be implemented on a smartphone, a PND, or other consumer-grade navigation device, as part of an intelligent positioning system [7], along with height-aided conventional GNSS positioning, and potentially other technologies, such as Wi-Fi and inertial sensors to give the best overall positioning performance. / References [1] Wang, L., Groves, P. D. & Ziebart, M. Multi-constellation GNSS Performance Evaluation for Urban Canyons Using Large Virtual Reality City Models. Journal of Navigation, July 2012. [2] Groves, P. D. 2011. Shadow Matching: A New GNSS Positioning Technique for Urban Canyons The Journal of Navigation, 64, pp417-430. [3] Wang, L., Groves, P. D. & Ziebart, M. K. GNSS Shadow Matching: Improving Urban Positioning Accuracy Using a 3D City Model with Optimized Visibility Prediction Scoring. ION GNSS 2012. [4] Obst, M., Bauer, S. and Wanielik, G. Urban Multipath Detection and mitigation with Dynamic 3D Maps for Reliable Land Vehicle Localization. IEEE/ION PLANS 2012. [5] Peyraud, S., Bétaille, D., Renault, S., Ortiz, M., Mougel, F., Meizel, D. and Peyret, F. (2013) About Non-Line-Of-Sight Satellite Detection and Exclusion in a 3D Map-Aided Localization Algorithm. Sensors, Vol. 13, 2013, 829?847. [6] Bourdeau, A., M. Sahmoudi, and J.-Y. Tourneret, “Tight Integration of GNSS and a 3D City Model for Robust Positioning in Urban Canyons,” Proc. ION GNSS 2012. [7] Groves, P. D., Jiang, Z., Wang, L. & Ziebart, M. Intelligent Urban Positioning using Multi-Constellation GNSS with 3D Mapping and NLOS Signal Detection. ION GNSS 2012

Improving performance of pedestrian positioning by using vehicular communication signals

Pedestrian-to-vehicle communications, where pedestrian devices transmit their position information to nearby vehicles to indicate their presence, help to reduce pedestrian accidents. Satellite-based systems are widely used for pedestrian positioning, but have much degraded performance in urban canyon, where satellite signals are often obstructed by roadside buildings. In this paper, we propose a pedestrian positioning method, which leverages vehicular communication signals and uses vehicles as anchors. The performance of pedestrian positioning is improved from three aspects: (i) Channel state information instead of RSSI is used to estimate pedestrian-vehicle distance with higher precision. (ii) Only signals with line-of-sight path are used, and the property of distance error is considered. (iii) Fast mobility of vehicles is used to get diverse measurements, and Kalman filter is applied to smooth positioning results. Extensive evaluations, via trace-based simulation, confirm that (i) Fixing rate of positions can be much improved. (ii) Horizontal positioning error can be greatly reduced, nearly by one order compared with off-the-shelf receivers, by almost half compared with RSSI-based method, and can be reduced further to about 80cm when vehicle transmission period is 100ms and Kalman filter is applied. Generally, positioning performance increases with the number of available vehicles and their transmission frequency

GNSS Shadow Matching: Improving Urban Positioning Accuracy Using a 3D City Model with Optimized Visibility Prediction Scoring

The poor performance of global navigation satellite systems (GNSS) user equipment in urban canyons is a well-known problem, especially in the cross-street direction. A new approach, shadow matching, has recently be proposed to improve the cross-street accuracy using GNSS, assisted by knowledge derived from 3D models of the buildings close to the user of navigation devices. In this work, four contributions have been made. Firstly, a new scoring scheme, a key element of the algorithm to weight candidate user locations, is proposed. The new scheme takes account of the effects of satellite signal diffraction and reflection by weighting the scores based on diffraction modelling and signal-to-noise ratio (SNR). Furthermore, an algorithm similar to k-nearest neighbours (k-NN) is developed to interpolate the position solution over an extensive grid. The process of generating this grid of building boundaries is also optimized. Finally, instead of just testing at two locations as in the earlier work, realworld GNSS data has been collected at 22 different locations in this work, providing a more comprehensive and statistical performance analysis of the new shadowmatching algorithm. In the experimental verification, the new scoring scheme improves the cross street accuracy with an average bias of 1.61 m, with a 9.4% reduction compared to the original SS22 scoring scheme. Similarly, the cross street RMS is 2.86 m, a reduction of 15.3%. Using the new scoring scheme, the success rate for determining the correct side of a street is 89.3%, 3.6% better than using the previous scoring scheme; the success rate of distinguishing the footpath from a traffic lane is 63.6% of the time, 6.8% better than using the previous scoring scheme

UWB/GNSS-based cooperative positioning method for V2X applications

Limited availability of GNSS signals in urban canyons is a challenge for the implementation of many positioning-based traffic safety applications, and V2X technology provides an alternative solution to resolve this problem. As a key communication component in V2X technology, Dedicated Short Range Communication (DSRC) not only allows vehicles to exchange their position, but also traffic safety related information such as real-time congestion, up-to-date accident details, speed limits, etc. This position and traffic information could underpin various traffic safety applications - for instance, lane departure warnings, potential collision avoidance, and traffic congestion warnings. By taking advantage of DSRC, a vehicle in a GNSS denied environment is able to calculate its position using the assistance of other vehicles with sufficient GNSS signals to fix their locations. The concept of cooperative positioning, which is also called collaborative positioning, has been proposed to achieve this goal

Kinematic GNSS Shadow Matching Using Particle Filters

Student Paper Award Winner. The poor performance of GNSS user equipment in urban canyons is a well-known problem and is particularly inaccurate in the cross-street direction. However, the accuracy in this direction greatly affects many applications, including vehicle lane identification and high-accuracy pedestrian navigation. Shadow matching was proposed to help solve this problem by using information derived from 3D models of buildings. Though users of GNSS positioning typically move, previous research has focused on static shadow-matching positioning. In this paper, for the first time, kinematic shadow-matching positioning is tackled. Kalman filter based shadow matching is proposed and also, in order to overcome some of its predicted limitations, a particle filter is proposed to better solve the problem

Intelligent GNSS Positioning using 3D Mapping and Context Detection for Better Accuracy in Dense Urban Environments

Conventional GNSS positioning in dense urban areas can exhibit errors of tens of meters due to blockage and reflection of signals by the surrounding buildings. Here, we present a full implementation of the intelligent urban positioning (IUP) 3D-mapping-aided (3DMA) GNSS concept. This combines conventional ranging-based GNSS positioning enhanced by 3D mapping with the GNSS shadow-matching technique. Shadow matching determines position by comparing the measured signal availability with that predicted over a grid of candidate positions using 3D mapping. Thus, IUP uses both pseudo-range and signal-to-noise measurements to determine position. All algorithms incorporate terrain-height aiding and use measurements from a single epoch in time. Two different 3DMA ranging algorithms are presented, one based on least-squares estimation and the other based on computing the likelihoods of a grid of candidate position hypotheses. The likelihood-based ranging algorithm uses the same candidate position hypotheses as shadow matching and makes different assumptions about which signals are direct line-of-sight (LOS) and non-line-of-sight (NLOS) at each candidate position. Two different methods for integrating likelihood-based 3DMA ranging with shadow matching are also compared. In the position-domain approach, separate ranging and shadow-matching position solutions are computed, then averaged using direction-dependent weighting. In the hypothesis-domain approach, the candidate position scores from the ranging and shadow matching algorithms are combined prior to extracting a joint position solution. Test data was recorded using a u-blox EVK M8T consumer-grade GNSS receiver and a HTC Nexus 9 tablet at 28 locations across two districts of London. The City of London is a traditional dense urban environment, while Canary Wharf is a modern environment. The Nexus 9 tablet data was recorded using the Android Nougat GNSS receiver interface and is representative of future smartphones. Best results were obtained using the likelihood-based 3DMA ranging algorithm and hypothesis-based integration with shadow matching. With the u-blox receiver, the single-epoch RMS horizontal (i.e., 2D) error across all sites was 4.0 m, compared to 28.2 m for conventional positioning, a factor of 7.1 improvement. Using the Nexus tablet, the intelligent urban positioning RMS error was 7.0 m, compared to 32.7 m for conventional GNSS positioning, a factor of 4.7 improvement. An analysis of processing and data requirements shows that intelligent urban positioning is practical to implement in real-time on a mobile device or a server. Navigation and positioning is inherently dependent on the context, which comprises both the operating environment and the behaviour of the host vehicle or user. No single technique is capable of providing reliable and accurate positioning in all contexts. In order to operate reliably across different contexts, a multi-sensor navigation system is required to detect its operating context and reconfigure the techniques accordingly. Specifically, 3DMA GNSS should be selected when the user is in a dense urban environment, not indoors or in an open environment. Algorithms for detecting indoor and outdoor context using GNSS measurements and a hidden Markov model are described and demonstrated

A Comprehensive Review of the GNSS with IoT Applications and Their Use Cases with Special Emphasis on Machine Learning and Deep Learning Models

This paper presents a comprehensive review of the Global Navigation Satellite System (GNSS) with Internet of Things (IoT) applications and their use cases with special emphasis on Machine learning (ML) and Deep Learning (DL) models. Various factors like the availability of a huge amount of GNSS data due to the increasing number of interconnected devices having low-cost data storage and low-power processing technologies - which is majorly due to the evolution of IoT - have accelerated the use of machine learning and deep learning based algorithms in the GNSS community. IoT and GNSS technology can track almost any item possible. Smart cities are being developed with the use of GNSS and IoT. This survey paper primarily reviews several machine learning and deep learning algorithms and solutions applied to various GNSS use cases that are especially helpful in providing accurate and seamless navigation solutions in urban areas. Multipath, signal outages with less satellite visibility, and lost communication links are major challenges that hinder the navigation process in crowded areas like cities and dense forests. The advantages and disadvantages of using machine learning techniques are also highlighted along with their potential applications with GNSS and IoT

Positioning with GNSS and 5G: Analysis of Geometric Accuracy in Urban Scenarios

GNSS positioning in urban scenarios suffers for the scarce visibility of satellites. Integration with 5G services for positioning could improve this situation. In this paper, the digital surface models (DSMs) relevant to different urban scenarios, namely residential streets and urban canyons, are simulated around one observer in northern Italy (Milano) for one day of the year chosen as an example. The time series of the number of in-view GNSS satellites, their geometry and the derived quality indexes (position dilution of precision (PDOP)) are computed and analyzed. As expected, in urban canyons, a significant number of epochs does not provide four satellites within view, and many more epochs present really mediocre PDOPs. In residential streets, the situation is always quite fair. Different geometric configurations of 5G base stations are simulated around the observer. The availability of 5G times of arrival (ToAs) and their differences (TDoAs) is hypothesized, and the integration of these observations with GNSS pseudoranges is analyzed, again in terms of the PDOPs. In residential streets, 5G availability improves the positioning. In urban canyons, the optimal configuration of 5G base stations (five base stations around the observer) completely solves the positioning problem for all the epochs of the day. Less favorable configurations (four and three base stations) improve epochs with poor PDOPs in a GNSS-only configuration. They allow the positioning of epochs with few satellites but cannot completely replace the GNSS

GNSS Shadow Matching: The Challenges Ahead

GNSS shadow matching is a new technique that uses 3D mapping to improve positioning accuracy in dense urban areas from tens of meters to within five meters, potentially less. This paper presents the first comprehensive review of shadow matching’s error sources and proposes a program of research and development to take the technology from proof of concept to a robust, reliable and accurate urban positioning product. A summary of the state of the art is also included. Error sources in shadow matching may be divided into six categories: initialization, modelling, propagation, environmental complexity, observation, and algorithm approximations. Performance is also affected by the environmental geometry and it is sometimes necessary to handle solution ambiguity. For each error source, the cause and how it impacts the position solution is explained. Examples are presented, where available, and improvements to the shadow-matching algorithms to mitigate each error are proposed. Methods of accommodating quality control within shadow matching are then proposed, including uncertainty determination, ambiguity detection, and outlier detection. This is followed by a discussion of how shadow matching could be integrated with conventional ranging-based GNSS and other navigation and positioning technologies. This includes a brief review of methods to enhance ranging-based GNSS using 3D mapping. Finally, the practical engineering challenges of shadow matching are assessed, including the system architecture, efficient GNSS signal prediction and the acquisition of 3D mapping data