1,418 research outputs found
Dynamic and Static congestion models: A review
We begin by providing an overview of the conventional static equilibrium approach. In such model both the flow of trips and congestion delay are assumed to be constant. A drawback of the static model is that the time interval during which travel occurs is not specified so that the model cannot describe changes in the duration of congestion that result from changes in demand or capacity. This limitation is overcome in the Vickrey/Arnott, de Palma Lindsey bottleneck model, which combines congestion in the form of queuing behind a bottleneck with users' trip-timing preferences and departure time decisions. We derive the user equilibrium and social optimum for the basic bottleneck model, and explain how the optimum can be decentralized using a time-varying toll. They then review some extensions of the basic model that encompass elastic demand, user heterogeneity, stochastic demand and capacity and small networks. We conclude by identifying some unresolved modelling issues that apply not only to the bottleneck model but to trip-timing preferences and congestion dynamics in general
Dynamic and Static congestion models: A review
We begin by providing an overview of the conventional static equilibrium approach. In such model both the flow of trips and congestion delay are assumed to be constant. A drawback of the static model is that the time interval during which travel occurs is not specified so that the model cannot describe changes in the duration of congestion that result from changes in demand or capacity. This limitation is overcome in the Vickrey/Arnott, de Palma Lindsey bottleneck model, which combines congestion in the form of queuing behind a bottleneck with users' trip-timing preferences and departure time decisions. We derive the user equilibrium and social optimum for the basic bottleneck model, and explain how the optimum can be decentralized using a time-varying toll. They then review some extensions of the basic model that encompass elastic demand, user heterogeneity, stochastic demand and capacity and small networks. We conclude by identifying some unresolved modelling issues that apply not only to the bottleneck model but to trip-timing preferences and congestion dynamics in genera
Stochastic bottleneck capacity, merging traffic and morning commute
This paper investigates the impact of stochastic capacity at the downstream bottleneck after a merge and the impact of merging behavior on the morning commuters' departure-time patterns. The classic bottleneck theory is extended to include a uniformly distributed capacity and the commuters' equilibrium departure patterns are derived for two different merging rules. The results show that uncertainty in the bottleneck capacity increases the commuters' mean trip cost and lengthens the peak period, and that the system total cost is lower under give-way merging than under a fixed-rate merging. Capacity paradoxes with dynamic user responses are found under both merging rules
Congestion behavior and tolls in a bottleneck model with stochastic capacity
In this paper we investigate a bottleneck model in which the capacity of the bottleneck is assumed stochastic and follows a uniform distribution. The commuters’ departure time choice is assumed to follow the user equilibrium principle according to mean trip cost. The analytical solution of the proposed model is derived. Both the analytical and numerical results show that the capacity variability would indeed change the commuters’ travel behavior by increasing the mean trip cost and lengthening the peak period. We then design congestion pricing schemes within the framework of the new stochastic bottleneck model, for both a time-varying toll and a single-step coarse toll, and prove that the proposed piecewise time-varying toll can effectively cut down, and even eliminate, the queues behind the bottleneck. We also find that the single-step coarse toll could either advance or postpone the earliest departure time. Furthermore, the numerical results show that the proposed pricing schemes can indeed improve the efficiency of the stochastic bottleneck through decreasing the system’s total travel cost
Bottleneck model revisited: An activity-based perspective
The timing of commuting trips made during morning and evening peaks has typically been investigated using Vickrey’s bottleneck model. However, in the conventional trip-based approach, the decisions that commuters make during the day about their activity schedules and time use are not explicitly considered. This study extends the bottleneck model to address the scheduling problem of commuters’ morning home-to-work and evening work-to-home journeys by using an activity-based approach. A day-long activity-travel scheduling model is proposed for the simultaneous determination of departure times for morning and evening commutes, together with allocations of time during the day among travel and activities undertaken at home or at the workplace. The proposed model maximizes the total net utility of the home-based tour, which is the difference between the benefits derived from participating in activities and the disutility incurred by travel between activity locations. The properties of the model solution are analytically explored and compared with the conventional bottleneck model for a special case with constant marginal-activity utility. For the case with linear marginal-activity utility, we develop a heuristic procedure to seek the equilibrium scheduling solution. We also explore the effects of marginal-work utility (or the employees’ average wage level) and of flexible work-hour schemes on the scheduling problem in relation to the morning and evening commuting tours.postprin
Congestion behavior under uncertainty on morning commute with preferred arrival time interval
This paper extends the bottleneck model to study congestion behavior of morning commute with flexible work schedule. The proposed model assumes a stochastic bottleneck capacity which follows a uniform distribution and homogeneous commuters who have the same preferred arrival time interval. The commuters are fully aware of the stochastic properties of travel time and schedule delay distributions at all departure times that emerge from day-to-day capacity variations. The commuters' departure time choice follows user equilibrium (UE) principle in terms of the expected trip cost. Analytical and numerical solutions of this model are provided. The equilibrium departure time patterns are examined which show that the stochastic capacity increases the mean trip cost and lengthens the rush hour. The adoption of flexitime results in less congestion and more efficient use of bottleneck capacity than fixed-time work schedule. The longer the flexi-time interval is, the more uniformly distributed the departure times are
Modelling dynamic stochastic user equilibrium for urban road networks
In this study a dynamic assignment model is developed which estimates travellers' route
and departure time choices and the resulting time varying traffic patterns during the
morning peak. The distinctive feature of the model is that it does not restrict the
geometry of the network to specific forms.
The proposed framework of analysis consists of a travel time model, a demand model
and a demand adjustment mechanism. Two travel time models are proposed. The first
is based on elementary relationships from traffic flow theory and provides the
framework for a macroscopic simulation model which calculates the time varying flow
patterns and link travel times given the time dependent departure rate distributions; the
second is based on queueing theory and models roads as bottlenecks through which
traffic flow is either uncongested or fixed at a capacity independent of traffic density.
The demand model is based on the utility maximisation decision rule and defines the
time dependent departure rates associated with each reasonable route connecting, the
O-D pairs of the network, given the total utility associated with each combination of
departure time and route. Travellers' choices are assumed to result from the trade-off
between travel time and schedule delay and each individual is assumed to first choose a
departure time t, and then select a reasonable route, conditional on the choice of t. The
demand model has therefore the form of a nested logit. The demand adjustment
mechanism is derived from a Markovian model, and describes the day-to-day evolution
of the departure rate distributions. Travellers are assumed to modify their trip choice
decisions based on the information they acquire from recent trips. The demand
adjustment mechanism is used in order to find the equilibrium state of the system,
defined as the state at which travellers believe that they cannot increase their utility of
travel by unilaterally changing route or departure time.
The model outputs exhibit the characteristics of real world traffic patterns observed
during the peak, i. e., time varying flow patterns and travel times which result from
time varying departure rates from the origins. It is shown that increasing the work start
time flexibility results in a spread of the departure rate distributions over a longer
period and therefore reduces the level of congestion in the network. Furthermore, it
was shown that increasing the total demand using the road network results in higher
levels of congestion and that travellers tend to depart earlier in an attempt to
compensate for the increase in travel times. Moreover, experiments using the queueing
theory based travel time model have shown that increasing the capacity of a bottleneck
may cause congestion to develop downstream, which in turn may result in an increase
of the average travel time for certain O-D pairs. The dynamic assignment model is also
applied to estimate the effects that different road pricing policies may have on trip
choices and the level of congestion; the model is used to demonstrate the development
of the shifting peak phenomenon. Furthermore, the effect of information availability
on the traffic patterns is investigated through a number of experiments using the
developed dynamic assignment model and assuming that guided drivers form a class of
users characterised by lower variability of preferences with respect to route choice
Recommended from our members
Modeling Choice Problems with Heterogeneous User Preferences in the Transportation Network
Users of transportation systems need to make a variety of different decisions for their trips in the network, while their objective is to keep the generalized costs of their own trips minimized. In the transportation network, there is a diversity of different factors that can influence the decisions of the users, while the relative importance of these factors varies among the heterogeneous users with different trip purposes. Nonetheless, the cumulative result of the individual decisions of the users seeking to minimize their costs according to their own preferences leads to the user equilibrium condition in which no one can reduce his/her cost by changing his/her decision. In this research, we adapt the concept of the efficient frontier from portfolio theory (Markowitz, 1952) in finance in order to model the bicriterion choice behavior of users with heterogeneous preferences in transportation networks. We show that the efficient frontier has a set of primary properties that remains general in different problems. Thus, the primary properties of the efficient frontier can be employed to analytically model and solve different bicriterion choice problems in transportation.
For the first application, we use these properties to propose an analytical model for the morning commute problem when there is a heterogeneity associated with preferences of the users (Vickrey, 1969; Daganzo, 1985). A dynamic pricing strategy is also proposed to optimize the bottleneck by minimizing the total cost for users. In addition to the morning commute problem, Vickrey’s congestion theory is also shown to have applications in modeling and optimizing the operation of the demand responsive transit (DRT) system with time-dependent demand and state-dependent capacity as queueing systems. The efficiency of the DRT system can be improved by implementing a dynamic pricing strategy. The analytical solution of the morning commute problem can be also extended for modeling and pricing the DRT system when there is a heterogeneity associated with the preferences of the DRT service users.
For another application of the efficient frontier in modeling choice problems in transportation, we propose a traffic assignment model to account for the heterogeneity in sensitivity of the users to travel time reliability in a network under travel time variability. However, the proposed model can have wide applications in modeling the equilibrium condition of different multicriterion choice problems in transportation
- …