Coexistence and interference mitigation for WPANs and WLANs from traditional approaches to deep learning: a review

More and more devices, such as Bluetooth and IEEE 802.15.4 devices forming Wireless Personal Area Networks (WPANs) and IEEE 802.11 devices constituting Wireless Local Area Networks (WLANs), share the 2.4 GHz Industrial, Scientific and Medical (ISM) band in the realm of the Internet of Things (IoT) and Smart Cities. However, the coexistence of these devices could pose a real challenge—co-channel interference that would severely compromise network performances. Although the coexistence issues has been partially discussed elsewhere in some articles, there is no single review that fully summarises and compares recent research outcomes and challenges of IEEE 802.15.4 networks, Bluetooth and WLANs together. In this work, we revisit and provide a comprehensive review on the coexistence and interference mitigation for those three types of networks. We summarize the strengths and weaknesses of the current methodologies, analysis and simulation models in terms of numerous important metrics such as the packet reception ratio, latency, scalability and energy efficiency. We discover that although Bluetooth and IEEE 802.15.4 networks are both WPANs, they show quite different performances in the presence of WLANs. IEEE 802.15.4 networks are adversely impacted by WLANs, whereas WLANs are interfered by Bluetooth. When IEEE 802.15.4 networks and Bluetooth co-locate, they are unlikely to harm each other. Finally, we also discuss the future research trends and challenges especially Deep-Learning and Reinforcement-Learning-based approaches to detecting and mitigating the co-channel interference caused by WPANs and WLANs

Interference of 802.11B WLAN and Bluetooth: Analysis and Performance Evaluation

IEEE 802.11 and Bluetooth, these two operating in the unlicensed 2.4 GHz frequency band are becoming more and more popular in the mobile computing world. The number of devices equipped with IEEE 802.11 and Bluetooth is growing drastically. Result is the number of co-located devices, say within 10 meters, grown to a limit, so that it may causes interference issues in the 2.4 GHz radio frequency spectrum. Bluetooth supports both voice synchronous connection oriented (SCO) data and asynchronous connection less (ACL) packets. In this paper, we investigate the interference issues of 2.4 GHz frequency band. In addition, this paper presents a new Bluetooth voice packet Synchronous Connection Oriented with Repeated Transmission (SCORT) scheme to optimize the performance of 2.4 GHz frequency band by minimizing the interference between Bluetooth and 802.11 wireless networks. For the sake of experimental verifications, we provide a comprehensive simulation results using Matlab Simulink

On adaptive frequency hopping to combat coexistence interference between bluetooth and IEEE 802.11b with practical resource constraints

In contrast to traditional frequency hopping techniques, Adaptive Frequency Hopping (AFH) is a low cost and low power solution to avoid interference dynamically. While each AFH algorithm proposed previously is shown to be efficient, a detailed performance analysis of various AFH mechanisms under realistic resource constraints is yet to be done. In particular, based on our performance study on Bluetooth systems presented in this paper, we have found that the AFH mechanism adopted by IEEE 802.15 Task Group 2 (TG2) is very sensitive to memory and power limitations. We then propose a novel Interference Source Oriented Adaptive Frequency Hopping (ISOAFH) approach based on a cross-layer design, in which the baseband layer of Bluetooth considers not only the instantaneous channels condition but also the physical layer transmission characteristics of potential interference sources in determining the hop sequence. In our simulations using detailed MATLAB Simulink modeling, we find that our proposed method is much more robust in that it is insensitive to memory and energy constraints. Indeed, our approach generally achieves a lower collision rate and higher ISM spectrum utilization.published_or_final_versio

Survey of Spectrum Sharing for Inter-Technology Coexistence

Increasing capacity demands in emerging wireless technologies are expected to be met by network densification and spectrum bands open to multiple technologies. These will, in turn, increase the level of interference and also result in more complex inter-technology interactions, which will need to be managed through spectrum sharing mechanisms. Consequently, novel spectrum sharing mechanisms should be designed to allow spectrum access for multiple technologies, while efficiently utilizing the spectrum resources overall. Importantly, it is not trivial to design such efficient mechanisms, not only due to technical aspects, but also due to regulatory and business model constraints. In this survey we address spectrum sharing mechanisms for wireless inter-technology coexistence by means of a technology circle that incorporates in a unified, system-level view the technical and non-technical aspects. We thus systematically explore the spectrum sharing design space consisting of parameters at different layers. Using this framework, we present a literature review on inter-technology coexistence with a focus on wireless technologies with equal spectrum access rights, i.e. (i) primary/primary, (ii) secondary/secondary, and (iii) technologies operating in a spectrum commons. Moreover, we reflect on our literature review to identify possible spectrum sharing design solutions and performance evaluation approaches useful for future coexistence cases. Finally, we discuss spectrum sharing design challenges and suggest future research directions

Interference Effects of Blue tooth on WLAN Performance

In this paper, Network stumbler version 0.4.0 was used to estimate the impact of impulsive interference on Wireless Local Area Network (WLAN) when Bluetooth coexist by measuring radiation from a WiFi Access Point (AP) in a homogeneous and heterogeneous scenarios. The parameters measured include Received Signal Strength (RSS) and Signal-to-Noise ratio (SNR) while Bit Error Rate (BER) performance was theoretically deduced from the measured data. Results obtained from the measurements of both scenarios were compared and used in describing the interference problem. The study revealed that Bluetooth impact on performance was minimally significant with mean degradation of 4.74% in RSS and 0.77% in SNR despite the fact that its signal are weak and are designed to accommodate WiFi devices by AFH technology.http://dx.doi.org/10.4314/njt.v34i1.2

JamLab: Augmenting Sensornet Testbeds with Realistic and Controlled Interference Generation

Radio interference drastically affects the performance of sensor-net communications, leading to packet loss and reduced energy-efficiency. As an increasing number of wireless devices operates on the same ISM frequencies, there is a strong need for understanding and debugging the performance of existing sensornet protocols under interference. Doing so requires a low-cost flexible testbed infrastructure that allows the repeatable generation of a wide range of interference patterns. Unfortunately, to date, existing sensornet testbeds lack such capabilities, and do not permit to study easily the coexistence problems between devices sharing the same frequencies. This paper addresses the current lack of such an infrastructure by using off-the-shelf sensor motes to record and playback interference patterns as well as to generate customizable and repeat-able interference in real-time. We propose and develop JamLab: a low-cost infrastructure to augment existing sensornet testbeds with accurate interference generation while limiting the overhead to a simple upload of the appropriate software. We explain how we tackle the hardware limitations and get an accurate measurement and regeneration of interference, and we experimentally evaluate the accuracy of JamLab with respect to time, space, and intensity. We further use JamLab to characterize the impact of interference on sensornet MAC protocols

Interference charecterisation, location and bandwidth estimation in emerging WiFi networks

Wireless LAN technology based on the IEEE 802.11 standard, commonly referred to as WiFi, has been hugely successful not only for the last hop access to the Internet in home, office and hotspot scenarios but also for realising wireless backhaul in mesh networks and for point -to -point long- distance wireless communication. This success can be mainly attributed to two reasons: low cost of 802.11 hardware from reaching economies of scale, and operation in the unlicensed bands of wireless spectrum.The popularity of WiFi, in particular for indoor wireless access at homes and offices, has led to significant amount of research effort looking at the performance issues arising from various factors, including interference, CSMA/CA based MAC protocol used by 802.11 devices, the impact of link and physical layer overheads on application performance, and spatio-temporal channel variations. These factors affect the performance of applications and services that run over WiFi networks. In this thesis, we experimentally investigate the effects of some of the above mentioned factors in the context of emerging WiFi network scenarios such as multi- interface indoor mesh networks, 802.11n -based WiFi networks and WiFi networks with virtual access points (VAPs). More specifically, this thesis comprises of four experimental characterisation studies: (i) measure prevalence and severity of co- channel interference in urban WiFi deployments; (ii) characterise interference in multi- interface indoor mesh networks; (iii) study the effect of spatio-temporal channel variations, VAPs and multi -band operation on WiFi fingerprinting based location estimation; and (iv) study the effects of newly introduced features in 802.11n like frame aggregation (FA) on available bandwidth estimation.With growing density of WiFi deployments especially in urban areas, co- channel interference becomes a major factor that adversely affects network performance. To characterise the nature of this phenomena at a city scale, we propose using a new measurement methodology called mobile crowdsensing. The idea is to leverage commodity smartphones and the natural mobility of people to characterise urban WiFi co- channel interference. Specifically, we report measurement results obtained for Edinburgh, a representative European city, on detecting the presence of deployed WiFi APs via the mobile crowdsensing approach. These show that few channels in 2.4GHz are heavily used and there is hardly any activity in the 5GHz band even though relatively it has a greater number of available channels. Spatial analysis of spectrum usage reveals that co- channel interference among nearby APs operating in the same channel can be a serious problem with around 10 APs contending with each other in many locations. We find that the characteristics of WiFi deployments at city -scale are similar to those of WiFi deployments in public spaces of different indoor environments. We validate our approach in comparison with wardriving, and also show that our findings generally match with previous studies based on other measurement approaches. As an application of the mobile crowdsensing based urban WiFi monitoring, we outline a cloud based WiFi router configuration service for better interference management with global awareness in urban areas.For mesh networks, the use of multiple radio interfaces is widely seen as a practical way to achieve high end -to -end network performance and better utilisation of available spectrum. However this gives rise to another type of interference (referred to as coexistence interference) due to co- location of multiple radio interfaces. We show that such interference can be so severe that it prevents concurrent successful operation of collocated interfaces even when they use channels from widely different frequency bands. We propose the use of antenna polarisation to mitigate such interference and experimentally study its benefits in both multi -band and single -band configurations. In particular, we show that using differently polarised antennas on a multi -radio platform can be a helpful counteracting mechanism for alleviating receiver blocking and adjacent channel interference phenomena that underlie multi -radio coexistence interference. We also validate observations about adjacent channel interference from previous studies via direct and microscopic observation of MAC behaviour.Location is an indispensable information for navigation and sensing applications. The rapidly growing adoption of smartphones has resulted in a plethora of mobile applications that rely on position information (e.g., shopping apps that use user position information to recommend products to users and help them to find what they want in the store). WiFi fingerprinting is a popular and well studied approach for indoor location estimation that leverages the existing WiFi infrastructure and works based on the difference in strengths of the received AP signals at different locations. However, understanding the impact of WiFi network deployment aspects such as multi -band APs and VAPs has not received much attention in the literature. We first examine the impact of various aspects underlying a WiFi fingerprinting system. Specifically, we investigate different definitions for fingerprinting and location estimation algorithms across different indoor environments ranging from a multi- storey office building to shopping centres of different sizes. Our results show that the fingerprint definition is as important as the choice of location estimation algorithm and there is no single combination of these two that works across all environments or even all floors of a given environment. We then consider the effect of WiFi frequency bands (e.g., 2.4GHz and 5GHz) and the presence of virtual access points (VAPs) on location accuracy with WiFi fingerprinting. Our results demonstrate that lower co- channel interference in the 5GHz band yields more accurate location estimation. We show that the inclusion of VAPs has a significant impact on the location accuracy of WiFi fingerprinting systems; we analyse the potential reasons to explain the findings.End -to -end available bandwidth estimation (ABE) has a wide range of uses, from adaptive application content delivery, transport-level transmission rate adaptation and admission control to traffic engineering and peer node selection in peer -to- peer /overlay networks [ 1, 2]. Given its importance, it has been received much research attention in both wired data networks and legacy WiFi networks (based on 802.11 a/b /g standards), resulting in different ABE techniques and tools proposed to optimise different criteria and suit different scenarios. However, effects of new MAC/PHY layer enhancements in new and next generation WiFi networks (based on 802.11n and 802.11ac standards) have not been studied yet. We experimentally find that among different new features like frame aggregation, channel bonding and MIMO modes (spacial division multiplexing), frame aggregation has the most harmful effect as it has direct effect on ABE by distorting the measurement probing traffic pattern commonly used to estimate available bandwidth. Frame aggregation is also specified in both 802.11n and 802.1 lac standards as a mandatory feature to be supported. We study the effect of enabling frame aggregation, for the first time, on the performance of the ABE using an indoor 802.11n wireless testbed. The analysis of results obtained using three tools - representing two main Probe Rate Model (PRM) and Probe Gap Model (PGM) based approaches for ABE - led us to come up with the two key principles of jumbo probes and having longer measurement probe train sizes to counter the effects of aggregating frames on the performance of ABE tools. Then, we develop a new tool, WBest+ that is aware of the underlying frame aggregation by incorporating these principles. The experimental evaluation of WBest+ shows more accurate ABE in the presence of frame aggregation.Overall, the contributions of this thesis fall in three categories - experimental characterisation, measurement techniques and mitigation/solution approaches for performance problems in emerging WiFi network scenarios. The influence of various factors mentioned above are all studied via experimental evaluation in a testbed or real - world setting. Specifically, co- existence interference characterisation and evaluation of available bandwidth techniques are done using indoor testbeds, whereas characterisation of urban WiFi networks and WiFi fingerprinting based location estimation are carried out in real environments. New measurement approaches are also introduced to aid better experimental evaluation or proposed as new measurement tools. These include mobile crowdsensing based WiFi monitoring; MAC/PHY layer monitoring of co- existence interference; and WBest+ tool for available bandwidth estimation. Finally, new mitigation approaches are proposed to address challenges and problems identified throughout the characterisation studies. These include: a proposal for crowd - based interference management in large scale uncoordinated WiFi networks; exploiting antenna polarisation diversity to remedy the effects of co- existence interference in multi -interface platforms; taking advantage of VAPs and multi -band operation for better location estimation; and introducing the jumbo frame concept and longer probe train sizes to improve performance of ABE tools in next generation WiFi networks