Automatic Pronunciation Assessment -- A Review

Pronunciation assessment and its application in computer-aided pronunciation training (CAPT) have seen impressive progress in recent years. With the rapid growth in language processing and deep learning over the past few years, there is a need for an updated review. In this paper, we review methods employed in pronunciation assessment for both phonemic and prosodic. We categorize the main challenges observed in prominent research trends, and highlight existing limitations, and available resources. This is followed by a discussion of the remaining challenges and possible directions for future work.Comment: 9 pages, accepted to EMNLP Finding

Machine learning approaches to improving mispronunciation detection on an imbalanced corpus

This thesis reports the investigations into the task of phone-level pronunciation error detection, the performance of which is heavily affected by the imbalanced distribution of the classes in a manually annotated data set of non-native English (Read Aloud responses from the TOEFL Junior Pilot assessment). In order to address problems caused by this extreme class imbalance, two machine learning approaches, cost-sensitive learning and over-sampling, are explored to improve the classification performance. Specifically, approaches which assigned weights inversely proportional to class frequencies and synthetic minority over-sampling technique (SMOTE) were applied to a range of classifiers using feature sets that included information about the acoustic signal, the linguistic properties of the utterance, and word identity. Empirical experiments demonstrate that both balancing approaches lead to a substantial performance improvement (in terms of f1 score) over the baseline on this extremely imbalanced data set. In addition, this thesis also discusses which features are the most important and which classifiers are most effective for the task of identifying phone-level pronunciation errors in non-native speech

Phonological Level wav2vec2-based Mispronunciation Detection and Diagnosis Method

The automatic identification and analysis of pronunciation errors, known as Mispronunciation Detection and Diagnosis (MDD) plays a crucial role in Computer Aided Pronunciation Learning (CAPL) tools such as Second-Language (L2) learning or speech therapy applications. Existing MDD methods relying on analysing phonemes can only detect categorical errors of phonemes that have an adequate amount of training data to be modelled. With the unpredictable nature of the pronunciation errors of non-native or disordered speakers and the scarcity of training datasets, it is unfeasible to model all types of mispronunciations. Moreover, phoneme-level MDD approaches have a limited ability to provide detailed diagnostic information about the error made. In this paper, we propose a low-level MDD approach based on the detection of speech attribute features. Speech attribute features break down phoneme production into elementary components that are directly related to the articulatory system leading to more formative feedback to the learner. We further propose a multi-label variant of the Connectionist Temporal Classification (CTC) approach to jointly model the non-mutually exclusive speech attributes using a single model. The pre-trained wav2vec2 model was employed as a core model for the speech attribute detector. The proposed method was applied to L2 speech corpora collected from English learners from different native languages. The proposed speech attribute MDD method was further compared to the traditional phoneme-level MDD and achieved a significantly lower False Acceptance Rate (FAR), False Rejection Rate (FRR), and Diagnostic Error Rate (DER) over all speech attributes compared to the phoneme-level equivalent

A Mobile App For Practicing Finnish Pronunciation Using Wav2vec 2.0

As Finland attracts more foreign talents, there are demands for self-learning tools to help second language (L2) speakers learn Finnish with proper feedback. However, there are few resources in L2 data in Finnish, especially focusing on the beginner level for adults. Moreover, since L2 adults are mainly busy studying or working in Finland, the application must allow users to practice anytime, anywhere. This thesis aims to address the above issues by developing a mobile app for beginner Finnish L2 learners to practice their pronunciation. The app would evaluate the users' speech samples, give feedback on their pronunciation, and then provide them with instructions in the form of text, photos, audio, and videos to help them improve their pronunciation. Due to the limited resources available, this work explores the wav2vec 2.0 model's capability for the application. We trained our models with the native Finnish speakers' corpus and used them to provide pronunciation feedback on L2 samples without any L2 training data. The results show that the models can detect mispronunciation on phoneme level about 60% of the time (Recall rate) compared to a native Finnish listener. By adding regularizations, selecting training datasets, and using a smaller model size, we achieved a comparable Recall rate of approximately 63% with a slightly lower Precision of around 29%. Compared to the state-of-the-art model in Finnish Automatic Speech Recognition, the trade-off resulted in a significantly faster response time

Developing Sparse Representations for Anchor-Based Voice Conversion

Voice conversion is the task of transforming speech from one speaker to sound as if it was produced by another speaker, changing the identity while retaining the linguistic content. There are many methods for performing voice conversion, but oftentimes these methods have onerous training requirements or fail in instances where one speaker has a nonnative accent. To address these issues, this dissertation presents and evaluates a novel “anchor-based” representation of speech that separates speaker content from speaker identity by modeling how speakers form English phonemes. We call the proposed method Sparse, Anchor-Based Representation of Speech (SABR), and explore methods for optimizing the parameters of this model in native-to-native and native-to-nonnative voice conversion contexts. We begin the dissertation by demonstrating how sparse coding in combination with a compact, phoneme-based dictionary can be used to separate speaker identity from content in objective and subjective tests. The formulation of the representation then presents several research questions. First, we propose a method for improving the synthesis quality by using the sparse coding residual in combination with a frequency warping algorithm to convert the residual from the source to target speaker’s space, and add it to the target speaker’s estimated spectrum. Experimentally, we find that synthesis quality is significantly improved via this transform. Second, we propose and evaluate two methods for selecting and optimizing SABR anchors in native-to-native and native-to-nonnative voice conversion. We find that synthesis quality is significantly improved by the proposed methods, especially in native-to- nonnative voice conversion over baseline algorithms. In a detailed analysis of the algorithms, we find they focus on phonemes that are difficult for nonnative speakers of English or naturally have multiple acoustic states. Following this, we examine methods for adding in temporal constraints to SABR via the Fused Lasso. The proposed method significantly reduces the inter-frame variance in the sparse codes over other methods that incorporate temporal features into sparse coding representations. Finally, in a case study, we examine the use of the SABR methods and optimizations in the context of a computer aided pronunciation training system for building “Golden Speakers”, or ideal models for nonnative speakers of a second language to learn correct pronunciation. Under the hypothesis that the optimal “Golden Speaker” was the learner’s voice, synthesized with a native accent, we used SABR to build voice models for nonnative speakers and evaluated the resulting synthesis in terms of quality, identity, and accentedness. We found that even when deployed in the field, the SABR method generated synthesis with low accentedness and similar acoustic identity to the target speaker, validating the use of the method for building “golden speakers”

A comparison-based approach to mispronunciation detection

Thesis (S.M.)--Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Dept. of Electrical Engineering and Computer Science, 2012.Cataloged from PDF version of thesis.Includes bibliographical references (p. 89-92).This thesis focuses on the problem of detecting word-level mispronunciations in nonnative speech. Conventional automatic speech recognition-based mispronunciation detection systems have the disadvantage of requiring a large amount of language-specific, annotated training data. Some systems even require a speech recognizer in the target language and another one in the students' native language. To reduce human labeling effort and for generalization across all languages, we propose a comparison-based framework which only requires word-level timing information from the native training data. With the assumption that the student is trying to enunciate the given script, dynamic time warping (DTW) is carried out between a student's utterance (nonnative speech) and a teacher's utterance (native speech), and we focus on detecting mis-alignment in the warping path and the distance matrix. The first stage of the system locates word boundaries in the nonnative utterance. To handle the problem that nonnative speech often contains intra-word pauses, we run DTW with a silence model which can align the two utterances, detect and remove silences at the same time. In order to segment each word into smaller, acoustically similar, units for a finer-grained analysis, we develop a phoneme-like unit segmentor which works by segmenting the selfsimilarity matrix into low-distance regions along the diagonal. Both phone-level and wordlevel features that describe the degree of mis-alignment between the two utterances are extracted, and the problem is formulated as a classification task. SVM classifiers are trained, and three voting schemes are considered for the cases where there are more than one matching reference utterance. The system is evaluated on the Chinese University Chinese Learners of English (CUCHLOE) corpus, and the TIMIT corpus is used as the native corpus. Experimental results have shown 1) the effectiveness of the silence model in guiding DTW to capture the word boundaries in nonnative speech more accurately, 2) the complimentary performance of the word-level and the phone-level features, and 3) the stable performance of the system with or without phonetic units labeling.by Ann Lee.S.M

Articulatory-based Speech Processing Methods for Foreign Accent Conversion

The objective of this dissertation is to develop speech processing methods that enable without altering their identity. We envision accent conversion primarily as a tool for pronunciation training, allowing non-native speakers to hear their native-accented selves. With this application in mind, we present two methods of accent conversion. The first assumes that the voice quality/identity of speech resides in the glottal excitation, while the linguistic content is contained in the vocal tract transfer function. Accent conversion is achieved by convolving the glottal excitation of a non-native speaker with the vocal tract transfer function of a native speaker. The result is perceived as 60 percent less accented, but it is no longer identified as the same individual. The second method of accent conversion selects segments of speech from a corpus of non-native speech based on their acoustic or articulatory similarity to segments from a native speaker. We predict that articulatory features provide a more speaker-independent representation of speech and are therefore better gauges of linguistic similarity across speakers. To test this hypothesis, we collected a custom database containing simultaneous recordings of speech and the positions of important articulators (e.g. lips, jaw, tongue) for a native and non-native speaker. Resequencing speech from a non-native speaker based on articulatory similarity with a native speaker achieved a 20 percent reduction in accent. The approach is particularly appealing for applications in pronunciation training because it modifies speech in a way that produces realistically achievable changes in accent (i.e., since the technique uses sounds already produced by the non-native speaker). A second contribution of this dissertation is the development of subjective and objective measures to assess the performance of accent conversion systems. This is a difficult problem because, in most cases, no ground truth exists. Subjective evaluation is further complicated by the interconnected relationship between accent and identity, but modifications of the stimuli (i.e. reverse speech and voice disguises) allow the two components to be separated. Algorithms to measure objectively accent, quality, and identity are shown to correlate well with their subjective counterparts

Automatic Screening of Childhood Speech Sound Disorders and Detection of Associated Pronunciation Errors

Speech disorders in children can affect their fluency and intelligibility. Delay in their diagnosis and treatment increases the risk of social impairment and learning disabilities. With the significant shortage of Speech and Language Pathologists (SLPs), there is an increasing interest in Computer-Aided Speech Therapy tools with automatic detection and diagnosis capability. However, the scarcity and unreliable annotation of disordered child speech corpora along with the high acoustic variations in the child speech data has impeded the development of reliable automatic detection and diagnosis of childhood speech sound disorders. Therefore, this thesis investigates two types of detection systems that can be achieved with minimum dependency on annotated mispronounced speech data. First, a novel approach that adopts paralinguistic features which represent the prosodic, spectral, and voice quality characteristics of the speech was proposed to perform segment- and subject-level classification of Typically Developing (TD) and Speech Sound Disordered (SSD) child speech using a binary Support Vector Machine (SVM) classifier. As paralinguistic features are both language- and content-independent, they can be extracted from an unannotated speech signal. Second, a novel Mispronunciation Detection and Diagnosis (MDD) approach was introduced to detect the pronunciation errors made due to SSDs and provide low-level diagnostic information that can be used in constructing formative feedback and a detailed diagnostic report. Unlike existing MDD methods where detection and diagnosis are performed at the phoneme level, the proposed method achieved MDD at the speech attribute level, namely the manners and places of articulations. The speech attribute features describe the involved articulators and their interactions when making a speech sound allowing a low-level description of the pronunciation error to be provided. Two novel methods to model speech attributes are further proposed in this thesis, a frame-based (phoneme-alignment) method leveraging the Multi-Task Learning (MTL) criterion and training a separate model for each attribute, and an alignment-free jointly-learnt method based on the Connectionist Temporal Classification (CTC) sequence to sequence criterion. The proposed techniques have been evaluated using standard and publicly accessible adult and child speech corpora, while the MDD method has been validated using L2 speech corpora

Dealing with linguistic mismatches for automatic speech recognition

Recent breakthroughs in automatic speech recognition (ASR) have resulted in a word error rate (WER) on par with human transcribers on the English Switchboard benchmark. However, dealing with linguistic mismatches between the training and testing data is still a significant challenge that remains unsolved. Under the monolingual environment, it is well-known that the performance of ASR systems degrades significantly when presented with the speech from speakers with different accents, dialects, and speaking styles than those encountered during system training. Under the multi-lingual environment, ASR systems trained on a source language achieve even worse performance when tested on another target language because of mismatches in terms of the number of phonemes, lexical ambiguity, and power of phonotactic constraints provided by phone-level n-grams. In order to address the issues of linguistic mismatches for current ASR systems, my dissertation investigates both knowledge-gnostic and knowledge-agnostic solutions. In the first part, classic theories relevant to acoustics and articulatory phonetics that present capability of being transferred across a dialect continuum from local dialects to another standardized language are re-visited. Experiments demonstrate the potentials that acoustic correlates in the vicinity of landmarks could help to build a bridge for dealing with mismatches across difference local or global varieties in a dialect continuum. In the second part, we design an end-to-end acoustic modeling approach based on connectionist temporal classification loss and propose to link the training of acoustics and accent altogether in a manner similar to the learning process in human speech perception. This joint model not only performed well on ASR with multiple accents but also boosted accuracies of accent identification task in comparison to separately-trained models