Spectrum Sensing and Multiple Access Schemes for Cognitive Radio Networks

Increasing demands on the radio spectrum have driven wireless engineers to rethink approaches by which devices should access this natural, and arguably scarce, re- source. Cognitive Radio (CR) has arisen as a new wireless communication paradigm aimed at solving the spectrum underutilization problem. In this thesis, we explore a novel variety of techniques aimed at spectrum sensing which serves as a fundamental mechanism to find unused portions of the electromagnetic spectrum. We present several spectrum sensing methods based on multiple antennas and evaluate their receiving operating characteristics. We study a cyclostationary feature detection technique by means of multiple cyclic frequencies. We make use of a spec- trum sensing method called sequential analysis that allows us to significantly decrease the time needed for detecting the presence of a licensed user. We extend this scheme allowing each CR user to perform the sequential analysis algorithm and send their local decision to a fusion centre. This enables for an average faster and more accurate detection. We present an original technique for accounting for spatial and temporal cor- relation influence in spectrum sensing. This reflects on the impact of the scattering environment on detection methods using multiple antennas. The approach is based on the scattering geometry and resulting correlation properties of the received signal at each CR device. Finally, the problem of spectrum sharing for CR networks is addressed in or- der to take advantage of the detected unused frequency bands. We proposed a new multiple access scheme based on the Game Theory. We examine the scenario where a random number of CR users (considered as players) compete to access the radio spec- trum. We calculate the optimal probability of transmission which maximizes the CR throughput along with the minimum harm caused to the licensed users’ performance

Position and Orientation Estimation through Millimeter Wave MIMO in 5G Systems

Millimeter wave signals and large antenna arrays are considered enabling technologies for future 5G networks. While their benefits for achieving high-data rate communications are well-known, their potential advantages for accurate positioning are largely undiscovered. We derive the Cram\'{e}r-Rao bound (CRB) on position and rotation angle estimation uncertainty from millimeter wave signals from a single transmitter, in the presence of scatterers. We also present a novel two-stage algorithm for position and rotation angle estimation that attains the CRB for average to high signal-to-noise ratio. The algorithm is based on multiple measurement vectors matching pursuit for coarse estimation, followed by a refinement stage based on the space-alternating generalized expectation maximization algorithm. We find that accurate position and rotation angle estimation is possible using signals from a single transmitter, in either line-of- sight, non-line-of-sight, or obstructed-line-of-sight conditions.Comment: The manuscript has been revised, and increased from 27 to 31 pages. Also, Fig.2, Fig. 10 and Table I are adde

Spectrum sensing, spectrum monitoring, and security in cognitive radios

Spectrum sensing is a key function of cognitive radios and is used to determine whether a primary user is present in the channel or not. In this dissertation, we formulate and solve the generalized likelihood ratio test (GLRT) for spectrum sensing when both primary user transmitter and the secondary user receiver are equipped with multiple antennas. We do not assume any prior information about the channel statistics or the primary user’s signal structure. Two cases are considered when the secondary user is aware of the energy of the noise and when it is not. The final test statistics derived from GLRT are based on the eigenvalues of the sample covariance matrix. In-band spectrum sensing in overlay cognitive radio networks requires that the secondary users (SU) periodically suspend their communication in order to determine whether the primary user (PU) has started to utilize the channel. In contrast, in spectrum monitoring the SU can detect the emergence of the PU from its own receiver statistics such as receiver error count (REC). We investigate the problem of spectrum monitoring in the presence of fading where the SU employs diversity combining to mitigate the channel fading effects. We show that a decision statistic based on the REC alone does not provide a good performance. Next we introduce new decision statistics based on the REC and the combiner coefficients. It is shown that the new decision statistic achieves significant improvement in the case of maximal ratio combining (MRC). Next we consider the problem of cooperative spectrum sensing in cognitive radio networks (CRN) in the presence of misbehaving radios. We propose a novel approach based on the iterative expectation maximization (EM) algorithm to detect the presence of the primary users, to classify the cognitive radios, and to compute their detection and false alarm probabilities. We also consider the problem of centralized binary hypothesis testing in a cognitive radio network (CRN) consisting of multiple classes of cognitive radios, where the cognitive radios are classified according to the probability density function (PDF) of their received data (at the FC) under each hypotheses

SMARAD - Centre of Excellence in Smart Radios and Wireless Research - Activity Report 2011 - 2013

Centre of Excellence in Smart Radios and Wireless Research (SMARAD), originally established with the name Smart and Novel Radios Research Unit, is aiming at world-class research and education in Future radio and antenna systems, Cognitive radio, Millimetre wave and THz techniques, Sensors, and Materials and energy, using its expertise in RF, microwave and millimeter wave engineering, in integrated circuit design for multi-standard radios as well as in wireless communications. SMARAD has the Centre of Excellence in Research status from the Academy of Finland since 2002 (2002-2007 and 2008-2013). Currently SMARAD consists of five research groups from three departments, namely the Department of Radio Science and Engineering, Department of Micro and Nanosciences, and Department of Signal Processing and Acoustics, all within the Aalto University School of Electrical Engineering. The total number of employees within the research unit is about 100 including 8 professors, about 30 senior scientists and about 40 graduate students and several undergraduate students working on their Master thesis. The relevance of SMARAD to the Finnish society is very high considering the high national income from exports of telecommunications and electronics products. The unit conducts basic research but at the same time maintains close co-operation with industry. Novel ideas are applied in design of new communication circuits and platforms, transmission techniques and antenna structures. SMARAD has a well-established network of co-operating partners in industry, research institutes and academia worldwide. It coordinates a few EU projects. The funding sources of SMARAD are diverse including the Academy of Finland, EU, ESA, Tekes, and Finnish and foreign telecommunications and semiconductor industry. As a by-product of this research SMARAD provides highest-level education and supervision to graduate students in the areas of radio engineering, circuit design and communications through Aalto University and Finnish graduate schools. During years 2011 – 2013, 18 doctor degrees were awarded to the students of SMARAD. In the same period, the SMARAD researchers published 197 refereed journal articles and 360 conference papers

Convex Optimisation for Communication Systems

In this thesis new robust methods for the efficient sharing of the radio spectrum for underlay cognitive radio (CR) systems are developed. These methods provide robustness against uncertainties in the channel state information (CSI) that is available to the cognitive radios. A stochastic approach is taken and the robust spectrum sharing methods are formulated as convex optimisation problems. Three efficient spectrum sharing methods; power control, cooperative beamforming and conventional beamforming are studied in detail. The CR power control problem is formulated as a sum rate maximisation problem and transformed into a convex optimisation problem. A robust power control method under the assumption of partial CSI is developed and also transformed into a convex optimisation problem. A novel method of detecting and removing infeasible constraints from the power allocation problem is presented that results in considerably improved performance. The performance of the proposed methods in Rayleigh fading channels is analysed by simulations. The concept of cooperative beamforming for spectrum sharing is applied to an underlay CR relay network. Distributed single antenna relay nodes are utilised to form a virtual antenna array that provides increased gains in capacity through cooperative beamforming. It is shown that the cooperative beamforming problems can be transformed into convex optimisation problems. New robust cooperative beamformers under the assumption of partial and imperfect CSI are developed and also transformed into convex optimisation problems. The performance of the proposed methods in Rayleigh fading channels is analysed by simulations. Conventional beamforming to allow efficient spectrum sharing in an underlay CR system is studied. The beamforming problems are formulated and transformed into convex optimisation problems. New robust beamformers under the assumption of partial and imperfect CSI are developed and also transformed into convex optimisation problems. The performance of the proposed methods in Rayleigh fading channels is analysed by simulations

Spectrum Sensing in Cognitive Radio: Bootstrap and Sequential Detection Approaches

In this thesis, advanced techniques for spectrum sensing in cognitive radio are addressed. The problem of small sample size in spectrum sensing is considered, and resampling-based methods are developed for local and collaborative spectrum sensing. A method to deal with unknown parameters in sequential testing for spectrum sensing is proposed. Moreover, techniques are developed for multiband sensing, spectrum sensing in low signal to noise ratio, and two-bits hard decision combining for collaborative spectrum sensing. The assumption of using large sample size in spectrum sensing often raises a problem when the devised test statistic is implemented with a small sample size. This is because, for small sample sizes, the asymptotic approximation for the distribution of the test statistic under the null hypothesis fails to model the true distribution. Therefore, the probability of false alarm or miss detection of the test statistic is poor. In this respect, we propose to use bootstrap methods, where the distribution of the test statistic is estimated by resampling the observed data. For local spectrum sensing, we propose the null-resampling bootstrap test which exhibits better performances than the pivot bootstrap test and the asymptotic test, as common approaches. For collaborative spectrum sensing, a resampling-based Chair-Varshney fusion rule is developed. At the cognitive radio user, a combination of independent resampling and moving-block resampling is proposed to estimate the local probability of detection. At the fusion center, the parametric bootstrap is applied when the number of cognitive radio users is large. The sequential probability ratio test (SPRT) is designed to test a simple hypothesis against a simple alternative hypothesis. However, the more realistic scenario in spectrum sensing is to deal with composite hypotheses, where the parameters are not uniquely defined. In this thesis, we generalize the sequential probability ratio test to cope with composite hypotheses, wherein the thresholds are updated in an adaptive manner, using the parametric bootstrap. The resulting test avoids the asymptotic assumption made in earlier works. The proposed bootstrap based sequential probability ratio test minimizes decision errors due to errors induced by employing maximum likelihood estimators in the generalized sequential probability ratio test. Hence, the proposed method achieves the sensing objective. The average sample number (ASN) of the proposed method is better than that of the conventional method which uses the asymptotic assumption. Furthermore, we propose a mechanism to reduce the computational cost incurred by the bootstrap, using a convex combination of the latest K bootstrap distributions. The reduction in the computational cost does not impose a significant increase on the ASN, while the protection against decision errors is even better. This work is motivated by the fact that the sequential probability ratio test produces a smaller sensing time than its counterpart of fixed sample size test. A smaller sensing time is preferable to improve the throughput of the cognitive radio network. Moreover, multiband spectrum sensing is addressed, more precisely by using multiple testing procedures. In a context of a fixed sample size, an adaptive Benjamini-Hochberg procedure is suggested to be used, since it produces a better balance between the familywise error rate and the familywise miss detection, than the conventional Benjamini-Hochberg. For the sequential probability ratio test, we devise a method based on ordered stopping times. The results show that our method has smaller ASNs than the Bonferroni procedure. Another issue in spectrum sensing is to detect a signal when the signal to noise ratio is very low. In this case, we derive a locally optimum detector that is based on the assumption that the underlying noise is Student's t-distributed. The resulting scheme outperforms the energy detector in all scenarios. Last but not least, we extend the hard decision combining in collaborative spectrum sensing to include a quality information bit. In this case, the multiple thresholds are determined by a distance measure criterion. The hard decision combining with quality information performs better than the conventional hard decision combining

Opportunistic communications in large uncoordinated networks

(English) The increase of wireless devices offering high data rate services limits the coexistence of wireless systems sharing the same resources in a given geographical area because of inter-system interference. Therefore, interference management plays a key role in permitting the coexistence of several heterogeneous communication services. However, classical interference management strategies require lateral information giving rise to the need for inter-system coordination and cooperation, which is not always practical. Opportunistic communications offer a potential solution to the problem of inter-system interference management. The basic principle of opportunistic communications is to efficiently and robustly exploit the resources available in a wireless network and adapt the transmitted signals to the state of the network to avoid inter-system interference. Therefore, opportunistic communications depend on inferring the available network resources that can be safely exploited without inducing interference in coexisting communication nodes. Once the available network resources are identified, the most prominent opportunistic communication techniques consist in designing scenario-adapted precoding/decoding strategies to exploit the so-called null space. Despite this, classical solutions in the literature suffer from two main drawbacks: the lack of robustness to detection errors and the need for intra-system cooperation. This thesis focuses on the design of a null space-based opportunistic communication scheme that addresses the drawbacks exhibited by existing methodologies under the assumption that opportunistic nodes do not cooperate. For this purpose, a generalized detection error model independent of the null-space identification mechanism is introduced that allows the design of solutions that exhibit minimal inter-system interference in the worst case. These solutions respond to a maximum signal-to-interference ratio (SIR) criterion, which is optimal under non-cooperative conditions. The proposed methodology allows the design of a family of orthonormal waveforms that perform a spreading of the modulated symbols within the detected null space, which is key to minimizing the induced interference density. The proposed solutions are invariant within the inferred null space, allowing the removal of the feedback link without giving up coherent waveform detection. In the absence of coordination, the waveform design relies solely on locally sensed network state information, inducing a mismatch between the null spaces identified by the transmitter and receiver that may worsen system performance. Although the proposed solution is robust to this mismatch, the design of enhanced receivers using active subspace detection schemes is also studied. When the total number of network resources increases arbitrarily, the proposed solutions tend to be linear combinations of complex exponentials, providing an interpretation in the frequency domain. This asymptotic behavior allows us to adapt the proposed solution to frequency-selective channels by means of a cyclic prefix and to study an efficient modulation similar to the time division multiplexing scheme but using circulant waveforms. Finally, the impact of the use of multiple antennas in opportunistic null space-based communications is studied. The performed analysis reveals that, in any case, the structure of the antenna clusters affects the opportunistic communication, since the proposed waveform mimics the behavior of a single-antenna transmitter. On the other hand, the number of sensors employed translates into an improvement in terms of SIR.(Català) El creixement incremental dels dispositius sense fils que requereixen serveis d'alta velocitat de dades limita la coexistència de sistemes sense fils que comparteixen els mateixos recursos en una àrea geogràfica donada a causa de la interferència entre sistemes. Conseqüentment, la gestió d'interferència juga un paper fonamental per a facilitar la coexistència de diversos serveis de comunicació heterogenis. No obstant això, les estratègies clàssiques de gestió d'interferència requereixen informació lateral originant la necessitat de coordinació i cooperació entre sistemes, que no sempre és pràctica. Les comunicacions oportunistes ofereixen una solució potencial al problema de la gestió de les interferències entre sistemes. El principi bàsic de les comunicacions oportunistes és explotar de manera eficient i robusta els recursos disponibles en una xarxa sense fils i adaptar els senyals transmesos a l'estat de la xarxa per evitar interferències entre sistemes. Per tant, les comunicacions oportunistes depenen de la inferència dels recursos de xarxa disponibles que poden ser explotats de manera segura sense induir interferència en els nodes de comunicació coexistents. Una vegada que s'han identificat els recursos de xarxa disponibles, les tècniques de comunicació oportunistes més prominents consisteixen en el disseny d'estratègies de precodificació/descodificació adaptades a l'escenari per explotar l'anomenat espai nul. Malgrat això, les solucions clàssiques en la literatura sofreixen dos inconvenients principals: la falta de robustesa als errors de detecció i la necessitat de cooperació intra-sistema. Aquesta tesi tracta el disseny d'un esquema de comunicació oportunista basat en l'espai nul que afronta els inconvenients exposats per les metodologies existents assumint que els nodes oportunistes no cooperen. Per a aquest propòsit, s'introdueix un model generalitzat d'error de detecció independent del mecanisme d'identificació de l'espai nul que permet el disseny de solucions que exhibeixen interferències mínimes entre sistemes en el cas pitjor. Aquestes solucions responen a un criteri de màxima relació de senyal a interferència (SIR), que és òptim en condicions de no cooperació. La metodologia proposada permet dissenyar una família de formes d'ona ortonormals que realitzen un spreading dels símbols modulats dins de l'espai nul detectat, que és clau per minimitzar la densitat d’interferència induïda. Les solucions proposades són invariants dins de l'espai nul inferit, permetent suprimir l'enllaç de retroalimentació i, tot i així, realitzar una detecció coherent de forma d'ona. Sota l’absència de coordinació, el disseny de la forma d'ona es basa únicament en la informació de l'estat de la xarxa detectada localment, induint un desajust entre els espais nuls identificats pel transmissor i receptor que pot empitjorar el rendiment del sistema. Tot i que la solució proposada és robusta a aquest desajust, també s'estudia el disseny de receptors millorats fent ús de tècniques de detecció de subespai actiu. Quan el nombre total de recursos de xarxa augmenta arbitràriament, les solucions proposades tendeixen a ser combinacions lineals d'exponencials complexes, proporcionant una interpretació en el domini freqüencial. Aquest comportament asimptòtic permet adaptar la solució proposada a entorns selectius en freqüència fent ús d'un prefix cíclic i estudiar una modulació eficient derivada de l'esquema de multiplexat per divisió de temps emprant formes d'ona circulant. Finalment, s’estudia l'impacte de l'ús de múltiples antenes en comunicacions oportunistes basades en l'espai nul. L'anàlisi realitzada permet concloure que, en cap cas, l'estructura de les agrupacions d'antenes tenen un impacte sobre la comunicació oportunista, ja que la forma d'ona proposada imita el comportament d'un transmissor mono-antena. D'altra banda, el nombre de sensors emprat es tradueix en una millora en termes de SIR.(Español) El incremento de los dispositivos inalámbricos que ofrecen servicios de alta velocidad de datos limita la coexistencia de sistemas inalámbricos que comparten los mismos recursos en un área geográfica dada a causa de la interferencia inter-sistema. Por tanto, la gestión de interferencia juega un papel fundamental para facilitar la coexistencia de varios servicios de comunicación heterogéneos. Sin embargo, las estrategias clásicas de gestión de interferencia requieren información lateral originando la necesidad de coordinación y cooperación entre sistemas, que no siempre es práctica. Las comunicaciones oportunistas ofrecen una solución potencial al problema de la gestión de las interferencias entre sistemas. El principio básico de las comunicaciones oportunistas es explotar de manera eficiente y robusta los recursos disponibles en una red inalámbricas y adaptar las señales transmitidas al estado de la red para evitar interferencias entre sistemas. Por lo tanto, las comunicaciones oportunistas dependen de la inferencia de los recursos de red disponibles que pueden ser explotados de manera segura sin inducir interferencia en los nodos de comunicación coexistentes. Una vez identificados los recursos disponibles, las técnicas de comunicación oportunistas más prominentes consisten en el diseño de estrategias de precodificación/descodificación adaptadas al escenario para explotar el llamado espacio nulo. A pesar de esto, las soluciones clásicas en la literatura sufren dos inconvenientes principales: la falta de robustez a los errores de detección y la necesidad de cooperación intra-sistema. Esta tesis propone diseñar un esquema de comunicación oportunista basado en el espacio nulo que afronta los inconvenientes expuestos por las metodologías existentes asumiendo que los nodos oportunistas no cooperan. Para este propósito, se introduce un modelo generalizado de error de detección independiente del mecanismo de identificación del espacio nulo que permite el diseño de soluciones que exhiben interferencias mínimas entre sistemas en el caso peor. Estas soluciones responden a un criterio de máxima relación de señal a interferencia (SIR), que es óptimo en condiciones de no cooperación. La metodología propuesta permite diseñar una familia de formas de onda ortonormales que realizan un spreading de los símbolos modulados dentro del espacio nulo detectado, que es clave para minimizar la densidad de interferencia inducida. Las soluciones propuestas son invariantes dentro del espacio nulo inferido, permitiendo suprimir el enlace de retroalimentación sin renunciar a la detección coherente de forma de onda. En ausencia de coordinación, el diseño de la forma de onda se basa únicamente en la información del estado de la red detectada localmente, induciendo un desajuste entre los espacios nulos identificados por el transmisor y receptor que puede empeorar el rendimiento del sistema. A pesar de que la solución propuesta es robusta a este desajuste, también se estudia el diseño de receptores mejorados usando técnicas de detección de subespacio activo. Cuando el número total de recursos de red aumenta arbitrariamente, las soluciones propuestas tienden a ser combinaciones lineales de exponenciales complejas, proporcionando una interpretación en el dominio frecuencial. Este comportamiento asintótico permite adaptar la solución propuesta a canales selectivos en frecuencia mediante un prefijo cíclico y estudiar una modulación eficiente derivada del esquema de multiplexado por división de tiempo empleando formas de onda circulante. Finalmente, se estudia el impacto del uso de múltiples antenas en comunicaciones oportunistas basadas en el espacio nulo. El análisis realizado revela que la estructura de las agrupaciones de antenas no afecta la comunicación oportunista, ya que la forma de onda propuesta imita el comportamiento de un transmisor mono-antena. Por otro lado, el número de sensores empleado se traduce en una mejora en términos de SIR.Postprint (published version