Effects of low speed limits on freeway traffic flow

Recent years have seen a renewed interest in Variable Speed Limit (VSL) strategies. New opportunities for VSL as a freeway metering mechanism or a homogenization scheme to reduce speed differences and lane changing maneuvers are being explored. This paper examines both the macroscopic and microscopic effects of different speed limits on a traffic stream, especially when adopting low speed limits. To that end, data from a VSL experiment carried out on a freeway in Spain are used. Data include vehicle counts, speeds and occupancy per lane, as well as lane changing rates for three days, each with a different fixed speed limit (80 km/h, 60 km/h, and 40km/h). Results reveal some of the mechanisms through which VSL affects traffic performance, specifically the flow and speed distribution across lanes, as well as the ensuing lane changing maneuvers. It is confirmed that the lower the speed limit, the higher the occupancy to achieve a given flow. This result has been observed even for relatively high flows and low speed limits. For instance, a stable flow of 1942 veh/h/lane has been measured with the 40 km/h speed limit in force. The corresponding occupancy was 33%, doubling the typical occupancy for this flow in the absence of speed limits. This means that VSL strategies aiming to restrict the mainline flow on a freeway by using low speed limits will need to be applied carefully, avoiding conditions as the ones presented here, where speed limits have a reduced ability to limit flows. On the other hand, VSL strategies trying to get the most from the increased vehicle storage capacity of freeways under low speed limits might be rather promising. Additionally, results show that lower speed limits increase the speed differences across lanes for moderate demands. This, in turn, also increases the lane changing rate. This means that VSL strategies aiming to homogenize traffic and reduce lane changing activity might not be successful when adopting such low speed limits. In contrast, lower speed limits widen the range of flows under uniform lane flow distributions, so that, even for moderate to low demands, the under-utilization of any lane is avoided. These findings are useful for the development of better traffic models that are able to emulate these effects. Moreover, they are crucial for the implementation and assessment of VSL strategies and other traffic control algorithms.Peer ReviewedPostprint (published version

Freeway lab: testing dynamic speed limits

This paper presents the Dynamic Speed Limit (DSL) experiment that took place in June 2013 on the last 13 km stretch of the B-23 freeway accessing the city of Barcelona (Spain). The DSL system installed on that freeway in addition to the high density of surveillance equipment available makes this stretch a suitable highway lab. The objective of the experiment was to construct a comprehensive database of traffic engineering variables on a freeway site when different speed limits apply. Special attention was paid to ensure similar demand conditions. The experiment included the modification of the speed limits on a freeway segment making use of dynamic signals. Detailed measurements of vehicle counts, speeds, occupancies, lane changing maneuvers and travel times were taken. These simultaneous measurements obtained from very different types of monitoring equipment have been grouped into a single database. These include measurements from inductive loop detectors, radar, ultrasound and passive infrared non-intrusive traffic detectors, TV cameras and license plate recognition devices. The potential of this multi-source database is huge. For instance, a preliminary analysis empirically proves that drivers’ compliance with dynamic speed limits is very limited, unless speed enforcement devices are present. In addition, it is also proved that lane changing rates increase together with the occupancy level of the freeway. This comprehensive DSL database, unique in its nature, is made publicly available to the whole research community [Link], [1] in order to use up all its information. The present paper aims to present in detail this DSL experiment and its results and to contribute in the dissemination of the resulting database. This will facilitate its analysis to any interested researcher, and would lead to a better understanding of the causes and effects of DSL strategies on freeways.Postprint (published version

Fuzzy-Based Variable Speed Limits System Under Connected Vehicle Environment: A Simulation-Based Case Study in the City of Naples

This paper handles the problem of controlling speed limits on freeways in a connected traffic environment to reduce traffic congestion and improve both the operational and environmental performance of the road network. In order to achieve this objective, we present a Variable Speed Limit (VSL) system that utilizes fuzzy logic, which adjusts the speed limits that connected vehicles must comply with by leveraging traffic data such as vehicle flow, occupancy, and speed obtained from loop detectors installed along the road. To evaluate the effectiveness of the proposed Fuzzy-based VSL system and its potential benefits compared to the conventional rule-based VSL system in terms of traffic congestion and environmental impact, we conducted a simulation analysis using the microscopic traffic simulator, VISSIM. Specifically, three simulation scenarios are taken into account: i) no VSL, where the VSL system is not enabled; ii) Rule-based VSL system, where a typical a decision tree-based system is considered; iii) Fuzzy-based VSL system, where the herein proposed approach is appraised. The results demonstrate that the proposed approach enhances road efficiency by decreasing speed variation, increasing average speed and vehicle volume, and reducing fuel consumption

Modeling present and future freeway management strategies : variable speed limits, lane-changing and platooning of connected autonomous vehicles

Premi Extraordinari de Doctorat, promoció 2018-2019. Àmbit d’Enginyeria Civil i AmbientalFreeway traffic management is necessary to improve capacity and reduce congestion, especially in metropolitan freeways where the rush period lasts several hours per day. Traffic congestion implies delays and an increase in air pollutant emissions, both with harmful effects to society. Active management strategies imply regulating traffic demand and improving freeway capacity. While both aspects are necessary, the present thesis only addresses the supply side. Part of the research in traffic flow theory is grounded on empirical data. Today, in order to extend our knowledge on traffic dynamics, detailed and high-quality data is needed. To that end, the thesis presents a pioneering data collection campaign, which was developed in a freeway accessing Barcelona. In a Variable Speed Limits (VSL) environment, different speed limits where posted, in order to observe their real and detailed effects on traffic. All the installed surveillance instruments were set to capture data in the highest possible level of detail, including video recordings, from where to count lane-changing maneuvers. With this objective, a semi-automatic method to reliably count lane changes form video recordings was developed and is presented in the thesis. Data analysis proved that the speed limit fulfillment was only relevant in sections with enforcement devices. In these sections, it is confirmed that, the lower the speed limit, the higher the occupancy to achieve a given flow. In contrast, the usually assumed mainline metering effect of low speed limits was not relevant. This might be different in case of stretch enforcement. These findings mean that, on the one hand, VSL strategies aiming to restrict the mainline flow on a freeway by using low speed limits will need to be applied carefully, avoiding conditions as the ones presented here. On the other hand, VSL strategies trying to get the most from the increased vehicle storage capacity of freeways under low speed limits might be rather promising. Results also show that low speed limits increase the speed differences across lanes for moderate demands. This, in turn, also increases the lane changing rates. In contrast, lower speed limits widen the range of flows under uniform lane flow distributions, so that, even for moderate to low demands, the under-utilization of any lane can be avoided. Further analysis of lane-changing activity allowed unveiling that high lane-changing rates prevent achieving the highest flows. This inverse relationship is modeled in the thesis using a stochastic model based on Bayesian inference. This model could be used as a control tool, in order to determine which level of lane-changing activity can be allowed to achieve a desired capacity with some level of reliability. Previous results identify drivers' fulfillment of traffic regulations as a weak point in order to maximize the benefits of current management strategies, like VSL or lane-changing control. This is likely to change in the near future with the irruption of Autonomous Vehicles (AV) in freeways. V2X communications will allow directly actuating on individual vehicles with high accuracy. This will open the door to new management strategies based on simultaneous communication to groups of AVs and extremely short reaction times, like platooning, which stands out as a strategy with a huge potential to improve freeway traffic. Strings of AVs traveling at extremely short gaps (i.e. platoons) allow achieving higher capacities and lower energy consumption rates. In this context, the thesis presents a parsimonious macroscopic model for AVs platooning in mixed traffic (i.e. platoons of AVs travelling together with human driven vehicles). The model allows determining the average platoon length and reproducing the overall traffic dynamics leading to higher capacities. Results prove that with a 50% penetration rate of AVs in the lane, capacity could reach 3400 veh/h/lane under a cooperative platooning strategy.Per tal de millorar la capacitat i reduir la congestió a les autopistes cal gestionar el trànsit de manera activa. Les estratègies de gestió activa del trànsit són d’especial importància en autopistes metropolitanes. La congestió provoca retards i un increment del consum de combustible que va lligat a unes majors emissions de gasos contaminants, tots amb efectes perniciosos per la societat. La gestió activa del transit requereix regular la demanda i millorar la capacitat de la via. Encara que tots dos aspectes son necessaris, la present tesis només analitza la gestió de l’oferta. Part de la recerca en l’anàlisi i la teoria del trànsit es basa en dades empíriques. Per satisfer el requeriment de dades detallades i d’alta qualitat, aquesta tesis presenta una campanya pionera de recol·lecció de dades. Les dades es van recollir a l’autopista B-23 d’accés a Barcelona. Tots els instruments de mesura es van configurar per tal de registrar les dades amb el major nivell de detall possible, incloent les càmeres de videovigilància, d’on es varen extreure els comptatges de canvi de carril. Amb aquest objectiu, es va desenvolupar una metodologia semiautomàtica per comptar canvis de carril a partir de gravacions de trànsit, que es presenta en el cos de la tesi. L’anàlisi de les dades obtingudes ha demostrat que el compliment dels límits de velocitat només resulta rellevant en aquelles seccions que compten amb un radar. És en aquestes seccions on s’ha confirmat que com menor és el límit de velocitat, major es l’ocupació per a un flux donat. Per contra, la hipòtesi habitual de que uns límits de velocitat baixos produeixen una restricció del flux no es va observar de forma rellevant. Aquest comportament podria esser diferent en el cas d’implantar un radar de tram. Els resultats obtinguts també mostren com les diferències de velocitats entre carrils s’incrementen per a límits de velocitat baixos i en condicions de demanda moderada. Això, alhora, incrementa el nombre de canvis de carril. Per contra, els límits de velocitat baixos contribueixen a una distribució de flux més uniforme entre carrils, de forma que es pot evitar la infrautilització de carrils. L’anàlisi més detallat de l’activitat de canvi de carril demostra que una taxa elevada de canvis de carril impedeix assolir fluxos grans de circulació. En la tesi, aquesta relació inversa entre la taxa de canvis de carril i el flux màxim de trànsit a l’autopista s’ha modelat de forma estocàstica utilitzant un model basat en la inferència Bayesiana. Aquest model es pot utilitzar com una eina de control, per tal de determinar quina taxa de canvi de carril es pot permetre si es vol assolir una capacitat determinada amb una determinada probabilitat de compliment. En vista dels resultats previs, la falta de compliment de les normes de trànsit per part dels conductors s’identifica com un punt dèbil a l’hora de maximitzar els beneficis de les actuals estratègies de gestió del transit. Això probablement canviarà en el futur pròxim amb la irrupció dels Vehicles Autònoms (VA) a les autopistes. Els sistemes de comunicació V2X permetran actuar individualment sobre cada vehicle amb una gran precisió. Això obrirà la porta a noves estratègies de gestió, basades en la comunicació simultània entre diferents grups de VA i en temps de reacció extremadament curts, com per exemple és el “platooning”, que destaca pel seu gran potencial per millorar el trànsit en autopista. Els “platons” son cadenes de VA viatjant amb uns espaiaments extremadament curts que permeten assolir capacitats mes elevades i un menor consum energètic. En aquest context, la tesi presenta un model macroscòpic parsimoniós per a “platons” de VA en condicions de transit mixt, és a dir, compartint la infraestructura amb vehicles tradicionals. El model permet determinar la longitud mitjana del “platons” i reproduir el trànsit global dinàmiques que condueixen a majors capacitats. Els resultats demostren que amb un 50% la velocitat de penetració dels AV al carril, la capacitat podria arribar als 3.400 vehicles / h / carril sota una estratègia cooperativa de “platooning”Award-winningPostprint (published version

Modeling present and future freeway management strategies : variable speed limits, lane-changing and platooning of connected autonomous vehicles

Freeway traffic management is necessary to improve capacity and reduce congestion, especially in metropolitan freeways where the rush period lasts several hours per day. Traffic congestion implies delays and an increase in air pollutant emissions, both with harmful effects to society. Active management strategies imply regulating traffic demand and improving freeway capacity. While both aspects are necessary, the present thesis only addresses the supply side. Part of the research in traffic flow theory is grounded on empirical data. Today, in order to extend our knowledge on traffic dynamics, detailed and high-quality data is needed. To that end, the thesis presents a pioneering data collection campaign, which was developed in a freeway accessing Barcelona. In a Variable Speed Limits (VSL) environment, different speed limits where posted, in order to observe their real and detailed effects on traffic. All the installed surveillance instruments were set to capture data in the highest possible level of detail, including video recordings, from where to count lane-changing maneuvers. With this objective, a semi-automatic method to reliably count lane changes form video recordings was developed and is presented in the thesis. Data analysis proved that the speed limit fulfillment was only relevant in sections with enforcement devices. In these sections, it is confirmed that, the lower the speed limit, the higher the occupancy to achieve a given flow. In contrast, the usually assumed mainline metering effect of low speed limits was not relevant. This might be different in case of stretch enforcement. These findings mean that, on the one hand, VSL strategies aiming to restrict the mainline flow on a freeway by using low speed limits will need to be applied carefully, avoiding conditions as the ones presented here. On the other hand, VSL strategies trying to get the most from the increased vehicle storage capacity of freeways under low speed limits might be rather promising. Results also show that low speed limits increase the speed differences across lanes for moderate demands. This, in turn, also increases the lane changing rates. In contrast, lower speed limits widen the range of flows under uniform lane flow distributions, so that, even for moderate to low demands, the under-utilization of any lane can be avoided. Further analysis of lane-changing activity allowed unveiling that high lane-changing rates prevent achieving the highest flows. This inverse relationship is modeled in the thesis using a stochastic model based on Bayesian inference. This model could be used as a control tool, in order to determine which level of lane-changing activity can be allowed to achieve a desired capacity with some level of reliability. Previous results identify drivers' fulfillment of traffic regulations as a weak point in order to maximize the benefits of current management strategies, like VSL or lane-changing control. This is likely to change in the near future with the irruption of Autonomous Vehicles (AV) in freeways. V2X communications will allow directly actuating on individual vehicles with high accuracy. This will open the door to new management strategies based on simultaneous communication to groups of AVs and extremely short reaction times, like platooning, which stands out as a strategy with a huge potential to improve freeway traffic. Strings of AVs traveling at extremely short gaps (i.e. platoons) allow achieving higher capacities and lower energy consumption rates. In this context, the thesis presents a parsimonious macroscopic model for AVs platooning in mixed traffic (i.e. platoons of AVs travelling together with human driven vehicles). The model allows determining the average platoon length and reproducing the overall traffic dynamics leading to higher capacities. Results prove that with a 50% penetration rate of AVs in the lane, capacity could reach 3400 veh/h/lane under a cooperative platooning strategy.Per tal de millorar la capacitat i reduir la congestió a les autopistes cal gestionar el trànsit de manera activa. Les estratègies de gestió activa del trànsit són d’especial importància en autopistes metropolitanes. La congestió provoca retards i un increment del consum de combustible que va lligat a unes majors emissions de gasos contaminants, tots amb efectes perniciosos per la societat. La gestió activa del transit requereix regular la demanda i millorar la capacitat de la via. Encara que tots dos aspectes son necessaris, la present tesis només analitza la gestió de l’oferta. Part de la recerca en l’anàlisi i la teoria del trànsit es basa en dades empíriques. Per satisfer el requeriment de dades detallades i d’alta qualitat, aquesta tesis presenta una campanya pionera de recol·lecció de dades. Les dades es van recollir a l’autopista B-23 d’accés a Barcelona. Tots els instruments de mesura es van configurar per tal de registrar les dades amb el major nivell de detall possible, incloent les càmeres de videovigilància, d’on es varen extreure els comptatges de canvi de carril. Amb aquest objectiu, es va desenvolupar una metodologia semiautomàtica per comptar canvis de carril a partir de gravacions de trànsit, que es presenta en el cos de la tesi. L’anàlisi de les dades obtingudes ha demostrat que el compliment dels límits de velocitat només resulta rellevant en aquelles seccions que compten amb un radar. És en aquestes seccions on s’ha confirmat que com menor és el límit de velocitat, major es l’ocupació per a un flux donat. Per contra, la hipòtesi habitual de que uns límits de velocitat baixos produeixen una restricció del flux no es va observar de forma rellevant. Aquest comportament podria esser diferent en el cas d’implantar un radar de tram. Els resultats obtinguts també mostren com les diferències de velocitats entre carrils s’incrementen per a límits de velocitat baixos i en condicions de demanda moderada. Això, alhora, incrementa el nombre de canvis de carril. Per contra, els límits de velocitat baixos contribueixen a una distribució de flux més uniforme entre carrils, de forma que es pot evitar la infrautilització de carrils. L’anàlisi més detallat de l’activitat de canvi de carril demostra que una taxa elevada de canvis de carril impedeix assolir fluxos grans de circulació. En la tesi, aquesta relació inversa entre la taxa de canvis de carril i el flux màxim de trànsit a l’autopista s’ha modelat de forma estocàstica utilitzant un model basat en la inferència Bayesiana. Aquest model es pot utilitzar com una eina de control, per tal de determinar quina taxa de canvi de carril es pot permetre si es vol assolir una capacitat determinada amb una determinada probabilitat de compliment. En vista dels resultats previs, la falta de compliment de les normes de trànsit per part dels conductors s’identifica com un punt dèbil a l’hora de maximitzar els beneficis de les actuals estratègies de gestió del transit. Això probablement canviarà en el futur pròxim amb la irrupció dels Vehicles Autònoms (VA) a les autopistes. Els sistemes de comunicació V2X permetran actuar individualment sobre cada vehicle amb una gran precisió. Això obrirà la porta a noves estratègies de gestió, basades en la comunicació simultània entre diferents grups de VA i en temps de reacció extremadament curts, com per exemple és el “platooning”, que destaca pel seu gran potencial per millorar el trànsit en autopista. Els “platons” son cadenes de VA viatjant amb uns espaiaments extremadament curts que permeten assolir capacitats mes elevades i un menor consum energètic. En aquest context, la tesi presenta un model macroscòpic parsimoniós per a “platons” de VA en condicions de transit mixt, és a dir, compartint la infraestructura amb vehicles tradicionals. El model permet determinar la longitud mitjana del “platons” i reproduir el trànsit global dinàmiques que condueixen a majors capacitats. Els resultats demostren que amb un 50% la velocitat de penetració dels AV al carril, la capacitat podria arribar als 3.400 vehicles / h / carril sota una estratègia cooperativa de “platooning

Deployment of ITS: A Summary of the 2010 National Survey Results

This report presents summary results of the 2010 ITS Deployment Tracking survey, the most recent survey conducted by the ITS Deployment Tracking Project. The U.S. Department of Transportation and its member agencies, including the Research and Innovative Technology Administration, have pursued a research and development agenda, the Intelligent Transportation System (ITS) Program, designed to integrate the latest in information technologies to improve the safety, mobility, and reliability of surface transportation modes. Within metropolitan areas, implementation of these advanced technologies has been accomplished by a variety of state and local transportation and emergency management agencies as well as the private sector. In order to measure the rate of ITS deployment within the nation s largest metropolitan areas, the ITS Deployment Tracking Project has conducted a nationwide survey of state and local transportation and emergency management agencies nearly every year since 1997. The results presented in this report are intended to be a summary of the entire database from the 2010 survey. Access to the complete survey results and previous national surveys are available on-line at http://www.itsdeployment.its.dot.gov. The website also provides access to survey results in the form of downloadable reports, including a survey summary for each survey type and fact sheets. Nearly 1,600 surveys were distributed to state and local transportation agencies in 2010. A total of seven (7) survey types were distributed including: Freeway Management, Arterial Management, Transit Management, Transportation Management Center (TMC), Electronic Toll Collection (ETC), Public Safety Law Enforcement, and Public Safety Fire/Rescue. Among other things, the data collection results indicate that ITS has moved from being experimental to mainstream and interest in continuing investments in ITS continues to be very strong. When asked about future deployment plans, one-third to three-fourths of the different agency types report they will expand current deployments and about half are planning to invest in new technologies over the next three years

Effects of Traffic Incidents on Adjacent Facilities and Alternative Re-Routing Strategies

This study presents an analysis of detour operations as a concept of congestion management. Since a large portion of traffic delay emanates from traffic incidents, the goal of the study was to alleviate incident-induced impacts on freeways by diverting congested traffic on to adjacent roadway facilities. To balance the demand between freeway and arterial systems, optimization was required through Integrated Corridor Management (ICM). This thesis examines the justification and optimization of dynamic traffic routing strategies. Previous studies have justified detour operations based solely on traffic simulation results. This study quantifies the impacts from freeway incidents on a parallel arterial roadway using a data-driven signal processing technique, with operating speeds adopted as a performance measure. Results show that rerouting traffic to an adjacent arterial road, due to a freeway incident, can mitigate the mobility of the corridor with a probability of up to 88% depending on the type of incident and occurrence time. Results also indicate that diverting traffic during off-peak hours, especially for minor incidents, provides minimal mobility benefits. A secondary focus of this study explored the optimum dynamic traffic diversion, to an adjacent arterial roadway, from incident-induced freeway congestion to better utilize the freeway’s available corridor capacity. VISSIM, a microsimulation tool, was employed to simulate a freeway incident and measure the performance of detour operations. A 23 full factorial central composite design was used to establish a relationship between the performance of the detour operation and three control factors: incident duration, diversion rate, and demand level. The resulting regression equation predicts the corridor delay with over 83% accuracy. The findings of this study can potentially serve as a building block in the understanding and development of future ICM systems and incident management plans

Technology: a necessary but not sufficient condition for future personal mobility

Número especial: Sustainable Road Transportation Planning[Abstract:] Technological advances revolutionize industrial processes, science, communications, and our way of life. However, developed societies have reached a stage in which the fascination with technological innovations often results in their indiscriminate consumption. In this paper, road traffic is used as a line of argument to demonstrate that the random introduction of technology does not imply benefits to society. Particularly, it is analyzed why some of the potential benefits of technological progress are lost in fields such as traffic monitoring, data handling, and traffic management, or in sustainable mobility initiatives, such as the introduction of electric vehicles or the implementation vehicle sharing projects. The risks faced in the future advent of autonomous vehicles are also discussed, and ideas for improvement suggested. A critical reflection on other transportation modes that are expected to be realized in the near future is included as well. The performed analysis evidences that the potential improvement in personal mobility will not become a reality if it exclusively relies on the latest technological devices, in line with consumers’ fantasies or economic interests. This is a statement that could be generalized to many other fields. The implementation/consumption of a particular technology should not be an objective in itself, but a tool to bring benefits to society.Ministerio de Economía y Competitividad; TRA2016-79019-R/COO

Assessing the emission impacts of autonomous vehicles on metropolitan freeways

While recent studies demonstrate the societal and economic benefits of driverless vehicles, little is known about the emission impacts of autonomous vehicles (AVs) in the context of mixed traffic. This paper explores the environmental impacts of AVs along an urban freeway corridor in a metropolitan area using Vehicle Specific Power (VSP) and EMEP/EEA emission methodologies paired with VISSIM traffic model. Three different AV penetration rates were implemented for through traffic along a freeway corridor in the city of Porto (Portugal) by considering long-term market predictions (10%, 20% and 30%). Afterwards, these scenarios were compared to current situation in terms of carbon dioxide, carbon monoxide, nitrogen oxides and hydrocarbon emissions, and travel time and stop-and-go situations. The emissions and traffic performance of each scenario were evaluated on three levels: a) overall study domain; b) corridor; c) impact of AVs on conventional vehicles (CVs). AVs yielded small savings in emissions in the overall study domain for automation levels below 30% (differences in traffic performance and emissions were not statistically significant). Corridor-level analysis showed decreases of 5% in emissions can be expected with AVs technology, but it penalizes travel time up to 13% for both AV and CV, when compared to the existing situation.publishe