Towards zero-power wireless machine-to-machine networks

This thesis aims at contributing to overcome two of the main challenges for the deployment of M2M networks in data collection scenarios for the Internet of Things: the management of massive numbers of end-devices that attempt to get access to the channel; and the need to extend the network lifetime. In order to solve these challenges, two complementary strategies are considered. Firstly, the thesis focuses on the design, analysis and performance evaluation of MAC protocols that can handle abrupt transitions in the traffic load and minimize the energy consumption devoted to communications. And secondly, the use of energy harvesting (EH) is considered in order to provide the network with unlimited lifetime. To this end, the second part of the thesis focuses on the design and analysis of EH-aware MAC protocols. While the Frame Slotted-ALOHA (FSA) protocol has been traditionally adopted in star topology networks for data collection, results show that FSA-based protocols lack of scalability and present synchronization problems as the network density increases. Indeed, the frame length of FSA must be adjusted to the number of contenders, which may be complex to attain in dense networks with large and dynamic number of end-devices. In order to overcome these issues, a tree splitting-based random access protocol, referred to as Low Power Contention Tree-based Access (LP-CTA), is proposed in the first part of this thesis. In LP-CTA, the frame length can be very short and fixed, which facilitates synchronization and provides better network scalability than FSA. While LP-CTA uses data slots for contention, it is possible to use short access requests in minislots, where collisions are resolved using tree splitting, and avoid the contention in data. Since these minislots can be much shorter than the duration of a data packet, the performance can be improved. The Low Power Distributed Queuing (LP-DQ) protocol proposed in this thesis is based on this idea. LP-DQ combines tree splitting with the logic of two distributed queues that manage the contention resolution and the collision-free data transmission. Results show that LP-DQ outperforms LP-CTA and FSA in terms of delay and energy efficiency, and it relaxes the need to know the size of the network and adapts smoothly to any change in the number of end-devices. The approach of LP-DQ is convenient when the messages transmitted by each end-device fit in one single slot, however, if the end-devices generate long messages that have to be fragmented, it is better to add a reservation mechanism in order to boost the performance. In this sense, the LPR-DQ protocol is proposed as an extension of LP-DQ where the concept of reservation is integrated to allow the end-devices reserve as many collision-free slots as needed. The second part of the thesis is devoted to the integration of the MAC layer with the use of energy harvesting. The variability and fluctuations of the harvested energy is considered for the design of EH-aware MAC protocols and three performance metrics are proposed: the probability of delivery, the data delivery ratio and the time efficiency. Previous works on data collection networks with EH focus on DFSA. In this thesis, the EH-CTA protocol is proposed as an adaptation of LP-CTA that takes the energy harvesting process into account. Results show that EH-CTA outperforms DFSA if the energy threshold for an end-device to become active is properly configured. In addition, while DFSA needs to adapt the frame length dynamically, EH-CTA uses a fixed frame length, thus facilitating scalability and synchronization. Finally, the EH-RDFSA and EH-DQ protocols are proposed for scenarios where data must be fragmented. EH-RDFSA is a combination of RFSA and DFSA, and EH-DQ is an extension of LPR-DQ.Esta tesis contribuye a resolver dos de los retos para el despliegue de redes M2M en escenarios de recolección de datos para el Internet de las Cosas: la gestión del acceso al canal de un número masivo de dispositivos; y la necesidad de extender la vida de la red. Para resolverlos se consideran dos estrategias complementarias. En primer lugar, se centra en el diseño, el análisis y la evaluación de protocolos MAC que pueden manejar transiciones abruptas de tráfico y reducen el consumo de energía. Y en segundo lugar, se considera el uso de mecanismos de captura de energía (Energy Harvesters, EH) para ofrecer un tiempo de vida ilimitado de la red. Con este fin, la segunda parte de la tesis se centra en el diseño y el análisis de protocolos MAC de tipo "EH-aware". Mientras que Frame Slotted-ALOHA (FSA) ha sido tradicionalmente adoptado en aplicaciones de recolección de datos, los resultados muestran que FSA presenta problemas de escalabilidad y sincronización cuando aumenta la densidad de la red. De hecho, la longitud de trama de FSA se debe ajustar según sea el número de dispositivos, lo cual puede ser difícil de estimar en redes con un número elevado y dinámico de dispositivos. Para superar estos problemas, en esta tesis se propone un protocolo de acceso aleatorio basado en "tree-splitting" denominado Low Power Contention Tree-based Access (LP-CTA). En LP-CTA, la longitud de trama puede ser corta y constante, lo cual facilita la sincronización y proporciona mejor escalabilidad. Mientras que LP-CTA utiliza paquetes de datos para la contienda, es posible utilizar solicitudes de acceso en mini-slots, donde las colisiones se resuelven utilizando "tree-splitting", y evitar la contención en los datos. Dado que estos mini-slots pueden ser mucho más cortos que la duración de un slot de datos, el rendimiento de LP-CTA puede ser mejorado. El protocolo Low Power Distributed Queuing (LP-DQ) propuesto en esta tesis se basa en esta idea. LP-DQ combina "tree-splitting" con la lógica de dos colas distribuidas que gestionan la resolución de la contienda en la solicitud de acceso y la transmisión de datos libre de colisiones. Los resultados demuestran que LP-DQ mejora LP-CTA y FSA en términos de retardo y eficiencia energética, LP-DQ no requiere conocer el tamaño de la red y se adapta sin problemas a cualquier cambio en el número de dispositivos. LP-DQ es conveniente cuando los mensajes transmitidos por cada dispositivo caben en un único slot de datos, sin embargo, si los dispositivos generan mensajes largos que requieren fragmentación, es mejor añadir un mecanismo de reserva para aumentar el rendimiento. En este sentido, el protocolo LPR-DQ se propone como una extensión de LP-DQ que incluye un mecanismo de reserva para permitir que cada dispositivo reserve el número de slots de datos según sea el número de fragmentos por mensaje. La segunda parte de la tesis está dedicada a la integración de la capa MAC con el uso de "Energy Harvesters". La variabilidad y las fluctuaciones de la energía capturada se consideran para el diseño de protocolos MAC de tipo "EH-aware" y se proponen tres métricas de rendimiento: la probabilidad de entrega, el "Data Delivery Ratio" y la eficiencia temporal. Los trabajos previos en redes de recolección de datos con EH se centran principalmente en DFSA. En esta tesis, el protocolo EH-CTA se propone como una adaptación de LP-CTA que tiene en cuenta el proceso de captura de energía. Los resultados muestran que EH-CTA supera DFSA si el umbral de energía para que un dispositivo se active está configurado correctamente. Además, mientras que en DFSA se necesita adaptar la longitud de trama de forma dinámica, EH-CTA utiliza una longitud de trama fija, facilitando así la escalabilidad y la sincronización. Por último, se proponen los protocolos EH-RDFSA y EH-DQ para escenarios en los que los datos deben ser fragmentados. EH-RDFSA es una combinación de RFSA y DFSA, y EH-DQ es una extensión de LPR-DQ.Aquesta tesi contribueix a resoldre dos dels reptes per al desplegament de xarxes M2M en escenaris de recol·lecció de dades per a l'Internet de les Coses: la gestió de l'accés al canal d'un nombre massiu de dispositius; i la necessitat d'extendre la vida de la xarxa. Per resoldre'ls es consideren dues estratègies complementàries. En primer lloc, es centra en el disseny, l'anàlisi i l'avaluació de protocols MAC que poden manegar transicions abruptes de trànsit i redueixen el consum d'energia. I en segon lloc, es considera l'ús de mecanismes de captura d'energia (Energy Harvesters, EH) per a oferir un temps de vida il·limitat de la xarxa. Amb aquesta finalitat, la segona part de la tesi es centra en el disseny i l'anàlisi de protocols MAC de tipus "EH-aware".Mentre que Frame Slotted-ALOHA (FSA) ha estat tradicionalment adoptat en aplicacions de recol·lecció de dades, els resultats mostren que FSA presenta problemes d'escalabilitat i sincronització quan augmenta la densitat de la xarxa. De fet, la longitud de trama de FSA s'ha d'ajustar segons sigui el nombre de dispositius, la qual cosa pot ser difícil d'estimar en xarxes amb un nombre elevat i dinàmic de dispositius. Per superar aquests problemes, en aquesta tesi es proposa un protocol d'accés aleatori basat en "tree-splitting" denominat Low Power Contention Tree-based Access (LP-CTA). En LP-CTA, la longitud de trama pot ser curta i constant, la qual cosa facilita la sincronització i proporciona millor escalabilitat.Mentre que LP-CTA utilitza paquets de dades per a la contenció, és possible utilitzar sol·licituds d'accés a mini-slots, on les col·lisions es resolen utilitzant "tree-splitting", i evitar la contenció a les dades. Atès que aquests mini-slots poden ser molt més curts que la durada d'un slot de dades, el rendiment de LP-CTA pot ser millorat. El protocol Low Power Distributed Queuing (LP-DQ) proposat en aquesta tesi es basa en aquesta idea. LP-DQ combina "tree-splitting" amb la lògica de dues cues distribuïdes que gestionen la resolució de la contenció en la sol·licitud d'accés i la transmissió de dades lliure de col·lisions. Els resultats demostren que LP-DQ millora LP-CTA i FSA en termes de retard i eficiència energètica, LP-DQ no requereix conèixer la mida de la xarxa i s'adapta sense problemes a qualsevol canvi en el nombre de dispositius.LP-DQ és convenient quan els missatges transmesos per cada dispositiu caben en un únic slot de dades, però, si els dispositius generen missatges llargs que requereixen fragmentació, és millor afegir un mecanisme de reserva per augmentar el rendiment. En aquest sentit, el protocol LPR-DQ es proposa com una extensió de LP-DQ que inclou un mecanisme de reserva per a permetre que cada dispositiu reservi el nombre de slots de dades segons sigui el nombre de fragments per missatge.La segona part de la tesi està dedicada a la integració de la capa MAC amb l'ús de "Energy Harvesters". La variabilitat i les fluctuacions de l'energia capturada es consideren per al disseny de protocols MAC de tipus "EH-aware" i es proposen tres mètriques de rendiment: la probabilitat d'entrega, el "Data Delivery Ratio" i l'eficiència temporal.Els treballs previs en xarxes de recol·lecció de dades amb EH se centren principalment en DFSA. En aquesta tesi, el protocol EH-CTA es proposa com una adaptació de LP-CTA que té en compte el procés de captura d'energia. Els resultats mostren que EH-CTA supera DFSA si el llindar d'energia perquè un dispositiu s'activi s'ajusta correctament. A més, mentre que a DFSA es necessita adaptar la longitud de trama de forma dinàmica, EH-CTA utilitza una longitud de trama fixa, facilitant així l'escalabilitat i la sincronització. Finalment, es proposen els protocols EH-RDFSA i EH-DQ per a escenaris en els quals les dades han de ser fragmentades. EH-RDFSA és una combinació de RFSA i DFSA, i EH-DQ és una extensió de LPR-DQ.Postprint (published version

Contention tree-based access for wireless machine-to-machine networks with energy harvesting

©2017 IEEE. Personal use of this material is permitted. Permission from IEEE must be obtained for all other uses, in any current or future media, including reprinting/republishing this material for advertising or promotional purposes, creating new collective works, for resale or redistribution to servers or lists, or reuse of any copyrighted component of this work in other works.In this paper, we consider a wireless machine-to-machine network composed of end-devices with energy harvesters that periodically transmit data to a gateway. While energy harvesting allows for perpetual operation, the uncertain amount of harvested energy may not guarantee fully continuous operation due to temporary energy shortages. This fact needs to be addressed at the medium access control layer. We thus investigate the performance of an energy harvesting-aware contention tree-based access (EH-CTA) protocol, which uses a tree-splitting algorithm to resolve collisions and takes energy availability into account. We derive a theoretical model to compute the probability of delivery and the time efficiency. In addition, we conduct a performance comparison of EH-CTA using an EH-aware dynamic frame slotted-ALOHA (EH-DFSA) as a benchmark. We determine the parameters that maximize performance and analyze how it is influenced by the amount of harvested energy and the number of end-devices. Results reveal the superior performance of EH-CTA over EH-DFSA. While EH-DFSA requires an estimate of the number of contending end-devices per frame to adapt the frame length, EH-CTA uses short and fixed frame lengths, which enables scalability and facilitates synchronization as the network density increases.Peer ReviewedPostprint (author's final draft

Q-learning Channel Access Methods for Wireless Powered Internet of Things Networks

The Internet of Things (IoT) is becoming critical in our daily life. A key technology of interest in this thesis is Radio Frequency (RF) charging. The ability to charge devices wirelessly creates so called RF-energy harvesting IoT networks. In particular, there is a hybrid access point (HAP) that provides energy in an on-demand manner to RF-energy harvesting devices. These devices then collect data and transmit it to the HAP. In this respect, a key issue is ensuring devices have a high number of successful transmissions. There are a number of issues to consider when scheduling the transmissions of devices in the said network. First, the channel gain to/from devices varies over time. This means the efficiency to deliver energy to devices and to transmit the same amount of data is different over time. Second, during channel access, devices are not aware of the energy level of other devices nor whether they will transmit data. Third, devices have non-causal knowledge of their energy arrivals and channel gain information. Consequently, they do not know whether they should delay their transmissions in hope of better channel conditions or less contention in future time slots or doing so would result in energy overflow

Medium access control protocol design for wireless communications and networks review

Medium access control (MAC) protocol design plays a crucial role to increase the performance of wireless communications and networks. The channel access mechanism is provided by MAC layer to share the medium by multiple stations. Different types of wireless networks have different design requirements such as throughput, delay, power consumption, fairness, reliability, and network density, therefore, MAC protocol for these networks must satisfy their requirements. In this work, we proposed two multiplexing methods for modern wireless networks: Massive multiple-input-multiple-output (MIMO) and power domain non-orthogonal multiple access (PD-NOMA). The first research method namely Massive MIMO uses a massive number of antenna elements to improve both spectral efficiency and energy efficiency. On the other hand, the second research method (PD-NOMA) allows multiple non-orthogonal signals to share the same orthogonal resources by allocating different power level for each station. PD-NOMA has a better spectral efficiency over the orthogonal multiple access methods. A review of previous works regarding the MAC design for different wireless networks is classified based on different categories. The main contribution of this research work is to show the importance of the MAC design with added optimal functionalities to improve the spectral and energy efficiencies of the wireless networks

Performance evaluation of framed slotted ALOHA with reservation packets and succesive interference cancelation for M2M networks

[EN] Random access protocols like ALOHA have been considered for machine-to-machine (M2M) communication in future networks for their simplicity of operation. This paper evaluates the performance of a Frame Slotted-ALOHA protocol that uses reservation and data packets (FSA-RDP), in a scenario where a controller collects data packets transmitted by a finite number of M2M devices. In FSA-RDP, frames of variable duration are divided in two parts, the reservation and data subframes. During the reservation subframe, active devices send short reservation packets to the controller. The controller assigns reserved slots in the data subframe to those devices that succeeded with the reservation. At devices, the FIFO service discipline and two queue management schemes, tail drop and push-out, have been considered. When the queue size is of one packet, we develop a discrete-time Markov chain to evaluate the protocol performance, including the cumulative distribution function of the delay of data packets that are successfully transmitted. Analytical results are validated by extensive simulations. The simulation model is also used to evaluate the system performance when larger queues are used. In addition, we study the impact that implementing Successive Interference Cancellation (SIC) at the controller has on the system performance. We also evaluate the performance of implementing SIC at the controller together with Irregular Repetition Slotted ALOHA (IRSA) to send the reservation packets. Numerical results show that the protocol efficiency of FSA-RDP is between one and two orders of magnitude larger than the efficiency of conventional Frame Slotted ALOHA, when a perfect channel is assumed. In more realistic channel environments, the use of SIC brings an important performance boost.This work has been supported by the Ministry of Economy and Competitiveness of Spain through projects TIN2013-47272-C2-1-R and TEC2015-71932-REDT. The authors would like to thank the support received from the Institute ITACA (Instituto Universitario de Tecnologias de la Informacion y Comunicaciones) at the Universitat Politecnica de Valencia, Spain. C. Portillo acknowledges the funding received from the European Union under the program Erasmus Mundus Partnerships, project EuroinkaNet, GRANT AGREEMENT NUMBER -2014 -0870/001/001, and the support received from SEP-SES (DSA/103.5/15/6629).Casares-Giner, V.; Martínez Bauset, J.; Portillo, C. (2019). Performance evaluation of framed slotted ALOHA with reservation packets and succesive interference cancelation for M2M networks. Computer Networks. 155:15-30. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.comnet.2019.02.021S153015

Intelligent Medium Access Control Protocols for Wireless Sensor Networks

The main contribution of this thesis is to present the design and evaluation of intelligent MAC protocols for Wireless Sensor Networks (WSNs). The objective of this research is to improve the channel utilisation of WSNs while providing flexibility and simplicity in channel access. As WSNs become an efficient tool for recognising and collecting various types of information from the physical world, sensor nodes are expected to be deployed in diverse geographical environments including volcanoes, jungles, and even rivers. Consequently, the requirements for the flexibility of deployment, the simplicity of maintenance, and system self-organisation are put into a higher level. A recently developed reinforcement learning-based MAC scheme referred as ALOHA-Q is adopted as the baseline MAC scheme in this thesis due to its intelligent collision avoidance feature, on-demand transmission strategy and relatively simple operation mechanism. Previous studies have shown that the reinforcement learning technique can considerably improve the system throughput and significantly reduce the probability of packet collisions. However, the implementation of reinforcement learning is based on assumptions about a number of critical network parameters. That impedes the usability of ALOHA-Q. To overcome the challenges in realistic scenarios, this thesis proposes numerous novel schemes and techniques. Two types of frame size evaluation schemes are designed to deal with the uncertainty of node population in single-hop systems, and the unpredictability of radio interference and node distribution in multi-hop systems. A slot swapping techniques is developed to solve the hidden node issue of multi-hop networks. Moreover, an intelligent frame adaptation scheme is introduced to assist sensor nodes to achieve collision-free scheduling in cross chain networks. The combination of these individual contributions forms state of the art MAC protocols, which offers a simple, intelligent and distributed solution to improving the channel utilisation and extend the lifetime of WSNs

Energy Harvesting Wireless Communications: A Review of Recent Advances

This article summarizes recent contributions in the broad area of energy harvesting wireless communications. In particular, we provide the current state of the art for wireless networks composed of energy harvesting nodes, starting from the information-theoretic performance limits to transmission scheduling policies and resource allocation, medium access and networking issues. The emerging related area of energy transfer for self-sustaining energy harvesting wireless networks is considered in detail covering both energy cooperation aspects and simultaneous energy and information transfer. Various potential models with energy harvesting nodes at different network scales are reviewed as well as models for energy consumption at the nodes.Comment: To appear in the IEEE Journal of Selected Areas in Communications (Special Issue: Wireless Communications Powered by Energy Harvesting and Wireless Energy Transfer